It’s funny how people hate you until they need you.

The Stone Witch of Florence by Anna Rasche is a standalone novel and is an interesting take on dealing with the plague and being used for your gifts.

I’m not a huge historical fiction reader, but this one kept my attention fairly well. I had no idea what I was getting into prior to diving into this book and it wasn’t what I was expecting. Part of this is a good thing, and part, a bad thing.

While there is a really good story here and it brings up tons of crazy situations for the witch and the people who love/hate her, the pacing could be a bit faster. I don’t like how they treated her, but that’s just part of the conflict within the story, of course. I really liked that there were passages throughout the story that gave information about the different types of stones.

If you like the slow burn, magical stories with a taste of dark eras from that past, then this is for you!

*This was an honest review for a complimentary copy of The Stone Witch of Florence from Anna Rasche via NetGalley

I have to say my favorite historicals usually take place in Medieval and Renaissance Italy. One of them is the story of Ginevra, who became famous for her ability to heal the people suffering from the plague in Florence, and then notorious, tortured and exiled for being a heretic. More than a decade later, Florence again comes under attack by the plague and they want Ginevra back….
Immersive, insightful prose tells of Ginevra’s apprenticeship, romance, and fall from grace, how and why she returned to the place and the person who hurt her so. Highly recommended for lovers of historical novels.

“Magic, medicine, and religion were all tangled up with each other; it could be difficult to tell where one ended and the other began.”

Plot: ★★★★★
Characters: ★★★★★

The Stone Witch of Florence was a great time. It has a mix of witchery based on actual magical beliefs, medieval Italy, Catholicism, and the Black Plague combined to create an intriguing tale that kept me reading.

I haven't quite read anything like The Stone Witch of Florence before. If you enjoy fantasy based on actual historical events, women finding their own power in impossible situations, and underlying dry humor, I'm sure you will enjoy this book.

The writing was immersive, yet it felt a bit distant and impersonal. Rather than being a bad thing, I felt like the distant writing fit perfectly with the time period and made it feel more realistic and immersive.

I enjoyed each character (including Giancarlo and the gravedigger). The underlying humor was great - when the plot started feeling even a bit dragged on, some goofy medieval character would say something stupid, and I was right back in it.
"He is not whole. Not quite. Whoever heard of an evil spell using eleven of something? He will need twelve pieces. One for each of the apostles." "Well, there seems to be one part missing and it is not a loaf of bread." "Not THAT. Perverted woman. And besides, the left buttock of San Paolo is rather more complete than the right if you know what I mean.

Ah, yes, a penis joke in my historical fantasy. 10/5 stars.

Lastly, you can really tell that Anna Rasche put tons of effort and research into writing The Stone Witch of Florence. Kudos to you for writing such an interesting fantasy novel based on actual historical events.

5/5 stars! Thank you Anna Rasche, Park Row Publishing, and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to review this book.

I wanted to love this book, but the pacing was so slow that it was hard to stay focused on the narrative. The whole book felt like it moved at a glacial pace. I love a good description but there were times when the author would spend too much time focusing on minute details (like every single food available) and not so much on what would have been more interesting.

DNF - I attempted to start this book and it just did not hold my interest. This may be a book I come back to in the future.

The Stone Witch of Florence is an engaging and well written historical political fantasy by Anna Rasche. Released 8th Oct 2024 by HarperCollins on their Harlequin Trade imprint, it's 368 pages and is available in hardcover, audio, and ebook formats. Paperback due out from the same publisher in Aug 2025. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links.

Set in mid-14th century Florence, MC Ginevra has been exiled as a witch, but it called back to heal the sick, using her powers to tap the essences of precious stones. There's a geopolitical machinery in motion in which she's soon ensnared at great risk to herself.

The author has a good grasp of characterization, with clear, intelligent protagonists and a range of secondary characters. There are some issues with scene and dialogue (it's a debut novel), and there are long passages with a lot more "telling" than "showing". The only major, potentially deal breaking, issue is the pacing. It's glacial at points and it's not a short book, by any means. There are parts that were a slog to get through. Honestly, the author's *truly* impressive background research is admirable, but unless the reader is a fairly zealous history nerd, will likely prove an overabundance. The denouement and resolution felt rushed, for a book of this length.

Three and a half stars. It would be a good choice for public library acquisition, or for historical fantasy realism fans.

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.

The Stone Witch of Florence by Anna Rasche presents an intriguing premise with elements of magic and mystery, but it falls short in execution. The world-building is rich, and the characters have potential, but the pacing feels uneven at times. While it has its moments, there were a few plot twists that felt predictable and left me wanting more depth. Overall, it’s an okay read, but not something I’d rush to revisit.

This book is a pretty solid 3-star read for me.

