This was a cute fun book but I got a little bit lost in the plot, it seemed like a lot of moving parts that was a bit difficult to keep up with.

3.5 🌟's

this one was a mixed bag for me which is so disappointing ugh - the plot and the relationship wasn't holding my attention at many points throughout the story so i was just not truly engaged or enjoying my time reading this :/ there was just a lot going on and some of arthur's dialogue was kind of cringey to me lol

This was a unique and fun book. I really enjoyed the first book by this author, so I was looking forward to this one. Unfortunately, this novel did not engage me as much as the previous novel and novellas. It was not a bad book and I did like it, but I found that I was just not fully engaged and hooked on the next word. I wanted to find out what happened to Arthur and Lydia, so I was certainly invested enough to read the whole book, but I did skim quite a few parts because all the words seemed redundant or just too many words to express a simple point.

Arthur was a great character. He was a bit surly and brooding, but he loved Lydia so well. He desired to protect her and support her.
Lydia was fun to watch grow too. She was painfully shy, but it was lovely to see her overcome her fears and anxiety so she could help Arthur. It was quite inspiring.

Despite my criticisms of this book, I would recommend people to read it. I also want to read any new books by this author as they’re different and refreshing.

Thank you to Net Galley and Alexandra Vasti for the ARC.

This might just be my favorite Vasti book so far. I’ve often felt like an outlier in the book community for not absolutely loving her works, and while there’s something about her writing that doesn’t entirely resonate with me, I still recognize her talent. Vasti is undoubtedly a great writer, but her approach to Historicals often feels more like contemporary romance set in a different era. Additionally, her main characters, while admirable, tend to lack significant growth—they’re almost too perfect from the start, which can make their arcs feel a bit flat.

That said, the book was a fun read, even if it felt a bit scattered at times.

Provided this e-arc by Netgalley. I was so over the moon to be given the chance to read this early. I devoured the first one and was like why isn’t everyone shouting from the rooftops how fun and lovely this book is. The second book made me swoon and also love when a book is set in Scotland no matter the time period. I loved the main characters and it was fun seeing Georgina again but as herself and not pretending to be dumb. Arthur the man that you are. What a sweet cinnamon roll who also feels like hes not good enough and needs to give everything for others. It made me laugh having his family be like “its working!! Our plan is working “ I was next to them cheering them on. There was probably a lot of lines Arthur said that made me cry or swoon. One i loved was him telling her people would be so jealous that he was able to get someone so beautiful as her for his wife. The thing though that I loved about Lydia was her dramatics. She would say I have chosen the abyss let it take me. If this aint me at any inconvenience i dont know what is. Highly recommend this book overall.

Absolute perfection. 5/5 swoony stars for Earl Crush.

Don’t even know where to begin, maybe with the fact I finished this in one sitting? That I’m Alexandra Vasti’s newest fan girl? Or that she’s my new auto buy author? Her books are fun, witty, and romantic.

I loved Ne’er Duke Well, the first in the series, and found myself so eager for her next release. And this newest in the series definitely did not disappoint.

An introverted, socially awkward heiress decides to propose a marriage of convenience to the Earl of Strathrannoch, who she has been in correspondence with for years…only to show up in Scotland to meet the *real* Earl, Arthur, and find out that she’s been writing to his deceitful brother all along. Commence hi jinx, rogue zebras, a fake marriage, and the swooniest love story between two people who deserve so much love. Arthur and Lydia are absolutely perfect for each other.

Also, the epilogue 🥹🥹🥹

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc!

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for this arc!

What a good book! I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. This is a first by this author but will not be my last! I read this in one sitting because I just couldn’t put it down.

Alexandra Vasti is quickly becoming a must-read author, and Earl Crush is another winning entry to her booklist. I rooted for Lydia as she worked through her social anxiety throughout this story that is a little bit of mystery and a lot of romance. The epigraphs that come from Arthur’s personal correspondence are dreamy (get yourself a man who looks at you like Arthur writes about Lydia).

Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press | St. Martin's Griffin for an eARC. Opinions are my own.

