Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC in exchange for my honest review! Also thank you Sher for sending me a link!

I was a huge fan of Sher’s debut book. This was such a pleasant surprise and perfect timing that Sher reached out for me to read and review her sophomore novel.

I’m unfamiliar with the original story this was adapting, but it seemed like a very interesting tale. This was a quick read and I was thankfully able to finish it in a day.

I went back and forth on Xian. In the beginning he was so sweet but he still had moments that made me question him. After a while I was frustrated with him. The way he and Zhen flip flopped gave me whiplash. Zhen was the same throughout the whole book so I appreciated that. He was so cute and forgiving almost to an infuriating degree.

I expected the villain but the twist about it was very well done. Didn’t see it coming at all.

I’m always here for a queer historical romance, so this was right up my alley. Thank you so much again!

Was this review helpful?

I’M CURRENTLY WEEPING SO HARD OVER THIS BOOK SKDNSKXNSKXN

It got me hooked from the very beginning, I couldn’t believe that I was halfway through just an hour and a half into reading it. The writing is just so beautiful, it truly feels like reading an ancient tale from an old book. I could feel the magic in me as I read it.

Just like in Fake Dates and Mooncakes, author Sher Lee makes us connect with both the characters and the story. The plot and characterizations are balanced perfectly, one not overshadowing the other. I could feel the characters’ feelings as mine as I read it.

In the middle of the book, I paused and went to read the Chinese legend of the white snake to understand the story better-which only broke my heart even more while reading the story so I’d recommend for you to do the same.

I don’t know why, but I could imagine this book like some sort of an animation movie in my mind. It had that mystical atmosphere to it that felt out of this world. I feel like I was flipping through the pages of a beloved book of myths rather than something that’s happening at that moment as I read, and I feel as if it fits the atmosphere of this book more.

It was an amazing book overall that messed with my heart palpations. Seriously, it got too intense sometimes and too emotional and I adored it.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my gosh this book tugged on my heartstrings. This book had just the right amount of sass, humor and heartache which is the perfect recipe for a great love story. Reading how Zhen became a human, and found his family in Qing, was a different take on fated partners. It was also refreshing to read a book where the main lead was no ashamed of his attraction to the other lead, and was a setting that homophobia was not present. The friend and sidekick was also a fun dynamic to experience, and THE VILLAIN?? Yeah did not predict that one. That one got me good. I did a little gasp at that reveal. Whew. Ugh, nothing but love for this book. I want more! This was a fun and comfy read. This was a 5 star read for me! Thank you NetGalley for this, I will cherish this one!

Was this review helpful?

Had a blast reading this one!

Our backdrop is ancient China, and the story is a twist on a popular legend. The pacing of this story is breakneck. Something is literally always happening and consequences are fleshed out fast. I think that makes it a perfect read for teens who get intimidated by the length and accessibility of fantasy. There arent dull moments. I never felt like the story dragged. There is worldbuilding, there is attention to detail, but it is all woven in so carefully along with characterization that it is conveyed simply and naturally.

There are emotional moments of anticipation, both in the romance and the action, that really tie this book together very neatly into a sweeping story that is quick and easy to read.

Would recommend for teens looking for queer fantasy, epic romance, emotional punches and fairytale retellings.

Was this review helpful?

A magnetic connection, an unresistible pull, soulmates. That’s how I’d describe the way Xian and Zhen felt about each other from the moment they met.

I’m not a huge fantasy reader; I’ve said it before. Most and for all, I’m a contemporary lover. But sometimes, a fantasy book pulls me in, and I can’t let go. Legend of the White Snake is such a book. It reads like a historical (YA) romance set in ancient China with some fantasy elements added.

The start of this story, told from a dual perspective, blew me away. Xian and Zhen are both wonderful MCs, Xian the resilient, headstrong prince, and Zhen, the gentle, calm boy/white snake—two boys who immediately feel a bond with each other.

I loved the interaction between those two, the pulling and the pushing, and the tropes used (there’s only one room/bed!). Legend of the White Snake is on the lighter and sweeter side, just like Sher Lee’s debut Fake Dates and Mooncakes, especially in the first part of the story. My lips curved up in a smile so many times. The second part got a bit harsher, there are fights and people die, but that bond between those two boys was always palpable. And isn’t that cover stunning? It fits the softness of this story so well!

Thank you, Allison, from HarperCollins, and of course, dear Sher, for this ARC! I can’t wait to have the book in my hands!

Was this review helpful?

This book starts off really strong, but does not finish off as strong. The book is billed as danmei inspired, and while I do think it hits some of those points superficially, I feel like it does miss the mark in more substantial ways. The setting and characters are not really fleshed out, and there's not a lot of space given for meaningful character growth. The romance aspects also felt rushed and a bit haphazard, it really didn't make sense for them to make the choices they did given how things panned out, or at least not as quickly as it did. I also felt like the explanations were a little out of place and not always needed. I get wanting readers to understand what's being described, but unless it's really crucial, I feel like we don't need to get descriptions of all the inane things. Particularly since the way things are described often was not organically introduced and felt jarring. It also felt like there were too many ideas included, especially in the last half of the book where things need to get tied up but more and more obstacles are introduced. I think this book could have benefited from some better focusing of plot details and giving the characters more growth and interest.

Was this review helpful?