Member Reviews

A sweet book about kids connecting with a tree, missing a tree, and problem solving to plant a new tree. I wish there was a little more why that particular tree was so important or what makes a beech tree unique compared to other types of tree, but it doesn't add those additional layers and just keeps the story on the surface. Nothing wrong with that, just pointing it out. I will probably check out a physical copy of the book from the library, an electronic copy doesn't quite do it justice. It very well could be a classroom favorite for younger kids, depending on size and binding. Especially if you can get them outside and under a tree when reading it.

Was this review helpful?

In this heartwarmIng story a kindergarten class discovers that their favorite tree has been cut down and must figure out a way to work together to honor their beloved tree while taking action to help their community. I really enjoyed this story of community, activism, and creating beautiful, green spaces for all to enjoy.

Was this review helpful?

I found it very hard to rate children's books so everything is a 5 star read for me!!
I really loved this book, the illustrations are so beautiful and captivating that I found myself smiling through every page I read.
The story itself is very beautiful and inspiring <3

Was this review helpful?

Environmental justice based on a true story, I absolutely love this book!

The writing is perfect, it’s probably one of the smoothest stories I’ve read, I can see kids up to. 12 years old reading this, and not getting bored at all. It directs kids from a young age to value nature around them and connect with it, offers them ways to overcome their sadness of losing a valuable tree, including uniting their efforts to collect money and plant a new tree to love. I definitely will be looking forward to more books by Rasha, her direction is inspiring.

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyed "Hello, Beech Tree" by Rasha Hamid. Beautifully illustrated and a sweet story about the love of a tree, along with collective action from schoolchildren. Recommended. Thanks to Netgalley for the eARC.

Was this review helpful?

What a sweet story! I loved it. The illustrations were gorgeous and the story was perfect. It encourages littles to take action, be curious, and ask questions.
I love that this was based on a true story and even has questions at the end to get more involved and in depth. What a beautiful book!

Was this review helpful?

Hello, Beech Tree is a beautiful, true story, about kids in New York developing community and relationship around a tree. The illustrations are attractive and really tie the story to nature. Kids will be inspired by the power the students were able to exert on their own. They made a better place, just by acting to love nature.

Was this review helpful?

Cute story!

Loved the understanding as to why the tree was removed, then the action plan of planting another one, along with a realistic timeline.

Was this review helpful?

To what extent does the love of a class go for their favorite beech tree? The tree that gave them shade and brought them joy. When they found that the tree was gone, the class gave it their all to raise money and get a new tree in its place. It’s a simple story but has a very deep message hidden beneath it.

In these times and age, when thousands of trees get cut every year to make way for development of infrastructure, one ought to ask themselves, at what cost does it come to us? The parks and the trees, these places where some core memories are formed, of both children and elderly alike, what would happen if they disappear?

You would not want that. And when humanity realizes this mistake of theirs, it would cost them a great deal to undo the damage. This simple children’s story makes one ponder, about our actions and it’s effect on environment and how it affects our children.

I think there’s a great deal to learn from this book, by means of the initiatives the beech class takes to bring a new beech tree in the old ones place.

Rating- 3.4/5

Was this review helpful?

Hello, Beech Tree!
by Rasha Hamid
The book shows the young children's connection to nature near their school. When their beloved tree is taken down for safety they get together to solve the problem. The children fundraise... they work to get a new tree planted although they still have a connection to the old tree.
Showing how children can find ways to help their environment and social change.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with this book for free in exchange for my review! All opinions are my own.

This book was heartbreakingly beautiful. I don't really expect children's books to be sad, but this one kind of was. However, it also kind of needed to be in order for the lessons of this book to come out strong on the pages. Like leaves on trees, there are many seasons of life, and the children in this book experienced one of them. I definitely recommend this book!


Connect with Me <3

My blog is https://bookreviewsbyjules.blogspot.com/


Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/44083250-julia (follow me and/or send a friend request!) - This is how I keep track of all of the books I read each year. I also crosspost all of my NetGalley reviews here.

