If you’re a fan of the Graves Glen series, The Wedding Witch is perhaps worth reading for completion’s sake. Erin Sterling’s mix of magic and humor charmed in the past and conjured up a deliciously compelling character in Bowen. However, this book struggled to deliver on the romance, making it difficult to overlook a rough and uneven plot.

The chemistry between Bowen and Tamsyn, which should have been the heart of the story, felt thin and unconvincing. Their connection relied heavily on tropes, and hot hookup scenes, without the emotional groundwork to make their happily ever after work. If this story occurred outside the genre guidelines, I’d say this was Bowen finding a fun fling before he figured out who was Ms. Right Witch.

Tamsyn was meant to be playful and carefree, but often came through as self-absorbed in a way that distanced her both ethically and emotionally from her romantic pairing. She never seemed to be a character that was interested in a relationship and would be perfectly happy staying single with occasional side action. This is fine for a main character outside a genre Romance, but I need to see more internal growth and connection to her partner to believe their ever after status.

Bowen was brooding as expected, but he also felt a bit inconsistent from previous books—almost as if he got sent through the cinnamon roll glazer to cover over his spice. He was grumpy when it was convenient to the story, but he also seemed oddly fine capitulating to Tamsyn when she flatly deserved a lot more hell given her way.

This may be a side-effect of using the grumpy/sunshine trope to carry a pairing instead of a more nuanced delivery. Often those characters end up feeling like caricatures from under development both separately and shown growing together.

The time-travel premise—being transported to a Yuletide celebration in 1958—initially promised intrigue and spooky atmosphere, but never fully came together. The setting felt underutilized, and the stakes, whether romantic or magical, didn’t carry much weight. If the time-travel premise was going to be deployed effectively, their leap backward needed to occur far earlier in this shorter narrative.

It felt as if the first third was meandering around with these two on literal separate continents. The book is practically half over by the time leap, leaving no space to develop their in person chemistry and relationship while also doing the tough work of time-travel intrigue. The plot left so many strings untied as a result and the relationship was reduced to a physical connection without an emotional backing.

As the conclusion to an otherwise enjoyable series, this story didn’t cast a spell. If anything, I was rooting for Bowen to get another crack down the line after Tamsyn leaves to go find herself on a different continent again.
__________
Thank you to Avon and Harper Voyager for the Advanced Reader Copy. Expected publish date: Oct 8, 2024

I've enjoyed the previous two books in this series, The Ex Hex and The Kiss Curse, but I think this book is my favorite in the series! (I do recommend reading the others in the series first, though.)

Bowen hires Tamsyn to help him track down magical artifacts, and after a year of exchanging flirty messages, they make a plan to meet up on Christmas Eve. But plans change when they are separately tasked to crash a wedding in a remote Welsh castle and end up traveling back in time.

I love a good time travel story, and this one had a fun keep-your-grandparents-from-breaking-up storyline (sort of like Back to the Future) that also helped to develop some backstory about Bowen's father, which has been a storyline throughout the series. I think fans of the series will enjoy learning more about the history of Bowen's family.

This might be my favorite book in the Graves Glen series! I adored Bowen and Tamsyn together and had so much fun watching their love story unfold. It was great to see the whole trilogy come full circle and I will miss these characters!

I really liked the first two books in this witch romance series. The Wedding Witch is slightly different - it takes place during the Yule festivities in Wales. It does involve a Penhallow brother, however. Bowen Penhallow feels guilty about the fate of his college mate, Declan, who exists only as a ghost in a spell gone wrong. He has employed Tamsyn Bligh (who is not a witch) to acquire objects he thinks will help him get his friend back. However, through a series of coincidences and mishaps, Bowen and Tamsyn find themselves under a different spell that is quite disorienting. They have to solve their predicament but end up falling in love while doing so. This book is somewhat seasonal for Christmas but could be read anytime in the fall. I thought the romance worked really well and the machinations of the plot made the book adventurous. Always entertaining, Sterling has delivered again!

Thanks to the publisher for the gifted copy.

