Member Reviews
Thanks to PeachTree Teen for an eARC in exchange for an honest review!!
This is my third AJW and definitely my new favorite! Just as raw and brutal as his previous works, but thematically stronger than previously as well. Social change doesn't come from an individual or a few individuals; it comes from community. It is not easy trying to enact change to an unjust system, and I will continue to feel grateful that AJW has books for teens (especially queer and/or autistic) to relate to and help guide them through this complicated feelings. If you haven't checked out any of AJW's works yet, I implore you to start sooner than later. AJW continues to be a powerhouse in the YA horror/thriller space.
Andrew Joseph White can do no wrong! One of the best new YA authors out there, and this one stands up to that title.
DNF at page 95 (Chapter 15). I don't wanna rate the book but since feedback here requires star rating I'm giving it average 3 stars.
Unfortunately, this book didn't work for me as much as I thought it would. I was really looking forward to it bc the main character is a transboy who is on the autism spectrum. So when I got the ARC I was over the moon. But, unfortunately, after reading more than 90 pages of it, I don't wanna continue bc I realise I had completely different expectations from it.
First of all, I didn't know this is a YA horror not adult. I don't usually read YA books so this already put me off. Secondly, I didn't like the main character. Not bc of his personality but rather lack of it. We don't really see much of his personality other than the traumatic stuff. He is also on the spectrum but ngl I didn't like the depiction of it sometimes bc there was inconsistencies. Like sometimes he would 100% understand what people were implying but other times he couldn't even read sb's expression or understand what they meant. I was confused. But even though this put me off a bit, I can understand that people aren't exactly consistent in real life either. So this isn't exactly a criticism. Finally, the plot was very slow. The prologue was great but after that I was mostly bored. I read almost 100 pages but I still didn't feel any horror vibes from the book. And when I realized I still had 270 more pages to read I just gave up. It felt more like a contemporary fiction with some dark moments. But maybe this typical for YA horror idk bc I haven't read any, as far as I'm aware.
It's also set in West Virginia so it's also kind of about the life of people living in the rural parts. I would've liked the setting more if it discussed conservatism in these rural areas among the working class better but instead it came across to me as more patriotic and more of an excuse than a nuanced look at living on the edge of poverty. But since I'm not from US and know nothing about these regions, I have no idea whether this was a good and accurate depiction or not.
All in all, I would still recommend this book if you wanna read a YA horror book with a trans protagonist. Apparently he is also aromantic but I haven't reached that point in the book where he realizes it so I only found out about it from other reviews. I think the writing was good. Also it's set in West Virginia, as I mentioned, so if that's sth that interests you, I'd recommend checking this book out.
Andrew Joseph White's writing is stronger than ever in his third novel, Compound Fracture.
I've loved his massive, out-there concepts, but he does small-town speculative just as brilliantly!
One of the most resonant elements of this story was White's portrayal of living in poverty. It felt authentic and relatable, not overdone or ridiculously dramatised like you see a lot of people do when trying to write a poor family. It was awesome, too, that this was so intrinsic to the plot. Marginalisation doesn't have to be, but it's awesome when it is! I loved how this poorness was directly related to where they lived and their familial connection to the town's historical activism.
Compound Fracture didn't hesitate to confront issues from transness and undiagnosed autism to assault and murder with various nuances and realistic exploration of all avenues.
Stunning. Can't wait to get my hands on a physical copy!
This book had my blood boiling, I was so angry with the injustices and how awful people were. Unlike White's previous books, this barely had any paranormal aspects and mostly focused on the all-too-real mistreatment that anyone labeled as "different" can endure.
There were some pretty violent scenes, but they helped show the severity of the feud and the story will definitely stick with me. There's also a lot of queer and neurodivergent representation and I enjoyed having a more diverse cast.
There's an author note at the end about Miles' parents and how they resemble White's real life experiences and I appreciated that bit of lived experience.
I voluntarily read and reviewed this book. All opinions are my own. Thank you to Peachtree Teen and NetGalley for the copy
Brutal. This story gripped me by the collar and never let go. I feel weird saying I loved this, solely because how much trauma Miles went though. Definitely look at the trigger warnings.
