I loved this book. Great characters. The story had a lot going on, and there was a complicated back story that was vivid, engaging, and felt very real. The small town setting description was good. New York City was a good backdrop as well in parts of the book, but I felt throwing 9/11 in the mix didn't add much to the story. The main character felt a little unglued in her actions at times. Impulsive. Overall though, an engaging and emotional read about impossible choices that many have to make in life. It was relatable and well-written.

Brilliant, engaging, thrilling from start to finish. Loved the atmosphere. The writing was both stylish and easy to read. I'd read more from this author.

An unimaginable incident occurs ultimately involving several families and generations. This is a poignant story of love, lost and found but always changing as time passes.
It is one of the most moving and emotion filled stories I have ever read. It is also one the the best books of the year.

This book is much more than a legal thriller. It was a riveting, gut wrenching story with a variety of believable and unique characters. The reader is taken on a journey with two connected families dealing with past/present tragedies while experiencing a myriad of emotions from grief, hope, blame, love and most importantly, forgiveness.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

A thought provoking and devastating story that spans decades and settings between Colorado and New York. When a 13 year old shoots and kills her brother lives are shattered. Two families with a complicated and troubled history must confront events in their past as they navigate the current tragedy. It is a story of complicated families, redemption and forgiveness. I enjoyed and recommend this book.

I’ll start out with the good. She’s a very good writer with smooth, flowing prose and a well developed enfolding of the story. Good transitions between past and present. However, one of the main characters, Angie, demonstrated no penitence whatsoever. I always enjoy an author who makes me hate a character, but I don’t think that was the author’s intent. This would be a great book club read as it provokes much discussion and ranting. Thank you so much NetGalley and Celadon Books for the opportunity to read this novel.