Member Reviews

Thank you to Atria books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book in advance of its release.
As someone who was not a fan of 'The Long Game', I wanted to give this author another chance, and I am so glad I did!
I loved this book. Elena Armas is known for a good slow burn, and she did not disappoint.
This title is fake dating, marriage of convenience at its finest.
Josie and Matt have amazing chemistry and Elena makes us work for their first kiss. The buildup is EVERYTHING!!
Josie is a runaway bride of sorts,and has been engaged 5 times. We never really find out what happened in the previous engagements, which was disappointing considering this was a major plot point.
Josie is quirky, smart, and talks so much. I absolutely loved her. I don't see how anyone wouldn't fall in love with her as a MFC.
She is a kind and genuine person, but I am unsure why Josie felt the need to get this raveled into a lie for the sake of her father's good name. Those daddy issues are running strong.

Other than wishing there was a bit more backstory here, I loved this one and would highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Elena Armas is great at slow-burn. I was practically begging for the leads to just kiss already!

I loved the small-town vibes and now I want to visit Green Oak to pet goats and piggies.

The fake dating plot was fun, with real chemistry and witty banter between Josie and Matthew. It was a perfect summer read. I enjoy a male lead who believes in soulmates and happily ever afters. Both leads were easy to like and relate to.

Thank you Atria Books and Netgalley for the arc!

Was this review helpful?

4 stars

I enjoyed this book and I loved the flirty banter between the MCs. I also liked this more than The Long Game. However, I felt some things were missing, particularly more information about the backstory of the 4 ex fiancées. And some things were mentioned but never expanded on(where was the senator on September 15th?!?). I also think the book could’ve been 5 stars if it had been dual POV because I would’ve LOVED to see the MMCs intense pining from his side, I think it would’ve made me kick my feet endlessly.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book and could not put it down! It had me laughing and crying and falling for Matthew myself! I don’t normally reread books but this one I would over and over again!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars!

Thank you to the publisher and Elena Armas for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

I really enjoyed this! I fell in love with Josie and all her quirks in The Long Game and I was so happy to know that The Fiancé Dilemma would center around her and Matthew.

Just like Josie, this book was a whirlwind that kept you guessing. I loved Matthew and Josie together and the fact that Matthew was always in her corner from day one - especially considering how their first meeting went!

I also loved seeing Adalyn and Cam again!

Was this review helpful?

WOW I loved this so so much.

Matthew was so perfect and the way he showed up for Josie just had me swooning nonstop. I’m a sucker for a good fake dating trope and this book just did things so so so right.

I’m literally already itching to read this again.

Thank you to Atria Books + NetGalley for this eARC!

Was this review helpful?

The obsession I have with this book. Matthew coming to Josie’s help randomly at first and then continuing to try to show Josie that she is worth more than what everyone expects of her or what the media is saying melted my heart. Also the fact that he’s her newfound sister’s best friend who can’t stand the deadbeat dad (for Josie) and isn’t afraid to go against him or the people’s he’s hired to “fix the mess” that is his new daughter’s PR nightmare of almost weddings? Love him. Josie is a sweetheart who deserves protecting and I’m glad Matthew recognized that

Was this review helpful?

I didn't read the first book in the series before this one and I feel like I should have to fully get this one. I think this book could still be a stand-alone, but background and context was missed without the first. I think I had a hard time understanding Matthew and Josie's dynamic because he likes her almost immediately. I wish we got to see more growth there because I kept thinking "was I supposed to read the one before this to get it?". I also think Cam and Adalyn were mentioned too little for them to hold any emotional stakes to me as someone who is reading this stand-alone, but too often that it made me confused on if I actually HAD to read that book before.

I liked Josie as a character, but I wish we got more depth on her role as mayor. Like I said, maybe they do that in the last book, but it felt more like something that was occasionally said in this one. I also think we never saw her coffeeshop again after about halfway through.

Matthew felt pretty one-dimensional to me. I only learned that Matthew loves Josie, Boston, and not his old job. I'm not sure I know much else about him than his feelings for Josie.

We also never found out why her engagements ended before. At one point, I thought it was hinting that it would be like a big reveal later but it just... wasn't. I think there were too many half baked antagonists: Bobbi (who I actually enjoyed lol), Andrew, Otto (is he one? idek!), Duncan.

Fake dating is my favorite trope and I don't mind formulaic aspects about it. I think, however, that this one just didn't do it for me. I'm rating this 2.75 stars!

Was this review helpful?

i absolutely loved this book! i was in a reading slump for a while and this was the book that broke me out of it. Josie and Matthew’s story literally made me tear up, i kid you not. i laughed, i cried, this made me feel everything. Fake Dating is one of my favourite tropes and Elena Armas captured it perfectly. I started this book on the way to work and i wasn’t able to continue reading until I got home, where I finished it in one sitting. It was a fast paced book and I loved every moment of it. Thank you for the opportunity to give me an ARC!

Was this review helpful?

💜Fake Engagement
💜He Falls First
💜Small Town
💜Slow Burn

This was such a fun and entertaining read. I enjoyed the fake dating aspect and that Matthew went along with Josie’s hare brained idea…going along with her telling her dad she was engaged to him. I loved that he stood up for her and fell hard for her. Josie was an endearing character that I loved from the get go. She was down to earth and relatable as well as funny. These two had me cracking up multiple times! Over all I really enjoyed this book. The only thing was I wish that we had gotten more of Matthews point of view.

