Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for a free ARC in exchange for a review.

First off, I must say that my ARC was missing half of chapter 31, most of chapter 41, and some of 51. So I lost some stuff!

But! I enjoyed this one! The competition was fun even though the ending was a little rushed. I still wish I knew Genevieve better, and Blackwell's <spoiler> reveal and him being forgiven was very fast </spoiler>. But overall, it was a fun, dark, paranormal romp. Well suited to the spooky season.

The portrayal of Ophelia's OCD was innovative and informed by the author's own experiences, and really made her a unique protagonist, as well as her other traits and personality. I also always appreciate a content warning at the beginning of a book!

Also, I KNEW Blackwell was Danny Phantom-coded with his silver hair and green eyes, and that author's note confirmed it. I see you, Kaylie, I get it.

If you're looking for a quick, spooky read, I recommend picking up Phantasma! It's probably not going to be your next most favorite book, but it is going to be a great time! Three and a half stars, rounded up to 4 for Goodreads.

I really enjoyed this book!
It reminded me so much of Caraval by Stephanie Garber, that it was at times difficult to separate them, having finished that book not long ago.
There is a lot of spice here, so if you have the audio , be careful of prying ears!
The narrator is brilliant, I only needed a couple of days to finish the book.

Firstly, thank you to Netgalley and Second Sky/Forever for this ARC!

I could not put this book down. The world is so interesting and I love the gothic atmosphere. It’s like a dark, adult version of Caraval with gothic CW The Originals vibes (New Orleans).

There’s devils, ghosts, necromancers, phantoms, a ghost cat 🐈‍⬛ etc.

This book is a perfect blend between paranormal, plot, romance and atmosphere. The characters each have their own personality that shines through. I love that the deadly trials are based off the circles of hell.

I also appreciate how Kaylie Smith depicted her own journey with OCD and intrusive thoughts/tics through the FMC (portrayed a monstrous voice in her head). I thought it was very interesting to read it webbed up in and truly part of the story rather than it just being an essay on OCD. It was remarkably done.

I have noting bad to say about this book and I would highly recommend it to lovers of paranormal fantasy. An easy 5 ⭐️rating!

Gosh Darnit!!! This was such a good read!! The tension, the passion, the twists! I am dying for the second one and I have way too long to wait for it to come out! There was a perfect amount of horror and gore mixed in with some nice palate cleansers of spicey fun. The setting was eerie and haunting and the perfect vibe for the start of spooky season!

I know this comparison is made quite a bit but this book was very much Caraval vibes but with more heat and darkness.
I loved Blackwell. Ophelia and Genevieve were fine. I saw some of the twists coming but I enjoyed it all the while. There were some reveals that left me speechless though.
I did also like the portrayal of mental illness. It felt like the shadow was there the whole time.

I really really enjoyed it!! I genuinely thought it wasn’t that dark tho but that might just be me...
If you want Halloween vibes and sometimes to binge read, read this book!!
I loved Ophe and Blackwell’s relationship so much (I especially like Blackwell)

This book was so good! It was giving caraval vibes but I loved this way more. Will be continuing the series once more comes out

Honestly I’m not quite sure how to rate this one.
Did I enjoy it? Absolutely. Can I recommend it? That will definitely depend on who’s asking. 😅

Kingdom of the Wicked meets Dante’s Inferno in a haunted house and a deadly competition where the stakes are much higher than they seem.

Spicy, creepy as heck, a bit gory, and definitely not what I expected but not in a bad way? Like I’d almost classify it as horror more than anything but it’s like horror and romantasy had a baby. 😬

If you’re not comfy with demon characters (see the above Kingdom of the Wicked reference for the vague sorts we’re dealing with) ghosts, and necromancy, pass on this one.

If those aren’t turnoffs for you and you’re into gothic New Orleans vibes, you might want to grab this one!

I received an advance copy from the publisher, all opinions are my own and a review was not required.

