Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the free ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions within are my own.

I did also read this in conjunction with the audiobook that I purchased myself. The audio narration was excellent.

RATING AND OVERALL THOUGHTS:

3 stars, barely. “Bruh.” I am sad to say, that I am left with a sour taste in my mouth from this novel. It had a strong beginning and I was here for the ride (despite a few minor dislikes) but then the last half of the novel nose dived off a cliff into the Heaven Lake and never resurfaced the same. It ended up a twisted and confused version of its former self that not even samgaetang can fix. I am not sure if I will read book 2 but I am leaning towards no.

SOME SPOILERS AHEAD

---

“Besides, what does my choice of going furry or not have to do with my destiny?”

WHAT I LOVED:

- The intro was very strong and had me really hooked. Really the first 40-50% of the novel was easily a 4 star read.
- I did love the descriptions of magic, lore, and places. It was all very vivid.
- Korean folklore were very well weaved into this.
- The narrators were great. A great audiobook read.
- The cover is absolutely beautiful.
- I will be craving steak and sunny side eggs for days now. Thanks.
- I did really enjoy the humor and the banter between the MCs in the beginning.

WHAT I DISLIKED:

- The ages of the MCs in relation to their romance later on left a sour taste as she kept thinking of him as a teenager that she once knew at first. They could’ve had the same bonding experience they did with everyone older.
- The FMC found everyone hot, had constant butterflies in her stomach, and displayed a lot of lust towards everyone which just left the what I was believing to be the main romance at that point kind of unbelievable.
- The back and forth will-they-won’t-they for the main MCs was so grating after the millionth time. The way that *one scene* ended was beyond infuriating.
- It got very repetitive and then new plot lines, people, and places were suddenly thrown in to shake things up but it made it a confusing mess.
- The obvious nudge of a love triangle at the end there was annoying. I can do love triangles but right there at the last 10-15%? No.
- The last 30-40% of the book felt like a different author wrote it. I got the vibe that it was decided to make this into a series suddenly instead of letting this be a strong standalone and so those new plot points, places, and people were thrown in in a half baked attempt to keep it going. What is worse is that major points just got abandoned by the end. Like why have her sign up to go into this trial if nothing about it is mentioned again later in that same book? It really read as if the author struggled to weave the threads together later on and then just gave up.
- I cannot get over the fact that she walked around topless for like hours in front of a bunch of people and it was such an out of pocket and unnecessary thing. Like I felt like it was put there for the FMC to say she was all confident but then in a scene not long after that, she shys away from being seen unclothed. Pick one. Either make it Mardi Gras for girlypop all the time with the swagger to prove it or make her a shy virgin like it alluded to her being the entire book.
- The end was like a really bad anime and the bad references to pop culture nearly made me throw my iPad across the room.

WHAT I AM NOT SURE ABOUT/WANTED MORE OF:

- I was expecting more detective work. I mean I guess it did have that but it was a different twist and felt breezed over.
- The characters were all very much cardboard cutouts. That wasn’t a bad thing at first because I was getting exactly what I expected from this novel but then it was a bad thing.
- The BBEG just felt flat. Such much was talked up about him but then when he finally came on screen to show his powers I just felt “meh”.
- Should’ve gotten the found family sooner. I love that she found one but they were all introduced so late that there wasn’t any real buildup for it to mean anything.

I really enjoyed this book! It was like none other I have read. It is a Koren background with love and mythology intertwined. I enjoyed the romance and would like to read more by this Author.

The beginning of this book was hard. I didn’t like how fast Sunny fell for Ethan and it felt very forced. I will say that the combat scenes were really well written! The plot twist of Ethan “betraying” her was predictable but i actually didn’t mind it.

I was given an advanced copy in exchange for my review. This is my honest opinion I am giving voluntarily. This is a Korean romantic fantasy with adventure and a ton of Korean mythology. While it was fun, I had a hard time keeping up because of the mythology.
I don’t think I’m a fan of the authors writing style. The romantic aspect felt forced because there was no lead up it was instant attraction and I personally need tension or banter. The plot was a good idea but it heavily needs editing, not in punctuation aspect but in a flow of the story way.