If The Wedding Witch by Erin Sterling isn’t already on your TBR, you’re seriously missing out. As the third book in the Graves Glen series, it’s the perfect blend of spooky, swoony, and laugh-out-loud fun—basically everything you’d expect if you’ve loved the first two. Spoiler alert: this one might just be my favorite (but don’t tell Vivi or Gwyn!).

This time, we dive into a magical wedding that’s equal parts chaos and charm, with Sterling’s signature wit in full force. If you’re a fan of cozy witchy rom-coms, The Wedding Witch is your vibe. Erin Sterling, you’ve done it again!

Studious recluse Bowen Penhallow is in need of a magical artifact that will fix a mistake from his past. Smart and adventurous Tamsyn Bligh is the perfect acquirer for Bowen to keep on retainer. Well she was, before Yuletide last year, now Bowen’s worried she’s just the perfect woman for Bowen to keep in his life. So when Yuletide rolls around this year and the two coworkers - strictly coworkers - find themselves guests with ulterior motives at a haunted mansion in the Welsh countryside who knows what will happen.

I love these two idiots!!!! Bowen and Tamsyn were so fun and so lovable and I enjoyed watching them realize their feelings for each other. This series from Erin Sterling is so cozy and lighthearted and the perfect read when you want a book that’ll make you smile, blush, and feel like a warm hug all in one. This book particularly isn’t for readers looking for well developed plot and intricate magic systems. I also wish I would’ve re-read the other two ahead of this book to get the full effect of the Penhollow brothers and their significant others come full circle. But all in all a quick cheerful read! Can’t wait to see what Erin Sterling comes out with next!!

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for an e-ARC in return for an honest review.

Omg! I am so happy to have gone back to Graves Glen to follow Bowen’s story with Tamsyn! It was so cool to go back in time and try to figure out how to get back to current time. This book will take you for a silly goofy time but it was so fun and sweet! Loved getting to see snips of Vivi, Rhys, Gwyn, and Wells!

I absolutely love this series from Erin Sterling. I am very picky about rom coms and these are just a perfect in my opinion. The level and amount of spice is just right. You don’t get too, too much spice but what you do get it perfectly done! I loved The Ex Hex and The Kiss Curse but The Wedding Witch is my favorite without a doubt. The gorgeous but spooky Welsh castle at Christmas-time setting and the adventure elements really knocked this installment in the Graves Glen series out of the park. Bowen and Tamsyn are so lovable and easy to root for and I can’t wait to see how they’re doing in the next book. If you love a magical rom com (or really any rom com) you must put this series on your list!! Thanks to NetGalley and Avon publishing for the eARC of this novel.

I enjoyed this! It was definitely not my favorite of the series and I didn’t really feel the connection between the characters but I liked the storyline and the mystery!

Ok! I am a little late with this review, apologies. I was behind a book when I got approved for this one. I LOVED the Ex Hex and reviewed it here but was turned down for the Kiss Curse and had to get it from the Library, which was a long wait. The good news is, this is a Holiday book! I am claiming it as such, its a Yule book and there is mistletoe!

The characters celebrate Yule, a witchy take on Christmas, making it a festive and atmospheric choice for the season.

I was flying through the pages thanks to the captivating spice scenes but the beginning was a bit of a challenge. The world-building was decent, but the introduction to the plot and its direction left me feeling confused. Loose threads abound at first, and although everything ties up by the end, it happens at a breakneck pace, I wish that pacing had been more even.

However, once you get a handle on the storyline, the pace picks up, and it becomes engaging enough to keep you invested until the conclusion. 

Best parts:

The grumpy male main character

 The short length, making it a quick read

 The straightforward plot, even with its many subplots

 Established world of Grave's Glen that continues into this book

Overall I say now is the perfect time to gove this book a read.

I really enjoyed the premise of this book and how it all ended wrapping up!! So smart and clever!! It had a very different feel than the previous two books in this world and I did miss my talking cat friend, but I still enjoyed it and would suggest checking it out!

