I was pleased to receive a copy of Queen Macbeth for review, but sadly I found it disappointing.
It reads more like a précis of a longer novel, and seems very superficial. It has no character description, far less development, and is completely emotionless. I got no sense of Gruoch and her three women at all. Deaths are glossed over in a matter-of-fact manner, no grief or regret is expressed.
The two timelines appear to bear no relation to each other, and the ending is a big surprise, but not in a good way. It gives the sense that the author ran out of steam, or ideas, or interest, and just cobbled it together.
It’s like wading through treacle at some points ,then suddenly changes pace and gallops along for a while.
Not for me, I’m sorry to say.
My thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for my advance copy of this book.

When I first requested this DRC, I mistakenly thought that I would be receiving "Lady Macbeth"... I didn't read closely enough! However, I did attempt to give "Queen Macbeth" a try. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to get into the writing style, and about a fourth of the way through I had to give up. I rarely DNF books, so this was disappointing for me. While I admire the author's intentions, as well as the intense research that must have gone into bringing medieval Scotland to life, everything felt very surface-level to me. Perhaps if I had stuck it out, I might have found more depth and meaning—but alas.

I received a complimentary ARC copy of Queen Macbeth, A Novel by Val McDermid from Net Galley and Grove Atlantic | Atlantic Monthly Press

...a captivating and interesting read with strong, intelligent female characters, beautiful friendships, drama, and heartbreak...

In this retelling of Macbeth author, Val McDermid gives us another take on Shakespeare’s perhaps most famous work. McDermid sets out to offer the reader a more accurate picture of who Macbeth and Lady Macbeth were. From Queen Gruoch’s point of view we meet a strong courageous woman, not a villainess as portrayed. We then jump back and forth in time from her first meetings with Macbeth when she was already married to his cousin and self-proclaimed king, Gille Coemgáin. We then flash to several years later when she hears that King Macbeth has been killed at the battle of Lumphanan. In exile Gruoch and her dearest friends, not witches, Eithne, Aife and Ligath are on the run finding refuge in a monastery by Loch Leven. When they get news that her son Lulach has been killed and King Malcolm's men are closing in they must flee for their lives.
I haven’t revisited Shakespeare for a while but really looked forward to this interpretation from an author I admire and I wasn't disappointed.
I also appreciated the glossary with Scottish words that I otherwise might have struggled with.

Overall, I really found this to be a captivating and interesting read with strong, intelligent female characters, beautiful friendships, drama, and heartbreak. My only complaints would be the pacing, which felt a bit slow at first and I wish it was longer. All in all, I really did enjoy the book and would highly recommend it.

This was a fantastic novella that not only goes into the idea of what if Lady Macbeth didn’t kill herself and also what if the play Shakespeare wrote was completely false? 🗡️

We follow the grief stricken Gruoch as she lies hides away with her beloved four ladies in waiting and most-trusted guard. I just loved this portrayal of this woman. She’s not only a someone who has withstood tragedy and hardships, but she’s a person who is always looking out for those that she loves. Her tenacity and the relationships that she’s built with her women were well fleshed out and you can see the love they have for each other. I especially loved the addition of a wise woman and how even women who were gifted in different aspects were often looked upon with suspicion. 🌿

Her love with Macbeth is instantaneous, and yet it feels like you see the natural progression of their relationship. Even when they finally come together, there’s no power struggle between the two, and Macbeth seems to even love that she’s calculating and someone who he can turn to for advice. 💭

I really enjoyed the simultaneous recounting of both her current situation and the past, but I can see how this might be an issue for some people. And as much as I loved the length of this novella, I do feel like the ending came on a bit abruptly. I would have loved if this was a full on novel because I just loved the way McDermid wrote this world of 10th century Scotland and its people. The people are definitely more believable than a different Lady Macbeth retelling I read earlier. 😒

Big thank you goes to Polygon/Grove Atlantic and NetGalley for accepting my request to read this in exchange for an honest review, and to the author, McDermid, for writing a stellar Lady Macbeth novella. ❤️

Publication date: September 24!

Overall: 4.75/5 ⭐️

The writing style is not for me and I kind of got confused reading it. I typically love the story of MacBeth and Val McDermid's writing but this book was not a hit for me.

A well written historical retelling with just the perfect amount of intrigue and suspence. The characters were well written and this is a perfect example of a how a strong female character is to be written.