Instagram/bookstagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookreviewsbyjules/ (I try my best to follow back all Book accounts back in 48-72 hours)

2nd Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bookreviewsbyjules_/ (This account is used as a backup Instagram because my original bookstagram account which I created in 2022 has been getting action blocked quite frequently (I was hacked in February 2024 and lost access to my account for about 5 days, and I think that has something do with why I have been having issues with my account. I have reported the issue to Instagram several times). I try to post on Instagram at least 3x a week. I post many NetGalley ARC books on Instagram, but I also enjoy talking about previously released books that I love. With the exception of NetGalley books, I enjoy both listening to and reading all the books I read.

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61556223311374

Substack: https://bookreviewsbyjules.substack.com/ (feel free to subscribe!)

Tik Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bookreviewsbyjules?lang=en

StoryGraph: https://app.thestorygraph.com/profile/bookreviewsbyjules

Was this review helpful?

This was a beautiful story that reminds us to look up at the trees and say hello. The story follows a class of kindergarteners who are draw to the city’s beech tree but find it gone one afternoon. Together they rally to honor the tree and leave a green fingerprint in their city. It’s such a wonderful message to all kids that no matter how young they can make a difference in their community and school. The facts at the end of the book was fascinating as well. What a great story!!!

Was this review helpful?

This is the true story of a Kindergarten class named the Beech Class, after the Beech tree that lived in the park near their school. They would visit each day to say hello and enjoy it. One day, they came out to find the Beech tree had been cut down due to illness. They decided to raise money to plant a new tree. They raised enough money to plant a new Beech tree the following year.

Great, true story with beautiful illustrations. I loved the letter from the author, the questions to think about and the how to take action section too. This would be a great read aloud for Arbor Day!

Was this review helpful?

I received a free ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

This was a beautiful true story. I loved the illustrations and the text flowed well. I liked the action points at the end.

Was this review helpful?

This is a story about a kindergarten class in Brooklyn who loved a beech tree in a park near its school. The tree was cut down by the park ranger. Find the reason why and how the class was able to solve this problem. This is a heartwarming story of the children’s love over a tree. In the end, they found ways to bring back their tree by being creative and taking action. I wish we got to see the gradual growth of the tree from a sapling to the full-grown tree.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks NetGalley for the ARC!

A very sweet story of kids living their tree. A class of children in New York City loves their beech tree well through all seasons. It’s very engaging for little one and bigger ones too!

Was this review helpful?

"Hello, beech tree! You look beautiful today!," sing the children of the Beech Tree class in Brooklyn, NY. They play, eat and observe critters under the canopy of the beech tree. Until one day, they arrive to find just a stump where their beloved tree once stood. A charming story of love and loss of a favorite thing - and what even a child can do to honor it and bring it back. Beautiful illustrations that draw you into the story. I loved this book - and love that it is based on a true story and ends with discussion questions and ideas that children can use to make a difference of their own.

Was this review helpful?

What a lovely book about nature, group, learning, and growing.

Very cute story with great illustrations.

Thank you Net Galley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is:
A true story
A nature story
A story that teaches science
A very sweet picture book with gorgeous pictures about young children

In the US, most people live in cities, and we don't spend enough time appreciating nature. These children loved a special tree and, when it got sick and had to be cut down, they worked together to get a new tree while still honoring the original. Fantastic book.

Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read this

Was this review helpful?

"Hello, Beech Tree" written by Rasha Hamid and illustrated by Sofia Moore, is a children's picture book about the true story of a kindergarten class in Brooklyn, New York. The class was called the Beech Class and named after a huge Beech tree in the path near the school. The kids loved the tree. One day, their Beech tree was missing. It had to be cut down because it was sick. They decide to raise money to get a new one planted. They succeed, and the new tree is planted the following fall.

The pictures by Sofia Moore are colorful and easy to understand.

This book supports the idea of environmental justice. The idea is that everyone deserves to live in a clean and safe space with green areas. This is a great book I highly recommend!

Thank you to Netgalley, Teacher Created Materials - Free Spirit Publishing, and author Rasha Hamid for providing this ARC e-book so I could give you my honest review.

Was this review helpful?