**Review: The Crescent Moon Tea Room**
**Rating: 4 Stars**

Thank you to NetGalley, Atria Books, and Stacy Sivinski for an ARC of this book.

I absolutely loved the sister themes in this story. As someone with two sisters (not twins, but still deeply connected), the bond and love between the characters felt so relatable and touching. It was a beautiful reminder of the strength and connection between siblings.

This book is a perfect read as we head into fall, with its super cozy vibes—definitely one to curl up with on a cool evening. However, I did struggle a bit to pick this one up. While the story and characters were both well-done, for some reason, it felt like it was missing that "something" to fully suck me in. I can't quite put my finger on it, but I didn’t feel that irresistible pull to dive back in between reading sessions.

Overall, though, it’s a warm, enjoyable read that’s especially great for fans of family dynamics and seasonal charm.

Triplet witches Anne, Beatrix, and Violet own a Chicago tearoom which the three run smoothly due to being always insync. However, things are changing for them and their secrets are damaging their easy flow. The story is told by all three as they navigate through rough terrain. A very enthralling novel.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of the book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

A well-balanced, cozy fantasy novel that follows the Quigley triplets, Anne, Beatrice, and Violet.

A good read for a cold autumn night when you’re feeling a little witchy!

Thank you NetGalley, Atria Books, and Stacy Sivinski for this ebook ARC of The Crescent Moon Tearoom in exchange for my honest, in my own words review.

Debut novels are my bread and butter and I’ll tell you this one did not disappoint. As far as debut novels go, I was surprised at home well the author was able to hold my attention without extending so many plot branches - which can create holes. Well done.

The cozy fall vibe coupled overall loving atmosphere makes this book stand out over other “cozy reads” I’ve read this season.

The Quigley triplets have always been close (mostly trying to break the family curse) - they were extremely different but shared in the love of their family, tea, and of course, magic.

When they find themselves in yet another unexpected situation the three close-knit sisters find that their strengths (also being so different) are pulling them away from one another.

The curse begins to show its ugly head and the sisters have to make a tough decision.. what will they chose?

Publication date is 10-1-2024! Make sure you head out to your local bookstore or purchase online and grab yourself a copy with your fave cozy fall beverage and dive in to this short but incredibly sweet debut novel by Stacy Sivinski

Triplets Anne, Violet and Beatrix, along with their house/tea room are center stage as the characters in this cozy fantasy set in Chicago in the late 1800’s. The three orphaned sisters run a tea room loves by their clients who come for delicious treats and tea infused with a hint of magic, and to have their tea leaves read when they face decisions and questions in their lives. When an unexpected visit by the council of witches threatens to upend their lives the three sisters find the ties that bind them so closely begin to fray. Ultimately this is a story of each sister discovering their own paths, hidden secrets and desires, overshadowed by a curse. Each sister telling her own story shed more light on each of their personalities and dreams than if it had been told by just one sister. It was just a tiny bit slow in places, and it took me some time to warm to Anne, who I saw as a bit of a martyr, but as I got deeper into the story I was especially drawn in to Violet and Beatrix’s choices they were making. The house itself as a character was a nice addition, it certainly made itself felt and tries to look after the girls, and anyone who loves an afternoon tea will find themselves wishing for a place at one of it’s tables.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the opportunity to read this as an eARC.

If you’re looking for a cozy, comforting read for fall, this is it. Three sister-witches run a tea-leaf-reading cafe in 1800s downtown Chicago. But when the witch council informs them that they may be plagued by a curse, the sisters must work together to ensure their futures stay entwined. While the hands of fate try to force them apart, the girls learn more about themselves as individuals and as a family. This is a heartwarming tale about the magic of sisterhood - and an excellent cup of tea.

Characters:
I loved learning about each sister’s journey of individual growth - Anne, Violet, and Beatrix each developed and matured as characters. They were complex and multi-dimensional - just how I like my characters! The side characters, such as Mr. Crowley, Katherine, and the house were charming too. I felt like I was becoming friends with each character, which really contributed to the cozy, comforting atmosphere of the book.

Plot:
As a cozy fantasy novel, this was a slightly slower paced read. It was clear that we were building to a climax as the sisters completed the challenges assigned by the Witch Council and attempted to fight off their own curse. I’d describe this is a soothing and relaxing book, not high stakes or fast-paced. There was a twist near the end that really surprised me and tugged on my heartstrings, though!

Writing Style:
Sivinski has real gift for writing - she can truly make magic with her words. She has a clear voice, using beautiful imagery to describe the enchanted house, the welcoming tearoom, and each of the character’s inner monologues. I was highlighting many passages to go back and re-read!