"Shakespeare created the myth of the Macbeths as indefensible murderous conspirators. But now internationally bestselling author Val McDermid drags the truth out of the shadows, exposing the patriarchal prejudices of history.

Britain's reigning "Queen of Crime" (The Scotsman), Val McDermid has ensnared audiences worldwide for over thirty years with her thrilling and masterfully plotted crime oeuvre. A radical, rip-roaring counternarrative drawing on the historical record, Queen Macbeth delivers an illuminating portrait of Shakespeare's most famous villain, and the treacherous pursuit of ambition that made her legendary.

A thousand years ago in an ancient Scottish landscape, a woman is on the run with her three companions - a healer, a weaver, and a seer. The men hunting her will kill her - because she is the only one who stands between them and their violent ambition. She is no lady: she is the first queen of Scotland, married to a king called Macbeth. As the net closes in, what unfurls is a tale of passion, forced marriage, bloody massacre, and the harsh realities of medieval Scotland. At the heart of it is one strong, charismatic woman, who survived loss and jeopardy to outwit the endless plotting of a string of ruthless and power-hungry men. Her struggle won her a country. But now it could cost her life.

Immersive and utterly riveting, Queen Macbeth is an electric reimagining of one of Shakespeare's most celebrated tragedies and reaffirms McDermid as one of the preeminent writers of our day."

Because I know, like me, you've always wondered about the truth of Lady Macbeth...

I enjoy Shakespeare, and the retellings can be a fun way to revisit the story, but this was extremely dry in the storytelling. I tried desperately, but nothing was keeping my attention.

Val McDermid definitely did her research! I loved reading about Lady (Queen) Macbeth as a powerful and fierce woman. That said, I found this novella very dry and at times hard to follow. Overall, I think this book’s abbreviated length stifled its potential. It seemed McDermid had more to say and skimmed over exciting scenes that could have gone a long way for reader engagement and interest.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read an ARC.

In this short novel – it’s almost a novella, really – McDermid revisits the story of Macbeth. She is interested in telling Queen Macbeth’s story in a way that is closer to the historical record than the version made famous by Shakespeare.

I feel that a plot summary is barely necessary – you all know the story of Macbeth, right? But this version is slightly different, told from the point of view of Gruoch, also known as Queen Macbeth. It tells of how the two came together, became rulers of Scotland, and of the jealousies, feuds, and fighting that came after.

Far from the scheming and ambitious woman presented to the popular imagination by Shakespeare, Gruoch is a young woman whose primary ambition is to be with the man she loves. Unfortunately, in an era when women got to explicitly make few choices, Gruoch has little option but to turn to scheming and plotting to achieve her goals.

McDermid depicts Gruoch in a way that humanises her and rounds out her character. We see her strong bonds with her women, her love for Macbeth, her strengths and her weaknesses. She’s a much more sympathetic character than the one likely lodged in your imagination. McDermid shows that she is much more than the famous play would have it.

I was also fascinated by the historical setting. It’s well researched and well depicted, and makes clear how much of Gruoch’s character and actions are shaped by the society she lives in. Although in some ways a simpler time, there are political and social considerations most of us don’t have to deal with.

I really enjoyed this. If you love McDermid’s crime novels, this is a bit of a change – the subject matter is very different. But it’s equally well written, with her strengths in characterisation and plotting on full display. Even if you have little interest in Shakespeare, this is worth reading for the way it shakes up your perspective.

This was a great book but the back and forth might be a bit for some readers. It goes back and forth between the past where Macbeth met his Queen to the future where she is on the run from Malcom and others who want the throne of Scotland. Very entertaining and a fun read.

I was drawn to this book because of the author and because the synopsis was intriguing. The idea of the tale of Macbeth, from the viewpoint of Macbeth's, unnamed, wife, certainly must be fascinating.

The book didn't disappoint. The tale of these four women, surviving the challenges of the this brutish violent world, displaying each of their varied abilities was excellent. The ending was absolutely unexpected.

If I had one suggestion, for the US audience and others, placing the glossary in the front of the ebook might be useful. I tried looking up bannock in an online dictionary, with no result. I was so pleased to find the answers in the glossary.

