I had high hopes for this story and it fell short. Throughout it seemed shallow, almost elementary in its style. I had a hard time keeping the various characters straight until I went back to read the initial description where each protagonist was briefly described.

The former-employee boyfriend was pretty standard in his chauvinistic mindset and behaviors and Mary Jo's struggles between motherhood and supporting the family in the face of her husband's debilitating injury both contributed to the book's predictability, for me.

Many thanks for the opportunity for an early read!

Thank you so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc of this one in exchange for an honest review!

This book is set in the 1950s and follows women that work at a large department store. A mystery unfolds and the women have to figure out what is going on.

I thought this book was just ok. I liked how it was set in the 1950s. It was interesting to see the different styles and the different times. I liked how the POVs kept changing throughout the book as well. I liked all of the characters backgrounds and learning about them.

I do feel like the mystery took too long to happen and I was just a bit bored throughout. I thought there was just a bit too much drama for my liking as well. Overall, not my favorite book but not bad either.

This story takes place in the '50s and has a great cast of characters who all work at Wynton's Department Store.! Strong female characters - the business-savvy secretary, the women who run the bridal boutique, a mother of 2 whose husband was injured during a construction accident and now she needs to work to help the family, etc. There's also the son and daughter-in-law of the store owner who are up to no good.
I loved the time period of this book and the varying storylines. Highly recommend.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for access to this eARC.

** “David had his sling and rocks, Joshua had his marchers, and Deborah had her faith. She’d won a small battle on many fronts tonight. But a larger war still brewed. And she had nothing to aid in the fight.” **

Donna Mumma offers a fantastic mystery filled with revenge, bitterness and greed in “The Women of Wynton’s.”

When mysterious and deadly events keep occurring to Mr. Wynton, the owner of Wynton’s Department Store, an unlikely mismatched group of women must come together to solve the murder and mayhem that keeps occurring — and to save one of their own.

The prim and proper Audrey Penault is Mr. Wynton’s secretary. Vivien Sheffield runs the store’s bridal salon. Gigi Woodard is a cafeteria worker. And new hire Mary Jo Johnson works in cosmetics. As the women work together to figure out what’s going on, they seem to repeatedly be foiled by the owner’s seemingly-so-nice daughter-in-law Cissy.

Who is truly at fault and responsible for the dastardly deeds going on? Will they be able to sift through the facts and determine the truth?

Mumma does an incredible job of reflecting a 1950s department store era while creating a fun murder mystery, while also developing great characters — ones to root for and ones to loathe. She subtly reminds us that God is with us in the wars we face in life and the impact of bitterness and greed.

Fans of series like Robert Thorogood’s “Marlow Murder Club series,” or even Katherine Woodfine’s “Sinclair’s Mysteries” will love “The Women of Wynton’s,” which is due out July 1.

Five stars out of five.

Barbour Fiction provided this complimentary copy through NetGalley for my honest, unbiased review.

I received a copy for review purposes; all opinions are honest and mine alone.


The 1950’s are alive and living on the pages of THE WOMEN OF WYNTON’S, by Donna Mumma. Full of strong female characters, fashion, makeup and sensibilities from the fifties, this is a book to enjoy by anyone who longs for the more genteel days gone by. But not to worry, there’s plenty of hijinx happening in WYNTON’S Department Store…

Make sure to read the author’s note at the back of the book. I’d suggest you do it before reading the story as it will help give a sense of what was happening in Florida at that time. Mumma does a very good job of weaving racial issues into the story and developing characters that buck stereotypes. I also appreciated that the “southern speak” was natural, not trumped up to absurdity by any of the characters, regardless of social or racial status.

One thing you’ll discover sooner rather than later is that the mystery in this story isn’t a secret. Readers are SURE who done it in short order. What we don’t know is how and that is quite a tangled up mess. Mumma uses the four POV’s to keep the story moving, filling in backstories, diverting attention and splitting allegiances; well done!