I adored this cozy, witchy, debut that has three triplet clairvoyant sisters being tested as they fight to keep their tearoom/fortune telling business while having to complete three tasks mandated by the Witches council AND having to fight to keep their sisterly bonds close while they grow as individuals. Great on audio, this was a compelling and interesting story that I devoured! Highly recommended for fans of authors like Kate Johnson. Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital and audio copy in exchange for my honest review!

The Crescent Moon Tearoom is the effect cozy fantasy! The stakes are low and the vibes are strong. There is a sentient house with a playful attitude, three sisters: Violet, Anne, and Beatrix, who have grown up together and now work together. However, life seems to be pulling them in different directions now and there is a curse at work. This book explores themes of growing up, the pursuit of happiness, and a fear of change beautifully. The tea reading scenes were fun to read!

I just found myself a bit irritated by the characters at times. Especially Violet and Beatrix who seemed fairly hypocritical and like they weren’t putting any effort into breaking the curse, unlike Anne. I also don’t think Violet’s romance was well developed at all.

Three clairvoyant sisters—Anne, Beatrix, and Violet Quigley—run a tea shop where they divine futures from tea leaves. When the city’s Diviner loses her powers, the sisters face a family curse pulling them apart. Anne’s evolving magic, Beatrix’s writing success, and Violet’s fascination with a trapeze artist at the local visiting circus strain their bond. As they race against time to rewrite their fates and aid three other witches who need to discover their lifetime Tasks before moving on from this world, they must decide whether saving each other means losing themselves. This tale explores family, destiny, and the challenge of balancing personal desires with the family ties that bind us.

4 stars

I am not usually one to dive into a fantasy novel. I dabble in magical realism, but this novel required true acceptance of a different world. The bond between the three sisters is clear from the beginning. They each have their own strengths that they bring to the table, but also clear interests aside from the tearoom and their day-to-day occupations.

The book is well written and pleasant to read, and I was drawn most to Beatrix's and Anne's stories. It is a perfect read for fall, uplifting and heartwarming all wrapped up in the intricacies of family. This is not a hard-hitting mystery or witchy thriller, but it will be great for the reader who wants to curl up on a cool autumn day and read a cozy story about the magic of sisters.

Thank you to NetGalley, Atria Books and Stacy Sivinski for providing me with access to this early copy of The Crescent Moon Tearoom - out October 1, 2025!

This was such a great autumn read! A cute town with a magical family. There were so many interesting characters in this story. It was the perfect book to read with a cozy blanket.

This was my third or fourth beverage related book this year somehow - is this a thing now? In The Crescent Moon Tearoom, three witch sisters, orphaned long ago by their beloved parents, live and work in a house with some personality, telling fortunes to people who want to know what life has in store for them. When the local witch leadership comes knocking, asking for their help in guiding other witches to find their Tasks, or their ultimate purpose in life, the sisters start to realize that maybe the insular family they've created isn't what they all want.

There was a night circus, reminiscent of The Night Circus, an author who's stories get immediately snapped up by publishers despite her lack of confidence, and a seer who is scared at what her powers may mean. This was a good one time read, very autumnal, and honestly, I LOVED the house.

I enjoyed this book, I found the setting super cosy & would be perfect for a fall read! The book cover art really caught my eye.

"An "impossibly endearing" (Sarah Penner, New York Times bestselling author) debut novel about three clairvoyant sisters who face an unexpected twist of Fate at the bottom of their own delicate porcelain cups.

Ever since the untimely death of their parents, Anne, Beatrix, and Violet Quigley have made a business of threading together the stories that rest in the swirls of ginger, cloves, and cardamon that lie at the bottom of their customers' cups. Their days at the teashop are filled with talk of butterflies and good fortune intertwined with the sound of cinnamon shortbread being snapped by laced fingers.

That is, until the Council of Witches comes calling with news that the city Diviner has lost her powers, and the sisters suddenly find themselves being pulled in different directions. As Anne's magic begins to develop beyond that of her sisters', Beatrix's writing attracts the attention of a publisher, and Violet is enchanted by the song of the circus - and perhaps a mischievous trapeze artist threatening to sweep her off her feet - it seems a family curse that threatens to separate the sisters is taking effect.

With dwindling time to rewrite their future and help three other witches challenge their own destinies, the Quigleys set out to bargain with Fate. But in focusing so closely on saving each other, will they lose sight of themselves?"

Can I just go live in this world?