The violence is what some face every day so if you can read this, I recommend it.
I was fortunate enough to receive and read an ARC. I also pre-ordered this title, securing a signed first edition copy and borrowed the audiobook from my local library via the Libby app.
Incredible read, I fell in love with the setting, as it hit close to home, being from a town similar politically to Twist Creek. Miles is exceptional, for standing what up for what he believes in, given everything that happens to him, and his loved ones. When it would’ve been easier to submit and placate.
The audiobook was perfection. Immersive storytelling, and the accent the narrator used was excellent, as well as their tone used to convey plot points/conversations.
I can’t wait to see what AJW writes nexts
Compound Fracture by Andrew Joseph White is a gripping, visceral novel that touches on the complexities of identity, survival, and trauma. Our main character Miles navigates a hostile, oppressive environment while confronting his past. He lives in a town that's silent and docile as a result of not only physical but emotional tragedy. Something that's not unheard of in many places around the world.
The writing is gritty and at times unsettling...but this is quite appropriate given the issues being discussed. The real-world struggles faced by marginalized groups, particularly the LGBTQ+ community are front and center as well.
This thriller gets 3.5 stars. However do read the trigger warnings as some of the subjects may be disturbing for some. Thank you to Netgalley and Andrew Joseph White for this review copy!
Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this early in exchange for a review.
as an avid reader of anything andrew joseph white makes, he cooked with this one. if theres anything i didnt like it was how the middle kinda felt a little slow, but the last 100 pages of the book makes up for that. the trans rep is solid as it usually is, and I really related to the autism rep too. the setting is quite nice, and overall this is a really solid read. solid 5/5, another great book. cant wait to read AJW's adult book next year.
(NOTE: I forgot to copy and paste my Goodreads review and got too anxious so I waited till now. My bad 😭)
This book was INCREDIBLE, but so hard to read because it was so real and so raw. It’s horror, where the horror is the system and also real people and not supernatural beings. It’s also a much better glimpse into the people of Appalachia than some other trending books (massive side eye and middle finger to some other author).
Miles is a trans boy living in a former coal mine town in West Virginia which has been ravaged by the closing of the mine and also by the *insane* corruption of the sheriff. Anytime anyone tries to make change - from Miles’ great grandfather leading a strike to his father running for office - the sheriff either kills or maims them. But when Miles is attacked within an inch of his life, he and a few others finally band together to end it once and for all. Helping guide him is the ghost of Miles’ great-great-grandfather Saint, who was murdered for unionizing the mines.
Miles is targeted for so much of who he is - a trans man, autistic, a socialist-leftist, the descendant of his particular family - in a way that reads so true in modern America. But so does the fact that even in a corrupt town, Miles isn’t actually alone in any of these. This is such a beautiful example of what community can be and the lengths to which people are forced into the worst of situations. There is murder and torture and animal torture in this, but frankly that’s true in life. I’m a huge Andrew Joseph White fan, and this newest is *so* SO good. An absolute must read!
ANDREWWWWWWW. Why is AJW so good at these stories? It's gross and I want to adopt Miles and so very relevant to today and Andrew is one of my favorite writers. I can't wait for his adult debut.
Compound Fracture follows a trans autistic teen named Miles Abernathy. After Miles discovers that the accident that injured his parents is part of the decades old family feud that has haunted his family for generations, he goes to a party and becomes the next victim of the feud. While in the hospital, Miles is threatened by the sheriff to not tell the truth of his "accident," and after the stress, he starts seeing a specter straight from the mining town of old. What will happen when the town decides they are done with the crooked sheriff and Miles has to find a way to end the bloody feud that has plagued his family and community for generations.
This book was wonderful, nail biting, and politically charged all in one. I loved following Miles and reading about Appalachia. You can tell that White truly loves his home and as he has stated, this does read as a “Love Letter to Appalachia” and all the hope for the future shines through. As always the LGBTQ representationwas amazing to read. Every Book by Andrew Joseph White has blown me away and this is his best work yet! If you're looking for a gore filled, fast paced, and revolutionary novel this is for you!