This was a very fun book! It reminded me a lot of Caraval, but New Adult, and I really enjoyed it. I loved the game/contest aspect, and I'm always up for a magical/sentient house story, so I loved this! I thought the romance was really well-done, and I loved the banter between Blackwell and Ophelia so much. I liked Ophelia as a main character a lot as well, and the OCD representation was done well. Overall I would recommend this book, and I'm excited for Enchantra next year! :)

Ringrazio Kaylie Smith, la casa editrice e NetGalley per l’eARC in anteprima in cambio della mia onestà opinione.

Voto complessivo: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Dramma: 💧💧
Sugar: 🧁
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️.5

Trope: paranormal romance - forbidden love - g0re - deadly quest - magic

Una casa infestata itinerante. Prove m0rtali con in palio la possibilità di vedere realizzato qualsiasi desiderio. Tutto è possibile dentro Phantasma, ma c’è una regola da rispettare: non innamorarsi….

Alla fine ho deciso per una valutazione leggermente superiore alla sufficienza per premiare alcune buone idee di base.
Il problema, però, è che non vengono sfruttate fino in fondo.
Siamo a New Orleans: perché non dare un’impronta più decisamente southern gothic? La protagonista è una negromante, ma non la vediamo mai usare davvero questo tipo di magia, bensì altre capacità. Per Phantasma e i gironi infernali avremmo dovuto avere descrizioni molto più evocative, invece è tutto abbastanza scontato.
Data l’ambientazione, l’autrice avrebbe dovuto andarci giù più pesante, sia con il g0re, sia con lo spice: man mano che la storia procede, è come se ingranasse, ed ecco che finalmente abbiamo un po’ di sängūę, ma è un po’ troppo blando. Discorso analogo per lo spice.
Ci sono inoltre tante ingenuità, a partire dalla storia d’amore al centro della vicenda, con un plot twist telefonatissimo, per cui in alcuni momenti mi sono davvero trascinata nella lettura.
In conclusione, la mia valutazione, pur evidenziando diverse criticità, vuole essere uno sprone ad osare di più nei lavori futuri, perché, a mio avviso, ci sono margini di miglioramento.

This book was so good. I really enjoyed the writing. Even though the events of the game were not as well written, I enjoyed the characters. I’ll definitely be reading the next one too.

I’m not 100% sure what I was expecting when I dove into this, but this surprised me the whole way!! Give me dark, trigger warnings and morally gray all day!

Uhm this book is just perfect for the spooky season and I’m glad I got to read it😍 The gothic atmosphere made me love it even more. It was so fast paced and forbidden and fun that it made me giggle out loud a few times. Ophelia and Blackwell’s dynamic was something that I really appreciated as well because you don’t see this kind of sarcastic banter a lot. Also the OCD representation was amazing! Another unique aspect about this book.

Spice level is high, which I do not mind when it is done correctly. It was never cringy. I loved the beginning, middle, and end of this book. In fact, if my TBR wasn't so currently large I feel like I would want to immediately re-read this book. I also got the audible version and enjoyed the narrator: Laura Horowitz. Thank You Netgalley for the electronic version of book. This is currently available on KU.

When the cover & book vibes match 100%, I'm a happy reader! Smith absolutely delivered on the gothic, mysterious, sexy story that was promised. Overall, I recommend this book to romantasy readers who prefer stories more heavily weighted to romance themes.

The plot: When Ophelia's mother dies unexpectedly, leaving behind even more unexpected debts, Ophelia is left reeling. The next day, her sister leaves without a word and enters a deathly competition at Phantasma where most entrants will die in search of the elusive prize: one wish granted. Ophelia is forced to compete to save her sister, facing 9 levels of intense challenges in the haunted and twisty manor where physical and spiritual threats alike are on the hunt for blood. The most dangerous temptation facing Ophelia may be a less obvious threat: the charming phantom stranger who offers to assist her in exchange for help in his own fate... because falling in love is, of course, forbidden at Phantasma.

