Member Reviews

Kate and Tristan are back, this time investigating the cold case of a young girl who went missing in 1988 on behalf of a production company that is planning a podcast studying the case. But are they really interested in Kate and Tristans' skills, or is it because Kates ex Peter Conway, the notorious Nine Elms Cannibal has been linked to the case?

Robert Bryndza has presented us with another great thriller. It's a great story, entertaining, and to me vecçry believable. Tristan is possibly my favourite side kick of all the detective novels I read (and there's a few!). I'm looking forward to the next instalment.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Robert for bringing back Kate and Tristan. They are as good a friend to each other as they are work colleagues. I am not often keen on historic stories of murder and how they find the killers but this one was done really well. Its one of those books that is easy to read and the chapters are short. It flowed really well and the ending was nice and tidy.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, the publishing house, and the author for the opportunity to read a complimentary copy of this book in return for a review, based upon my honest opinion.

This is the fifth book in the Kate Marshall series, this book could easily be read as a standalone book, but I think you should definitely read all of the books as this is a fantastic series. This author writes such good books. The storylines always grab me right from the start, and keep me on the edge of my seat waiting to solve the mystery with Kate and Tristan.

This book Kate and Tristan, as Private investigators are approached about doing a story about a missing girl from years ago a girl whom may have been killed by her ex, Peter Conway, who turned out to be the Nine Elms Cannibal, a serial killer she helped put away. A man who is also the father of her son Ryan. Kayden Tristan decide to accept the offer and start delving into the missing girl while trying to unravel the story. There are many twists that leave you wondering who really did kill Janey Macklin; was she a victim of the nine Elms cannibal or was there another killer amongst their midst.

I really enjoy the series and I cannot wait for the next installment. This book came full circle from the first book and I can’t wait to see what adventures Kate and Tristan will get Involved in.

Was this review helpful?

Kate and Tristan are back and travel to London to look into a case of a missing girl from the 80’s. The victim is linked to Peter, Kate’s ex who’s still in prison for his crimes. This was a really good read and while it can be read as a stand alone it would be better to be read in book order so you know the background of the characters. Fast paced and engaging crime book, I can’t wait for the next one!

Was this review helpful?

I’m a massive fan of Robert Bryndza and the Kate Marshall series. This one didn’t disappoint, it was a cracking read which kept me entertained, in fact I couldn’t put it down. I love the Erika Foster series too and a potential collab book with the two is super exciting. This was a really interesting cold case which had a brilliantly written storyline full of twists and turns to keep the reader guessing. Loved this book, very highly recommend. I’m definitely buying this book for a friend who is also a Robert Bryndza fan.

Was this review helpful?

17. The Lost Victim by Robert Bryndza

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I love this series and adore Kate and Tristan.

🔪 Packed with twists and turns
🔪 Plenty of creepy moments
🔪 Kate’s back story gets even more depth

Another great addition to the series!

Was this review helpful?

THE LOST VICTIM is the fifth novel Kate Marshall Crime Thriller Series by international bestselling author Robert Bryndza. The novel’s central character Kate Marshall, is a police officer turned private detective. This novel can be read as a stand-alone, but I recommend starting with book one for clarity and content.

Novels In The Kate Marshall Series Include:
1. Nine Elms (2019)
2. Shadow Sands (2020)
3. Darkness Falls (2021)
4. Devil's Way (2023)
5. The Lost Victim (2024)

This is my review of The Lost Victim.

This is the story of a school girl Janey Macklin who disappeared in London in 1988, and now 30 years later private detective Kate Marshall and her associate, Tristan accepts a contract by a crime podcast producer to investigate this cold-case file.

Could Janey have been killed by Peter Conway, the notorious Nine Elms Cannibal?

There was no body or witnesses.

Peter Conway, Kate's ex, a serial killer now in prison in poor health, was the last person to see Janey alive and has been cleared of her murder.

After further investigation and reviewing the case notes, phone calls and limited poor DNA evidence, Kate and Tristan must look elsewhere for more information.

Slowly Kate and Tristan start piecing things together.