Compound Fracture, much like White's previous works, is jampacked with LGBTQIA+ representation, political activism, violence and gore. Never have I not been wildly impressed by the risks White takes in their novels, especially this one. Being set in modern times, I did find that some of the content throughout felt a little on the nose to the point of risking being cliché and preachy. This is not inherently a bad thing, I just find that my general preference in reading is to not have everything so blatantly spelled out to me. If you are a fan of White's prior books, Compound Fracture will not disappoint. I would not say that this is my favorite work to date by White, but a fantastic achievement nonetheless!
Compound Fracture just launched itself into my personal top ten favorite books I've read this year and maybe my lifetime. As a neurodivergent myself, I do prefer to read books about autistic characters who are written by autistic authors. They just feel more real than characters that are written as a socially awkward stereotype. The average person might not be able to tell the difference, but we definitely can.
Andrew Joseph White is known for the gore in his books and this is no different. It's not too terribly gross, but it's there. It does kind of sneak up on you in a few scenes which adds to the shock factor. It's definitely appropriate for a YA audience.
Andrew Joseph White blew me away with his debut Hell Followed With Us and followed it up with the phenomenal The Spirit Bares Its Teeth so I went into Compound Fracture with high expectations and wow did he meet them.
One thing that's important to know is that while his first two books are YA horror, this is a thriller. Yes, there are gruesome elements and some depictions of graphic violence, but it is by far the least gory of his books. It does have the same rage that I love and have come to expect from an Andrew Joseph White book.
I had the opportunity to hear White speak at the National Book Festival just before this book was released and he talked about how this book was a love letter to Appalachia and his apology to young adults who feel helpless about the work they'll need to put in to clean up the messes of older generations and all of that absolutely shines through. This book takes place in modern times and follows Miles, a young trans boy who loves his small West Virginia town as much as he hates it. I loved that AJW wrote about an autistic trans boy who doesn't want to leave. Honestly Miles's drive to make his hometown better was so compelling to me in ways that I probably can't articulate very well but I deeply related to Miles love of his hometown despite all the bad.
I also loved that this book highlighted West Virginian history. In modern times, WV is seen as a deeply red backwater, but West Virginia only became a state separate from Virginia in 1863 because of the Civil War. AJW also pulls in real life socialist history by including Miles's great great grandfather who led a miners' rebellion in the 1920s. The hardcover edition even includes photos saved in the Library of Congress of the West Virginia coal wars.
Overall, I really loved this book and I highly recommend it, especially for those who have been interested in his work but have maybe been turned off by the gore of his previous releases. I cannot wait to see what White writes next as he has absolutely become an auto-buy author for me.
This book I requested from NetGalley because I had heard many good things about this author (and already owned one of his books to read). This is a book about Miles Abernathy, whose family is in a blood feud with the Davies family, especially Sheriff Davies. Along the way, Miles comes out as trans to various people (some who take it better than others), wrestles with labels and finds a way to fight back when the fight has already left him seriously injured in hospital (it happens in the first 10% of the book).
This book is graphic and brutal with it, it doesn't shy away from the damage bigotry and oppression can do. When Miles is terrified of the escalation of the blood feud, he is not just looking back at what the Davies family did to his ancestors, but what the Sheriff has done to his family and his friends in very recent past. His fear is very rational and I think the author does a good job of showing how that paralyses Miles, as well as showing the stubborn core of the family that keep on staying in a town where the existing power structure works against them. The whole family is bitter and resentful about what has been done to them but they are also loving and proud and so very determined. The feud does escalate and again, the book doesn't shy away from showing you the impact of this. Teenagers are killed and the narrative shows them compassion, because even though they did horrific things, they were still children who were shoved into a corner most adults can't get away from. It shows how the people in power hurt others, but also how they hurt themselves, their children and everyone around them.