My opinion: I liked this. The premise was a unique spin on the challenge/battle theme, and I enjoyed the explorations of deadly sins as challenge themes. There was also a great variety of magical beings from devils to ghouls to necromancers, which added interest. and depth to the story. The explorations of Ophelia's OCD were vivid and bold, especially the personification of her condition during Phantasma's manipulations and her explicit thoughts of harm. The romance between Blackwell and Ophelia was enjoyable, although a bit too "insta-love" for my tastes and verging on the border of smut vs. romance with fewer scenes emphasizing emotional connection compared to physical connection. I would have liked to see a bit more exploration in the challenges themselves of how the sins affected the contestants, and possibly more interactions between the other contestants and Ophelia. This would have added more depth to Ophelia's character (aside from her relationship with Blackwell and Genevieve) and allowed her to mature in her social relationships beyond her standoffish, isolationist start at Phantasma. The ending was somewhat predictable but in a satisfying way given the unfolding of the story throughout. Overall I rate this 3.5 stars and recommend to romantasy/gothic fiction readers.

Thank you NetGalley and Second Sky/Forever for this ARC!

Overall I quite liked the story. Was it good? Yes. Was it great? Not really. Would I recommend it? Ummm, I don’t know. But I quite enjoyed reading it.
I found the premise of this story quite interesting. A necromancer and a ghost, it’s quite an intriguing pair.
I found that the plot itself was fun and the characters were varied.
I would give this a 3.5 stars just because the fantasy was not as present as the romance was. I also felt like there could’ve been a slower burn and more chemistry between both MCs.

Phantasma was a cross between the trials from Serpent and the Wings of Night, and the Haunting of Hill House were unexpected family secrets lie, with a heavy dash of gore.

Ophelia inherits her mother’s powers as a necromancer when she finds her mother’s died unexpectedly. As she struggles with the grief she discovers her mother’s debts and her sister’s plan to attend Phantasma mansion, a competition wherein deals with devils could cost more than your soul. The prize is a boon that could bring back a loved one. Ophelia doesn’t know what she’d ask for, and doesn’t care as long as she can get her sister back.

Ophelia finds herself attending Phantasma, but is in a separate part of the trials, locked away in another wing. She quickly sees things other attendees does not with her experience as a necromancer, and while people make deals with devils, she finds an ally in a phantom called Blackwell. He’s able to help her through the trials, for a price; find out why he’s trapped in Phantasma. Between him and her own moxie she survives both the trials and the nightly horrors of the house, and the pair quickly find themselves falling in love. Only the house won’t stand for it, and if they want to find Ophelia’s sister, and break whatever bond holds Blackwell to the house, they may have to give each other up.

This story had one of the best opening scenes I’ve read for a while, with a promise of complicated magic woven into a family legacy that Ophelia was ready to shoulder. However I found that while Ophelia was an interesting character, it wasn’t until they get to the Phantasma mansion that the story really picks up. I loved her bite and cynicism and her banter with Blackwell, but the romantic scenes were more like erotica than a standard romance which was fine, it was more that for such an interesting concept the characters arrival to this intimacy was rushed, and there were a lot of the cliché expressions in the scenes that made this arc fall flat. I still very much enjoyed their banter and the relationship arc. The problems picked up for me when I started to notice a series of contradictions from page to page that didn’t flow well. There were rules to the trials that later were broken without comment, characters would contradict themselves, and there were world building problems with the magic systems. This was an imaginative and dark read that once got into the thick of the plot was predictable but very engaging with unique characters and interesting magic system.

I loved this story. It was described as caraval meet throne of the fallen and that is exactly what it delivered. Those are two of my very favorite books and I was not disappointed.

WOW. The romance wasn't so much for me but the concept of this book and the levels/games were deeply fascinating and I enjoyed them thoroughly. I'm ready for the second book! Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the advance copy.

I was stuck between giving this book a 3.5 or 4 star rating. The spice is what pushed it to a 4 star for me.

I LOVED the cover, LOVED the blurb however maybe I hyped this book up too much for myself or maybe it was the seeing it EVERYWHERE. This book just fell short for me.
I would have liked to have seen a bigger build up to the romance side and a more explosive ending.