Member Reviews

I enjoyed this book. It was a quick and easy read. I was engaged the entire time I was reading this book.

Was this review helpful?

My first reaction to the idea of this book amounted to "not another banned-books book." There are an awful lot of books out there about kids fighting book bans. And if that's all this was it would be worthy of a weary sigh. But Levy doesn't just give us kids protesting an unfair decision. This book looks at a lot of context, both within the school system and in the character's lives, for the situation. Really, it's less about the book ban and more about Molly's motivation for fighting the situation. It asks what things are worth fighting and when you look for alternatives. This is a more complex, introspective narrative and is well worth reading and discussing.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely fantastic plot! I could not put the book down once I began reading it. Such a good message.

Was this review helpful?

Dana Alison Levy's Not Another Banned Book is a timely middle-grade novel tackling book banning with humor and heart. It follows twelve-year-old Ro Laws, a passionate reader who's outraged when her favorite book is banned from her school library. Levy skillfully portrays Ro's frustration as she navigates the adult world's confusing reasoning behind book bans. Ro doesn't just accept it; she forms a banned book club and launches a campaign to get the book back on shelves. The supporting characters are equally well-developed, and even the adults are portrayed with nuance. Not Another Banned Book is a story about friendship, courage, and standing up for what you believe in. It encourages critical thinking and prompts readers to consider the power of words and the dangers of censorship. Levy's writing is accessible, balancing humor with sincerity. It's a must-read for anyone who cares about books and the freedom to explore different ideas.

Was this review helpful?

This middle grade novel hits close to home. Molly just wants her middle school book club and her favorite teacher back who got suspended becuase of the books the kids were reading because some parent complained. As a kid who hated middle school because she got bullied the book club and my school librarian was my safe place. And if parents had tried to pull that stunt I would have been Molly.

Was this review helpful?

There is such relevance between this book and what is going on in our society today. Not another banned book is about book banning, activism and censorship. Easy read - middle grade.

There are quite a few heavy topics in this book.

It was great to read a book about the students fighting back against the book banning.

Thank you to NetGalley and Delacorte Press for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

definitely a great read detailing the reality of censorship and banning books. Felt inspired by the tenacity of the characters and hope that we will continue to speak up about our first amendment rights and freedom of speech

Was this review helpful?

Banned books and the banning of books is a common thing in the news the past few years. The premise of the story is a beloved teacher who runs a lunch-time book club for students gets put on suspension due to the content of some of the books read in the group. The main character has issues at home and feels like she has no one to talk to about her feelings now that her teacher is gone. She and her friends organize themselves to find out who complained about the book club and work to bring it back. She learns that to deal with answers, even when they aren’t the ones she has been looking for.

Was this review helpful?

Great book to bring to light the book banning craze that we are currently in. Presents the material in a way that tweens can understand the injustice of not being able to read a book you want to because an adult has decided that they think you should not have access to it. Loved the characters in the book and the creative ways that they fought back. Hopefully it will inspire other students to act!

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

This is a wonderful book. I really enjoyed reading it with my niece!

Was this review helpful?

I’ve read a few middle-grade books about banned books before this one. I wasn’t really sure why I read this one since I didn’t enjoy the others. I’m generally fascinated (and infuriated) by censorship and book banning, but I haven’t read many books about it for this audience that do a great job (in my opinion) of exploring those concepts. I did consider this one of the good ones.

One of the things that would annoy me about other middle-grade books about banned books is that it was almost too focused on book banning or a particular book and not enough on the character’s journey. So often the books on censorship have so much rage or frustration that it overshadows good storytelling or character development. In this case, the story shows why book banning affected these characters so strongly. I think that is the value of a book on the topic. Moving from rage to movement is reflected in how this book is written and Molly’s journey.

In this book, it’s clear why the main character, Molly, cares so much (even when she doesn't always understand herself). She needs the support of the book club in a time in her life when her world is changing and scary for her. Books and the club where she read books and engaged in discussions about the sometimes difficult topics in the books were a lifeline when her world was hard.

Molly’s reason for being so upset makes sense for the character. It’s not too broad or too overwhelming. I liked that Molly, in many ways, is a pretty ordinary, unassuming person to take objection to book bans. We also, fortunately, get perspectives on the banning from kids of different minorities as they share their opinions as part of their book club and friendship group.

Molly is an intriguing character. At some points, she’s a little clueless. She’s focused on figuring out who did it and why rather than trying to figure out how to move forward. The efforts to handle the book banning mirrors her efforts to handle the other difficult things in her life, and she grows and changes with her discussions with other people. She learns to be more empathetic and tackle challenges even when encountering roadblocks.

Not Another Banned Book is about more than a banned book. It’s about grief and change, friendship and relationships, and about how important feelings and personal experiences are to have and be able to reflect. By going into more detail about how book banning affects the kids who need these books, it presents how censorship is so much more complicated than whether a book is allowed to be on shelves. It’s about not being alone or feeling like there’s something wrong with you because books about people like you are banned.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for giving me an advanced copy to review in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I did not get to read this before it was archived but we are purchasing it for my library and I am so excited to read it when it arrives!

Was this review helpful?

I'm not sure I would agree with all of the author's conclusions but I do love how this whole story was from the student's perspectives. It was excellently done, taking a heavy, hard issue and placing it in the hands of middle grade students who are probably experiencing this in their real life. I loved the characters and the grief that the main character is going through at the same time. These are not one-sided characters only made for the plot to move forward or for the author's views to be platformed. They are real and fun!

Was this review helpful?

