Member Reviews

Historical Fiction at its finest...

In "What the Mountains Remember" Joy Callaway weaves real landmarks, events, and people into a fictional story of self-discovery, stubborn love, and the grit of ordinary people. A beautifully heartfelt page-turner full of detailed imagery and interesting characters. The author clearly did her research to bring the Grove Park Inn and the Vagabonds to life with her distinct imagination and heart.

Was this review helpful?

This story is set in 1913, North Carolina, during the built of the Grove Park Inn. Belle Newbold and her parents are invited along for a glamping adventure, during which the hotel is visited, and Belle starts to write an article about the Inn and all the people taking part in its built. Still traumatized by the loss of her birth father, Belle does not want to marry for love. She agrees to get engaged to Worth Delafield, the owner of the land being used for their campsite, who she has only met once before. Worth feels similar about love matches, but both of them soon come to care more for each other than they intended.

What drew me to this story was the beautiful cover and the atmosphere it promised. I was not disappointed in this regard and thoroughly enjoyed the descriptions of the mountains and the construction of the impressive Grove Park Inn. Belle, coming from a modest background, pays much attention to the people around her and makes them feel valued, especially when it comes to those people she interviews for her article. Her approach to writing was very wholesome and heartwarming. As a result, this book was an homage to the workers on the construction site.

I really liked Belle and Worth’s characters and their growth. The story turned out to be much more romantic than I thought it would be, a welcome surprise in my eyes.

The only thing that dulled the wholesome atmosphere of the book for me, was Marie Austen, Belle’s cousin. Her character is rather annoying from the start, and the reader quickly learns that something will go wrong whenever she is around. She is childish, selfish, jealous, and constantly scheming for an advantage. Her character is rather one dimensional and did not add much to the story in my eyes.

Overall, this was an enjoyable and surprising read for me. I listened to the audiobook version of the book and can highly recommend this format.

Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Collins Focus for gifting me this ALC of the audiobook to review.

Was this review helpful?

This novel was based on the history of the Grove Park Inn of North Carolina.
Belle Newbold is invited to join a Vagabond camping tour and writes the history of the people that built Grove Park.
A great story of the challenges of being brave enough to find love.
Thanks to @NetGalley and @HarperCollinsFocus for the opportunity to listen to this audiobook.

Was this review helpful?

I fell in love with this story. It centers around Belle Newbold, a young woman attending a Henry Ford vagabond camping tour in Asheville, NC with her parents. Belle is struggling with the reminders of her childhood as she gets to know the man she is engaged to marry and becomes fascinated with the construction of the Grove Park Inn. Historical fiction isn't typically a genre I pick up, but I'm so glad that I kept coming back to the description for What the Mountains Remember. The setting, characters and the history all come together to create a wonderful story that drew me in. I will be searching out more of Joy Callaway's books.

The narrator did a fantastic job as well!

Thank you to #NetGalley and #HarperCollinsFocus and #HarperMuse for a free copy of #WhattheMountainsRemember by Joy Callaway. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to @harpermusebooks for allowing me this audiobook for review. Honestly, I just love #historicalfiction and the cover of this just screams that and of beautiful American mountains … this story has so many themes that I enjoy: rags to riches, a plucky female lead who goes against the conventional expectations of her class and gender to seek her true happiness, MC’s with wonderful heart and souls, fought against feelings, and an actual place and time fictionalized with well-researched actual history of an actual place. The author does all this and creates a story that feels like a warm hug with just enough tension to propel the novel forward in a perfect flow. I really also enjoyed the narrator of this @britpressley who narrated this with multiple different voices of male and female flawlessly and evoked all the right emotions in them! Awesome job! As for the author, @joywcal, her author’s note at the end made me realize that there was an actual place she was talking about in the story, a place that she often visited in her youth, and one that she decided to research and write about in a way that brought to light all of the laborers that helped create the gorgeous resort. (Grove Park, NC) her MC Belle of said rags to riches, had to keep her origins hidden from “polite society” to avoid being shunned (a big part of the tension of the story) and due to her origins, she writes of and tries to help the workers of this estate, who many of were inflicted with TB. The workers of early America, without employer sick leave, were working til they dropped, to avoid their families from starving, infecting others in the process. There is so much to be said about how the author (and Belle) gave a voice to the poor mountain folk, showing the poverty, yet pride and work ethics of those people. I really enjoyed this story & recommend it for those that love early 1900s American historical fiction, mountain resorts, love stories and/or just an overall feel-good story!!
Thanks again to @harpermusebooks for this opportunity. Thanks to Joy (from me, Hope) for bringing this place to my consciousness, I’m sure I’d love to see it one day!!

Was this review helpful?