This was a great book. Jayci Lee has a great story telling ability. The world in this story was amazing and I loved the characters. They were all so much fun to follow. Her writing is magical and has a flow to it that keeps you invested in the story and characters. I really loved this and the cover is equally as stunning and fun as the book was.

Sunny cho is a Nine tailed fox who has been on the run from her past since she was eighteen. Because of who she is and what she is she can never stay in one place for long if she wants to risk being discovered. But when an old friend tracks her down and asks for her help she has no choice but to face her past head on if she wants to protect the people she loves.

This book has one of the most unique premises ever and I was so disappointed by how it was executed. I wouldn’t necessarily classify this as one of the worst books I’ve ever read but It got repetitive and I was completely thrown off by the insta- lust and insta love. A lot things that needed to be explained was often vague. And sometimes it felt like most of dialogues weren’t well timed.

It had all the potential to be an epic slowburn romance, with a grumpy girl on the run and a sunshine boy who would do anything to protect her.

<I><b>“Love is fleeting, Ethan,” I lie woodenly. “I’ve lived a hundred thirty-two years. I would know.” “Let me love you for a thousand years and prove you wrong,” he says, his voice breaking.</b></I>

As this was based on Asian folklore it would have been cool to have most of beings heavily part on their quest. Especially the part where Ethan and Sunny got separated, that could have been a great opportunity for the author to explore Ethan’s POV and give us the intricate details to how Ethan discovered who he was and how he was coping with all of it whiles he was hunting the yellow assassin.

But overall I enjoyed it. It was actually easy to follow through I hope the sequel has more rounds of editing, is action packed and has much more backstory

<b>“You . . . you are evil,” the mudang shrieks. “You will kill everyone if you unleash that power.” “No, I won’t.” My eyes flutter shut.</b>

<I><b>“Because I choose to be good.”</b></I>

Thank you Netgalley for providing this ARC in exchange of an honest review

Thank you Netgalley, Montlake, and the author for the opportunity to read this in return for an honest review. And let me just say it will be an honest review.

1. From the beginning, I disliked the FMC. Explain to me the reasoning for the annoying repetitiveness of "I'm a mythical creature that hurts everyone I get to close to" conflicting with her other internal monologue of "I must help this person find the killer of someone I got too close with in the past."
2. What is up with the integration of the romance into the plot line? The FMC admits that she's an 100 year old plus virgin by choice, yet this MMC has come in and she suddenly has these wild thoughts of attraction towards him, ADMIST the following inappropriate times: hearing that his brother died, someone is trying to actively kill you, AND in the midst of fighting an assassin (which sounds like the last point but different, you would understand if you read this, which I am completely not recommending this). If you thought Fourth Wing and Iron Flame was poorly edited/written with the mixture of spicy scenes and the the rest of the story, this is WAY worse. And the hinting of her "lust" or physical feelings towards the potential build up of a love triangle? Is that happening? I have no idea. But to describe your FMC feeling the heat rise to her cheeks at the feeling of her skin to clothing as she's being held in his arms is appropriate while being transported to another world? I don't know. I just don't know.
3. And the one major spice scene? HOW DO YOU LEAD UP TO THIS WITH MINIMAL FLIRTING??? HOW DO YOU GET TO THIS POINT AND JUST THROW IN THOSE NICKNAMES OUT OF NO WHERE? And to throw in the practical "we can't do this because we don't have a condom" really threw me for a loop. WHO THINKS ABOUT CONTRACEPTIVES AT A TIME LIKE THAT? Clearly someone who was like, "no this is important to address." Please, someone tell me I'm not crazy. I mean other books address it with taking some kind of herbal/medicinal thing, but like why? In a book like this?
4. Last but not least, this book deserved way better help and editing. It has potential, it has a chance to be better than it is and to grow. However, I think that the final product completely missed the mark by trying to be so much. Please pick a lane and stick with it. You have the main protagonist who is the chosen one, with a star crossed lover that is destined to fail and bring upon death. You have the potential love triangle, the MMC also being the chosen one. destiny, found family, touch upon possible lead up to academia things... There are probably more and they are just beyond my grasp at this moment.