Sorry cannot read. Not in Kindle format. So sad, really wanted to read this too.
XXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXX

Set in the middle ages, Queen Macbeth (2024) by Val McDermid is the story of what happens after the death of Macbeth. Gruoch (Lady Macbeth) is in exile, hiding from Malcolm’s soldiers who are out for revenge. Gruoch and her three consorts are hiding away in a monastery by a Scottish lake. They are forced to flee when 2 stangers arrive at the abbey, forcing them on the run and needing to avoid local bandits as they head west for safety. A novella, Val McDermid has reimagined the middle ages and the characters of Macbeth sketched in Shakespeare’s play. With richly drawn characters, its a believable tale of Lady Macbeth’s life and enduring love. It's an enjoyable tale, requiring little knowledge of the play, that has a four stars read rating. With thanks to Grove Atlantic and the author, for an uncorrected advanced review copy for review purposes. As always, the opinions herein are totally my own, freely given and without any inducement.

Unfortunately, a few things disturbed me while I was reading. The novella is split in two timelines, and I did enjoy the present timeline. I did not like the past timeline at all, though. And I felt like this timeline took more space than the other, so that bothered me.
Also, in the past timeline, I felt like Queen Macbeth was not the main character, that we had a story of et son through her eyes instead. And I hated that. It was not interesting to me at all. I wanted the past timeline to be focused on her instead — as it should have, given the title.
Not enough Queen Macbeth for me.

Thank you to Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for a honest review.

This is not a retelling of the Shakespeare play - instead, it’s a reimagining of the historical story of Macbeth and Gruoch. We get a dual timeline narrative between the current timeline of Gruoch and her maids hiding out from those that want her dead now that Macbeth and her son are dead, and the past timeline of how she and Macbeth met and how they ended up married when she was married to another.

While just a novella, McDermid uses her words wisely. The writing style is beautiful and poetic, mixing in quite of bit of Scots (not to worry, there is a glossary). And while Gruoch may not be the scheming villainess of the play, she still has her ambition and cunning. There’s a few fun nods to Shakespeare as well. I thought this was quite well done as a retelling, as well as an ode to Scotland. Would highly recommend if you’re looking for a Macbeth retelling.

Thanks to #GroveAtlantic for the digital arc

This short story packs a punch. Taking both the Shakesperean play and the real life of Queen Gruoch, QUEEN MACBETH is a tale of the realities of women in medieval Scotland and the dangers of being a queen that wants the best for her country. It kept me on the edge of my seat and I finished it in one sitting.

This book - Queen Macbeth - was written as part of a series called The Darkland Tales in Scotland. The idea behind this project is an attempt to write the real stories of Scottish history. There are a lot of myths prevalent about the Past of Scotland. These myths have been converted to stories with as much historical accuracy as was possible and research available. The author Val McDermid, has termed her work as a 'charmingly plausible' recounting of a possible history of the Macbeths. They ruled over Scotland for seventeen years and made a long trip to Rome when they handed over the reins to a regent in their absence.

You may or may not agree with this retelling of history but its a most enjoyable read. Queen Macbeth is a short read - short but action packed. The story of Queen Grouch and King Macbeth turns out to be not as bloody as we were led to believe by Shakespeare but it is a tale of romance, war, betrayal and trust as most royal histories are. Not just the love between the protagonists, the most striking is the bond among all the women.

The women characters who are companions to the queen are strong and loyal. They also serve as a healer, a weaver and a seer to the protagonist. The queen is in hiding and has to flee a safe haven to protect herself and perhaps finds her husband. Surrounded and protected by these women and other loyalists, she faces the violent times and enemies.

I found this book an easy read but with not as much drama and tension as is normal in other books by Val McDermid. I like the writing style where she toggles between the present and the past while giving us a complete narration of the queen's struggles and journey. I enjoy reading history specially written in this form, so I quite enjoyed the book.

I have to thank Netgalley and Grove Atlantic for providing me with an ARC of one of my favourite authors in exchange for an honest review.

Gruoch was my cousin as I also hail from Clan mac Alpín, we share a grandfather in Cináed (Kenneth II) mac Máel Coluim , King of Alba. I found this telling of her story only slightly less fanciful than Shakespeare's writing. It's hard to explain that thinking fully without spoilers, and it may be a little challenging for a reader to follow the story the way it's written without prior knowledge of or researching while reading about Gruoch and Macbethad (Macbeth) mac Findláech. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the read, it had the right amount of romance, drama, and tragedy, I've just never heard of the outcome in all my research.

A fantastic female centered retelling of Macbeth. The story gripped me from the start and I couldn't put it down!