Member Reviews

MUAH I LOOOOOOOOOOOVE THIS.
Caste Summer is so goood!!!!!. everything about this webtoon is amazing and beautiful.
I loved the concept of the story and plot which was done brilliantly. The creation of the magical Sea World was fantastic.
The main leads stole my heart they were so very cute and delightful. The artwork and colorful illustrations were mind-blowing.
Great great great graphic novel about two mermans who have been born to fulfill their destiny with or without their own choice but all they want is to find themselves, live their lives without all the burden of others.
Can't wait for this to release so I can have it on my shelf and excited about volume 2.
Thank you NetGalley and Ten Spread Press for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely stunning usage of color theory in this webtoon. The formatting is beautifully translated from webtoon scrolling to book format. The story does a great job giving you the understanding of what’s happening with the Beacon in a playful tone but knows when to deal out the darker more crucial tones like with the sharks’ curse. This is also supported by the color shifts in how dark blues and purples shroud the sharks and their lair, which draws out the bright pink and red scars they suffer from. The Beacon’s bright yellow scales are also a literal symbol of hope. Very excited to see this in its published version.

Was this review helpful?

I remember reading this back when it first came out on webtoon and absolutely loving it. I was so excited to see that it was getting a print edition and jumped at the chance to read the ARC. I still love the artwork and enjoy the story. At times, I found both Siren and Kappa a bit too awkward and would have to step away because of the second hand embarrassment, but I loved watching their relationship grow. I’m probably going to have to redownload the webtoon app to reread this series.
I can say, though, that this volume is mostly setup. The plot is introduced, but you are mainly just learning about the characters and their motives. The ending of this volume is pretty abrupt and leaves you on a bit of a cliffhanger. That said though, you can always finish reading it on webtoon for free (at least I assume webtoon is still free, it was starting to make you pay for comics more and more when I was last on it). If you are looking for a cute story with an interesting setup, I recommend checking this one out..

Was this review helpful?

SOOOOOOOOOOOO GOOD!! I can not EXPRESS HOW GOOD THIS WAS.
The art, the story, the characters omgg. SO GOOD.
Unlike some manga/yaoi/bl/whatever, there is an easy plot to follow and you don't have to fill in any gaps yourself.
The boys are so sweet and the art IS SO CUTE.
When siren gets nervous and boils omg. I boiled with him.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for access. Overall it’s a cute YA story about young mermen feeling the burden of prophecies, family expectations, and little control over their own lives. While I’ve only read this first volume, it’s an interesting underwater world with a budding romance on the horizon. Sweet start to a story, but probably not something I’ll continue.

Was this review helpful?

Castle Swimmer is a gorgeously illustrated graphic novel about the burden of destiny. Both Kappa and Siren had their lives predetermined at the time they were born. Kappa is the Beacon - he is drawn to places to fulfill their prophecies - literally pulled from place to place without care for what he wants. Siren is the prince of the shark kingdom, destined to kill the Beacon and save his civilization. When Kappa and Siren meet, it's like looking in the mirror - each one a young merman who was never given the agency to discovery themselves. Siren knows what he is destined to do, but as the two grow closer they push their fates further away and grow closer. Teens will love this sweet graphic novel about choosing to define yourself. Excited to see what's in store for Kappa and Siren in volume 2!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this story so so much. It's absolutely wonderful. So whimsical and heartwarming. I fell in love with the two main characters Kappa and Siren. And the plot is very interesting. I can't wait to read more. I had a blast reading volume 1. And the artwork is so very beautiful. I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

This is not my first time reading Castle Swimmer by Wendy Martin. I like many other readers started reading it on Webtoon years ago. But I personally struggled with Webtoon's format and a bad connection. So, I'm so happy and excited that Castle Swimmer is being released as a comic/graphic novel series!

It has been so long since I read Castle Swimmer on Webtoon that I didn't remember much of the story. What I did remember was I loved Castle Swimmer. I may be a bit bias. However, this was the first nostalgia read for me that felt like I was reading it for the first time all over again. The Characters, the lore, the art, the plot its so good! It all just pulled me in and I was and am content to stay.

The main characters Kappa and Siren are precious and relatable. I just want to hug them. They deserve hugs with the trauma they carry. Speaking of which, this volume cut off at the perfect moment. Nearly all the characters are left in intense time sensitive situations. The cliff hanger has me wishing the second volume was already out. Even though this (the first) volume isn't even out yet. (One of the downside to ARCs).

In my opinion Wendy Martin has done an amazing job at creating the fantastical world of Castle Swimmer. We as the readers are given so much information but it is not in any way overwhelming. We get to see a bit of the world and its magic. We are introduced to the main characters as well as several other types of Mer. The lore is just so interesting. We little glimpses of different cultures and see so many different prophecies and how bias changed them. That combined with themes of loneliness, self-sacrifice, and fate not always being what it seems sets up the story beautifully. I can't wait to read the next volume in the series.

Overall, I'm excited for the next volume. Not just because I love the story and characters, but because I do remember one big event in this series and it didn't happen in this volume. I could see it being set up through the actions of different characters. I am so ready for more. Are there going to be more types of Mer? Whats going to happen to Kappa? Whats to become of the seemingly doomed budding romance? I can't wait to find out, I can't wait to finally finish reading this story. Lastly I want to say that the little extras included at the end were delightful.

