Member Reviews

100% yes. this one was amazing! it gave me all the warm & fuzzies, and it was exactly what I hoped to get from a Casey McQuiston book.

though nothing can take the place of RW&RB in my heart, this one was a pleasant, happy read that had me in a chokehold from beginning to end! and the steam was perfecttttt

💞friends to lovers
💞second chance
💞hookup challenge
💞bi main characters

I went back and forth between audio and ebook and it made it even better!

Was this review helpful?

This was definitely mcquiston's spiciest book yet. They once again knocked the romance out of the park. I'm not usually one for second chance but I really enjoyed this.

The food descriptions and number of adjectives were a bit much for me, but over all this was a great book that I'm so glad I got to read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillian Audio for an advanced listener copy of this book.

Casey McQuiston wrote the "is somebody gonna match my freak" book of the summer. This one was very "ive been a nasty girl" vibes.

The Pairing is the story of Theo and Kitt, two childhood friends and former lovers who reunite for the first time in four years on a three week food and wine tour in Spain, France, and Italy. As the trip progresses, they clear up their massive miscommunication issues and reconcile the resentment and the feelings they still have for one another.

I don't think much of European vacations, unsurprisingly. However, this book did a very good job of walking me through the most gorgeous parts of a European summer. I was super sad about my lactose intolerance which meant I probably couldn't sign on to my own tour.

The characters are surprisingly likeable. There was only one point at around the 85% mark that I got annoyed at Theo, but other than that? I understood the tension and longing and inability to say the important things. This audiobook is very long and the story definitely could have been cut by two stops, but it never dragged. I think there were moments that didn't move the plot forward, and could have been edited down for brevity's sake.
But when I say this book gets FREAKY, I mean it. I was listening to this mouth AGAPE at the sexual content in this book. Casey McQuiston really went there this time around. Some of the language around sex in this book made me cringe, but that could have just been the audiobook narration.

All in all, I enjoyed the audiobook narration. Theo's narrator was excellent and missed them after the narration switch halfway through. Kitt's narrator was good, but the voice they put on for Theo did not fit the feeling I had for the character.

I am 4/4 on Casey McQuiston books (it's a hit!). If you like Red White and Royal Blue, this one is for you.

Was this review helpful?

I'm always grateful to receive an ARC from NetGalley and Macmillan Audio.

Well, with this book, I'm officially 50/50 on Casey McQuiston. I know this will probably be a minority opinion, but besides Red, White, & Royal Blue, each successive book has featured AT LEAST one insufferable main character.

I was primed to love this book, but it was all right. We meet Theo and Kitt, 28-year-old Bi disasters exes who end up on a three-week food tour through western Europe. It's Eat, Pray, Love but make it queer! I did enjoy the Eat part of the story, and I'm ready to book my tour tomorrow based on the delicious descriptions of the food and scenery. The Pray portions showcased Theo's struggle as a nepobaby which never landed. She refuses to accept help from her family because...reasons. The focus on their processing of gender and their clear challenges with executive function would have been better. Kit fairs better in this part as we discuss his need to balance dreams and reality along with lingering grief. It all goes completely off the rails at the Love part. I'm a sucker for a second-chance romance, and this was a disappointment. Kit and Theo spend the book acting like sex-obsessed teenagers who refuse to have a direct conversation. This is ironic because they are both desperate to show the other how they've matured and grown since their breakup. I'm used to reading books with a lot of "spice," but this story was more titillating/salacious but missing the emotional component to make the scenes truly sing.

The book devotes the first half to Theo's POV and the second to Kit. To be frank, if this had been only in Theo's perspective, I would have DNF'd the book, which I never do for an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I adore Casey McQuistons writing so much. There writing is unique and fun to read.

The overall story was entertaining, but a bit repetitive. The main character Theo was a bit annoying with all the lying to try to impress others and lack of communication. The audio book was a lot of fun! The narrators did a great job.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this one - I've always been a fan of McQuiston's work, and I LOVED the idea of this premise. A perfect summer story that takes us on a European food tour and a second-chance romance. This should have worked PERFECTLY for me.

Instead, I was pretty disappointed. 90% of this book is miscommunication and then having sex with other people to get over each other. It's also each of the two main characters saying how much they love the other person and how smart/strong/sexy that person is, but we never really see anything that is evidence to back that statement up. Ex. Kit tells us over and over how amazing Theo is and how they're the smartest and most impressive person he's ever met... except everything we see of Theo is them not committing to anything, refusing help from others when other people would KILL for an investment, and overall trying to pretend like they don't come from a rich family which will always give them a leg up in the world even if they don't want to be connected to that name.

I think Theo just annoyed me a little too much (and I say that as a 29-year old who doesn't know what her purpose is in life, which means I'm basically neck and neck with Theo), and Kit was portrayed as way too perfect most of the time. I wish we had a little more heart to more of the background characters as well - there is definitely plot there, don't get it twisted. But I just never really felt connected to any of the other characters (whereas in RWRB, June and Nora were my favorite characters).