Miles coming out is almost a subplot but not really, because it is woven into the main plot as well. It happens in the very first chapter when he comes out to his parents and then to various friends and enemies, deals with being called by his dead name (by accident as well as on purpose) and the very real possibility of corrective rape. I love how this author handled Miles' parents dealing with Miles' revelation. There is a line about how there is total acceptance and complete rejection but there is so much in between those two polar opposites and Miles' parents fall along that line. Miles doesn't have to persuade his parents to accept him, he's just very honest with them and they deal with their own reaction on their own (so off page).
While I enjoyed Miles and Cooper and the strange relationship between the two of them, I didn't find Dallas as compelling. Maybe because they showed up later or because they felt more like a character to help with the plot, I'm not sure. I did appreciate seeing someone else dealing with the trauma and the fear of what the Davies family had done and seeing how all three of them (Miles, Cooper and Dallas) handle it differently. Miles' family is important to him but so is his friend group and I appreciated that we got to see how complicated both sets of relationships are. No one is perfect and everyone has their own shit going on.
I really liked the ending and how Saint's ghost played a part. I enjoyed how the book's compassion with the younger characters, even the teenagers who did horrible things, continued with the ending.
The writing style of this book was compelling, even as the subject matter was distressing. Despite all the small town stuff going on, the author didn't shy away from real world politics and the wider look as well. It felt like it's own world and yet we were constantly reminded that small towns like these made up a big portion of the USA.
And regarding the dog, they survive.
4.5 stars!
09/12/2024 || Compound Fracture by Andrew Joseph White || #CompoundFracture #NetGalley #queer
Please note: This review may not be reproduced or quoted, in whole or in part, without explicit consent from the author and myself.
All of my thoughts are my own~
Thank you NetGalley, Andrew Joseph White, and Holiday House / Peachtree / Pixel+Ink | Peachtree Teen for making this e-ARC available!
5 stars
CW/TW: please heed and acknowledge all content warnings! They are there for your safety and mental health!!
From the author himself over on GoodReads:
"COMPOUND FRACTURE is about Appalachian history and blood feuds. While it isn’t as gory as my other work, there are still topics that may be difficult for some readers. These include:
*Graphic violence, with a focus on politically motivated, cyclical feud violence involving law enforcement and/or children
*Queerphobia and transphobia: deadnaming, misgendering, family conflict regarding trans identity (resolved), internalized queerphobia from a character on the aromantic spectrum (resolved)
*Opioid dependency and its effects on family; main character uses opioids after surgery and undergoes withdrawal after quitting without medical supervision
*Physical force and emotional manipulation by intimate partner
*Animal harm (butchering deer, off-page revenge killing of a dog)
*Discussions of ableism, including internalized ableism; brief mention of disfiguremisia
*Emetophobia (vomiting) warning
The dog named Lady is fine, I promise."
The Spirit Bares Its Teeth was my first Andrew Joseph White novel, then recently over the summer I listened to Hell Followed With Us and just this week finished up this ARC of Compound Fracture. AJW has really found his voice and footing when writing and it shows in Compound Fracture so much- the prose, the complexity of the characters and events, the atmosphere. He has been really evolving and honing his craft and I await, with much anticipation and excitement, what he will come out with next!
Compound Fracture follows Miles Abernathy- a 16 year old socialist from West Virginia, who recently came out as trans to his parents in light of school ending for the summer. What follows next is a series of horrid events that play their role in a bigger mess- a long standing, bloody feud between the hard working coal mining families like the Abernathy's vs the greedy, capitalist and their bastard cop family, the Davies. There were many times I had to stop, put this book down, and decompress. The subject matter is intense and very real and very heavy. This book contained little tid-bits of book titles to check out yourself if you feel the same as Miles and his family.
I cried a few times, and as usual- AJW provides us with an ending that is both great but also feels like the calm before the next storm. I loved this one, hope you do too.
As always thank you Net Galley and Publisher for a copy!!
