Member Reviews

Truly sensational art that tells a story centered around the importance of kindness. Gillen tells a story of a world on its last legs, and the mysterious giants that might be responsible for its downfall.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know how to feel about this because this is probably the most depressingly and hopeless graphic novel I've ever read. The art and writing were beautiful, but wow, I felt like watching a rom com after reading this. I wasn't expecting it to be just so miserable and sad of a story. I can see so many people loving this, but I don't love anything that makes me stare into space wishing I hadn't read it because I'm going to be depressed the rest of the day.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful illustrations that balances wonder with a strong unsettled feeling. Found the story super engaging and didn't want it to end.

Was this review helpful?

Was a fun read with a interesting world. I do wish we could see more of it though to understand more about what is going on now with the world.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced readers copy of We Called Them Giants. This was a nice quick graphic novel set in a fantasy, apocalyptic time. The artwork was nice and the dogs were creepy. The ending didn’t feel totally pulled together and finished but overall it was a good short story. Thanks again for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't expect this to bring me to tears like it did. It's a testament to the writer and illustrator that you were able to feel such emotion from the giant without him ever having said a word.

Was this review helpful?

gorgeously illustrated graphic novel with an interesting post-apocalyptic setting and story. the art did so much for me. i enjoyed the characters and the story had an unexpected "twist," which i greatly enjoyed. i just wish there was more to the story as there seems to be so much unsaid world-building, and I wish had more interaction between our main characters and the Giants. Super recommend it though!

Was this review helpful?

This one drew me in on cover alone. She looked like a fearless main character taking on the world, and that is exactly this story. Alone in a world filled with alien-like creatures, finding a friend who is exact opposite of you is another task for another day. Surviving over thriving and just trying to make the best of it. How scary it must be to realize everyone just vanished and having to figure it out. Truly mind boggling but I think I loved the emotional grasp of figuring out a scary situation. I have not read anything by this team but they quickly became one I will keep an eye out for anything they come up with because it is absolutely amazing. This is a immersive tale, you get to feel and see all the details of the world around them, while lacking in character details, it makes up with giving you life in this world. I think that is hard to do in many of this, is able to give you the whole picture, emotions of what these characters are going through. Absolutely stunning, and beautifully done. Cannot wait for more of these tales. Well done.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully drawn. Though the main character is not necessarily the nicest (but can you afford to be in the apocalypse?), she ends up learning a meaningful lesson from the feared Giants. Worth a read, but I feel it could be a bit more fleshed out. Hoping maybe there will be more eventually...

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the art of this graphic and the flow of the story was easy to follow. The story itself is where it kind of lost me. While it was good, I didn’t really like Lori as a character and I feel like there was part of the story missing.

Was this review helpful?

We Called Them Giants is a story of finding magic in the mundane when all feels lost.

This little story has a whole lot of heart. It's magic lies in it's quieter moments when the characters are learning that survival isn't just about the logistics. It celebrates connection when all feels lost through the eyes of some quirky and lovable characters. The illustrations are endearing and they absolutely do the story justice elevating it to something special!!

A great choice if you are longing for connection.

Was this review helpful?

*Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.*

The art style was stunning, the premise was intriguing, and the characters were believable. This graphic novel told such an interesting story, but I was left wanting more information at the end. I do however get the feeling that that as the point, so I can't be too mad. I'm a details person, not knowing things like "where did everyone go?" is always going to bother me.

Was this review helpful?

"We Called Them Giants" is a a moderately paced apocalyptic tale that is both poignant and thought provoking. Expect an angry narrator, a benevolent supernatural patron, a blighted Winter landscape, threats form every angle and a ray of iridescent hope.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher, Image Comics, for providing, me with an eARC in exchange for my honest review.

4.5 stars rounded to 4.

Was this review helpful?

Lori wakes up in a world were most people have disappeared leaving behind only baked beans, this abandonment isn’t unusual for Lori who has lived in the foster system for a long time but this is different.

Whether an act of god, alien abduction, or other catastrophe Lori and the others left behind have to find a way to survive.

Some join a gang called The Dogs but Lori and Annette stay outside this and the gangs violent ways.

Then the Giants arrive and things change. From nowhere with no explanation of who or what they are and whether or not they were involved in the disappearances, faces full of eyes like angels but with the nature spirit bodies of a Miyazaki film they are gorgeous.

The art work is stunning and vibrant, and really build a believable world with great characters in it, and the art of the giants stands out so vividly from the world around them that it really makes them ‘out of this world’ be they angels, aliens, or a mix of both.

A story of love, found family, and what that means we may do to keep that family. I really enjoyed this and would love to explore the world of the giants further.

I was given this on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Perfect apocalyptic read with funny lovable characters that must work together to find out what happened to all the adults. Quick and fun read.

Was this review helpful?

The art style is gorgeous - I always love Stephanie Hans work and I particularly enjoyed her and Kieron Gillen's collaboration on Die, so I was very pleased to read this too.

I did find it quite hard to follow at times, but it was a generally quick read. Nice simple plot and think it will be well received.

Was this review helpful?

The artwork in this is beautiful and creates a world with an intriguing story about understanding, broken communication and love.

Was this review helpful?

We Called Them Giants is a masterful piece of speculative fiction with art that stuns in every page. I found the giants and their homes to be the most beautifully drawn in the graphic novel. The story takes on a more emotional tone that I wasn't expecting, especially towards the end, but it definitely hits hard when you have a character like Lori , cynical and struggling to live in this apocalyptic/dystopian world, narrate the story and realize the deeper meaning behind her, and her friends', relationship with the red giant. The epic conclusion is truly gutwrenching and a tale to remember.

Was this review helpful?

I usually like Kieron Gillen's work, so that I loved this is no surprise.
I want to talk about it! But I don't want to give away spoilers,
so please everyone read it so I can talk about it with someone.

Was this review helpful?

An astonishingly beautiful book with a fairly flimsy plot. I really enjoyed reading this, but came away wanting much, much more about the characters, the giants, the dogs, the timeline, ALL of it really. But what was on the page did an excellent job of pulling me in.

Thank you to the author and NetGalley for granting me the opportunity to read this in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?