This was a fast-paced well written mystery crime thriller with well-defined characters and believable plot. Clues are disclosed on a need-to-know basis, and this gripping novel will keep you hooked until the very last page.

Many thanks to the author, Raven Street Publishing and NetGalley for my digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

I love a well crafted thriller and this definitely was one. It's a thriller that makes you feel for the characters and get invested. A brilliant page turner about a cold case and the multiple possibilities.

Loved the theme and characters. The impossibility of a cold case was brilliantly shown. Read this as a standalone and found no difficulty in catching up. Recommend!

Thank you Raven Street Publishing and NetGalley for this e-arc in exchange of my unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

The Lost Victim by Robert Bryndza
Kate Marshall Thriller #5

Another cold case or Kate and Triston to solve – if they can? What happened to Janey Macklin and why wasn’t her body ever found?

What I liked:
* Kate: once on the police force, taught forensics at a university, tenacious, utilizes investigative techniques wisely, organized, methodical, intuitive, focused, intriguing
* Tristan: intense, focused, good brother, capable, great investigative skills, interesting character that I would like to learn more about
* Jake: Kate’s son, university graduate, on break from internship in USA, brought Olivia home for the holidays, son of a serial killer, proposes an option to Kate & Tristan that may improve their financial stability
* The prologue that set the stage for the cold case
* The tidbits about the main characters gleaned though not many were shared in this book
* Police procedural elements
* The plot, pacing, setting, and writing
* The tie-in to Peter Conway and his impact on more than one character in this book – hoping his part in future books will be minimal
* That all of the loose ends were tied up by the end of the story and there was closure for Janey’s family
* Wondering what the next book will be about

What I didn’t like:
* Who and what I was meant not to like
* The evil some of the characters were willing to do and the impact it had on more than one in the story
* Thinking about choices made and what would have happened if a different choice had been made

Did I enjoy this book? Yes
Would I read more in this series/by this author? Yes

Thank you to NetGalley and Raven Street Publishing for the ARC – This is my honest review.

4-5 Stars

Was this review helpful?

Robert Bryndza (https://www.robertbryndza.com) is the author of 20 novels. The Lost Victim was published last month and is the fifth book in his Private Investigator Kate Marshall series. It is the 63rd book I completed reading in 2024.

Opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own! Due to scenes of violence, I categorize this novel as R.

Private detective Kate Marshall and her colleague Tristan Harper have been engaged to investigate a cold case. Thirty years earlier, in 1988, the young teen Janey Macklin disappeared. A true-crime media producer wants to develop a podcast around the unsolved case.

Many think that serial killer Peter Conway, the notorious Nine Elms Cannibal, might know what happened to Macklin. Marshall has a connection to the case. Conway had been a detective when she first joined the police force and she had worked for him. Poor judgment on her part led to Conway becoming the father of her now-adult son. It had been Marshall who broke the Nine Elms case and arrested Conway.

Conway was reportedly seen in the area where Macklin lived. Perhaps even spending time in the pub where Macklin’s mother worked. A pub where Janey and her sister often sat at a table playing video games until their mother was ready to go home. Another possible suspect is Thomas Black. He, too, is a convicted serial killer. He hung out in the same area. He is now serving prison time at the same location as Conway. After many years in prison, both Conway and Black are plagued with health issues.

Marshall and Harper interview as many as they can find who knew Macklin. A local teen, Robert Driscoll, had been convicted of Macklin’s death but was later released after the case was overturned.

With little to start with Marshall and Harper slowly gather evidence and uncover secrets. Not everyone they speak with wants the case reopened. Many they speak to clearly have secrets. While there is no motive for Macklin’s disappearance, several knew the girl and had the opportunity. Marshall must face the man she once thought she loved. A man who betrayed her trust and tried to kill her.

I enjoyed the 7+ hours I spent reading this 322-page mystery. I have had the opportunity to read three other excellent mystery novels by Mr. Bryndza. They are The Girl in the Ice, Fatal Witness, and Lethal Vengeance. I liked the plot twists in this novel. I like the chosen cover art. I give this novel a rating of 5 out of 5.