Compound Fracture follows Miles, as they start uncovering just how twisted and awful their town is, and how rotten people can become from it. Their family name has been plagued for hundreds of years and he feels as if it is his time to fix the wrong doings against not only his family but his friends as well. After being beaten half to death by the sheriff's son and his friends, Miles sets out on path to try and stop the bloodshed once and for all.
I felt as though this story was much more tummy turning for me than the other stories as it felt much rawer and more open. I fell in love with all of the characters for both their good and their bad traits and even the antagonists. The way White writes always finds a way to take hold of me and leaves me constantly wanting more. The whole time I was waiting and anticipating what could happen next, while also dreading the outcome. Miles story felt like such a raw transgression that only got more aggressive as the story went on.
Again, Andrew Joseph White with another fantastic YA novel. This one, however, holds a special place in my heart.
This book is a tribute to the people who do what needs to be done, to the hundreds of thousands of Appalachians who have been denigrated and bullied by the powers that be. This book’s focus on being queer in Appalachia alongside the long history of labor unrest in the mountains, and the effects that has on the present and future, work together to weave an interesting narrative of resilience and generational trauma.
Thanks, Net Galley for the ARC! I had already preorder the book back when it was announced.
PS the dog doesn’t die, and she’s the goodest girl.
[Review text lifted from Goodreads.]
I received a digital copy of Compound Fracture through Netgalley. Many thanks to both the site and the publisher.
☆☆☆.5/5 rounded up. Great read. Spoilers present briefly, but said spoilers are important to the story.
"It's like everyone knows there's something off about me, and they don't like it, and they don't quite know what to do about it." —Miles Abernathy
I have been a fan of AJW for some years now, and hearing about Compound Fracture's (at the time) upcoming release elated me. I was thoroughly captivated by TSBIT, more so than HFWU, but knowing that Compound would have less of an abundant supernatural aspect left be curious as to how I may feel about the book.
I felt that, as always, White's portrayal of autism was stunningly accurate to not only my experiences, but experiences that I know about and want to learn more of. For Miles' part of not knowing about his disorder, I appreciated how bluntly he narrated his autistic traits while also providing a sense of subtlety. He clearly knows about and accepts these traits, but the subtlety comes from the lack of someone describing him as autistic every time he does something autistic. We are given these things to know about him—for instance, his special chewing shoelace is mentioned outright in the beginning of the story—and they are left there for us to do with what we please.
The politics were a little convoluted for my liking. I appreciated the depiction of a Southern anarcho-commie alliance, but the line between socialism, communism, and anarchism is not clearly drawn and these terms tend to be used interchangeably. Any issues I have with this topic throughout any of White's published works I choose to attribute to YA publishing restrictions. Perhaps my views will change with his upcoming adult novel.
I also felt the supernatural presence of Saint as a character was underdeveloped. While I've never been super fond of stories that introduce exactly one supernatural element and then do not explain how it came to be, I can accept that the explanation I desire may not be necessary for this story to fulfill itself. Miles' motivations are pulling him towards personal vendettas and familial scores to settle, not discovering the supernatural nature of his world, and that is okay with me. It didn't majorly detract from the writing.
As a reviewer, I tend to focus on the things that didn't work for me, even in a story I loved, because I don't know how to process my favorite parts into speech sometimes. I will point out clearly now: I loved this novel. I loved how similar Miles was to me, while also not feeling like a depiction of myself on page—I like to read about a character that I can understand, but don't necessarily relate to entirely. Miles was this for me. Not to say that I couldn't connect with him, because I do feel that I did. He was fascinating to me, and I personally loved that WV dialect was heavily present in his speech as well as the side characters'. I am southern but from the opposite side of the south, you could say. While I do wish I had more depictions of my own life and childhood in the Western South to read about, this novel did not need to give me that and I'm glad it didn't. I love to learn about southern experiences that aren't my own.
Overall, while some aspects took me out of the story as a reader, White's writing style and characterization ultimately kept me entranced. Highly recommend to those who enjoy teenage horror pushing the limits of what YA will allow and a love story about a boy and his homeland that can't treat him wrong—only the folks inhabiting it. TSBIT is still my favorite, but Compound Fracture ain't half bad. :)