Member Reviews

There truly is nothing better than an absorbing, beautifully written novel that illuminates particular aspects of history and lived experience. This exquisite novel dives deep into the history of the Penobscot people and the 'laws' that determined their identity and land claims. The author frames this around the story of a man and his daughter, and the search for identity, family and the ownership of our own stories and truths. Great narration, too.

Was this review helpful?

Fire Exit by Morgan Talty is an exploration of family bonds, love, and the quest for one's place in life, set against the backdrop of the Penobscot Reservation in Maine. Through the eyes of Charles Lamosway, Talty navigates the nuances of life choices, reflecting on past and present experiences.

Despite its brevity, this novel packs a powerful punch. The narrative alternates between two timelines and cultures, offering a rich examination of identity and belonging. Talty's intricately developed characters feel personal and memorable, a testament to Talty's ability to create profoundly resonant and enduring stories.

I highly recommend Fire Exit to anyone who enjoys literary fiction with complex characters. Talty’s second book cements his status as a truly talented writer, and I eagerly look forward to following his career.

Was this review helpful?

A Short Synopsis
Fire Exit talks about how the blood that runs through us is the same, yet different in many ways. The story is about Charles Lamosway, who lives near the Penobscot Reservation and watches his neighbor, Elizabeth, from afar. Little does Elizabeth know, she's his daughter, a secret Charles can no longer keep. As he deals with his worries and takes care of his home, friend Bobby, and mother, he's haunted by his past and the question of whether to reveal the truth to Elizabeth. It's a story of family, secrets, and tough decisions.

My Review
Fire Exit seemed promising based on the synopsis, but it fell short, and I couldn't finish it. It was boring and lacked depth in both the setting and characters. I usually don't read literary fiction, but I wanted to try it. Unfortunately, I was among those who didn't like it. However, I want to thank NetGalley for providing me with an audio ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

3.5*
Charles Lamosway lives in Maine, across the river from tribal lands. He is not Native, but his stepfather was a tribal member and Charles has grown up surrounded by local Indians. Charles’ stepfather died a few years back and now he alone takes on the take care of his mother who suffers from dementia. He has had a sad history of alcohol abuse plus the loss of the girl he loved. Yet Charles is a tender, loving caretaker to his mom. He also is a good friend to Bobby, who’s an alcoholic. Like Charles, Bobby is a complex character who does stupid, self-destructive things, but has a good heart.

Staring across the river, Charles is mesmerized by occasional sightings of his former girlfriend and his secret daughter, Elizabeth. He yearns to reach out to the girl that long ago he was forced to give up. Since then, he has suffered his loss in silence; not allowed to tell anyone. His tenderness and patience in caring for his mother says a great deal about the goodness of his character.

This is a book about Native rights, parental rights, mental illness, alcoholism, genetics and family dynamics. Charles is a memorable character and his story of regret and longing hover over all he does and thinks. In the past his yearning to make a family connection added to his regrets for actions not taken. Readers will root for him to catch a break.

The audio was ably done but I think the novel is better to read than listen to because it is a book that one needs to savor.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited about this one after loving Night of the Living Rez. It’s, an often bleak, story about family, history, and tradition that doesn’t fall into cliche. For all the sadness of it, there is real love and humor between these characters, but they just didn’t quite grab me the way the characters in Rez did. Solid read though.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for this Audiobook!

This is a story of a man reflecting on the outcomes of the decisions he's made throughout his life and trying to wrangle a different outcome. It's poignant, sad, and frustrating at points. The book does not shy away from our desire as humans to be known and to belong and what that means for our identities.

Was this review helpful?

The beginning and the end were so beautifully written, wow. As some have said, I needed some time to engage with the story and the characters when I started to read, to understand what the story was and what to look forward to. It was a new world for me as I am not familiar with Native Americans or their culture and history (I'm not american), however, I could realize and relate to the need to preserve your culture wherever you are, the being alienated because of your identity, the need for family and belonging. I admire Charles care for his mother at the end of her life, his patience and attention to the details. I understand how that takes a toll on your own health and well being. There were other matters dealt with in the book, such as alcoholism, mental illness and some others. It's a short read but very complete and insightful.

