Member Reviews

I enjoyed Casey McQuiston's new novel The Pairing. I'm nervous to say too much so I don't spoil anything, but once the twists are revealed, the story takes a significant upturn in mood. Honestly, I was so anxious during Theo's part (the first section of the novel) that I wasn't sure I'd be able to finish it.

Mostly I'm kidding about that, but you know that sensation of being "on edge"? That's how it started out for me.

Now partially it is because I don't read blurbs, and because this was an ARC I hadn't read any reviews yet, but if you're starting this book and have the same experience, please just keep going!

I definitely liked the narrators. Emma Galvin and Max Meyers do a wonderful job with these characters, not to mention the supporting cast and all their accents.

McQuiston brought back so many memories for me of my own travels through Europe as a young person, The Pairing is a whole lot of fun and 100% worth reading.

Was this review helpful?

I love Casey Mcquiston books however this one was nothing short of awful. If you are looking for a nice romance like in her others, look elsewhere.
Kit and Theo were set to go on romantic food and drink tour abroad when they had an argument on the plane. They broke up and went their separate ways, never really knowing what happened. Four years later they both decide (separately) to finally use their voucher for the trip.
Kit and Theo are surprised to find each other on the trip and try to become friends again. It’s difficult and they make light of it by challenging one another to one-night-stand war, who can get the most lays. The teasing banter between them is pretty vulgar and it just got tiring. I felt like the writer was just trying too hard here and it felt out of place.
The European tour of food and drink is described at great length and becomes boring. I ended up trying to forward through those parts because I had had enough.
My advice, don’t waste your time, there is so much better out there.

Was this review helpful?

Amazing. Another 5 star read from Casey McQuiston. I have loved all three of their previous books and The Pairing did not disappoint! Complicated and lovable characters!

Was this review helpful?

Every book by Casey McQuiston I've read I've really enjoyed. This one not so much.

It wasn't horrible, but it was far from great.

Theo and Kit broke up years ago but right before they broke up they had tickets for a tasting around Europe (both cook/bake for a living). Now back in Europe they both decided to take the same tour...at the same time. Talk about tension!

So I was expecting some cute sexual tension between Theo and Kit. Instead we got a sexual competition to see who can sleep with the most people. When I say that is all the book is about, I'm not kidding. There were some cute moments with Theo and Kit but I thought for sure we would get more sexual tension between the two...not everyone around Europe. Just an odd "romance" story in my opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I've never wanted two people to be together but also stay as far away from each other more than now. I don't know how I feel yet, but I will say it's crazy that CMQ fans are critiquing this novel for being unrealistic. Their work is fun to read because they're idealistic. RWRB was set after the 2016 election with a woman president... and Texas flipped blue in it. The narrators were phenomenal and they fit the two characters so well. I think consuming this as an audiobook enhanced the experience. Anyway, I'm gonna process how annoying and messy Theo and Kit were. But also how much I love that they're different from most book couples????

Was this review helpful?

Theo and Kit, two exes with a complicated past, were once childhood best friends, then crushes, and eventually in love—until a messy breakup tore them apart. Four years later, each decides to redeem their unused vouchers for a European food and wine tour, thinking they’ll travel solo. But they end up on the same tour bus, embarking on a three-week journey through the most romantic cities in France, Spain, and Italy. What starts as an attempt to prove they’re over each other turns into a playful hookup competition, but as they explore stunning locations, indulge in delicious food, and savor fine wines, they begin to wonder if their story is really over.
I’ve read all of Casey McQuiston’s books, and while The Pairing wasn’t my favorite, it was still a fun and enjoyable read. I found it a bit hard to believe that all of Europe seemed to be attracted to Theo and Kit, and I liked Kit more than Theo. The vivid descriptions of the places they visit, the food they taste, and the wine they drink really brought the story to life for me.
The audio version, narrated by Emma Galvin and Max Meyers, was well done, with both narrators bringing the characters and story to life. Thank you St. Martin's Press, Macmillan Audio, and NetGalley for the gifted copies.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the narration of the story. The voices suited the characters well, and I liked hearing Casey narrate some too!

