Skip to main content

Member Reviews

First, I'd like to extend a big thanks to the author, Yuval Noah Harari, the publisher, and NetGalley for the opportunity to be able to read Sapiens: A Graphic History, Volume 3. I will share my review to Amazon, Goodreads, and Barnes & Noble upon release. I'm a fan of Harari's work and his method of historical thinking, and these volumes are not excepted. This third volume focuses on certain figures or movers of history, and how they may intertwine to change the trajectory of mankind. These are really serious questions set in an interesting way, as more of a game show with a jury that is deciding the main driver of the universe. Each of the main themes or characters that is arguing for their version of historical influence is a humorous dive into what makes the gears of the historical clock turn. The layer of creativity and playfulness can appeal to just about any age, middle grade and higher, because even adults can appreciate the jokes.

I really think an impressive aspect of this series is putting such big ideas into a graphic format, which I know has to be tough. Some of these concepts were things we discussed in my master's level history courses, like how the expansion of empire and religion shape cultures, politics, economies, and the role of money and capitalism in the shaping of behavior. One of my favorite characters was Clashwoman, who shows how narrow history becomes in that more reactionary mindset. The abstract concepts are kept engaging because of the bold colors and interesting characters presented. I think a lot of the characters are really helpful, because as humans we like to think of history in a narrative format. We like to give structure that history doesn't necessarily have as it occurs, and these can be helpful for just processing and categorizing a lot of the info. All of this is to say that I think these volumes can be super helpful for getting young people to think about history in a deeper way, beyond memorization of dates or names or focusing solely on American history. I would recommend for any fan of Harari's past work or anyone who wants to dive in - I loved this book!

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting book. It was both fun and informative. I love the idea of telling history through graphic novel. It allows a heavy topic to seem a bit lighter. It also makes the telling of history easier to engage with, and helps visual learners truly embrace what they are reading. I thought the information was provided in a unique way without detracting from what was being conveyed. I think this would be a great book for anyone high school aged and up.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Harper Perennial for the ARC. Unfortunately I couldn't get through this one. The high concept, while clever, was a bit too removed from the subject matter for me, making it hard for me to engage with the book. I didn't find the illustration style or coloring particularly compelling, either. That, coupled with the huge amount of text in many of the panels made this one much less fun than it should be. However impossible to make happen, I definitely expected this to be a zippy graphic novel condensing Harari's excellent book into a readable graphic novel for young-ish readers — but it was a bit too laborious of a read for even me. The concept of news reporters or presenters narrating such heady topics instead of showing these concepts "in action" was a bit too removed from the subject matter for me.

Was this review helpful?