As a young, privileged woman, main character, Audrey, had the opportunity to attend charm school. She was impacted for life by Miss Evelyn, the owner of that establishment who plied the girls with brief but memorable life mandates, many of which come to the book in Audrey’s thot’s while gathering strength or patience in difficult circumstances. It’s via these nuggets that Mumma deliverers many of the same attributes Proverbs 31 does for godly women. The religious aspects are subtle in the story but rich if you take the time and choose to ponder them.

Moderately paced, an enjoyable cast of characters, (even the baddies have their moments), not the same old thing cozy mystery and a trip back to the 1950’s - what’s not to love📚


Read and Reviewed from a NetGalley eARC, with thanks

For a murder mystery and the number of bodies, this really is a sweet read.
As the bodies pile up the women working at Wynton's know they have to find the killer before their beloved store is lost.
As one who works in retail it was interesting to be reminded that not too many years ago, retail was seen as an important job. One where people were respected and those that worked it held their heads high. Take a walk down memory lane while you help Audrey and several of her fellow employees save the day from someone trying to end a beloved store in town.
I really did enjoy this read even though I did figure it out pretty early who the bad guy was.

Donna Mumma's "The Women of Wynton's" is a delightful journey into a 1950s murder mystery, brimming with charm and nostalgia. Set in the glamorous world of a department store, the novel vividly brings the era to life, capturing its essence without relying on the trappings of modern fiction—sex, violence, or foul language.

What sets this book apart is its purity and focus on character and setting. The murder mystery, though straightforward to solve, takes a back seat to the richly depicted lives of the women who populate Wynton's. Each character is fleshed out beautifully, offering glimpses into their aspirations, struggles, and the interconnectedness of their lives in the bustling store.

Mumma's narrative skillfully immerses the reader in the ambiance of the 1950s, evoking a sense of nostalgia for a bygone era of elegance and style. The attention to detail in depicting the department store adds layers of authenticity to the story, making it not just a murder mystery but a compelling slice of social history.

I couldn't help but imagine "The Women of Wynton's" on the silver screen. Its colorful characters and glamorous backdrop seem tailor-made for cinematic adaptation, promising a visual feast akin to classic Hollywood films.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a refreshing read that transports you to a different time and place, where the focus is on story and character rather than shock value, "The Women of Wynton's" is a perfect choice. Donna Mumma has crafted a novel that celebrates the charm of the 1950s while weaving a tale that lingers in the mind long after the final page.

Ooh this was such a fun read! The mystery was interesting and the time period and setting were a cool element to the plot. The characters and the fact there was real animosity between them at first that grew into actual friendship was also really well done and added another layer to an already well done story. I was completely immersed in the read and read it in an afternoon as it was tough to put down. This is an excellent read!

I received an ARC of this book from the author and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts on my own.

This was great I loved the 50s setting and the mystery was so cozy the characters really were fun my favorite was mary jo Johnson I loved her life as a mother

Imagine stepping into a world of 1950s glamour, set against the backdrop of a bustling department store where intrigue and murder lurk behind the elegant displays. Donna Mumma's The Women of Wynton's transports you to this enchanting yet perilous setting, where four women’s lives intertwine in unexpected ways.

Audrey Penault, once a glamorous model, now serves as the devoted secretary to Mr. Wynton. Her elegance and poise often come off as vanity to her colleagues. Then there’s Mary Jo Johnson, a shy housewife yearning for more than her role in the cosmetics department. Vivian Sheffield, proud owner of the bridal salon, fiercely guards her accomplishments, while Gigi Woodard, a waitress in the store’s lunchroom, battles her own insecurities to keep her job.

These women, despite their differences, unite to protect their beloved employer, Mr. Wynton, from a threat that could destroy the very foundation of the store. As mysterious deaths occur among the staff, the women must pool their detective skills to unravel the mystery. Can they trust each other enough to solve the murders, or is one of them harboring a dark secret?

As a Christian reader, I initially craved more overt, impactful Christian faith content throughout the narrative. However, as I continued to read through a Biblical worldview, I prayed for discernment and viewed the narrative through that lens. The "Miss Evelyn" statements peppered throughout the book became more than just pearls of wisdom; they prompted me to reflect on Scripture, examining how these principles aligned with or challenged God’s perspective. This introspective journey enriched my reading experience, offering a blend of mid-century etiquette and timeless spiritual truths.