I requested and read this book because I felt the FOMO of others on bookstagram posting about it and, sigh. If I could get my time and energy back from reading this, I probably would. Do I recommend this? Not really. Do I think I want to read the next in the series? Possibly, as I would like to see where it leads. Overall it's a 1 point something rounded to a 2? Yeah. Let's go with a 2.

I will be posting this to Instagram, Goodreads, and Storygraph

I enjoyed Nine Tailed - this is a 3.5 star book for me, but found there was so much Korean mythology that was unknown to me that it was quite hard work to keep up to speed with all the terminology and what type of creature or being was what.

Of course, that is my own lack of knowledge, so I don't fault the author for that at all, but it did reduce my enjoyment. I also, somehow, didn't realise that this was the first in a series, and while I wouldn't say this ends on a big cliffhanger, the story is definitely not neatly tied up. I am sufficiently invested that I want to read more, and now that I've read the first book I think I understand the world sufficiently for the next story to be a little easier to read.

I enjoyed the movement between the modern mortal world - mainly around Las Vegas, and the world of the Korean gods, the evolving story with Ethan, as well as having such as capable, fierce female lead who is so protective.

It was such a magical and quick read ! I love all the types of folklore, but the Korean is the one I know less about.. so I was really captivated by it’s big presence in the book! I loved the romance end the K-drama vibes that it gave me, and i love the chapter’s about Sunny and Ethan. I was captivated by this book and I definitely recommend it!

I knew I was going to love this book from the moment I’ve saw it here and I’m beyond thankful for the change of reading, I won’t spoiler but I have to say Sunny you’re really a bad ass gumiho.. and Ethan??????? Sorry I wasn’t expecting that, now how can I continue without knowing the rest of it???

Nine Tailed by Jayci Lee is a Korean romantic fantasy. The title caught my attention and anyone who enjoys epic Kdramas such as Goblin, Tale of the Nine-Tailed, Alchemy of Souls, The Mystic Pop-Up Bar, etc., will enjoy this book. Someone described it as urban fantasy mixed with Korean folklore and I agree! It's also quite fast-paced and intriguing. I really enjoyed this. Thank you, Netgalley and Montlake for giving me the ARC in exchange for my honest review. I look forward to the remaining books in the series.

I really loved this book! The relationships, Korean folklore and plot all came together so beautifully. I especially loved the interspersed scenes that provided background on the folklore and history of the characters. It was so effective in providing more information to the reader without info dumping, especially because it was written like a beautiful storybook.

Sunny was a great character to read and I loved her relationship with Ethan. The plot got so intriguing by the end, I can’t wait for the next book! I encourage you to pick up this book if you enjoy urban fantasy, folklore and great relationships and characters!

Nine Tailed by Jayci Lee was a wonderful romantasy story,
The structure of the book was something I hadn't read before and the anticipation was one of my favorite parts.

Urban fantasy infused with Korean folklore

Sunny is a century old gumiho, a nine-tailed fox, hiding out in Las Vegas for her misdemeanours as a teenage monster, when an old friend walks back into her life, and the world she thought she had left behind, of mountain gods and powerful cypress spirits, revenant assassins and angels with invisible wings, comes crashing into her less-than-satisfying life.

The first half of the book is largely an urban fantasy infused with Korean folklore, and the quick quips, the seediness of Las Vegas and the backroads of the Pacific coast are an excellent foil to the growing mysteries of who is chasing Sunny and her old friend Ethan. A little spice, a too quick romance, and then a revelation propel the book into its second half, that takes place mainly in a fantasy world of Korean monsters and celestial beings, but this is where the book starts to fall apart, with new information, new revelations and magics revealed in the moment that they're needed, turning something with promise into something pedestrian. Clearly the opening to a series, this still has much promise but Lee has painted the world into a corner form which there might be no escaping.