3.5
This was a fun read, I loved the characters and the story. Once I got to about 30% I couldn’t stop!

Spoilerish warning…. I didn’t love the resolution between Davis and Arthur. I mean, I it was resolved but it felt like a little more time could have spent on that situation for better closure. But that’s just me.

Content: I skipped a lot of spicy stuff. I’m not sure how may scenes exactly but at least 3…the good thing for us Closed Door readers is that it’s obvious when things are heating up and you can just skip on to the next chapter.

Vasti is undoubtably THE talent to watch in the histrom space. Every detail is meticulously researched, every page dripping with beautiful prose and zippy humor. Lydia and Arthur are the couple of histrom dreams. I am down bad for a down bad hero like Arthur. The book starts with a dramatic flourish and stays zany in the best way. Vasti is an auto-buy author.

Thank you SMP for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Earl Crush is a charming Regency rom-com with a light-hearted tone, but the romance felt rushed. The connection between the main characters lacked depth, making their love story less convincing than it could have been. It seemed as though the author hadn’t fully fleshed out their personalities, which made it hard to fully invest in their relationship. Additionally, the espionage subplot felt overly complex, adding unnecessary confusion to the narrative. That said, there are still enjoyable moments throughout the book, making it a fun, if somewhat uneven, read.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an eARC of this book via NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press, St. Martin’s Paperbacks. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Rating: 5/5 Stars
Published: January 21, 2025
Pages: 352

Alexandra Vasti introduced herself to me as a new author with “Ne’er Duke Well” where I thoroughly enjoyed the read. So what can I can say about “Earl Crush”…just absolutely a wonderful historical romance novel. This was a well-written, and well-developed story that has scandal and social awareness in this delightful and steamy regency romp.

Lydia Hope-Wallace a sheltered but wealth heiress writes and publishes pamphlets under a under a pseudonym about her opinions because she is unable to talk to men when she goes to balls and can get quite ill. The pamphlets become popular and catches the interest of the Earl of Strathrannoch who starts a written correspondence with the heroine about what she writes. When the heroine gets the courage to confront the Earl, she goes to him in Scotland to assist him in his dire situation. It is unfortunate that the hero does not know she is…not having corresponded with her for over three years.

Ms. Vasti leaves you very much enthralled with her characters and all their nuances in this story. The characters and witty and well-developed individuals. This was one book that had me from the beginning to the end…hard for me to put down. Slow burn romance to smiling cheek to cheek. The story has romance, mystery and puts you into that comfy read mode. Highly recommend this one also from the author.

*3.5 stars*

This might been a case of I just wasn't in the right mood for this. I enjoyed the first book and this was cute. It started out so fun and spunky but then I got kind of bored. I feel like the overall plot was just really simple and not much too it. I was ready for something different to happen or for it to speed up. But it was as sweet read and like I said it might have just been my mood. I wanted a little more complexity or depth to it..

Earl Crush by Alexandra Vasti

I received a digital copy of this book from NetGalley for review. My opinions are my own.

4/5 stars

I was a big fan of Vasti’s first novel and really enjoyed this one! I did find the character of the Earl a bit stereotypical, hence the 4 instead of 5 stars, but loved Lydia - she really made this book for me.

Lydia - a wallflower with anxiety and big opinions ends up on the doorstep of Earl Strathtannoch’s door, proposing marriage. However, there has been a clear misunderstanding and this book tells the tale.

4.5 stars
For the past few years, wallflower Lydia has been anonymously publishing “radical” political pamphlets through the Belvoir Library. During this same period, she thought she was exchanging letters with the Earl of Strathrannoch (Arthur). When she goes to Scotland to meet her pen pal and propose marriage, learns he didn't write the letters. The letters were, in fact, written by the Earl’s missing brother, and Lydia and Arthur team up to find him.
I really enjoyed this book. I had read the first in the series, and while I enjoyed it, I found myself liking this book even more. For me, it was the perfect mix of romance, humor, emotion, and a bit of mystery. I found the romance to be well paced – a nice build of tension before the spice, and the humor was often laugh-out-loud.
The characters were very likable. The pacing was great. The story focuses on the relationship between Lydia and Arthur, but there are some great family dynamics and just enough regency era politics to help move the plot along.
If you hadn’t read the first in the series, you might miss a couple of small details, but the book stands on its own very well.