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to like this one, but I was bored reading it. Theo and Kit had booked a European tour back when they were still together. After they broke up, they each received a voucher for the tour in the future. Coincidentally, they both booked the same week (4 years later right before it expires) and ended up on the same food and wine tour bus through France and Italy. I never connected with either Theo or Kit as main characters. They seemed whiny and overly sexual. I usually enjoy a second-chance romance, but the fact that Theo and Kit kept trying to “one up” each other during this vacation in Europe, was not great. The plot was lacking, and I can’t remember a single side character. I listened to the audiobook and the narrator never brought me in. Unfortunately, this book was not memorable. On to the next.

Was this review helpful?

I tried to like this book. I really did. The concept is simple: two lovers headed for a European trip break up on the plane before the trip. One flies back to the States, and the other moves to France. But lucky them—they get vouchers to take the trip at a later time. Lo and behold, they meet up again since they, obviously, chose the same date, albeit years later, for the trip. As far as I can tell, all they did was drink, hook up with others... many others... and lament about their past. Every character in the book was young, attractive, and bisexual. There were no meaningful secondary characters and no depth to anyone.

Gender identity, sexual identity, and self-worth are strong themes.
The narration of the story was excellent.

If you're looking for a light read with lots of sex, then this is your book.

Was this review helpful?

Advanced Reader’s Copy provided by NetGalley, and Macmillan Audio in exchange for an honest review.

Everything about this book was delectable! Theo and Kit's relationship is so layered, complex, beautiful and so messy (deliciously so). Their relationship paired with the descriptions of their travels and the food was incredible! I could say so much about this book, but I'm afraid everything would be a spoiler. I've read everything McQuiston has written since their debut, and it's been so great to see how much they've grown! McQuiston just keeps getting better and better!

I recently just came back from a trip to Venice, Florence and Rome and seeing these places and then reading about the characters experiences in those same places seemed to heighten my reading experience; though this book would be a great way to experience a euro-summer! If you're traveling soon, or need a quick get away try this book!

Was this review helpful?

Casey is my favorite author so I'm extremely happy that I received this arc! I loved this book so much. Not quite as much as One Last Stop but close. Thank you so much for letting have this arc. I also love that Casey narrated the audiobook!

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars. ummm what was this book? I love love love love Casey's books but this one was not good. From the description this book should be every thing I like, but oh my god the first half of half of the book is boring and oh my god Theo is the worst person on the planet. I am honestly grateful for the ambiguous ending because I can choose to believe they don't end up together. I was hoping this book would make me excited for my trip to France this fall, but it only made me mad.
That being said, I did enjoy the narrators for the audiobook. Emma Galvin and Max Meyers did their best to bring these two to life and honestly the audiobook was probably the only thing that kept me going in the beginning of the book.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a really fun time with our two main characters on a food and wine tour of Europe. I enjoyed the story and the side characters a lot. My biggest issue with this book was I felt like I didn’t really know who the characters were and how they saw themselves. It felt like everything we learned about the characters was what the other character was saying about them.

Was this review helpful?

I am sort of at a loss for how to review The Pairing. It is a love story between two people, Kit and Theo, who broke up right before a food tour of Europe, only to be reunited years later on the same tour before their voucher expired. I loved these characters. They were so well-developed, so multi-dimensional, so honest. I laughed out loud so many times - big guffaws. It made me hungry with the food descriptions. I loved the romance. But it was also a bit long and seemed a bit repetitive. And while I loved the romance, the competition between Kit and Theo on the trip made my romantic heart hurt and I may have said argh a few times. So take that for what it is….

Was this review helpful?

Casey McQuiston is one of the few romance writers that I enjoy reading and as always, her book did not disappoint. This story follows Theo and Kit, childhood best friends and now estranged exes who find themselves on the same European food and wine tour, an experience they'd booked together years prior but didn't think the other would be on at the same time.

The set up? Ridiculous, I love it. It's a very sort-of cute and corny way to introduce the characters and their personalities. I instantly loved both of them and really enjoyed getting their backstories of what they'd done throughout their years apart to bring them to the present in Europe. Also I just have to say, I started reading this book HOME from my trip to Italy (I never read book synopses before I start them) and this whole story made me just want to get on a flight back to Europe immediately.