(Actual: 3.5⭐️, rounded up) This was a very cute, very cozy magical mystery— perfect for this Fall season (and any other season for that matter). I love how the house felt like a main character too tbh! Haha 😅 Anyway~ I thought the plot was evenly-paced and that the relationship dynamics & sisterly bonds between Anne, Beatrix, and Violet were portrayed very well. I also enjoyed how, in a more general sense, we got to really spend time with each sister and how it’s made clear that they each have their own respective hopes, dreams, and anxieties separate from one another. Overall I’d def recommend this book out to others, especially if you love cozy. mysteries with dashes & threads of magic and wonder.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Stacy Sivinski for providing me with a complimentary digital ARC for The Crescent Moon Tearoom coming out October 1, 2024. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

I’ve read a lot of witch stories lately! I really love witches and cozy autumn vibes! I didn’t know what to expect with this book. I love sister stories. It felt a little like Charmed with the three sisters. I really enjoyed this story. They had different personalities. I loved the tea shop. I would definitely read other books by this author!

I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys cozy witch stories!

I found the characters to not be especially relatable; however, the environment was vibrant and I loved the various places portrayed in the book. The longer you read the more you want to yell at the sisters to just go their separate ways and live their dreams.

You’re in for a treat, if you grab this book, it is a perfect fall read reminding of Hocus Pocus but with good witches.
The Quigley sisters, Anne, Violet and Beatrix are triplet witches and are running a magical tearoom in their late parents’ enchanted house. Even though each one of them has very different talents, they complement each other perfectly and enjoy each other’s company. One day, the Council of Witches springs a challenge onto them that seems to be impossible to solve. They find out that they are cursed and must stay together or lose their tearoom. But soon each sister starts drifting towards individual interests and they struggle to focus on the task at hand. Anne, who was always the strongest of the witches, discovers new potent powers. Beatrix, the quiet sister, finds her passion for writing, and Violet is attracted to the local circus (and maybe the Trapeze artist who teaches her how to ‘fly’). Torn between the sisterly bond and the personal growth and individuality, will they be able to find peace and overcome the curse?
I loved this book from the first line. A cozy, heartwarming story with just the right amount of fantasy and magic. Beautifully written in the perspective of each sister alternatively, the tale comes together perfectly. I didn’t want this book to end and would like to read more about the Quigley sisters. A wonderful and atmospheric debut that grips you from beginning to end. I loved the tearoom scenes with the demanding visitors, delicious pastries and variety of teas. This is a story about family, love and sisterly bonds but also about finding your own place and letting go of the past. I’m looking forward to reading more of the author. A fantastic debut indeed.
I would like to thank Netgalley, Atria Books and Stacy Sivinsky for the opportunity to read this advance copy. I truly enjoyed it and the above is my honest review and own opinion. This book releases on 10/1/2024.

Sadly DNF @43%

I really wanted to like this book. It was pitched to me as a cozy fantasy similar to The Spellshop & Legends & Lattes. But I just couldn’t for the life of me get into this story. Which sucks because cozy fantasies have been my jam lately. This story feels like it’s missing something and what I did see of our characters I found them bland and hard to relate to.

The reason I read for as long as I did was because of the house. I’m a sucker for sentient objects/buidlings. I loved how sassy and judgey the house was.

Hopefully this book makes someone else happy it just wasn’t my cup of tea.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

Calling all lovers of witches, magic and cozy fantasy. This is one for your radar!

Anne, Beatrix and Violet are three sisters surviving after their parents death by running a magical tearoom, but add in a curse and battling fate and you have ourselves this book.

I do struggle with cozy fantasy. It’s not my thing. I like more stabbing and morally grey characters in my fantasy books, but if you want a magical hug, this is a great choice.

The Crescent Moon Tea Shop by Stacy Savinsky is a cozy, witchy read that focuses on family and discovering your own path. It’s a gentle, feel-good story, perfect for curling up with a blanket and a cup of tea on a crisp fall day.

One of the standout elements for me was the tea shop’s enchanted house, which felt like a character in its own right. From doing the dishes to pulling your chair closer to the fire when you’re feeling down, it added a lot of charm to the story. If I could live in a house like that, I don’t think I’d ever leave!

The story follows the Quigley triplets as they each navigate their own personal journeys, weaving three storylines into one. I enjoyed watching their paths unfold, and the ending, while simple, was sweet and heartwarming.

However, I found the pacing a bit slow at times. Despite enjoying the atmosphere, I kept waiting for more to happen and felt myself tempted to skim ahead just to see how it would all conclude.

Overall, I’d give this book 3.75 stars. As cozy and enjoyable as it was, this isn’t something I would pick up again for a reread.