I think some McQuiston fans will still enjoy this book, but it just wasn't up to my personal taste (and that's okay!). Here's hoping that their next novel will blow me away spectacularly.

Was this review helpful?

It's Pride Month! Read ALL the Casey McQuiston books you can get your hands on! The Pairing was an amazing story of love, food, sex, and adventure! Also, the narrators were fantastic!

Was this review helpful?

This book was absolutely fantastic. It was filled with so much longing and love and culture and I devoured it in two days! I happened to read it while also traveling in Italy and it totally added to the experience. I adored the main characters, they were chaotic and angsty and their love for each other was so gorgeous. McQuinston really knocked it out of the park with this one! I just finished it and I already want to read it again!!

Also it was so steamy and written so well I was literally fanning myself at times😂

🌈Queer rep: NB/M main relationship, nonbinary bi/pan protagonist, bi/pan male protagonist, NB/F and M/M relationships. Secondary FF and MM relationships.

Was this review helpful?

Theo and Kit broke up right before going on a European bus tour, but now with their vouchers for a free bus tour about to expire, they both unexpectedly end up on the same bus tour. It's told first from Theo's perspective then Kit's as they travel through France, Spain, and Italy discovering both food and all the ways they've changed over the past four years.

I really enjoyed this. I thought it was a really lovely contemporary romance between two people who are so clearly meant for each other figuring out if and how they can really be together. And I thought the perspective shift halfway through the book was a great way to get insights into both characters.

I thought both narrators did a wonderful job giving the characters a distinctive voice.

Was this review helpful?

I completely devoured this book. Each book by Casey McQuiston pulls me in and has me believing in love, even through the lens of imperfect people. I was rooting for Kit and Theo the entire story,

Was this review helpful?

Theo and Kit were best friends growing up, next came the crushes and then the relationship. They break up after a disastrous trip to Europe. Years later they accidentally reconnect on another tour. This was a bit of a bummer for me. I really have loved Casey's other books. There is a lot here to like in the conversations about gender and sexual identify. I liked both of the characters on their own but never really connected with the romance between the two. The miscommunication was so heavy handed.

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillian Audio for the ALC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was the perfect summer read! It is beautiful, both in it's writing and it's backdrop of Europe. This story is filled with longing, desire, and love. Watching the characters fall back in love with each other was beautiful. The spice in this book was top tier as well! I am such a fan of Casey McQuiston and loved seeing her writing in the adult genre. I look forward to what she writes next!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillian Audio for an Advanced Listeners Copy of this book. I thoroughly enjoyed the European travel aspect of this book and especially reminiscing about my own trip to Italy while Kit and Theo were there. However, I wish I would have read the synopsis before requesting this book. The premise of the “hookup competition” did not appeal to me. I ended up stopping the book at 60% because the spicy scenes just seemed gratuitous at that point and weren’t adding to the story, in my opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t know if this was a case of too high expectations and being so excited for this book or if I still wouldn’t have loved it if my expectations were none existent.

It’s second chance romance: Theo and Kit end up on this incredible all over Europe tour for the summer and they are childhood besties turned lovers turned exes but still have been pining over each other for the last 4 years.

What did work for me was the quick quippy fun conversations they would have when they would talk, the descriptions of the food and drinks, the side characters and how sex positive everyone was.

What didn’t work for me was first and foremost second chance isn’t my favorite but I like it when the reason for breaking up makes sense and the character growth and communication shows that a hea is achievable… I didn’t see the character growth that I was hoping for. And probably should have dnfed around halfway when I got bored.

I did the audiobook and I liked the narrator for Theo just fine but the narrator for Kit wasn’t a new favorite-quite whiney.

Thanks to netgalley and Macmillan audio for an alc

Was this review helpful?

What I loved:
Binary representation
Bi rep
All the travel
Cocktails and wine in detail (however went into extreme detail ad nauseam

What didn’t work:
The length of this book. Cut it down
It was a little too spicy for me

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for an advance copy of the ebook and audiobook.

This wasn't exactly what I thought it was going to be. Exes who go on a sexual conquest bender across Europe to prove how over the other they are when they find themselves on the same trip sounded like catnip to me. This ended up not being quite right. I don't know if this was an audiobook problem for me but Theo's narration started feeling very manic in the first half.

I'm wildly annoyed that the initial breakup and years lost amounted to a miscommunication from two people who talk constantly and are relatively decent at having the hard conversations. The time apart was good for them but come on.

I loved that the minute Theo had a conversation with Kit about pronouns and their identity, that was it. All the 'she's' used in the story to that point are retconned and that's all they wrote on the matter.

Was this review helpful?

This is an unfortunate occurrence.

