Member Reviews

I received a copy of this novel from the author and Historian Press through NetGalley. This is my own unsolicited opinion. In all honesty, this is more and less than I expected. It was more vivid in description, heartbreaking in the reality of what an oppressive life the coal miners and children fought to survive through. It is intense. When I say less, the full story wasn't there yet from the blurb about innocent miners being executed. I finally understood there is more to be written.
In the 1880's after the civil war life was far different from what we know today. It was heartbreaking in the coal mine country of Pennsylvania. Hopeless. Yet this incredible people; men, women and children trudged forward day after day. Author Michael Dunn paints the dark picture, fills the lungs with coal dust and the screams of the next child to lose a limb.
It's an incredible, well written story. It reflects a reality that is hard to take at times. Definitely gritty and raw. It's not romantic or pretty.
Characters involved in strikes after wage cuts, terrible work conditions, police violence, spies and managerial abuse are written to tell their stories. The author does a great job leaving himself behind.
Important mentions:
Pinkertons (Gave me an eye-opening insight)
Molly Maguires Ancient Order of Hiberians
Workingman's Benevolent Association 1868 (one of the nation's first industrial unions)
There may be triggers for some readers, horrendous abuse, offensive language, sexual innuendo and violence.

Was this review helpful?

Anywhere But Schuylkill was a fast paced book that kept me turning the page wanting to know what happens next. I had no idea about the Avondale Mine disaster despite growing up in the area. The book had a good mix between fiction and history, i wish mike got a happy ending but i think the ending he got was more realistic.

Was this review helpful?

A great novel! On the one hand, the storyline is very interesting as well as informative as to life around and in the coal mines; on the other hand, the plot is thrilling and full of tension! Indeed, trying to get improvement on salaries and life conditions can lead to much violence within the families and outside... How can you judge someone who does not want to take part in a strike, when it means no money for food? How can you just accept the abject conditions of working and living? The story revolves around these themes, and to even more violence and disputes among the ones fighting.... The end is however a bit of a cliff hanger! Is there maybe a book 2? Nevertheless, I really enjoyed it!
I received a digital copy of this novel from NetGalley and I am leaving voluntarily an honest review.

Was this review helpful?