You can access more of my book reviews on my Blog ( https://johnpurvis.wordpress.com/blog/).

My book reviews are also published on Goodreads (https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/31181778-john-purvis).

Was this review helpful?

Always excited for a new Kate Marshall book.

Kate and Tristian have an opportunity to crack a cold case. The excitement is a little muted as they realize the missing girl may be tied to Kate's serial killer ex, who also is the father of her child. Time is short to find answers from him and from others,and someone is shadowing them all the way.

I was especially excited to see Tristian be given the opportunity to do more things alone. As he and Kate move through the case, it becomes apparent that some people are not being truthful about the past. The new direction that looms as a career prospect is also intriguing, especially since Kate's son see the opportunity to take her business to a new level. I love this, because with the high profile cases it always seemed that they should be able to do better financially.

It was also great to see Kate come to terms with how she could stop hiding from her past, ad possibly use it to her advantage.

I felt like there was a lot of misdirection that made it great to consider different suspects.

Bryndza is good at allowing you to root for and understand characters that are not "perfect"

I look forward to the next installment to see where Kate and Tristian go from here.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy in exchange for my honest comments.

Was this review helpful?

I am so excited whenever Robert releases a new book because I know it will be a 5 star read. This book was no different and I inhaled it! That's my only complaint - I read it too quickly and now I have to wait again! Thank you for the opportunity to read this fantastic book.

Was this review helpful?

The Lost Victim by Robert Bryndza
Raven Street Publishing, 11th July 2024

When schoolgirl Janey Macklin disappeared in 1988, the case went cold, with no body and no witnesses.
Now, 30 years later, PI Kate Marshall is hired by a true crime podcaster to look into it. With little for Kate and partner Tristan to work on, and the landscape where Janey went missing having altered so much, the detecting duo need their wits about them.

The author skillfully brings Kate and Tristan to life from the pages, and as the pace really picks up at the halfway point, shows why he earns such rave reviews from crime readers. The plot is strong, and the surprises along the way are unexpected and brilliant.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Thanks to Raven Street Publishing and Robert Bryndza for providing an eARC via NetGalley; this is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is book #5 in this fantastic series and I have to hold my hands up and say this is only the third I have read BUT it didn't at all affect the understanding of the storyline or plot. I'll admit it most definitely helps if you have read at least a couple of the previous books though as there are references to past relationships etc.

Ex poloce detective Kate and her business partner Tristan are contacted with a new proposal for a job. A job that could come in at just the right time, Kate is in need of a cash injection for her other business and Tristan is behind on payments.

In 1988 a young girl, Janey Mackin, disappeared whilst on an errand to the local corner shop for her mum. She was never seen again. No body was ever found. What happened to Janey, was she taken or did she run away?

These are the questions that a true crime podcast producer wants answered and feel that Kate and Tristan, with their success at cold cases, can answer.

Investigating, lots of the clues, evidence and testimony of others points to Peter Conway. A man already serving life in prison, also the man that Kate had a relationship and child with, before arresting him for multiple murders, warming him the moniker of the 'Nine Elms Killer'.

The podcast producer puts them up in a flat in London so they are local enough to investigate Janey's disappearance but while there things start happening to make them think that someone is hiding something. As they claw closer and closer to the truth, the danger also feels like it it casting its shadows.

Running around London, trying to uncover all they can, Kate also has the reminder of Peter Conway weighing heavily on her shoulders. Their son has flown back home after being told his Dad is seriously ill. After dental issues which required surgery, he has since been hospitalised after an infection caused him to collapse and cause skull damage. Can Kate put her personal feelings aside to ask him the one question she's desperate to ask.. 'was Janey one of his victims?'

Can they figure it all out before the shadows enclose them completely?

This is th3 epitome of a real crime thriller. Packed with suspense and twists, I found this completely unputdownable.

Thanks to Netgalley and Raven Street Publishing for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting case making the book unique, it had the twist you’re looking for in this genre as well. I’m interested to see what’s next.

Was this review helpful?