Was this review helpful?

From Spanish Love Deception to The Long Game Elena Armas has had an incredible way with words and has become a writer whose works I enjoy greatly. The Fiancée Dilemma was absolutely no different.
First I would like to give a huge thank you to #NetGallery and #Atria Books for an Arc copy in exchange for my honest opinion. I truly am grateful for having an opportunity to read this story.
The Fiancée Dilemma is an extreme good time. For fans of The Long Game you are definitely going to want to read about Josie and Matthew’s story.
What I loved about this story was how funny it was. Grandpa Moe, Adalyn and Maria do not disappoint. There is no third act breakup and he falls first. I also love the idea that along the way Matthew and Josie fall in love and he sees her for who she truly is. Josie for along time hasn’t been seen or heard by the men in her life. Matthew accepts and loves her for everything she is and everything she stands for. Matthew was a man you would definitely need in your own relationship.
Overall i thoroughly enjoyed this story. My overall rating is 4 stars. The only wish i had was to get more of Matthew’s p.o.v but even though we didn’t this story was overall a good time

Was this review helpful?

The Fiancé Dilemma

Thank you NetGalley and Atria books for the advanced readers copy of The Fiancé Dilemma.
This was a different plot than I’m used to: Josie has been engaged four times and this book highlights the story of her fifth engagement. I mistakenly did not read The Long Game, which is this book’s predecessor. I assume I would have more background story if I had read it prior.

Josie and Matthew were a cute story, but not the most believable, even for a fiction novel. I enjoyed my time reading this and I suggest fans of Elena Armas add this book to their reading list!

Was this review helpful?

I finished this gem a while ago and finally get to gush about it! I love Elena Armas- her writing is hilarious, fast-paced, and creative. I also love that the characters that she creates are real and experience feelings in a realistic way. The entire book I was laughing because of the crazy situation the FMC finds herself in, but what I LOVED was that the MMC gave up and just went with it! Yes, it's a slow burn, fake dating, small-town story, but it feels original because of the characters Armas developed. There's SO much chemistry throughout the entire book that I was screaming at some points for the two goofballs to finally give in, and it did not disappoint! I do love a story where the MMC falls first (and hard)! I didn't need confirmation, but yeah, I'll read anything Elena Armas writes! Highly recommend this wonderful read! Brb, about to start my reread...
Thanks, #NetGalley for my ARC of #TheFianceDilemma

Was this review helpful?

loved this book! the fiance dilemma is just marriage of convenience perfection. in elena fashion, its so funny and chemistry filled.

Was this review helpful?

Elena Armas at her best. Fast paced, entertaining, everything you want out of a contemporary romance. I found myself grinning at the ARC far more often than I care to admit. A perfect summer romcom.

Was this review helpful?

This book was not a favorite for me and I had hoped it would be. It seemed like a light and fun read, but overall it did not hit home for me. The characters were just ok, the banter was off, and the whole thing made for an ok read. The characters were choppy, the storyline was blah, and it just made for a difficult read. I didn't connect with any of the characters and the storyline should have been easy and light, but this was hard to finish. Overall this book was not for me.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Good book. Elena Armas has a way of writing characters that you can hate at the beginning but then love by the end. Josie was manipulative, but you understood her by the end. Matthew single-handedly saved this from being a terrible romance.

My outward facing notes are here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6552900768.

Copyedit notes:
Pg 45 2nd paragraph: "I also wish I hadn't," -- just (suggesting adding a comma for clarity). Had to reread the sentence.
Pg 111 second paragraph should read "concern surged..." -- not "concerned surged"?
Pg 260 1st paragraph last sentence "...Or when I flip you on your* belly?..." -- "your" is missing?
Pg 295 paragraph 3 last sentence, "...but my hormones are on* high alert " -- not "in high alert"?
Pg 299 paragraph 2, 4th sentence "...telling you anyone's story..." -- "anyone's" instead of "no one's"?

Was this review helpful?

ELENA DID IT AGAIN! Josie and Matthew are quite possibly my favorite couple, they are so amazing. Matthew is 10/10 and possibly one of my favorite MMCs ever. I missed the cute quirky Josie I got to see in The Long Game but my love for her is still strong. Genuinely loveable characters and a great book!

Was this review helpful?

"Beautiful things shouldn't be boxed. It eventually dims their light."

I am very conflicted on how I feel about this book.

What I liked:
- Matthew is 🔥🔥🔥
- the small town is a joy to be back on. I wish we got more time with the all the kids in town
- I enjoyed the parts with Josie and Shark, where she really stood up for herself.

What didn’t work for me:
- When the scenes at the end of chapters were just cut off, and the next chapter would pick up days later. It happened so many times.
-Some of the chemistry between Matthew and Josie felt lacking

Was this review helpful?

3.75/5 stars: I was grateful to receive an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. This was my first Elena Armas book. I enjoyed the romance a lot and Matthew Flanagan is the KINDEST soul. I loved that there is no third act breakup! I just found myself super confused about what any of this has to do with Josie’s dad. I HATED Bobbi the whole story. She was annoying & honestly felt unnecessary. I didn’t like the podcast & thought it was unnecessary. I wished there was more of a redemption arc with Josie & her father’s story. I enjoyed the romance, but the plot with her dad & the PR was hard to understand. Overall, I did enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?