Anna Rasche does a beautiful job with the historical aspect of this historical fiction. As a historian, Rasche has a solid foundation in this regard. Rasche paints the world of 14th century pandemic Florence. From the descriptions of architecture, to the prevalence of the plague, to the sheer desperation of people in the city, I found no fault with her writing. It is well informed and well done.

Rasche’s unique background as a gemologist, as well as a historian, lends this storyline an interesting and unique personality. The use of stones and gems, combined with witchcraft, in this setting is incredibly interesting.

I found the main character, Ginevra, exceptionally naive, and had a nard time relating to her as a character. Contextually, I understand that she lived a mostly sheltered upbringing, but even as an adult, I found some of her thoughts and actions frustratingly naive.

There is a lot of exposition in this book- the majority of the first half is just building and building and building. It’s not a very fast-paced book, and I found my mind wandering during some of the more foundational areas. While it is important for much of this to be laid, I find there may have been a more efficient way to incorporate the information we needed, without losing forward momentum.

Where this book was the most disappointing for me was the dialogue. Compared to the author’s writing of the historical aspects, the dialogue lacked the same sophistication. Again, there was a level of naivety.

I will say, the physical copy of this book is beyond beautiful. The flowered pattern, the blue-sprayed edges of the first edition copies, the end papers - all of them are visually stunning.

Long blocks of text for 400 pages is a tough sell, and I found myself skimming more often than not, especially the first chapters before Ginevra reaches Florence and the mystery begins. Definitely an original idea and a great witchy vibe--but it was just tough to physically get through.

Most of my hgh school students probably don't have the stamina to keep plodding through this one, but I'm adding it to my classroom library for the girls who devour anything witchy, mysterious, and magical!

***Thank you to NetGalley and to the publisher for providing me with a digital copy of this book to review.***

When I read the description of the this book, I was so excited! But this one just didn't do it for me. It was very wordy and seemed to meander through the story. I also got confused with some of the time jumps. I see the potential though and I look forward to seeing what the author has in store in the future. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC.

Historical fiction but make it witchy? Sign me up. I knew from the get-go that I was going to enjoy this. I loved everything about it, from the historical setting, to the writing style, to the magic. Easy 5 stars!

"A woman's secret. A deadly Plague. Unleash the hidden magic…"
The Stone Witch of Florence was one that drew me in by the intruging plot, but sadly this one was not for me. I struggled to get through this book because of how slow it seemed and at times it was confusing. The author did a good job with the world building and the historical details. The characters I could not connect to and I did not like. Sadly, this one was not for me but if you like fantasy or historical fiction then give this one a try. Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing/Park Row for this one in exchange of my honest review of The Stone Witch of Florence by Anna Rasche.

THE STONE WITCH OF FLORENCE is a beautifully written tale steeped in history and magical lore. Rasche effortlessly weaves together mysticism and intrigue with the reality of what a woman could go through once being forced into exile. It instantly transports the reader to a place in time where all of this seems very possible.

With this story, the author delivers a compelling and all-consuming read. I was pulled into Ginevra’s world from beginning to end, and I didn’t want to leave without knowing how her story would end. The secrets she had to keep, combined with the emotions of love, loss, and perceived betrayal, made this world come alive.

This book has heart, magic, and a mystery to solve surrounding what is going on with the missing relics. To make it better, the historical setting enriches the plot and creates an atmosphere ripe for duplicity and hidden truths. And this is why it was so good.

I usually enjoy reading books set in this time frame. I was pretty disappointed by this novel. It is set in the 1300's, in Italy. Genevra has been taught in the ancient ways of healing and heals through the power of stones. This part of the book was compelling--I believe in magic. My problem with this book is that I could not FEEL the times--too many parts of this book didn't fit the times. One thing that didn't shout fourteenth century was in the way the characters spoke to each other. The dialogue was straight out of the twentieth century.The other thing that didn't work for me: Genevra has been appointed to find out where the stolen religious artifacts went and who took them. In return, she would be safe to practice "medicine." Women did not do things like that in those times. I understand that this book was researched and I believe it was BUT I don't think that research went far enough to paint an accurate picture of Florence during the plague in 1330. I received a complimentary ARC from the publisher and NetGalley. This opinion is my own.

This was such an emotional and devastating book! The story is so strong and pulls you in immediately, and I loved the found family/sisters aspect so so much. The last 100 pages flew by because I was so anxious/excited, and I did not see that ending coming!

Witchy historical fiction? Yes please! This impressive debut had my attention from the get-go and clearly shows how well versed Anna Rasche is with this time period, especially for women and healers along with religious & magical superstitions and fear, at that time. In many ways it's eerily relevant to our present day.

