Member Reviews

An unabashedly queer story that tells several perspectives and experiences. While it is absolutely a horror, the horror comes more from how our MCs are treated than the from the monster. Yes, there is a monster, but it's not necessarily the big bad of the story. Had some pacing issues for me personally, but I think this is a really important book to have our there and lots of teens will enjoy it. Definitely for fans of Andrew Joseph White.

Was this review helpful?

Old Wounds is an emotionally raw & tender story that tackles both internal and external transgender topics with a sharp tooth and tongue, all wrapped up in a wonderfully queer horror metaphor. Our main characters, Max & Erin, are hard not to fall in love with immediately, from their complicated history to their general rapport they were an absolute treat to read and go on this adventure with. The stand-out of this book is definitely the way Kisner explores transness so fiercely and thoughtfully and going even further to elevate the commentary by delving into in how Max and Erin exist in the world with both shared *and* uniquely individual trans experiences. Reading the acknowledgements and learning that this story comes from a love of horror movies (and specifically watching them through a queer lens) makes so much sense when you experience all of the complexities and layers of symbolism Kisner lays out for us in this. The cherry on top is one of my favorite elements in horror, challenging the audience's preconceived notions about what a monster really is. While hopefully obvious for most readers, it's just as impactful and relevant to recognize the monstrosity in our everyday society, in laws being passed and harmful rhetoric that continues to persist. Kisner does a great job with the pacing in this, balancing wonderfully fraught moments of tension with soft moments of confronting emotional vulnerabilities.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Due to unforeseen life circumstances, I have only been able to sit down and read this book now, and I will be picking up a copy as soon as I post this.

When I first saw this book mentioned on Twitter, I jumped at the chance to be an ARC reader for it. It has everything I've ever wanted to see in a novel, especially trans characters and some kind of strange, unknowable force of nature that humanity cannot hope to understand. Old Wounds definitely delivers on both, and it has some of the richest characterization I've ever seen.

Max and Erin are such beautiful, flawed, interesting, and imperfect characters that make you care about them right away, which ratchets the tension of the book higher and higher. They are such an amazing juxtaposition of experiences. Max has just freed himself from being denied from transitioning into a man while Erin has been allowed to transition, though the process has not necessarily been easy for her. Max's parents are not supportive; Erin's mother is trying even as she has flaws. Neither of them have it truly easy; both of them have their own unique struggles, and where they are so similar, they are also so different, which makes for utterly captivating writing.

Old Wounds is easily a 5 star read. The tension, the struggles, and the importance of a book like this cannot be understated. And it absolutely wrenched open my chest every time they discussed the reality of trans people we've lost due to the prejudice and bigotry in this world. There is something so raw and so beautiful in the way they are both fighting, in the way they were both survivors even before they ended up in Kentucky, fighting for their lives in the most literal sense.

Utterly stunning book. I hope to see more trans horror in the future, and this book has my hopes high.

Was this review helpful?

Max and Erin are two teens embarking on an epic road trip from Ohio to California. That sounds banal, until you learn that both Max and Erin are transgender, they used to be a couple, and they haven't spoken in two years until Max asked Erin to accompany him on his escape from his transphobic family. Just when they're settling into the journey and overcoming the strangeness of their relationship, their trip is halted with a flat tire...and then the horrors begin.

Although the exposition leading to the real action was a little long for a relatively short novel, this book was a nail-biting horror story, and I loved every second of it. Kisner manages to cover the topics of gender, toxic family dynamics, teen relationships, and new beginnings. And if you've ever wondered how a gender-specific, murderous backwoods cryptid interprets the existence of trans people...you'll find your answer here. As in real life, however, sometimes the real horror may be in what humans can do to other humans.

I was able to read this digital ARC thanks to Netgalley. There were a handful of continuity errors and misused vocabulary, but I suspect those will be fixed before the final published versions. Overall, I'm adding queer horror as my new favorite genre.

Was this review helpful?

Oh, I wanted this to be good, and it did not disappoint! Kisner does an excellent job talking about the trauma in Max’s past while still making this a story of trans joy and resilience. Literally battling monsters. Even though we all know the real monsters are other humans.