STORYTELLING

I would think that at the highest level of publishing, something like this wouldn't pass muster. Let's forget the line edits needed and think more broadly. Structurally, this narrative is…off.

I appreciate the symmetry of telling the story of childhood, early relationship, breakup, then present day first from Theo’s POV and then Kit’s. However, inherent in that structure is overlap that can lead to repetition.

Also at issue is the fact that we’ve come so far with Theo that starting all over again from the beginning with Kit feels more like a setback than an interesting storytelling device.

WHO EVEN IS THEO?

A deliberate choice was made to obscure Theo’s gender identity. Unfortunately, this led to an unknowable blank space of a character that I could not relate to, especially as the character devolved into something grotesque, so often treating Kit like trash and forever wanting to be congratulated for choosing to make life harder for themselves.

But make no mistake, it's not Theo’s gender in and of itself that's key here. It’s that understanding how Theo identifies would have gone a long way to understanding the character.

What does it mean when Theo looks at Kit hitting on a femme woman and says to themselves, “she’s the woman I’ll never be?”

How does Theo experience and interact with the world? What motivates Theo? What challenges is Theo facing? If this was a book about gender exploration, there would be so much here for me, an agender person, to relate to and maybe even identify with. Instead, we get a nothing of a character. A blank space, forcing the reader to search for context clues and make assumptions.

And, as a corollary, Theo has got to be the only non-binary person in the known universe who simply does not think about gender. At all. Ever. Head empty. No thoughts. Of course we can be comfortable in our own skin when it comes to our gender identity, but being comfortable doesn’t mean we cease to think about the way we experience the world. Though, to be fair, Theo isn’t exactly the kind of character you rely on for introspection. As I said. Head empty. No thoughts.

THE BISEXUAL BACCHANALIA

I see in the reviews that many people took issue with the parade of conquests, as well as the fact that every single European in this book is bisexual and DTF. Sure. Fine. Okay.

More than that though, what got me was that even when these MCs figured out, individually, that they were in love with the other one and wanted to get back together, rather than, you know, talking about it, they continued to have sex with other people who they didn’t actually want to have sex with.

I know this kind of thing is not unrealistic, but I certainly could not relate to this part of the story..

NARRATION

This is written in first person, with each MC being voiced by a different narrator. By the time we got to Kit’s first person POV, I already loathed Theo, so it's unfortunate that the narrator voicing Kit bumped it up a notch and made Theo well and truly the worst via their narration. Probably the narrator wasn't trying to push Theo even further up my No Thanks list, but they did it anyway. Oops.

Was this review helpful?

4.75⭐️ SHUT UP! THIS WAS EVERYTHING TO ME.

I didn't think I would love it this much, and I'm very happy to have been wrong.

The writing was easy to read, beautiful (I barely made it through Kits POV as I was pausing every 30 seconds to crumple up and die), fun, silly and just overall what I love from this author.

The characters, although a little hard to like at first, really really grow on you. To the point where I was mourning Theos POV when the switchover happened. The relationship between the main characters as well as the relationships they make with the side characters were super well done. Although, I think we could've used a little more side character action as there are so many of them that I did start to forget who certain people were by the end.

Even though it was more smut heavy than what I personally like to read, I can't say that it wasn't well written!! Like, go off! I think if I wasn't listening to the audio narrators moaning into my ears, I might've been less adverse to the number of scenes.

My only reason for it not being a five-star is that at one point, it did feel like it was going on forever. It gets pretty repetitive towards the end, which really makes it feel much longer than it is. I kept expecting to be at the last chapter only to discover that I had hours left to read.

I hope we continue to get books that are this much fun in the future!!

Thank you to Netgalley for the Audio Arc❤️

Was this review helpful?

Foodie, fun and escapist, although the fact that his feels aggressively Gen Z may be off putting to McQuiston's older fans. A recommended purchase for collections where contemporary romance is popular.

Was this review helpful?

Sadly I have to say I found this book to be flat and unexciting for the most part. I was interested in the beginning but I didn't really love either character so that didn't help me stay invested. I almost DNF this one but stuck with it hoping the author who I normally really enjoy would pull a rabbit out of their hat and surprise me.

Theo was very immature, insecure and just didn't endear me to this "love" story. Kit was more likeable but I felt was also very naïve when it came to Theo. This relationship just didn't feel like love to me and maybe that is because the falling in love happened before the book started and so it felt like they were just saying they were in love. I didn't feel the chemistry and the sex scenes were a bit unexciting. I did enjoy a lot of the side characters, the witty banter & the setting. I didn't hate this book but I just found it a fell a little flat for me.

The narration was good. I enjoyed Emma Galvin but Max Meyers just didn't fit the voice I had in my head for Kit when we finally get Kit's POV.

Thank you to NetGalley for an advanced copy of this audiobook.

Was this review helpful?