What the Mountains Remember
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
A perfect great Historical fiction story that has everything you want it to be. Unique setting, story, & characters that makes you want to keep turning the pages. Bonus is some fun romance too. I love all of Joy's books. This is another lovely story!
Thank you NetGalley for this opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

Moving from poverty to immense wealth after a tragic accident, Belle Newbold must keep her past a deep secret in order to continue living in luxury and marry well. Set in Edwardian Asheville with a lush North Carolina mountain backdrop "What the Mountains Remember" is the story of a poor miner's daughter learning to trust and let love in.

I wasn't a huge fan of the insufferable cousin and overacting performed by the audiobook narrator, so I definitely recommend reading this one instead of listening. It might make the melodramatic side character more tolerable.

**Thank you NetGalley for a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.**

Was this review helpful?

Author Joy Calloway has brought to light another piece of history in this fictional story. She combines her research on the construction of Grove Park Inn near Asheville, NC with a fictional story of those who built this magnificent inn.

Belle has not been back to the Inn since her father died and she, her mother ,and stepfather are returning for a "glamping" trip, or what was then called "Vagabonds", with Henry Ford. She hopes to reunite with Worth, her future fiance. An arranged marriage but she likes it that way. So many challenges face Belle on what she sees is a simple way to a life with money and without worries. So many secrets from the past she discovers. But no one escapes life without problems - in the present and from the past.

The Author's Note is not to be missed!

My thanks to Net Galley and Harper Muse for an advanced copy of this e-book and Harper Collins Focus for an advanced copy of the audiobook. Narration by Brittany Pressley was especially good!

Was this review helpful?

Joy Callaway has once again written a page turner. She has a way of creating a time and place in history that I can easily escape into. In this novel, the setting is 1913 Asheville, North Carolina, during the building of the beautiful Grove Park Inn. The heroine, Belle Newbold, is participating in one of Henry Ford's Vagabonds camping tours. Another member of the tour group is Worth Delafield, a man she's agreed to marry, though she met him only once years before. Both Belle and Worth have experienced tragic loss and deep grief causing them both to vow to not fall in love, to protect their hearts from grief again. Their relationship is certainly not a case of "where fools rush in", but a slow burn of two people realizing they are not only perfect for each other, but a balm to the soul of the other. During their stay in the mountains around Asheville, Belle has the opportunity to interview the construction workers on the Inn for an article to promote the Inn's opening. Through these interviews, you appreciate the danger, risk, and incredible craftsmanship behind the Inn, and learn of Asheville's history too. The book is set in April, and lush descriptions of Asheville's landscape make this a great spring read.

Was this review helpful?

WHAT THE MOUNTAINS REMEMBER by Joyce Callaway

Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Muse Audiobooks for the audiobook of, What the Mountains Remember.

Narration by Brittany Pressley, whose readings are always well done and enjoyable. This is my first read by Joy Callaway and was captivated because of the Grove Park Inn, in the North Carolina mountains. It is a beautiful place to visit that is built on the slope of Sunset Mountain overlooking the tops of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Known by locals as, the
Eighth Wonder
of the World. Joy Callaway brings to life the construction and the grandeur of the Grove Park Inn along with the struggles of the laborers tasked with the construction.

I loved the telling of the famed Vagabonds and their summer wilderness camping trips. In 1913, Belle Newbold, along with her family, are invited by Henry Ford to embark on this spectacular trip; primarily to reunite with her future fiancée, the owner of the land the Vagabonds are using for their campsite. This novel delves into the lives of historical figures like Henry Ford, Thomas Edison, and Harvey Firestone which I found intriguing.

The group is invited to tour the Grove Park Inn and Belle finds herself thrust in the position of writing of the construction of the inn. Both Belle and her future fiancé are struggling to fit in society and finding who they are meant to be. A moving novel that explores memories from the past, forging a new future, and how hardships that have been endured can make us stronger. Touching upon hope, self-discovery, and love in this wonderfully researched novel.

Was this review helpful?

@joywcal does such a fantastic job of researching her novels to make them accurate to the time period and have tidbits of truth in her novels. All The Pretty Places was my favorite non-thriller read last year and Joy’s newest novel, What The Mountains Remember is equally as good. The story is set in Asheville, NC while the famous Grove Park Inn was being constructed in 1913. The main character, Belle Newbold is on a family vacation in the area and is tasked with writing an article about the Grove Park Inn for the local paper. The story is historical fiction with a dash of romance. It has themes surrounding socioeconomic issues from that time period, as well as the health and wellbeing of laborers. I cannot recommend this book enough especially if you love strong female protagonists in historical fiction novels. I loved the narration in the audiobook and thought that Brittany Pressley really brought the characters and story to life.

Thank you @harpermusebooks for allowing me to listen to this audiobook in exchange for my honest review.

(This same review was shared on the Barnes & Noble website)

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley and Harper Muse Audio for the free audiobook in exchange for my honest review. This is narrated by Brittany Pressley who does a great job!