The story, rich with themes of self-respect and integrity, resonated deeply. The subtle yet profound life lessons made this book a standout for me.

Some of my favorite quotes from the book include:

"Miss Evelyn said a lady makes sure to appear relaxed and unrushed in all activities."

"Miss Evelyn taught her, no need to make a spectacle of oneself."

"True ladies remained calm in crises. Kept pleasant expressions on their faces and kind words spilling from their mouths. And no public tears."

"Miss Evelyn always said a true lady was measured by how well she could compose herself when she was in a fix."

The Women of Wynton's is a fabulous story that I hope will be the start of a series. I would love to see more of these characters and, ideally, a more integral inclusion of rich and authentic Christian faith in future stories. Donna Mumma has crafted a compelling narrative capturing the essence of the 1950s while weaving in suspense, drama, and the power of female friendship magnificently.

This book has it all—1950s glam, mysterious deaths, a beloved boss, and even a fashion show. It’s a captivating blend of historical fiction and cozy mystery that will keep readers hooked. Whether you're a fan of vintage murder mysteries or simply enjoy a well-told story with rich character dynamics, The Women of Wynton's is a fun, must-read.

I received a digital ARC of The Women of Wynton’s from the publisher, Barbour Publishing. I am not required to write a positive review in any way or for any reason. My honest and unbiased opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the writing style, the pacing, and the story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.

💄1950s glam ✅
☠️ mysterious deaths ✅
🎄Christmas parade ✅
👨🏻‍🦳 boss/owner who is loved ✅
💃 fashion show ✅

This book has it all - the glam and glitz of the 1950’s era with the dash of suspense and drama.

Follow along as Audrey, Vivian, Mary Jo, Gigi, and Mirette work together to solve the mystery and mayhem they are facing at Wynton’s fine department store.

The author sucks you into each characters side story and masterfully stitches their stories together. As the full mystery unfolds, the plural stories become more singular as they work to solve the crimes.

I received an advance readers copy through NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. I do recommend this book without reservation and hope you pick it up when it releases on July 1.

I was drawn in by this book and couldn't put it down! Four women:

Audrey - devoted secretary to the owner of the department store (but she is oh so much more behind the scenes!)
Mary Jo - a housewife forced to go back to work because of her husband's wartime injury
Vivian - owner of a bridal salon
Gigi - a lunchroom waitress yearning for a step up in life

all work for Wynton's Department but couldn't be more different! As their lives collide, they make choices that will be life changing. When someone seeks to destroy Wynton's and harm innocent people, can they pool their resources and work together for the ultimate good? Or will gossip and slander tear them apart? You will be transported back to the 1950's where race is an issue and women in the workplace "should know their place." Donna Mumma weaves a tale so heartwarming - and at times, heartrending - you'll feel like you are eating in the cafeteria or working alongside a bridal genius. This is definitely a must read for 2024!

Thanks to Barbour Publishing and NetGalley for gifting me a copy of this novel. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

"Mid-Century Glam Meets Murder Mayhem.

Get swept away to the glamor of a 1950's department store where four women's loyalties, vanity, friendship, and detective skills are put to the test.

Audrey Penault once led a glamorous life as a model but now works as devoted secretary to Mr. Wynton. To her fellow employees, she is too vain and uppity.

Mary Jo Johnson, a wife and mother, longs to find her worth in the cosmetics department, but it may take a while for the shy housewife to discover her voice.

Vivian Sheffield owns and runs the bridal salon within Wynton's. She is proud of her accomplishments and won't let anyone take them away.

Gigi Woodard dislikes her job as waitress in the store's lunchroom, but she is determined not to let her secret shortcomings cause her to lose the position.

These four women have much to dislike about each other, but they unanimously agree that Mr. Wynton is the best of employers and must be protected at all costs from someone who seems determined to see him gone for good. When other employee deaths occur, can the women band together to solve the murders, or will they discover it is one of their own bent on destroying Wynton's from within?"