Three stars, just.

I really wanted to like this one but it didn't work for me :( the characters are completely annoying and I didn't identify with the writing, it seemed very amateurish to me.

I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review

Nine Tailed by Jayci Lee is a mixed first and third person multi-POV romantic fantasy starring Korean-American leads and Korean folklore. Sunny is a hundred and thirty-two years old gumiho living in America after her mother told her to flee South Korea. She meets up with her childhood friend, Ethan, who she hasn’t seen in eight years only to find out that his older brother is now dead. Sunny agrees to help him but holds a few things back and so does Ethan.

I love stories about nine-tailed foxes. There's so much room to play and do interesting things and I liked how Jayci Lee made her gumiho a member of the Korean diaspora. Sunny moves from town to town every ten years to make sure nobody realizes she’s not human, but she misses making strong human connections and having a family. You can feel her struggle to let Ethan in and let herself be vulnerable, but she chooses a more physical side to their relationship over talking through certain things and further deepening their emotional connection.

Ethan is a comfort to Sunny and a romantic interest, but she also struggles to fully tell him anything until he absolutely needs to know. Ethan’s older brother, Ben, was also in love with Sunny but nothing really happened between the two. There’s another potential love interest in Jihun, a celestial being who serves the Kingdoms of the Four Realms, though that’s a bit more up in the air. Sunny has a lot of options to explore in the next book and I’d love to see her relationship with Ben eight years ago fleshed out a bit more in future books.

I liked how we got chapters showing the world’s lore and bits of Ethan and Sunny’s childhood. It helps flesh out the worldbuilding and several even had a more fairy tale vibe, which connects the story more firmly to folklore. I cannot say I’m super familiar with Korean folklore beyond gumiho, celestial beings, and pulgasari, but I was really interested in the idea of a creature in Heaven’s Lake akin to the Loch Ness monster.

I would recommend this to fans of Romantasy utilizing folklore, readers looking for fantasy with Korean-American leads, and those looking for a book with a nine-tailed fox for a lead.

Thank you NetGalley and Montlake for this e-copy in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

This is by far the most Korean folklore I’ve learned from a single work. I’ve been watching Korean dramas of all genres for years, so I was already excited to read this book. But this book implemented so much folklore and taught me a lot more than what I already knew. Not only was the folklore in this book extensive, but it was weaved in seamlessly, enhancing the plot.

The book begins with Sunny, a gumiho who has been hiding amongst humans for the past one hundred years. One day, she’s found by Ethan, who tells her his brother, Ben, was murdered and wants her help in finding the murderer. Soon, Sunny realizes Ben’s murder was likely done by a mythical being. She thinks it’s all her fault and that her old enemy might be using Ethan to come after her. However, as Sunny and Ethan continue to work together, they unravel secrets that change everything either of them have ever known. And, of course, their old friendship begins to turn into something more.

I enjoyed how the story progressed. Sunny and Ethan worked together, they met beings who would help them, met others who wanted to hurt them, and learned more about themselves and each other. What began as a simple hunt for a murderer turned into so much more; story wise, this book sets up for a great sequel.

Sunny felt like a great main character and narrator. She was a lone wolf, who never let herself get close to anyone… in case she’d become too attached. Her prickly personality and snarky remarks provided a good chunk of the humor, which I enjoyed. Ethan, on the other hand, didn’t feel like he had much of a personality to me. Maybe it’s because we see him from Sunny’s perspective, who hasn’t seen him in almost a decade. Most of her thoughts about him simply felt like lust, which made for a bland romantic relationship. We could tell these two characters loved each other as friends from their past, but nothing in the present developed their relationship. It seemed to be rooted in sexual attraction only. I honestly enjoyed Sunny’s interactions with the supporting characters more than her scenes with Ethan.