This is a historical drama and romance set in 1913, North Carolina. The Vagabonds members, Henry Ford, Thomas Edison, Harvey Firestone and John Burroughs are going on one of their camping tours and along with them is the family of Belle Newbold. The story focuses on the building of a remarkable historic landmark, the Grove Park Inn near Asheville, NC, with a story that intertwines both real and fictional figures.

The nearby town of Asheville, once a tourist destination, is now (1913) used to house tuberculosis patients and in sanatoriums. Belle is horrified when she sees how many people have tuberculosis.

Belle and her suitor, Worth, were as likable of characters as her cousin, Marie, was as unlikeable. I felt the courting between the younger pairs was appropriately done for the timeline.

It was nice to read a historical fiction novel that was not based upon WWII but on another time in history that I really did not know much about. The characters for the most part behaved as expected for 1913, with a car trip to a park for camping by very wealthy families.

3 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Title: What the Mountains Remember
Author: Joy Callaway
Narrated by: Brittany Pressley
Publisher: Harper Muse
Length: Approximately 12 hours and 16 minutes
Source: Thank-you to NetGalley for the audiobook review copy. Thank-you Bethany House and Austenprose for the review copy of the physical book.

Do you prefer to read indoors or outdoors? I love both!

What the Mountains Remember by Joy Callaway is the story of a young woman named Belle Newbold set in 1913. Belle was a miner’s daughter, but after her father’s death, her mother remarried a titan of industry, Shipley Newbold. Both Belle and her mother are afraid that their past will be found out and they will be thrown out of their life of luxury. Belle is determined to marry for convenience to make sure she has a good life where she never will have to worry about hunger. Worth Delafield seems like the perfect match who can give her all that she asks for. When Henry Ford invites the Newbold family on one of the Vagabond camping trips, Belle gets to know Worth better and determine what is important to her in life.

I just discussed how I want to visit North Carolina and visit the Biltmore estate as part of a review last week. This novel gave me another North Carolina point to visit, Grove Park Inn, which is called the eighth wonder of the world. This Inn is in Ashville, North Carolina and it was a major construction project in the early 20th century.

My thoughts on this novel:
• I loved that this novel focused on how buildings are usually remembered by the person who financed them, but the architect and construction workers who made it possible are often overlooked. I will also put engineer in this category as I have spent my life designing large projects that dignitaries get gold shovels at while I stood in the background. I loved how Belle loved to talk and learn about all the people who worked on this construction project.

• This book was a love story to Asheville and the Appalachian mountains and the people who lived, worked, and died there.

• I really disliked Belle’s “friend” Marie Austen. Marie Austen had a lot of cringe worthy behavior in this book both to Belle and to men. She might win the award for worst fictional friend ever.

• It was interesting learning about the TB crisis in North Caroline during this time period. It’s interesting and sad that there was a real fear that TB hospitals would overtake the community.

• I loved the characters of Belle and Worth. I loved learning more about them and how they learned more about each other and came to an understanding. I also loved how Belle was able to work on an article about the Grove Park Inn and highlight the workers. I enjoyed that she had a coming of age herself and discovered what she really wanted out of life.

• This novel has a marriage of convenience and friends to lovers’ tropes. The romance was beautiful in this novel.

• The camping trip with the Vagabonds was very interesting, but the Vagabonds were very much minor background characters. It left me wanting to know more about their adventures.

• There was a great author’s note at the end of the novel that discusses how the author has visited and been fascinated with Grove Park Inn since she was a child. It discussed her research and changes that she made to make her story work.

• I read this book both physically and on audiobook and kept switching to whatever format worked best for me at the time. I had a lot of travel during the last couple of weeks, so this worked well for me. Brittany Pressley was a great narrator.

• This was my first Joy Callaway novel, but it won’t be my last.

Overall, What the Mountains Remember by Joy Callaway was an excellent historical fiction novel with a great unique setting, interesting characters, and wonderful romance.

Was this review helpful?

I love the Grove Park Inn so when I saw the cover, I knew I had to read it. I loved the background and details into the building of the Grove Park Inn. Bella tries to play it safe and marry for security over love but is happy to learn that Worth Delafield feels the same way. The love story was definitely second fiddle to the history of the Grove Park, but I thought it was a good read.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting book to read. It is a picture of the haves and have nots. The Vagabonds were a group that Henry Ford started. The very rich would go camping, (More like glamping) They would learn about the area they were in and participate in different "outdoorsy" games. It was all fun and games.
Belle Newbald and her mother are invited to join one of the Vagabond's trips. She heads to the mountains around Ashville NC. What she finds there is the memories of her past that her and her mother have vowed to keep secret. They also visit Grove Park Inn and see the wonder some claimed was the 8th wonder of the world.
Joy Callaway pens an tale of not the rich backers of the building of the Grove Park Inn, but of the workers who actually built the place. It made me want to do more research into the building. What a place!
This was an enjoyable tale and I am glad I read it.