Altogether this was a quick, breathless read, and the best bit of horror I have read in a while. The scenes are well drawn and immersive. I will 100% be looking for more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

Oooof. This is a hard read. It’s difficult to read about human beings treating other humans horribly. However, it’s really important to have trans narratives, and this is a good addition to the genre.

Two trans teens, one male, one female, find themselves in the middle of nowhere with a broken down vehicle. Considering they made themselves impossible to track, they both are completely at the mercy of some people with nefarious intentions. Add some typical horror elements, and you’ve got yourself a page-turner.

CW: There’s a lot of blood and gore here. The cover should warn you what you’re getting into.

Thanks to NetGalley and Delacorte Press for the eARC. All opinions are mine alone.

Was this review helpful?

Old Wounds follows two such teens Erin and Max, as they attempt to make their way to California when their car breaks down. Despite being stranded in the middle of nowhere, this backroads town seems to be suffocating the two. As horrific as the potential to be outed, there seems to be something more bestial lurking in the shadows. It’s up to Erin and Max to set aside their history and work together to save themselves.

The story is visceral, gripping, and possesses some of the most realistic depictions of the transgender experience from totally opposite ends of the spectrum. Max and Erin not only have their own fully realized voices, it’s those voices that carry the story and make the seemingly unbelievable monsters all the more real. Protect trans kids.

Was this review helpful?

Definitely not a bad book, just not my cup of tea. The plot dragged in the beginning a bit, and I feel like there was less of the cryptid than I had initially imagined there'd be.

Was this review helpful?

This is hands down one of my favorite books I've read this year. Which, considering the amazing books I've gotten my hands on, is saying something.

I literally couldn't put it down. I read it all in one sitting, skipping lunch because I couldn't bear to put it down. There are so many things I could say about this book--how much it horrified me, how much it made my heart hurt, how much I've ranted about it to friends in the last few days, how unapologetic and vivid the writing was, how much I adored these two messy flawed trans kids--but the biggest thing I've found myself thinking about it how it managed to be hopeful, heartfelt, and empowering. This story wouldn't have worked or captured me in the way it did without that. Because while the horror was great, those things were what lifted this book to fantastic.

It never flinched, it never let up, it had a chokehold on me the entire time I read, and this is a book I'm already wishing I could read for the first time again.

Thanks to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Two trans teens leave their homes in Ohio for San Francisco, but they don’t get far until things take a frightening turn.
Lost in a small town in West Virginia they encounter monsters they must try to survive. What’s worse, a mysterious creature? Or murderous humans?

This story was action packed, but also had heart. The author did a great job of showing the trauma Max had faced in the past, and why that has led to hi current actions and attitudes. Erin is along for the ride, but wondering why.
The story separates the two and they both must use their wits to try and survive and get back to each other.
The setting of the story is a perfect creepy backdrop for the monster in the woods, and the murderous humans hunting the pair. This would be a perfect read for Halloween season.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for letting me read an e-arc of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVE queer horror and Old Wounds is just another example of why. The way that the trans characters are not just ‘trans characters in a scary book’ but are THE trans characters in this wonderfully spooky book is everything. I can’t put into words just how beautiful the prose is, how amazing the characters are fleshed out into being these unique and deeply real people and how much I loved the movie that played in my head while reading this. I can’t recommend this enough, I couldn’t put this down and there’s a reason for that.

This review is also posted on Goodreads! Thank you so much to the publisher and the author for giving me the opportunity to read this INCREDIBLE arc for free. 🖤🏳️‍⚧️

Was this review helpful?

I LOVE trans horror and have to read everyone I find, and this one is now one of my faves in the genre. Horrifying, brutal and with fantastic trans characters leading the story.
These characters felt like so many people I’ve met. I’ve known these people and it made me love them and worry about them in a way that made the story feel so real.
The monster reveal? Fantastic. Loved the allegory of the monster to the trans characters, where the people scared of them were the real danger the whole time. The horror in this is so well handled in a way that it doesn’t shy away from its themes, but isn’t over the top in a way where it becomes too much. Just a fantastic example of horror writing.