The Wedding Witch by Erin Sterling is such a fun, festive read, perfect for fans of contemporary romance with a witchy twist! This third installment in the Graves Glen series was a quick and lighthearted story that blends Halloween vibes with Christmas cheer.

I really enjoyed the time-travel element—it added a wacky, whimsical layer to the romance. The banter was sharp, the chemistry was strong, and the “there’s only one bed” trope is always a win. The secondary characters were delightful, and the mix of humor, spice, and holiday magic kept me entertained from start to finish.

While I didn’t feel the earlier books in the series fully held my attention, this one stayed engaging the entire way through. It’s the perfect book to pick up for some seasonal fun!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

Really interesting story for the fall and winter holiday season! Not as witchy as the other books but overall a fun read!

I was so thrilled to be back in Graves Glen! Books 1-2 were such winners for me so “The Wedding Witch” was sure to be another. And boy did it deliver!

Sterling’s newest book gives us time travel, witches, and a romantic plot — do we need more? Also, it’s safe to say he falls first (which I’ve discovered is my newest favorite trope).

What I loved most about this one was that there was a level of mystery in Bowen and Tamsyn’s circumstances during their visit to Tywyll House. It’s this mystery that carried the story for me.

I’m not sure if there will be more Graves Glen books but if so, you can count me in on reading and L O V I N G them!

One of my favorite book series. Filled with love, hope, humor, and the best cast of characters, I always have a wonderful time with Graves Glen. More of this series, please!

"The Wedding Witch" by Erin Sterling is a captivating blend of romance and magic that kept me thoroughly entertained. The story follows Bowen Penhallow, a reclusive witch who prefers studying dark and ancient magic on a Welsh mountaintop. When his ghostly friend Colin convinces him to attend a Yuletide wedding at a grand estate, Bowen reluctantly agrees.

Tamsyn Bligh, a non-witch who makes her living selling magical items, is also attending the wedding with hopes of making a big score. Bowen, an occasional customer and the star of many of Tamsyn's fantasies, becomes her unexpected partner when a powerful spell and a wedding mishap transport them to the past, to the Yuletide Celebration of 1958.

The characters are well-developed and endearing. Bowen's journey from a loner to someone who opens up to love is heartwarming, and Tamsyn's resourcefulness and charm make her a delightful heroine. Their chemistry is palpable, and their adventures in the past add an exciting twist to the story.

One of the highlights of the book is the seamless integration of magic into the plot. The spells and enchantments are imaginative and add a fun twist to the romantic storyline. The pacing is well-balanced, with just the right amount of tension and resolution to keep the reader hooked.

However, there were a few moments where the plot felt a bit predictable, and some of the magical elements could have been explored more deeply. Despite these minor issues, "The Wedding Witch" is a thoroughly enjoyable read that will leave you smiling.

Overall, Erin Sterling has crafted a charming and magical tale that is perfect for fans of romantic comedies with a supernatural twist. I highly recommend it for a cozy, feel-good read.

The Wedding Witch is pure magic! Bowen, a brooding witch, and Tamsyn, a clever magical artifact dealer, are thrown back to 1958 by a spell gone wrong. Together, they unravel a haunting mystery, navigate a glamorous Yuletide party, and fight their undeniable chemistry.
With spooky charm, hilarious banter, and a touch of romance, Erin Sterling delivers another spellbinding read that’s perfect for any season!

3.5 💫

Probably my favorite of the series! Very cute & quick read. The magic and time traveling had me intrigued in this one. A little behind on my ARCs, but I couldn’t help saving this until Christmastime (thank you NetGalley & Avon Books!)

Witchy, ghosty romcom in October? Say less! We travel back to Graves Glen by way of Bowen - the middle, bearded Penhallow brother - on his quest to right a ghostly wrong from his past. Witty, swoony, and the perfect mix of romance, spells, and sibling love, The Wedding Witch was a great third act in Graves Glen!

I really liked this book. I love how this series has grown on me. I didn't like the first at all but I have loved the second and now third! The writing was fun and the romance was romancing in this one. Two thumbs way up!