Was this review helpful?

"What the Mountains Remember" offers a detailed look at the building of the Grove Park Inn in the early 1900's. I loved the setting, the romance, and the touches of real history like the Vagabonds camping trips. However, I feel there was a bit too much detail written about the construction of the inn itself. I think a higher level of information could have sufficed, and taken roughly 50 pages out of the story, which I feel it could have benefited from. Other than this small critique, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and look forward to checking out more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

This book had a great writing style. I loved the imagery used to describe Asheville in the past. The storyline reminded me of the Bridgetown books with more historical representation. While I found a lot of the plot to be predictable, I still think it was an enjoyable book.

Was this review helpful?

What a truly beautiful book!
Once again this one made me feel all the feels…
Love, heartbreak, jealousy, hatred, and the huge open hole that’s left when you lose someone you love!

Belle Newbold is a young woman who does not really want to get married.
She lost her Dad several years ago in a mining accident and was shattered afterwards. Her Mom, who loved her Dad, heart and soul, never imagined she would love again…yet she found love…and her life and her daughter’s changed forever.
Her new husband is a gas magnate with huge pockets…as opposed to their humble beginnings of living paycheck to paycheck.
When her stepfather introduces her to Worth Delafield, who is also wealthy and looking for a wife…things are about to change for her…. But, is her heart in it?

This one made me laugh and smile as many times as it brought me to tears!
It is so beautifully painted and told…

And Belle is such a beautiful soul. You can actually FEEL her love and tenderness as it unfolds throughout the storylines. ❤️

The same cannot be said for her cousin. She is meanness personified…over and over….

On this journey you will see Belle grow and learn as her horizons expand…and the changes she makes will be felt for lifetimes to come!
And the fact that she is open, willing and eager to take things on that women of that time would never even consider…well, that just speaks volumes!

Beautiful story with remarkable, wholesome, kind, loving bones!

5 + ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ for me!

#WhatTheMountainsRemember by #JoyCalloway and narrated beautifully by #BrittanyPressley.

Thanks so much to #NetGalley and #HarperCollinsFocus and #HaperMuse for an ARC of the audiobook which was released on 4/2/24…so you should be able to find it on shelves now! I am so happy to have been gifted this ARC…It is truly special!!

Feel free to like, follow and friend me on: Goodreads,
IG @ #BookReviews_with_emsr or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine.

Thanks so much for reading! And if you 'liked' my review, please share with your friends!! 📚⭐️

Was this review helpful?

I loved this story by Joy Callaway! What the Mountains Remember is the story of two people determined to not fall in love. Worth and Belle truly believe that love only leads to heartache because of past experiences. Their relationship is to be a practical one, with no emotion attached to each other. However, the reality is that life doesn’t work that way. Join them as they face their past and hope for their future. You’ll be glad you did!
Also, the narrator did a great job!

Was this review helpful?

Belle Newbold knows she walks a precarious line, and it has never been more obvious until now. Her stepfather Shipley has been invited by friend Henry Ford on one of his famous vagabond weekends camping, or rather “glamping” in the Blue Ridge Mountains. Having been raised in the mountains of West Virginia as a small child she hasn’t seen a peak in seven years, since her father’s mining days. And her heart aches being back in nature where she feels most like herself.
When her biological father died in an accident her mother fell into a deep depression and fought her way out of it and out of that life. With a few white lies, Belle’s mother moved them into a new life with Shipley in Gas City. In this life, Belle is well educated and pampered. Shipley has even helped arrange a marriage between her and Worth Delafield, which is pretty astounding considering his fortune will be left to his biological son and a small pension for Belle’s mother, and not a penny will follow Belle.

When a reporter on the the Vagabond camping trip is thrown out, Belle is unexpectedly thrusted into the roll of reporting on the new Grove Park Inn. A role recommended for her by Worth after he boasted of her writing abilities he’s seen displayed through their correspondence. She prefers researching and interviewing the workers at Grove Inn rather than tromping around participating in Ford’s made-up contests in their camp.

This trip aides Belle in realizing how fragile her future is, and what she really wants in life. With her stepfather’s friend’s a stone’s throw from the workers of Grove Park Inn, Belle sees their circumstances in sharp contrast and does what she can to shed light on blue collar America in her article.

Joy Callaway has obviously taken great care with her historical research, especially the information pertaining to the spread of consumption, and building construction of the time period. Belle is an easy character to admire, but I found her cousin irritating every time she appeared on the page. Though I enjoyed the story, parts of it did lag a little for me.

Thank you to NetGalley, Harper Muse, and the author Joy Callaway for the advanced copy of the audiobook. What the Mountains Remember is out now. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?