Anyone else love vintage murders set in period department stores? I know I can't be the only one loving very specific episodes of Ms Fisher's Modern Murder Mysteries and Endeavour!

Set in the 1950's, this story is filled with mystery, murder, family drama, suspense, fashion, business troubles, and much more. Just when I thought I knew who was guilty, I was wrong. I enjoyed the way the author kept me reading and built the suspense on each page. The twists and turns were intriguing. I received a complimentary copy of the book. No review was required.

Audrey is ahead of her time working hard as a secretary for the owner of Wynton’s Department Store in small town 1950s
Florida. Gigi is working as a server on the cafeteria line and Mary Jo is a housewife who has had to start working because her husband has lost his arm in an accident. Mrs. Vivian is the owner/designer of a bridal studio inside Wynton’s. These ladies have to work together to figure out who is trying to hurt Mr. Wynton

I really really enjoyed this book. I was invested in the mystery and was loathe to quit reading so I could go to bed. Mrs. Mumma does a great job of making the reader like and or dislike characters. She also does a wonderful job of tying together all of the backstories of the characters.

If I had a negative about this story, it would have been the fact that it started slowly. It took a minute for me to become invested. Another minor complaint I had was the fact that the racial tensions mentioned seemed to just be thrown in for good measure. They really didn’t help advance the plot. They were historically accurate, but as I stated seemed to be almost an afterthought. The faith content of this book was very light. The theme of love your neighbor as yourself is definitely there, but it is not in your face preachy.

I would recommend this book to people who enjoy clean historical mysteries. I would not recommend this book to people looking for evident Christian faith.

The Women of Wynton’s is a well written historical book. I enjoyed the plot and the character dynamics. I recommend this book. My thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for my advance ebook. This is my unbiased review.

If you want to know how 1950s department stores impacted American culture, this is the book for you! The Women of Wynton's by Donna Mumma gives great insight on a difficult time period in American history. With the war recently over, women were expected to stop working & go back home so returning soldiers could have their jobs back. Many women were left as widows with no means of support, & other women enjoyed working even though society wasn't quite ready for that. Audrey, Mary Jo, Vivian & Gigi all work at Wynton's in different departments. They have different backgrounds & don't appear to have much in common. When Mr. Wynton, the store owner fall ill under mysterious circumstances & mysterious deaths begin, these four women form a friendship and alliance to find the truth behind what's going on in order to save one of their own. I truly enjoyed this book & lived through that time period so I understood their frustration & desire to succeed. The story line keeps you guessing and the characters were all fun & sometimes a bit quirky which made it a great book. I was given a complimentary copy of this book by Barbour Publishing & was under no obligation to post a review.

The Women of Wynton’s gives you a glimpse into the lives of women in the 1950’s. It was full of female friendships, fashion, and department store gossip but also the frustrations and hardships of the time period and murders galore. It’s one of those books that offers you so much more than murder and intrigue and it’s one I’ll be thinking about for quite a while! It’s a wonderful book!

Audrey, Mary Jo, Vivien and Gigi work at Wynton's Department Store in a small town in Florida in 1955. The departments they work in are varied as are their backgrounds. What kind of pulls them together is a conspiracy that seems to be trying to take out kindly old Mr Wynton, owner of the store. It's kind of an odd premise for the kind of book that seems as though it just wants to tell a story about women at a certain place and time. And that's its primary weakness. The mystery is weak and the bad guy(s) are telegraphed very early on. We also don't get to know any of the women well, except for Mary Jo. So ultimately it's an interesting book that could have been much better. Thank you to NetGalley.com for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book.

This book had a lot of characters and it was hard to keep everyone straight. I didn't really connect with any of the characters except for Mr. Wynton. The level of deceit was uncomfortable for me and I wasn't sure which characters to trust. I didn't enjoy the rivalry between Audrey and Cissy.

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.

In accordance with the publisher's request, this review will be posted on my blog 30 days prior to publication.