Member Reviews

I actually am not familiar with the Blue Beetle Story, but this graphic novel was impactful and a must read. As a native Texas, watching Jaime Reyes’ see white supremacists marching in Texas is scary and very real with our current political issues. This story rocked me and it is one I am definitely telling people to read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick and vivid read that felt very timely and honest. Julio Anta pulled no punches in his plot, and in representing the current political clime, especially around the bigotry and racism in reaction to immigration. This Land Is Our Land was a blunt look at the life, opinions, and actions of people, teens especially, when raised on either side of the divide on regarding these issues. If you read any book this year, read this one.

Was this review helpful?

This Land Is Our Land: A Blue Beetle Story by Julio Anta is a powerful graphic novel that combines superhero action with a poignant exploration of immigration and belonging. Jaime Reyes’ journey as Blue Beetle is both thrilling and deeply resonant, showcasing the struggles and strength of a young hero fighting for his family and community. Anta’s storytelling is sharp and heartfelt, complemented by stunning artwork that brings the narrative to life. A must-read for fans of Blue Beetle and socially conscious storytelling.

Was this review helpful?

I am not familiar with this version of Blue Beetle, but I really enjoyed the story. I didn't feel lost not knowing the character, the art was adorable. I am looking forward to find more stories about him.

4 stars

Was this review helpful?

Blue Beetle's origin story again. It's pretty much the same as the last 5 times it's been retold. This time though they added in Jaime dealing with white supremacists marching in Texas as well. I found it to be heavy handed but I get it. There are plenty of people living in border states that have been citizens for generations that are treated as lesser because they aren't white even though they ARE American citizens.

Was this review helpful?

It was a nice intro, but left me wanting more. Some things felt a bit heavy handed, rather than authentic. Over all I enjoyed the story and loved the illustrations. I also think it could be used in classes to have difficult difficult dialogues.

Was this review helpful?

I'm such a sucker for these superhero origin stories. I love that they show the heroes when they are still average teens. This story is incredibly timely and showcases the political climate in The United States of America. I will definitely be adding this one to my classroom library.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a great DC comic! I love the superhero Blue Beetle, and I'm glad DC finally did a standalone (well, hopefully more) comic like this! Blue Beetle is such an underrated character, and I hope that this incarnation of him will get more stories to be told. I'm definitely buying a copy for myself.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a DC fan, but I've only read a few Blue Beetle comics. This Land Is Our Land makes me want to rectify that ASAP. Jaime Reyes showed strength and courage by standing up to hate groups in his community and also extraterrestrials coming to do something likely negative to the entire planet. The real-world issues he faces are timely, and the authors convey the urgency of standing up for each other and fighting hate in a way that is accessible to everyone. I look forward to learning more about Jaime Reyes, his family, and his friends in future comics.

Thanks to NetGalley & DC Comics for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Fresh take on Blue Beetle. Characters and setting is well done, story is good and relevant to current social issues. The art is unique for a major comic publisher like DC, has a very independent feel to it. Overall a great story from start to finish.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC of this graphic novel. 4/5 stars.

Honestly, I only put it at 4 stars instead of 5 because I do not know nearly enough about DC and Blue Beetle to read this without needing at least a little more context. It is made for the beginning of the story arc e.g. you don't need to know anything, but it also needed more context for some of the world building parts.

Overall though, I'm a big fan of graphic novels since they're quick reads. This one also has a lot of sociopolitical elements such as conversations about migrants and the right's rhetoric -- along with references to hate groups and neo nazis.

I think this would be a great graphic novel for Latinx students, which makes sense since the author is also the author of Frontera.

Was this review helpful?

Dc Comics has really done a good job with their young adult graphic novels recently, and This Land is Our Land: A Blue Beetle Story is no different. You should definitely check it out.

To be completely honest with you, I don’t know a ton about the Blue Beetle. Prior to the recent Blue Beetle movie Xolo Maridueña, my only other experience with the character was in the animated show Batman: The Brave and the Bold (I still think it might be the best animated Batman show. It’s so good.). However, I think it’s a cool concept of a character for the DC universe, and one that’s very unexplored in the “mainstream”.