I have only one crit with this book, and one that sadly drove me crazy the whole time.. Throughout this book the main characters talk alot about escaping their home town. Talk about how they were alone, had no resources, were outsiders. Their home town? Columbus ohio. The 15th gayest city in the US. Also, very much a city, not even close to a town. Speaking as a reader who grew up in appalachia and moved to columbus for college, columbus is seen by many queer small towners as a city to go to for resources. I know countless people who drive hours to columbus for their gender affirming care. It just drove me crazy everytime they were mourning their small town upbringing and it was columbus, I really wish the author chose an actual small town for the characters to be running from to make it seem more real.

Overall, loved this book. Finished it days ago and its still stuck in my brain, can’t wait to add a copy to my personal library.

Was this review helpful?

Damn. Just - damn.

I had no idea what to expect going into this, but it had everything I'd hope going into it - fantastic sharp writing, complex main characters, a creepy cryptid that may or may not be what it seems - and so much more. I feel like I can't gush like I can without going too in depth in the story. It very much feels like a book I would love to talk about with friends who've also read it.

I saw some reviews going on about how the monster wasn't that scary or didn't play a bigger part in the story than they thought it would, but I think they're missing the point. The monster in horror stories typically represent the overall real fear behind it, and in this book it's the very horrible reality of transphobia, the lengths it would go to in order to erase trans people from existence. The monster is never the thing with glowing eyes and sharp teeth; the worst ones are those who wear human faces.

That's all I really have to say about the story. What I really recommend is for everyone to go into this only have read the synopsis. Trust me - it's so much better this way.

Was this review helpful?

Trans kids are probably the bravest human beings on the planet.

This book rocked, and I stayed up way too late reading it. But honestly, isn't way-too-late the best time for horror?

Kisner's writing is razor-sharp and thrillingly visceral, and when you pair that with a lightning-strike plot and characters that radiate from the page, you've got a 5-star read from me that had me burning through each chapter. I loved Erin and Max so much, and I really can't stress how much I was locked into their road-trip from hell. Trans people have had to fight for their lives since the beginning of time, and, as a result, Max and Erin were two of the most believable horror protagonists I've had the pleasure of meeting. Absolutely give this book a go if you want a goosebumps-raising, bloody scream in the dark of a story with a heaping side of heart.

Bonus Points: The cultural references were *chef's kiss* and absolutely beefed up those moments in the narrative where so often I find myself taken out of the story when authors try to make such allusions. A couple more kindred spirits to Old Wounds that live in the same filing cabinet of my heart are the Attack the Block (I love me a furry, toothy monster), Jeepers Creepers (F- it's director tho, he's the real creep), and Desperation by Stephen King. Like Steve, I have a lot of cars-going-bad anxiety, okay?

Pick this one up on September 10, 2024. My many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher(s) for the digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?

"Old Wounds" by Logan-Ashley Kisner is one of those books that grabs you by the throat from page one and doesn’t let go until the end—and even then, you’ll be thinking about it for days. It’s like Midsommar meets a trans horror survival story, and honestly, I’m here for every minute of it. The tension between Erin and Max is chef’s kiss—so much unresolved history, but then BOOM, small-town cult weirdness happens, and suddenly all that drama feels like the least of their worries. The twists were so sharp I had whiplash, and the monster? It’s legit terrifying, but also kind of a metaphorical boss fight for their identities. All I’m saying is, if you’re into queer horror that digs into the complexities of survival, both emotional and literal, this one’s a must-read.

Was this review helpful?

While this isn't my first go around with trans horror, it may be my favorite thus far. I really appreciated that this wasn't just a horror story with a trans person at the center, but the complexity of their experience was directly informed by Erin and Max's social and physical transitions. I really enjoyed that as you really get into the conflict, the monster isn't what you think it is. At the end of the day, in this story and all other horror stories that trans people experience in real life, the monster at the heart of these experiences are people. I also really enjoyed exploring the question, do cryptids conceptualize gender? Overall I absolutely loved this concept, I loved how deeply we explored these characters, and I loved the inclusion of the horribly real experiences of trans people that were murdered. Now they will live forever.