The Stone Witch of Florence by Anna Rasche is a richly atmospheric historical novel that captivates with its blend of magic, mystery, and the dark backdrop of 14th-century Italy. Ginevra di Gasparo, a woman with the ability to heal using gemstones, is summoned back to Florence during the Black Plague after being exiled for her unorthodox powers. Instead of the healing work she expects, she is tasked with finding a thief who is stealing sacred relics. What follows is an engrossing mystery that reveals dangerous conspiracies and forces Ginevra to confront her past.

Rasche excels at creating a vivid historical setting, using the plague and medieval Florence as a chilling yet fascinating backdrop. Ginevra is a compelling protagonist—brave, intelligent, and determined to prove her worth despite being branded a witch. The pacing is solid, and while some plot twists are predictable, the suspense and intrigue keep the reader engaged.

For fans of historical fiction with a touch of the supernatural, The Stone Witch of Florence is an enchanting, well-crafted read.

This was an impressive debut novel. It is clear that Anna Rasche did her research to create an immersive picture of renaissance Italy. This story follows Ginerva di Gasparo as she returns to Florence during the plague. She has been enlisted to solve the mystery of who is stealing religious relics around the city, as the plague ravages the population. Ginerva's magic is very subtle, and I liked learning about the different kinds of stones and the "powers" associated with them. Fundamentally it is a story about one woman fighting for a life on her own terms at a time when women were not given much autonomy or power. I really enjoyed reading about her developing friendship with Lucia, an abandoned nobelwoman. The politics of the church, as exemplified in the character of Michele, the inquisitor, were also very interesting. I strongly recommend this book for anyone who is a fan of historical fiction, the fantasy elements were very subdued.

I enjoyed how Anna Rasche's set out a steady, engaging mystery plot. I am interested in reading whatever she comes out with next.

Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing for providing an eARC in return for my honest thoughts.

This book captivated me from the first page. Historical time piece, Italy, plague - say less. I ate it up. Easily a 5 star read.

3.5 || This started off strong, but it didn't stick the landing.

I was thoroughly enjoying this until quite literally the second half. From the 51% mark onwards, the main plot kicked off and unfortunately disappointed me.

So what is the plot?

Well, we mainly follow Ginevra, a young woman that has been called back from her exile to the city of Florence in the late 1340's—AKA: peak Black Death time. As pestilence takes the lives of many, another thief stalks the streets of Florence taking something else almost just as valuable to the Florentines: their relics. The holy relics that the many churches of Florence keep safe. That is until this mysterious thief starts collecting them, stripping the city of its holy protectors.
This is why Ginevra has been summoned from her hometown of Genoa—to find the culprit and return these most scared items to the Florentines. The reason she was given this task being the very reason she was banished in the first place. Ginevra is a woman with a special touch—a magic touch some might say—who can heal people in miraculous ways. The Inquisitor hopes that this woman who appears to be immune to the incurable disease can do her sleuthing without dying on him, as all of his men have. He also secretly hopes that someone learned in more mystical arts might be able to understand how exactly this thief has managed to steal the relics with ease and without getting caught. And so we follow Ginevra in her quest all the while learning about her past and her "heretical" practice.

Let's start with some pros shall we?

🔮 I really enjoyed Ginevra's characterization (which was mainly focused on in the first half) and her backstory—specifically the part where she learns about her magical ability and how to use it. I enjoyed reading about her dynamics and interactions with the other characters.

🔮 The magic in this book, which as the title suggests, has a lot to do with stones/gems and the many properties they possess. This was particularly interesting to read about and I think Rasche did a good job of setting up this magic system in that she explained everything well and at a decent pace.

🔮 The setting was particularly interesting in that anything set so far back as the 1300's is going to pique my interest, but it is also the fact that I happen to live in Florence that I found myself captivated by the descriptions of this historic city. Many of the piazze and its churches and other landmarks described in this novel are very familiar to me. I can attest that Florence is a magical city, making it all the more believable to this reader that a city such as Firenze can hold all kinds of secrets. I enjoyed reading about a city I am personally attached to, as well as being able to conjure up the streets I walk on daily, with it's river Arno that I depend on to guide me back home.

Alas, the big, bad con

⚰️ After the novel finishes with Ginevra's backstory, it becomes entirely plot-focused. Sadly, I found myself trudging along, getting through unnecessarily lengthy scenes that didn't appear to be of any importance until the very end. Instead of maintaining a good pace all throughout, the second half was repetitive and tedious in nature. There was a lot of back and forth that stole away a lot of the initial excitement, and it all led to what I found to be quite an anticlimactic ending.
I think many readers might find the ending to be satisfying, and objectively, so did I, but the novel lost its momentum as the pace slowed. This also affected my overall enjoyment of the "mystery" we are introduced to at the very beginning.

I think this can be a perfect book to many readers, and I hope in falls into those hands!

✨Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing | Park Row for providing me with this ARC in exchange for my honest review.✨