You will like this book if you like: sprawling epics of destiny that read like a gossip mag, the feeling of reading Daisy Jones & The Six for the first time, and the hunt for ice dance Olympic gold ⛸️🥇

BOOK: The Favorites, by Layne Fargo

I was looking forward to this book but for some reason, it just didn't grab me. I know others will like it so I will recommend it and try and revisit this book at a later time.

I enjoyed this book! It reads a bit like a young adult novel based on the early part of the book. It kept my attention and had me wanting more.

I know what the cover looks like, but this book was about Olympic ice dancers and it was fabulous! Kat and Heath take you along on their tumultuous journey from kids to adult Olympians and all the bumps along the way. I love the Olympics so much, so this one had me hooked pretty quick. It is written a little similarly to Daisy Jones and the Six’s documentary format but with narrative chapters that follow. I highly recommend if you love Olympic drama and an all around good story.

a thrilling tale of passion, lust, jealousy and competition. I loved the competitive nature of the ice skating world and really loved the two main characters and their love story

I am a big fan of Layne Fargo so I was ecstatic to get read The Favorites. I was hesitant due to the plot but I loved it, and wouldn't really change a thing! She is a must-read!

<i> Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC!</i> (3.5/5 stars).
To start, this is a positive 3.5, I really enjoyed The Favorites, but I felt like it needed a little something more to truly stand out. It follows childhood friends Heath and Kat through their journey from small town kids to ice dancing (essentially figure skating) competitors. We follow the duo through not only their skating journey, but their romantic and personal journey too. The format of this book is a lot of fun, as it has "interview" sections sprinkled throughout to mimic a documentary about the pair as outside perspective to contrast Kat's narration. It definitely has pieces of Daisy Jones & The Six, which Fargo mentions as inspiration in her author's note.

This book reads like a dramatic TV series filled with twists, turns, and well... drama. But none of it really was too surprising to me. Maybe because Fargo stayed so tightly in this figure skating world, the shock moments felt predictable (somewhat mirroring real world events, somewhat because there wasn't much room for her to explore or branch out). The only major mystery for me had an underwhelming reveal. The pacing was good, but the book felt like it dragged a bit in order to tell Kat and Heath's full story. There were points where I felt like the story could have finished and was surprised there was still more book left. The toughest part was that the book focused on the childhood experience of Kat, Heath, and their peers for a long time in the beginning. This set the tone to be more YA-friendly, and that tone carried throughout the book. I wish Fargo pushed herself to make the feeling more adult. Overall though, the writing was good and the characters were really well developed. I enjoyed this read and would definitely read another from Fargo.

I wanted to love this more but honestly it didn't hit for me like I thought it would. I think maybe the style of it? I might need to try the audio.

This Wuthering Heights-inspired story shows the cost of ambition and success. Cat and Heath (she, a figure skater with her eye on greatness; he, a reluctant figure skater who'd do anything to stay close to Cat) have grown up together, and nothing can come between them. But as her training grows and everything she's ever wanted feels more and more achievable, Heath becomes the cost she has to leave behind.

Revenge, jealousy, and attraction run rampant throughout this book. Even knowing the plot of Wuthering Heights, The Favorites packs some hidden surprises.

As a huge Layne Fargo, I was desperate for this book! I am sickly obsessed with They Never Learn. I adored the collab for Young Rich Widows. Layne Fargo has the ability to grab emotions and twist them while you squirm. I read an article recently about how The Favorites was a departure from her thriller writing yet, it had a grip on me.

I believe in negatives first: I don't like love stories or codependence. I don't read a lot of authors due to that disinterest. So if it hadn't been for this being a book by Ms. Fargo, I'd never have read it. The codependence of Kat and Heath in the beginning was sickly sweet. I was tempted to skip forward.

At times the book seemed to go on forever. I kept waiting for some actual drama or scandal... But the plot just kept on going...

I expected more from Lee, his character was so basic, so "Midwestern". I expected more yet, it was pretty exacting.

Garrett Lin at times was a baseline character. However if he was "normal" it showed how over the top everyone else was. But he wasn't normal. And truthfully, you see how Famous Professional Athletes act, how different was Kat's attitude? Or is it purely sexism?

The missing 3 years - it was predictable where he went but not what happened.

The 3 is company plot was odd.
--

Both Heath and Kat's codependence dissipates as they get closer to the Olympics. They start to become stubborn in their choices and realize that their passion isn't on par with their desire for Gold. As they gear up for The Last Time, I was utterly confused as to who the villain was. I will say I was shocked!

Positives:
I'm not sure why reviewers dislike Kat, she is tough as nails and stays completely in her lane. I found her impressive and professional at the height of Paparazzi.

Ultimately, while this is a departure from Layne Fargo's other books, it was really good. It did seem to go on forever though. I still am not interesting in ice skating or ice dancing, but I do find myself impressed by the dedication of the athletes.