Alexandra Vasti's books are so funny and sexy I always have to read them right away! Earl Crush is about socially anxious heiress/radical pamphleteer Lydia and semi-reclusive earl/inventor Arthur. They've been corresponding about politics for several years, so Lydia comes up with the brilliant idea to travel to Scotland and surprise Arthur with a proposal of marriage! Except Arthur has no idea that they've supposedly been sending each other letters and has no idea who she is. They set out on a li'l road trip together to figure out why Arthur's brother was catfishing her that really turns into a tour of all my/our/your favorite sex tropes (someone's coming, quick kiss me! Only one bed! Makeout/dry hump up against the wall! AND MORE!).

We feel like these books fill the Tessa Dare niche of "hilarious, super sexy, and emotional," and we're just so happy every time we pick one up.

This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.

this. book. is. amazing. I could scream about it from the rooftops 😫 the representation of social anxiety, being the oddball out, and still having confidence and power in your decisions is what made Lydia one of my favorite characters ever. There was NOTHING about this book I didn’t like, the story, characters, the quirks 🧑‍🍳💋 I’m usually not one for annotating but I was SCRIBBLING LIKE A MADWOMAN over some of the things said in this story.

Thank you so much Alexandra for sending me an ARC and letting me delight in this story.

Review posted to GoodReads 8/31, posted to evelynlainebooks on Instagram 8/31, and TBD future date.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

This was such an enjoyable romp of a Regency romance. We have the Scotland highlander romance hero, a dash of spies and tension, and lovable main characters. And paced perfectly. I read this book all in the span of one sleepless night. I'm so excited to read more of the Hope-Wallace family (Jasper??? swoon? I'm rooting for him and Lydia's best friend) and get the rest of their stories.

ABSOLUTELY PERFECT! A stunning regency romance! Just a brilliant romance in general! From the very beginning I was enthralled by the characters and their story. Lydia starts off witty and brilliant and it’s hard not to immediately want to know more about what’s going on in her brain. Arthur, on the other hand, is introduced as aloof and mysterious and, well, giant and bearded, so… sign me up! Their love story is a slow burn that had me giggling and kicking my feet the whole way through. And the best part? We love it when a man is down BAD for his girl. I had heart eyes and red cheeks reading some of the earl’s POVs.
This book has romance. It has history. It has mystery. It has all the makings of a perfect comfort read! 10/10! No notes! Add this to your tbr ASAP!

When you think the man with whom you're corresponding knows you, but when you show up at his door, he's confused by your presence and it gets a bit awkward.

Lydia Hope-Wallace is a wealthy heiress that has been sheltered all her life by her brothers and mother. She started writing pamphlets under a pseudonym about her opinions and publishing them through her friend's bookstore since she's unable to talk to men when she goes to balls and can get quite ill. They become wildly popular and the Earl of Strathrannoch reaches out to her and starts to converse about her pamphlets. When she finally builds up the courage to go to him in Scotland and propose due to his lack of funds, Arthur does not know who she is because the he has not been writing to her for the past 3 years. When the Arthur convinces her to stay, she starts to for the first time get comfortable around him and push past her fear to help him find his brother.

Historical regency romance is one of my favorite genres. I read all of Alexandra Vasti's books in one week because I couldn't get enough and this is no exception. It has everything that a reader could want: mystery, romance, and an incredibly hot Scottish man (Jamie Fraser, anyone?).

The author wrote about Lydia's anxiety and showed how despite warring with herself, Lydia still pushed through to try new experiences rather than shirking them due to fear. There's so much positive progression from the Lydia the reader sees in Ne'er Duke Well and this book.

Arthur is so patient with Lydia so that she has gain more confidence to do what needs to be done. He is the strong, patient man that she needs to encourage her to find herself and never judges her for what she feels. His need to be loved was something that made me want to wrap him in a hug. Also the fact that he is quite clever with his inventions and a bit of recluse really complimented Lydia.

I receive an ARC via NetGalley for an honest review.