The combination of snow and horror is top tier. I love snowed in stories and the silence snow provides to really allow the story to grow.

Our Winter Monster is the perfect winter horror, a creature feature crime thriller with so much heart and a gorgeous snowy setting. I found it unputdownable, I think because the when the pacing slowed a bit, there were still a main mystery to figure out. I also really cared about the characters. I appreciated that they were smart and handled situations realistically.
One of the major positives of this book is that the story has several layers, so even if you figure out a twist or predict where one plot line is going, there are other elements to surprise readers. It also got surprisingly gruesome; while I didn't find it scary, it definitely fits as horror.
I'm excited to read more from the author, and I'd recommend this to all horror readers. I can see it being on winter horror lists for years to come.

It is hard to describe this horror. Some times it feels like creature feature and sometimes psychological horror. It was good for me but not very memorable. Some of the twists were predictable.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for granting me a free arc in exchange for an honest review.
2.5 stars rounded up

Awesome setting and interesting monster but unfortunately I ended up putting this down once the reveal behind the monster happened. Felt a lot better as a creature feature and there was more fear about who would live or die

Very standard - to its detriment, in my mind, but for others, possibly a benefit? It's very straightforward for what you might expect from a wintery horror book like this. It's just too formulaic for me, I liked the imposing weather but wanted a little bit more from it.

Loved this one! It can be hard to write a full-length book about one night, but this had just enough going on to pull it off. Multiple POVs, but not excessive and they were well-balanced. I was o surprised by what the monster was and LOVED the idea, so pick this one up!

A perfect winter horror read! It felt very Steven Spielberg because the monster is such an abstract thing. It's terrifying, but we don't know what it is for so long. I loved that aspect. I found myself rooting for our characters to make it through the night. Highly recommend.

Claustrophobic storytelling throws a snow storm around some surface-level characters. Shame, it had a lot of potential.

I liked that the book has multiple POVs, it helped the story unfold and create a more mysterious atmosphere.
I was invested in Holly and Brians story but I felt it took too long to get to what actually happened between them.
The monster felt a little underwhelming. I wanted more gore, more monster. But overall it was an easy, enjoyable read.

I love a good winter thriller and this one sounded good to me - who doesn't enjoy a holiday road trip gone wrong in a storm?? Unfortunately it got a little too out there for even me and I ended up DNFing fairly early on. Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read an early digital copy by this new to me author.

Unfortunately I found this one to be quite formulaic and cliched. Characters I wasn't rooting for and a "twist" that just didn't do anything for me. I'm sure a disappointed "oh..." is not the reaction the author was going for.

Thank you Soho Press / Hills Hundred & Dennis Mahoney for this read!

This book started with the perfect creepy setting. I begun thoroughly intrigued. However as it drew on I found it lacked the same appeal and the intensity begun to slow in certain parts. The mixed POVs were clever however at times took the pace down.

This winter horror is not your average creature feature! It ties together multiple themes at once and makes you crave the answer to the reasons why things are unfolding.

While the reveal was slightly less impactful than I thought, it does connect the characters in a unique way.

Overall this book was a hit and miss for me. However it will appeal to many others who love winter horror with creature features with emotional appeal.

3.5/5

ABOUT
Chilling holiday horror about an unhappy couple running from their problems and straight into the maw of a terrifying beast, perfect for fans of Paul Tremblay and Sara Gran.
READ IT IF YOU LIKE
- Supernatural horror
- Creature features
- Psychological suspense
- Crime fiction
- Stories set in winter
- Exploration of PTSD, anxiety
- Stephen Graham Jones, Paul Tremblay, Ian Reid

BRIEF REVIEW
Unique kills and a creative direction I don't see often in creature features along with plenty of twists and turns.

For me, this book was just okay. It has a really interesting concept, and I love the small-town blizzard setting, but I felt it could have been even more atmospheric. A stronger sense of place might have better connected me as a reader to both the story and the monster. While I don’t mind psychological horror, I didn’t care for the twist or revelation about how the monster connected to the two main characters. Another drawback was the protagonists themselves—they both felt whiny and distant, and I never really got a strong grasp on them as a couple beyond their unhappiness. I wish the characters had been more fleshed out. I did listen to the audiobook, and I think the narration helped strengthen some of the characters' presence that I felt was lacking. Overall, this book was just okay for me. I think others might enjoy it more, but I can also see why someone would rate it in the middle or lower.

Took me a while to get into but I will not deny that I slept on this... because when it started going it was GOING. I love a winter horror this time of year and this did not disappoint. I enjoyed the way it actually got pretty deep with the emotional trauma and complex human interactions and relationships and when there are times in our lives that we reflect on that. The characters were all well introduced and I loved the mystery of certain backstories with some. Especially "the bad date". Would highly recommend!

Unfortunately not for me. I struggled to connect with the characters, and found the switches in the POV to be fairly jarring, sucking the momentum out of scenes at times. There's something fun here, but it just didn't come together for me.

Snow yesterday and blistering cold today. Gotta love Minnesota winters – who knows what will come next! BUT one thing I do enjoy is winter horror

A couple struggling decides to have a nice secluded trip away together to rekindle and save their relationship. Holly and Brian’s lives changed last year, and ever since, their relationship and lives have begun to crumble, and bad luck seems to find them wherever they go. On their way to a secluded ski town, they encounter blizzard snow conditions, and things take a turn. As if being stuck in the storm isn’t bad enough, there’s something eerie and monstrous lurking around in the snow.

Going along with Holly and Brian’s storyline, we also meet the sheriff in the small town of Pinebuck. Sheriff Kendra Book is dealing with her own personal struggles on top of numerous missing persons in the area.

In my mind, I was trying to give driving advice for the snowy conditions, but alas, we needed the storm to set the perfect scene. I enjoyed seeing the two stories unfold and the switching POVs. If you’re a fan of thrillers, then you’ll love the back and forth and the pacing. It’s not too intense in terms of horror, but there is a nice little bloody scene in there you’ll enjoy! Some monsters, characters facing their emotional traumas, and trying to work together to survive. There were some good little twists, and while the big reveal wasn’t shocking, I was rather pleased with how things all came together!

I think over all I found this book to just be, alright. In some ways I think the trauma between Holly and Brian was displayed quite well. When someone is suffering, the other will pick up the slack. But at the same time I think these characters were pretty juvenile. They refuse to truly talk to each other in any adult capacity and refuse to even think of the issues they're going through.

Plot wise I think this was just awful. There's zero explanation for anything that's going on. No lore of the "monster" or why this is happening, everything's just dropped in your lap.

Zero character development. The couple goes through something traumatic that starts breaking them apart and then they go through something else traumatic and all of a sudden they're okay again? No. Also every time we get the perspective of the sheriff she's seriously complaining about the exact same thing. She hates snow, her girlfriend left her, maybe she should've gone with. It's always the same complaints and she's never trying to work through it. Again, zero development.

Our Winter Monster had an intriguing premise, but I struggled to connect with the story. The atmosphere was well-crafted, and the writing had a poetic quality, but I found the pacing slow and the characters difficult to engage with. While it may resonate with readers who enjoy dreamy, introspective narratives, unfortunately it just wasn’t for me.

Our Winter Monster has everything it needs to make a good horror novel; a small town, a big deadly snow monster, and a couple with a complex backstory. However, this one just missed the mark for me. About three quarters through, the story became a bit predictable for me and did not have the scare factor. I felt as though many of the characters fell flat and lacked depth that would have brought the story to another level. I really wanted to like this one, but it let me down unfortunately!