The story from Julio Anta follows Jaime Reyes in his hometown of El Paso. The racism from the anti-immigrant bigots is reaching a fever pitch, and the anti-racist community is trying to come together to fight back. When Jaime and the scarab become one, everything changes. Can Jaime juggle being there with his friends while also being the Blue Beetle?

I loved the art from Jacoby Salcedo and the colors from Francesco Segala. They really contributed positively to the story and let you feel the emotions of everything.

More Blue Beetle stuff is always appreciated. I thought this book was really good, and it’s a good lesson for kids that you can’t just be “not racist” but you need to be “anti-racist”.

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Really liked it, stuck with me & would recommend
This is a really great introduction/ origin story for Blue Beetle. I liked the political commentary that was weaved throughout in a fun,  light way. After all, this is a comic book for teens. In that way it was masterful. The art was great too, especially in its color just. 

Thank you to DC Comics, NetGalley, and author Julio Anta for providing me with a digital ARC copy of this graphic novel in exchange for an honest review. This Land Is Our Land: A Blue Beetle Story is out October 1, 2023.

Was this review helpful?

When kids grow up in a system that is against them they get very creative. It bings my heart joy to see this story of teens standing up for what is right. At first Jaime doesn’t really want to take part in the marches and protests, but as threats make themselves known from a local hate group he starts to realize that he does have to take part and do something.

Add on to his troubles with a mysterious blue beetle that connects him to an alien spaceship and grants him powers, you get a kid that no only needs to fight for his rights, but he also needs to help save the world.

I loved the nuance that this story takes. While I truly felt uncomfortable with the ‘friend’ that starts listening to and participating with the hate group. I understand Jaime wanting to give him a second chance. In this internet age, it is so easy to fall into a rabbit hole of misinformation. You can click on one thing and more and more of that will fill your feed until you are believing in something you never thought that you would.

Jaime wanting to believe in his old friend in spite of his changes shows a noble heart. I don’t think I would be able to accept a friend back after the lengths he goes to.

This comic exposes a deeper tension in the heart of America in todays time. Yes, it’s a fun and entertaining comic, but it is also very politically charged. The social commentary and the message to come together and see each other as fellow humans and strip away the politics is an important one. We are all at the end of the day just doing our best to survive in this world.

I highly recommend this comic. I hope that this is one that will be made available in the school systems and that kids can understand and carry the message of this comic in their hearts.

Was this review helpful?

Awesome graphic novel! You don't need to be a DC fan or even familiar with Blue Beetle to enjoy this book. The illustrations were on point! Highly recommended for YA collections.

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t really know anything about Blue Beetle before reading this, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The themes are very important and timely, and I thought they were handled very well. I liked that Jamie was grappling between what was right and wrong, and where his loyalties truly stood.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for proividng me with an ARC of this story.
SPOILERS TO FOLLOW

One of my favorite DC characters has always been Blue Beetle (Specifically Jamie Reyes although Dan and Ted are both really awesome in their own ways too!) This graphic novel was exactly what I expected form a Jamie story. Teenage Jamie doing what he can to fight against racism and protect his people while also fighting against The Reach and everything they stand for. I've always enjoyed seeing Jamie's struggle with his scarb/The Reach and how he eventually bonds with Khaji Da. This was a great story with an even better message and. really enjoyed seeing the P, B and J group + Riley come together!!!

Was this review helpful?

A well done story that uses Blue Beetle Jamie Reyes to tell a superhero origine that feels very poignant for this time in are history. This is a book that I could see sparking many good discussions and debates amongst its readers.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to DC Comics and NetGalley for this ARC! Been looking forward to this one.

I always appreciate new takes on comic book characters, which is something DC Comics loves to explore. I initially was not sure what to expect, but reading this after seeing the Blue Beetle movie felt like two completely different takes on the character (which is a good thing!). The topics present in this story strongly echo the current state of the United States, especially on the issue of being an immigrant family in the United States. These themes are presented in a manner that doesn't feel overwhelming and also add to Jaime's backstory as a superhero. I really enjoyed this tale, and appreciate it when DC creates stories that tie in more closely to the real world.

Was this review helpful?

Solid Jaime Reyes outing. Excellent character to explore real-world issues. Definitely recommended for YA collections.

Was this review helpful?