The audio narration was very good.

Was this review helpful?

Morgan Talty's debut novel, "Fire Exit," is a masterful and unforgettable story that delves deep into the complexities of family, legacy, and the secrets that bind us. Set against the backdrop of Maine's Penobscot Reservation, Talty weaves a poignant and compelling narrative that captures the essence of human connection and cultural heritage. His storytelling shines as the protagonist, Charles, grapples with his past and the choices that have shaped his life. Through his journey, we are taken on a reflective exploration of a lost childhood on the reservation, a tragically ended love affair, and the haunting death of his stepfather, Fredrick. The dynamic between Charles and his mother, Louise, who is succumbing to dementia, adds a layer of emotional depth as they disagree on where to place the blame for Fredrick's fatal hunting accident.
"Fire Exit" is a narrative rich with cultural and emotional resonance. Talty adeptly examines the nuances of what it means to belong to a community, the weight of inheritance, and the obligations we feel towards one another.
It was an interesting read, but I couldn't really relate to the cultural aspects. I rated the book three out of five stars.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a slow burn. It took me probably longer than I would have liked to connect with this book but having seen the reviews and having enjoyed Night of the Living Rez I was willing to stick with it and I’m glad I did.

Charles lives on the fringes of the Penobscot Reservation. Likewise his identity is also on the fringe. He grew up in the Penobscot tribal community because of his stepfather Frederik but is not native himself. From the fringes, across the river, he watches Mary and her partner Roger raise his and Mary’s child which we are told is so the child, Elizabeth, can be a part of the native community and can be considered to have enough native blood for the benefits in the community.

This book is a beautiful examination of identity and what makes us who we are. It calls into question how culture, community, and inheritance are passed on and what it means for a person to lose that sense of belonging.

This book is doing a lot. I do think the character of Bobby, Charles’ friend, dealing with alcoholism feels unnecessary. Besides showing Charles’s own sobriety in relief against Bobby’s inability to maintain sobriety I’m not sure what it added to the story that felt important to me. But I see how this could be a way blood affects identity through the history of alcoholism in Native communities.

In addition to themes of mental health/illness, loss, grief, and blame, as well as how family is defined and how family contributes to identity.

I think what I loved best is seeing the issue of identity turned on its head with someone who isn’t part of the community. It’s looking at the stories of people who feel connected to a community without actual blood ties and what that means to that person and how they are perceived by those around them.

Darrell Dennis is amazing as a narrator. I enjoyed his reading of Night of the Living Rez and this was no different.

Thank you @netgalley and @recordedbooks for the ALC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Very interesting book. I must admit, at first I had a hard time getting into it. It was difficult to find the narrative plot and fít took me a bit of time to get into the flow of the story. But once I did, I really enjoyed it. It was a very interesting story about belonging and identity. The meaning of family and a hard look at American natives situation. It was interesting to follow the main character as someone who had grown up a part of the native community, yet still did not quite belong. He was a character that is on the fringe of a community that is already on the fringes of society.
Overall, I'd recommend. It is different from many other books and offers a unique story.

Was this review helpful?

This is a tough one. I'm not sorry I read it (in audio form), but....

Let's start with the positives:

*The narrator is absolutely perfect - you always feel like Charles is talking to you, which must have been quite the acting/narrating challenge given the mix of inner monologues, dialogue, accounts of conversations, dreams, etc.

*The aforementioned currents and islands in the stream of consciousness are written in a way that flows organically and works surprisingly well. Regardless of what the characters are doing, thinking, or saying (more on that later), you never doubt for a moment that you're getting Charles' unfiltered thoughts on the matter, and you are confident that even at his most erratic what he's doing makes sense to him on some level.