Another reviewer said that Heath is the winner in the story. I'm inclined to half-agree. After Japan, Heath completely changed and he seemingly discovered that he was in control of his own destiny and he was an Adult. And he could be his own family. now that he had money. Heath got all the money, fame and family.

Ultimately, the winner (IMO) are the Lin Twins. They got to re-write their stories and move past their lineage and expectations. Bella got to lean into her passions and Garrett was able to let go and be himself.

This book is my favorite read of 2025 and it’s gonna take a lot to knock it out of first place. This book was so addictive and the messy in the best kind of way that I could not put it down and I recommended to everybody. There’s times where you love and hate all the characters and it’s done absolutely beautifully.

4.25/ This was so entertaining and so toxic. I was invested as this jumped from scandal to scandal and was rooting for Heath and Kat even though they're absolutely awful together. The ending was heartwarming.

ANGGGGGGGSTYYYYYY READDDDDD. If you want angsty, this book is the one for you! One of the best read this year and the way it had me hooked is insane

Two fiercely ambitious figure skaters, Kat Shaw and Heath Rocha, share an electrifying partnership on and off the ice, but their pursuit of Olympic gold is riddled with betrayal, scandal, and heartbreak. Told through a mix of gripping narration and a fictional documentary, this whirlwind tale of obsession, rivalry, and passion will keep readers on edge until the final, jaw-dropping twist. While the plot builds slowly, readers will be inexorably drawn in to the drama and intrigue of pairs skating. Perfect for anyone who loves reality TV, *Daisy Jones and the Six*, or intense romantic dramas.

this is for fans of "daisy jones and the six" and "magnolia parks"
not "or." "and"!!!
honestly, the Daisy Jones comparison mostly just covers the documentary-style chapter breaks and the long-spanning timeline of this book. I don't think this style was as effective in this book as it was in DJ—it felt like Layne Fargo forgot that these scripts were part of a documentary halfway through the book and they just became script-style conversations to move the plot along. I think if you actually acted out the scripts and filmed the b-roll she describes in these sections, it would make for a very bizarre documentary lol.
still, I didn't really mind the scripts. the "magnolia parks" comparison is where the stars fell off for me, as I tragically am a weak baby and I need my romance books (or books with romantic sub plots) to be absolutely drama and conflict-free. star-crossed toxic lovers make my tummy hurt
I was hoping that the tension in this book would more come from the (light light light—fyi) mystery element and the skating competition, not the interpersonal relationships. but that's just me!

AMAZING BOOK. The best read of 2025. I couldn’t put it down. The characters were amazing. The flow was amazing. The TS reference amazing.

First off thank you to NetGalley and Random House publishing for this ARC.

I love figure skating!! It’s my number one Winter Olympics event both singles and doubles. Even so I felt like I learned lots about the technical side. This book also hit on my love for true Hollywood stories, two pages in and I was hooked!!! Loved the format. So loving skating not necessarily required.

My one gripe is it could have been a bit shorter. But otherwise fantastic!!

4/5 ⭐️

Oh, this one was good! The obsession, the ambition, the messy relationships - it all felt so real. "The Favorites" is a whirlwind of passion and rivalry, following two figure skaters whose connection burns bright on and off the ice. The tension, the chemistry, and the emotional weight of their journey had me completely hooked.

The documentary/interview format was so compelling; it felt like I was uncovering a real-life scandal, flipping pages like I was watching history unfold. Katarina is flawed, fierce, and unforgettable (think "Carrie Soto Is Back" but with ice dancing and even more intensity).

That said, a couple of plot choices kept this from being a perfect five stars (no spoilers, but ugh). Still, if you love dramatic, emotionally charged sports stories, this is a must-read. And seriously, go watch Tessa Virtue & Scott Moir's performances: it's exactly the vibe of this book. 4.25/5 stars!

4.5 stars! Omg this book was so addicting. I was so obsessed and invested the entire time! I loved all of the drama and the ups and downs. It was just so good.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for the arc!

This book is everywhere right now, and it is so deserving of the hype! I will die on the hill that every audio should be a full cast audio. This was an incredible production with an all-star cast of narrators including two time Olympian Johnny Weir!! Have I pitched this hard enough that audio is the way to go with this book?

I’ve been a Layne Fargo fan for a while - you have to go back and read They Never Learn which is a massive shift from this story and is a much darker serial killer story but also incredible!

This is similar to Daisy Jones and the Six in its interview style narration and this format works so well for me. However, this is far more like Carrie Soto and is very heavily a sports story set in the figure skating world. This story is juicy, gossipy, and full of scandal and drama. This is reminiscent of a Bravo show or daytime soap opera! However - this is not quite the romance story it’s being marketed as so temper expectations with this piece. The story is completely addicting and you are guaranteed to have a lot of fun with this book!