When I saw this book on NetGalley my immediate thought was "Not another book. about banned books!" It isn't that I don't have strong. feelings on the subject - I think it is unconscionable and reprehensible - but the number of books on the topic seems to be growing exponentially. See bandwagon, jump on bandwagon. I am not sure you can put a new spin on the topic, just change the characters, the setting and the list of books. And oh yes, the villain.

And so when I sat down to read this book I was already convinced that I knew how it would go. And to be fair, part of it was indeed another book about banned books. However, this book was about so much more. It was about the characters and their relationships to their now dissolved book club and also to each other, their families and to themselves. It used the banned books as a catalyst for the actual story about grief, about being different, and about how the kids saw themselves in the banned books. The main character, Molly, was buried in grief about her brother dying and about changes in her life that she felt were obliterating his memory. The book club was the only place she had to discuss her feelings and it got ripped out of her life. Suddenly the banned books became the reason she was so miserable. The rest of the group cared but they had other things in their lives to fall back on and so they didn't feel as committed as Molly; causing a rift to develop in the group and threatening their purpose.

I think it was a masterful use of the topic of book bans to tell a story of how kids need to see themselves in the books they read to know that they are not alone and how being told those books were wrong made them feel like they were somehow wrong too.

Was this review helpful?

This was a cute story in terms of the friend group, but the book was FAR TOO LONG. It felt like the end of middle school was going on for months and months and months. I was thinking they were getting close to wrapping things up and saw I was only 60% through the book.

Banned books are a touchy subject and I fully agree is something we need to be talking about, even if I don't have kids. This author makes excellent points about contemporary fiction and the need for kids to see others like them grappling with the same situations and coming out ahead. I also thought the subject matter of the books the LBC was reading and sparking discussions was tremendous. Too bad someone had to ruin it for those kids.

I have to quibble a bit with some of the replacement books that show up when the banned ones are removed from Mrs. Lewiston's classroom. Two of them that stick out significantly to me were The Catcher in the Rye, which is a notoriously banned book and usually banned in high schools, so I thought it odd showing up in a middle school classroom, as an "approved" book no less. The other is the Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain, also another continuously banned book, especially given the repeated use of the "n" word?! That one is OK? Also, I read that one in high school too but... It just struck me as significantly odd choices for replacements.

I enjoyed the friendship aspect of this story but I could not get past that the book outstayed it's welcome and became monotonous after a while.

Thank you to Delacorte and Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. My opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Not Another Banned Book Review

Book Clubs are a safe space for readers to express their thoughts and feelings about a book, but what if your book club gets canceled in the future? Molly, in "Not Another Banne" Book" by Dana Alison Le'y, has to deal with just that, and to make matters worse, her favorite teacher is also forced to take a hiatus. 
Molly is your typical middle school girl trying to navigate life. The one thing she has is Ms. Lewiston's book. Lewiston's will change one day when the principal comes in and asks to talk to her. The club is worried but doesn't think much. Only on the test day do they learn that the book club has been canceled and Molly's world is down. Follow along as Molly navigates the school's policy on schoolbooks and friendship in the beautiful and powerful new book. 
Like Molly, reading has always been my escape; because of books, I have learned so many things. The best way to learn about the world is through literature, so I am against banning books. I hate that books are taken away from libraries for kids and teens. You never know when a book will help you better understand yourself or someone else's opinion. Do you know that the majority of books that are banned have LGBTQ+ themes in them? It's terrible that it is a thing. This book shows how a book can help someone. Molly is a great character because she asks all the hard questions and tries her hardest to fight for what she believes in. This world could be different if we all had a fraction of what Molly has. This book is excellent, and I love the issues it covers. While yes, it's a middle grade, we can get something from it even as adults.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great read and an important one. Book bans are sadly all too common in today’s day and age so it was interesting to read about the fallout of one. What I liked most was how the students worked together to fight this ban and spread the important message that everyone deserves to see themselves in a book. This is a must read for everyone!

Was this review helpful?

I think this is a beautiful book. Molly’s dealing with life seemingly falling apart all around her and still fighting to keep her teacher and their access to books safe is just a wonderful story. This book is a shout into the crazy that is currently happening with books. It is something that needs to be read and seen and for people to realize that it is through books and groups like the LBC that people can find ways to change the world. Books have power and limiting peoples access to them will not cause the situations discussed in them to disappear, they will still exist no matter how much people try to hide them. Everyone should have equal access to knowledge and books period. No matter who you are. Representation matters, as does equal and equitable access.
Thank you so much to Random House Children’s and Netgalley for allowing me to read an advance copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Fantastic read for our current state of book banning in the U.S. or anytime for lovers of books! A group of students are fighting book banning at their school. Their book club at school that means a lot to them is at stake and their teacher who leads it has been put on leave. Molly tries everything she can think of to help but it forces her to uncover some truths that are very hard to face.

Was this review helpful?

Molly is still mourning the loss of her older brother, but knows she has a place to talk about things in Ms. Lewiston's book club. It is more than a book club; it is a safe place for her and her friends to not only broaden their horizons with books, but be able to have open discussion. When someone complains about the books being read in book club, Ms. Lewiston is suspended and Molly and her friends learn about the book banning movement. With everything else in her life falling apart around her, Molly is determined to bring back Ms. Lewiston and book club. Will Molly and her friends have what it takes to counter the people wanting books banned? Will Molly be able to find her safe place again? A great middle grades read that helps readers to look at the importance of books, activism, and learning for oneself. Highly recommend this book for class and home libraries.

I received an eARC of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?