*There just aren't enough books set in Maine, particularly stories that aren't about rich people on summer vacation and/or self discovery through fishing. It's not a part of the world I've spent much time in, but I was truly brought into the perspective of these characters who have never been anywhere else.

- HOWEVER -

You know how everyone now assumes that most AITA posts are made by writers workshopping potential characters and plots? The people and events of this book feel like the outcome of that. The book isn't terribly long, but there are sections that feel like you are being sucked into the ESH swamp of poor life choices with completely foreseeable results and will never emerge. It's a hit parade of Reddit classics, including:

*How could lying to my child about their parentage ever possibly come back to bite me?
*Should I REALLY stop drinking when I start going to AA?
*I don't actually like any of my friends or surroundings or activities. Why am I unhappy?
*My friend or relative is a compulsive liar but I keep listening anyway.
*Should I unhappily build my life around completely arbitrary and erratically enforced property laws or seek loopholes or solutions?
*My family medical history is concerning - should I get more information or just believe my own conjecture based on a partial and uninformed opinion from a doctor that wasn't even there to examine me?

and there's even a cameo from the oldest hit of all:

*My childhood friend is/was secretly gay and obviously in love with me because clearly anyone interested in my presented gender would be - how much should I pity them?

I was genuinely surprised when the book ended without anyone arguing about requiring wedding guests to wear matching shoes or creating a dossier on their cheating sister in law.

If you're a person who enjoys books for their tone and writing style and can look past plot and character issues to enjoy those aspects, then this one's for you. The rest of us are going back to the subreddit to find out if the guy whose new wife is sabotaging his daughter through food allergies has decided to get divorced yet.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Engaging and deeply human. A recommended purchase for collections where literary and Native fic is popular.

Was this review helpful?

“We are made of stories, and if we don’t know them—the ones that make us—how can we ever be fully realized? How can we ever be who we really are?”

This was a really sad character study of a man caring for his mother with dementia and wanting to connect with the daughter who doesn't know she's his. He respects her current family but wants her to know where she came from.

Charles, the protagonist, is a white man who grew up on a Native reservation but was kicked off when he turned 18 - his stepfather, not a blood relative, was his connection to the rez. Now he lives across the river from his biological daughter, who has grown up believing a different man (than Charles) is her biological father.

I liked Darrell Dennis as the narrator. I didn't have a print copy to reference and so listened to Fire Exit a bit slower than my average speed.

Was this review helpful?

Charles grew up on a Penobscot reservation because his mother married a member of the tribe. He now lives across the river from the reservation, separated from his daughter who doesn't know who he is. He keeps a close eye on his mother, who has dementia. As Charles watches his daughter grow up and struggle with mental health issues, he becomes desperate for her to know her whole story. Their lives intersect in brutal ways as they learn important lessons about family and identity.

This is the kind of book that feels difficult for me to review because, for a piece of fiction, it feels extremely intimate and personal. It could almost be a memoir except that the characters aren't real. I was so moved by Charles' story and I think it's one that everyone should read or listen to. The audiobook was beautifully narrated.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, NetGalley for the audiobook copy of fire exit by Morgan Talty

This book was absolutely devastating in so many ways. It tackled numerous hard topics. Including, but not limited to: indigenous members of North America having to constantly prove their identity, what makes and binds a family, being a caretaker for a family member, and the slow descent into dementia for elderly family members. There were strong themes of mental health, depression, suicidal tendencies, and drug and alcohol addiction throughout this novel as well. It all felt very organic to the plot and not in any way forced.

While it covered some difficult topics, it did so very well. I definitely felt a kinship and relatability to our main character who is struggling to deal with a lot as he ages. Our main character is a white man who grew up on a reservation with an indigenous stepfather. While he feels very tied to the indigenous community due to growing up there, he knows that he is not a part of their community really. And he struggles with that loss of identity. He unfortunately is also dealing with a slew of personal issues in regards to many people in his life. Including, but not limited to trying to decide whether or not he tells the daughter that doesn't know he exists that he is in fact, her father. She believes her father to be another indigenous man that has raised her, and he does not want to take her identity away and have her feel the way he does about it. But he struggles with wanting to be known by her. Especially when he sees her struggle as an adult and thinks that she has a right to know her medical history as well.