Kate Marshall & her assistant private investigator Tristan are struggling financially. Kate's campsite that usually tides them over in lean times has been flooded & somehow she needs to find money for repairs. When they are offered a sizable amount from a podcast company it should have been the answer to a prayer. However the case is going to involve digging up things from the past she would really like to forget.! Many years ago Janey Macklin went down the road to buy her mother some cigarettes & was never seen again. The area of King's Cross has changed beyond all recognition. The last person known to have seen Janey was convicted but now has been acquitted & suspicion falls on the notorious Nine Elms Killer, who is also Kate's ex. It will not be an easy case in any way.

I have enjoyed the previous books in the series & have enjoyed watching the characters develop. However this book could easily re read as a standalone. The author captures the settings well & also keeps the reader guessing. Thanks to Netgalley & the publisher for letting me read & review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Robert Bryndza is one of my ‘go to’ writers of fast paced thrillers. I always enjoy his writing and his latest ‘The Lost Victim’ is no exception.
Private Detective Kate Marshall and her partner Tristan Harper are hired by a podcast company to look into a cold case, the disappearance of school girl Janey Macklin from the seedy streets of Soho in 1988. The money offered for their services is very tempting and much needed by their little agency but it means Kate coming face to face with a past she would rather forget. As they scour a Kings Cross very different from the run-down seedy side of London that it once was the case becomes complicated and despite everything Kate has to once again cross paths with the notorious Nine Elms Cannibal, who is also an ex-colleague and her son’s father, in the hope that it will solve the case and finally bring some answers and closure for Janey’s mum and sister after all these years.
The case is made more complicated due to the passage of time that has muddied people’s recollections of the case, as well as the fact that the landscape of the area where Janey disappeared has changed so much.
I really liked how Kate’s feelings and those of her son were dealt with and it showed that despite everything in the end Kate is able to push away her personal feelings in favour of those of her son. And in a way her actions concerning Peter Conway hopefully ultimately give Kate some sort of closure to that chapter in her life.
Another great read from Robert which will have you guessing until the end.
Thank you to NetGalley, Robert Bryndza and Raven Street Publishing for another great read.

Was this review helpful?

Kat and Tristan are private detectives who are hired to solve a cold case. The kicker is that Kat's former lover, a famous serial killer, might have had something to do with this victim. Overall the book was well written and filled with details. There's not too much action but twists and turns. Solving a cold case requires a lot of investigation and this book is filled with it. Since this is book 5, Peter who is involved in the previous books is an interesting character I want to learn more about so I will head back to the first book to learn more about his history.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you @netgalley & @robertbryndza and #RavenStreetPublishing for my complimentary copy. My thoughts are my own.

When Private Detectives Kate Marshall and Tristan Harper are hired by the producer of a true crime podcast to delve into the cold case of a young girl who went missing in 1988, Kate is aware that this case links to her past.

The missing girl is believed to be the victim of vicious serial killer, Peter Conway, otherwise known as the Nine Elms Cannibal. Conway, a former police officer, is now serving time in prison. Kate, who had actually been having an affair with Conway when she solved the case, also discovered she was pregnant with Conway’s child!

As Kate and Tristan question Conway’s friends and other interested parties, a truly ugly (and sad) story starts to reveal itself.

This page-turner takes place primarily in London, which is a change of venue for Kate and Tristan. Kate’s ties to this particular case provide for an interesting look into her character, as she must also consider the feelings of her son, Jake.
The story moves along at a good pace and unfolds primarily through the third person perspectives of Kate and Tristan, with occasional chapters devoted to other characters.

Robert Bryndza always presents a well-written and intricate mystery with a compelling storyline, well-developed characters, and a conclusion worth waiting for! I really enjoyed this one! Thriller lovers, don’t miss this chilling story!

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book of Robert Bryndza that I have read and really enjoyed it. There were enough characters to pick from to make them the murderer, so I had a fine time honing my detective skills which kept me busy trying to tie everything together. The main characters, Kate and Tristen, were a good duo and hope to meet them again in another of Robert Bryndza's books. The author's knowledge and description of London and surrounds allowed readers to feel they were there.

All in all a book well worth reading with enough twists and turns to keep you busy working on who the killer was.

Was this review helpful?