Was this review helpful?

I sadly think this one just wasn't for me, tha pacing and length of the volume did really take me out of the story. It feels like such an interesting series but the set up wasn't enough to draw me in.
The way the panels were set up made the reading experience feel convoluted.
The artstyle is absolutely gorgeous and i freaking love the color palette.
Overall i recommend checking it out

Was this review helpful?

the main characters are quite interesting! i love the simple art design and the thought-out worldbuilding rules that the author shared on the end. i like the struggles that the prince is facing and i'm interested in knowing how his story will go

Was this review helpful?

Not only was this incredibly cute and colorful it was also delightfully gay and sweet. I love a nice yet complex and deep gay love story and I cannot wait for the next book to come out. The colors are so amazing I just know this is beautiful in person and I desperately need a physical copy now.

Was this review helpful?

castle swimmer was my favorite webtoon in high school, 6ish years ago now, and when i saw its becoming a physical book (releasing on my birthday, at that) i was SO excited. i adore this story, the characters, the plot, and the author does an incredible job of explaining the plot and what’s happening while not having paragraphs of description. rereading it felt like visiting an old friend and id forgotten how wonderful this story is. i can not recommend it enough :)

Was this review helpful?

Super cute and a very intriguing start.
This seems like it'll be very fun and I'm excited to see how this current plot will go. The art is also beautiful I enjoy it very much.

Was this review helpful?

A very sweet and endearing story about 2 mermen falling for each other despite one being pushed to murder the other to fulfill the prophecy of his people. The illustrations are lovely as well.

Was this review helpful?

I have loved and followed this Webtoon for the longest time now. This serialization and publication of Castle Swimmer is so exciting. This volume depicts the first chapters of the comic, in which we are introduce to our two main characters: Kappa and Siren, and the conflict of this first arc. The pacing, narrative and art is as beautiful as vibrant as I remember.

Was this review helpful?

“You are a beacon, a light that shines for others. There are many prophecies in this world. You will have a key role to play in each one. The world is waiting for you. Go to the prophecies and fulfil your destiny!”
3.75☆|5

This was a really quick read, the pages were flipping between my fingers — figuratively, I read this on a screen —and I couldn't let it down. In fact, I read it in one sitting. Because if there is one thing that I will always recognize to this comic, it's that it is addictive. There's something so beautiful in the art style that made us unable to leave Siren and Kappa.

This first volume is very obviously a setup; we learn about the universe and how we ended up in this situation, and we learn a bit about the characters — even though it stays a bit superficial, I hope that we will learn more deep things about them later! And yet, enough things happen, the premise is intriguing, and it seems like it is going to be well done. So we stick to it and want to know what is going to happen. In fact, I am not even sure that I will be able to wait for the second volume, and I might really well go read the next chapters directly on Webtoon.

One of the major highlights of this story is its characters. I just love Siren and Kappa, they are opposed yet very similar. And even though I feel like the light romance developing between them is quick, it is cute to read about those two mermen having small crushes when they actually need to kill or be killed by the other. This comic is truly adorable, and I love the art.

I will make sure to read what happens after this volume, and I definitely recommend it if you want a quick, adorable read with nice art and prophecies. Thank you to Netgalley and Ten Speed Graphic for sending me an eARC of this book, it will be out on October 22.

My review will be available on Instagram and Storygraph around October 15th!

Was this review helpful?

**Book Review: Castle Swimmer**

"Castle Swimmer" is an absolute delight, transcending its origins as a Webtoon to become a highly anticipated book. As a librarian, I have witnessed the palpable excitement among many young readers eagerly awaiting its release. The narrative's charm lies in its richly developed characters, Siren and Kappa, who resonate deeply with readers of all ages.

Kappa, the reluctant "chosen one," brings a refreshing twist to the archetype. His journey is one of self-discovery and defiance against the predestined path laid before him. Siren, reminiscent of a modern-day Rapunzel, captivates with her wide-eyed wonder and exploration of a world beyond her confines. Their interactions are a beautiful blend of friendship, adventure, and growth, making the story both relatable and inspiring.

Moreover, the author's dedication to incorporating lesser-known and endangered ocean species into the narrative adds a layer of educational value and environmental awareness. This thoughtful inclusion not only enriches the underwater world of "Castle Swimmer" but also encourages readers to develop a deeper appreciation for marine life and the importance of conservation.

In summary, "Castle Swimmer" is a compelling and heartwarming tale that excels in character development, storytelling, and ecological consciousness. It is a must-read for anyone seeking a story that combines fantasy, adventure, and meaningful themes.

Was this review helpful?

One of the best graphic novels I've read this year. A sweet story that is sure to swim into the hearts of many. Compelling characters that will make readers care deeply. I can't wait to read more of the story!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a great graphic novel. The art design was so cute and I really like the story. I can't wait to read more!

Was this review helpful?

While I enjoyed this read, it left me a bit disappointed. Mostly because nothing really happens in this first volume. The art is great and fits the story well and we are presented to the story nicely, but it lacked the omph to make me want to keep going.

I might continue this, I might not. I think it'll be a great library book once more volumes are out.

/ Denise

Was this review helpful?