I picked this book up with the intention of reading 50 pages today and ended up reading the entire book. It was really really well done.

Was this review helpful?

I received an audio arc in exchange for an honest review.

I don't know if i was the intended audience for this book - to me, it was like listening to a stream of consciousness rather than following a plotted storyline, and i found it hard to remain interested while i was listening to it.

there was also a lack of distinction in the audio book between chapters, so the entire setting would change and it would throw me off for the beginning of the new chapter.

audio narrator was clear.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free Advanced Reading Copy via NetGalley in exchange for a complete and honest review.

"Fire Exit" by Morgan Talty is a powerful and unflinching portrait of contemporary Native American life. Talty's prose is both beautiful and haunting as he brings to life characters grappling with issues like substance abuse, domestic violence, and the generational impacts of cultural oppression. While the subject matter can be heavy at times, Talty balances it with moments of humor, tenderness, and hope. His ability to explore difficult themes with nuance and avoid stereotyping is impressive, especially for a debut work. Overall, this collection announces Talty as an important new voice in Native American literature.

Was this review helpful?

This was a well read audiobook- it was one of the few cases where I heard the author as a genuine character rather than a narrator to the novel. Excellent production in this audiobook.

The story, the book itself was a treasure. I’ve seen it promoted a few times in book stores and had that “oh! I read this and loved it!”moment that made me grateful for NetGalley for the audiobook copy of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

Fire exit :

Thank you to Netgalley, Morgan Talty and RB media for providing me the ALC of Fire exit.

"It’s strange: all blood looks the same, yet it’s different, we’re told, in so many various ways and for so many various reasons."

"Fire Exit offers an in-depth exploration of the complex and often indescribable concept of 'family.' The author has does a commendable job of presenting the multifaceted nature of this small yet powerful word, examining what truly constitutes a family."

The core of the narrative delves into how one's native Indian heritage profoundly shapes their life and the powerful influence ethnicity holds. Charles's story unfolds gradually: from his childhood and the mysterious circumstances surrounding his stepfather's death to his hidden daughter, his mother's enduring illness, and his friendships. The characters are portrayed with raw imperfections, which enriches the story's beauty. It deeply resonates with unexpected nuances, navigating through themes such as grief exploration, alcoholism, caregiving for elderly parents, fractured and complicated relationships, homophobia, domestic abuse, and the weight of separation guilt.

Though I'm unfamiliar with Native American history, Talty has offered a compelling perspective on how one's identity can shape their entire future and how being distinct impacts both individuals and families.

The story unfolds with a sense of quiet intensity, where seemingly little occurs yet much transpires. Its melancholic tone remains steady throughout, culminating in a much-needed revelation at the conclusion.

CW: Death of a loved one, grief, domestic abuse, alcoholism, constraint relationship with parents, dementia, arson.

Was this review helpful?

Loved reading this novel about an indigenous family. It’s such a sad read, but not in a tearful way. You just want more for the main character than what they had and wish that they had someone to support them versus constantly being the person that provides support. Everyone deserved more.🥹 the ending was wild for a bit! I couldn’t press the stop button on the audio.

Content warning, the main characters mom has dementia and the storyline follows how that progresses which can be tough to read about.

This wasn’t a super cohesive flow, but it made sense and I really enjoyed it. This was the break from romance that I needed and I’m so glad I read it in the summer!

In terms of audio quality, this was amazing. The narrator had a nice voice and he read at a fast rate to where I didn’t need to speed up the audio too much! Would recommend this in their ebook or audio format! “Only” one narrator but they did a great job differentiating characters.

Thank you NetGalley and RB Media for this ARC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?