For the most part, I did not enjoy the writing in this book. It felt repetitive and didn’t seem to flow well. The progression of Sunny’s thoughts and narration, as well as the dialogue in some parts, felt unnatural. BUT, other than the chapters from Sunny’s POV, there were a few short chapters throughout the book. Most of these short chapters were written in a style different from the rest of the book, which I liked a lot more and looked forward to as I read. These chapters also served to foreshadow plot twists, giving the reader information that Sunny herself did not know. The writing in these chapters was also more fairytale-like, which added to the folklore fantasy theme perfectly.

Overall, I very much enjoyed the theme and plot of Nine Tailed by Jayci Lee, but the execution was not on par. Despite this, I was captivated and would definitely read the sequel.

I'm really gutted to mark this DNF at 60%.

I tried taking it as a silly K-drama/comedy series and I still couldn't make it work.

I just could not stand the MC, Sunny. She's meant to be 132 years old and acts like a teenager, complete with edgy/angsty lines like:
I swore to never care about anyone again - to never grieve a loss again.
I honestly wouldn't know. I've never felt anything like this before.
The black coffee looks as dark as my soul. (Which made me cringe so badly, I nearly pinched a nerve in my neck.)

There are also sentences that include 'random dudes' and 'bad guys' as key targets and 'Now you just sound like a nerd'. Which drove me up the wall.

This is before even getting into the fact that Ethan has zero personality. His personality is literally 'hot'. Apparently this is also meant to heighten their sexual tension because Sunny is attracted to him but she can't be, but she is, but she shouldn't, oh but she does. And I do not care. The whole attraction thing is further weird since, despite it taking up most of her thoughts and interactions with Ethan, Sunny apparently never had this attraction before and is a virgin. But sure, just jump straight to friends with benefits with this guy you haven't seen in eight years but keep referring back to him as if he was still 16. That's not creepy at all. At least in K-dramas when there is a centuries old deity after someone they're generally adults the whole time and aren't swapping between lusting for them in the now while thinking about them as a minor.

Every argument or indecision is just resolved in the next sentence. "Don't come with me. I shouldn't drag you into this." "You didn't." "Oh, ok, I'm glad you're here." What?!

The sad part is when you get to these break up chapters throughout the book, they are so rich and vivid so it is obvious that Jayci has a talent in her writing. But it is immediately lost when you're back into the main story. If Jayci wrote a collection of legends or had done this book in the same tone, it would have been gorgeous.

Instead, I've had to put it down before I lost too much more time on it.

Sunny Cho is a nine-tailed fox spirit. Afyer leaving the magical realm many years ago, she now resides in Las Vegas where she keeps her fox buried deep inside her rather than risk losing control of her terrible powers.

Ethan Lee, a friend she left behind eight years ago, comes to town with news. He needs help finding his brother’s murderer. Does it have something to do with Sunny?

Traversing the mortal realm and the world of gods, Sunny and Ethan discover their quest is much more dire than mere vengeance, and their friendship might be…more. An ancient evil is on the rise.

The premise to this sounded so good. Everything is told from Sunny's point of view with a few chapters telling a story from the magical realm. Those chapters were good. I wish there had been more because I didn't enjoy being inside Sunny's mind.

She isn't an easy character to like which might be a little on purpose as Sunny keeps herself distant from everyone. Ethan is more likeable but neither of these characters are believable.

The story itself is also hard to get into. The details are confusing and this isn't helped by how much time is spent on Sunny pining over Ethan. It's an insta love situation, which doesn't always bother me, but Sunny acts very immature. The romance just isn't romantic. There is an explicit love scene which I didn't like and was unexpected due to the YA feel throughout the book.

Unfortunately the writing style also failed to grab my attention. This book just wasn't for me.

This was such a good read. I loved the characters and how they were all entangled as the book went on. I enjoyed the mix of modern day and Korean folklore - I am interested in reading more books like this and I can't wait for any future books in the series.