*I will share this review online closer to publication date.

Was this review helpful?

*Sacrifice in the Shadows* is a gripping thriller that melds intense horror with a deeply emotional narrative. In this pulse-pounding story, Erin and Max, two transgender teens, find themselves stranded in a remote Kentucky town with a horrifying secret: the locals believe they must offer a female sacrifice to an ancient monster that prowls the woods. This novel is a harrowing and imaginative ride, perfect for fans of *Midsommar* and *Hell Followed with Us*.

Erin and Max are on a journey to California—Max eager to start his transition, Erin grappling with the reasons for their trip, and their complicated past hanging between them. Their plans take a nightmarish turn when they end up in a small, insular town where the locals adhere to a gruesome tradition: an ancient monster only emerges if a girl is sacrificed, and it only consumes what it kills. With the locals convinced that Erin is the ideal candidate for their dark ritual, the stakes couldn’t be higher.

The tension in *Sacrifice in the Shadows* escalates with every chapter. The sense of isolation and dread is palpable as Erin and Max face not only the monstrous entity lurking in the woods but also the terrifying hostility of the town’s residents. The story deftly explores themes of identity, survival, and the struggle against an oppressive fate, using horror as a lens to delve into deeper emotional truths.

Erin and Max’s background adds layers of complexity to their predicament. Their struggle for survival is intertwined with their personal journeys and their fight for acceptance and understanding. The irony of their situation—that the locals unknowingly target individuals who have already endured profound personal battles—adds a poignant edge to the story.

The narrative excels in creating a claustrophobic atmosphere, with the isolated setting and the ever-present threat of the monster enhancing the sense of urgency. The ancient monster, a chilling embodiment of the town’s darkest beliefs, adds a compelling supernatural element that keeps readers on edge.

*Sacrifice in the Shadows* is more than just a thriller; it is a powerful exploration of resilience and self-discovery under the most extreme circumstances. The novel’s blend of horror and emotional depth ensures that it resonates on both a visceral and psychological level. With its vivid descriptions, relentless suspense, and multifaceted characters, this book is a standout read that will captivate and haunt readers long after the final page.

Was this review helpful?

I’d give this book a 4.5 but rounded up to 5 since we can’t do half stars and I think this is an important book to have out in the world for young queer teens to see themselves in the stories they read. Even the horror stories.

First, thanks to NetGalley, Random House Children’s and Delacorte Press for the ARC of this book.

Second, check your triggers on this book. It’s got a lot of transphobia and homophobia in it. As well as some misogyny and then some.

I just finished this and I’m still at a bit of a loss on how to even describe it. It was heavy, but it was so well done.

This is a LGBTQIA+ YA horror that follows two trans teens, Erin & Max, who used to be friends until two years prior. Erin doesn’t know what she did to make Max cut her off, but when they are 18 and he invites her to runaway to cali with him, she accepts.

I won’t lie, I didn’t care for Max in the beginning. I thought he was an ass to Erin and I didnt fully understand why she’d go along with him. As the book progresses we get more insight into each character and it really helps you to understand where each of them is coming from. Being teens is hard, but being trans teens makes it harder, especially in a conservative area.

The book started a bit slow for me. I know some of the build up was needed, but the pacing was just a little off for me in the beginning, but it picked up quickly and boy did it pick up.

So aside from the author writing about trans teens and the hardships they go through and writing that so well. He also did a phenomenal job with the horror. I felt myself tensing up and times and holding my breath.

I can’t wait to see what else this author comes out with.

Was this review helpful?

I will always be a proponent for more Trans stories, especially those that can be read by younger audiences. Not only is this a deeply entertaining book, it helps people see themselves more in stories.

Was this review helpful?

The question of whether cryptids and folk beasts are gender bioessentialists is so simple and brilliant that I'm mad I'd never thought of it before, but also delighted that Kisner's exploration was so well done.

Was this review helpful?