This book is spicy! I hate spice without plot, but luckily that was never the case here. Theo and Kit were so complicated and had so much depth, I loved watching them grow and learn throughout this book. The side characters were also very fun (albeit a little over-the-top) but I think they really added some light-hearted energy to the story. This was the perfect summer romance read and I really enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

I have loved Casey McQuiston's previous books, but this one was not for me. This was a second chance romance on a whirlwind trip through Europe. I didn't have any attachments to the two main characters, Theo and Kit. In the previous books, the supporting characters played a big part in the story and in this book that wasn't the case. It was really a struggle for me to finish the book. I really didn't care if they got back together or not. I had to switch from the audiobook to the book because I didn't enjoy the narrator for Theo.

My ranking of their previous books are: 1. One Last Stop, 2. Red, White, and Royal Blue, 3. I Kissed Shara Wheeler.

Thanks to St. Martin's Griffin and NetGalley for the advanced digital copy of the book and Macmillan Audio for the advanced digital copy of the audiobook.

Was this review helpful?

The pairing by Casey Mcquinston
Publication date: August 6th 2024

I got the ARC of the audiobook on netgalley thanks to macmillan audio.

The poetic and descriptive writing is chefs kiss omg. This book is so funny and witty I feel like I know Theo.

-we love forced proximity and second chance they are stuck on a European trip together
-the way Theo describes Kit makes me fall in love with every detail about him you fall in love with him through them😭🥹

My thoughts while listening to the book:

-this book had me feeling like i’m on trip in Europe this book is perfect for the summer
-Ouuu this book making giddy and tingling
-They are literally competing who can get someone while fighting the feelings they have for each other 😩
-Their sexual tension is TENSIONING 🤪
-One BED TROPE HELL YEAH 🥳
-The spice is spicing 👀
-This book did feel a little long but I still ate it up wow
-“i’ve never loved Theo more than in this moment. Love took root in me before I learned its name….” 😭
-the meaning behind pairing the title 😭
-this book was beautiful I feel like I came back from a trip from europe wow

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

I will forever and ever be a Casey McQuiston fan. This book, sadly, will be lowest in my rankings from them. The premise is fantastic. Two exes go on a wine and food tour of Europe four years after their split. I am here for the second-chance romance. What I'm not a fan of is the lack of communication about their real feelings and waiting so long to talk about what happened that fateful day 4 years ago. That being said, the sex positivity is great and I love the unapologetic queerness in the book. I do wish there wasn't as much hooking up with other people during the tour but that is most likely just a personal choice. I have a hard time wrapping my brain around "I love you but I'm going to go do this with them over there." The queerness, though, and the discussions around how they both changed was everything and the reason this book was saved for me. If you are a foodie, you will salivate at all the descriptions of their meals and snacks throughout their journey. It felt very European throughout, providing the best escape from my own couch here in the States. The audio for this one was very well done. Reading it in this format puts the reader right in the scene with the accents and personalities of all the characters on the tour.

Overall, this wasn't a top read for me but I still enjoyed it and loved certain aspects. I will always be wanting the next Casey McQuiston. One of my favorite things about their books is how very different (and yet fantastic) each one is. I cannot wait to see what's next.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun second chance romance that paired food, wine, travel, humor, and spice. These characters are unapologetically queer and horny. I was rooting for these characters the whole time, even though I was mainly thinking just stop miscommunicating/not communicating and just admit your feelings already! This book had a lot of pining so if you enjoy that you will love this one.
I did find the fact that the book was split up into 2 POVs but instead of alternating it was 1 for the first half and 1 for the second a bit jarring, but that is probably because I knew one of my favorite narrators was narrating the second half and I just wanted to hear him haha. But that being said, I get why it was done that way and I think that it did work for the story because alternating would have definitely taken away from the impact of the second half. It's just not a type of dual POV that I see very often. Also the second half was definitely my favorite half of the book. It was just great getting into Kit's head after being in Theo's.
Overall another good queer book from Casey McQuiston

Audiobook specific: both narrators were good but Max Meyers is definitely a favorite to listen to.

Content warning: spicy content, death of parent, grief

Thank you to @macmillainaudio for an ALC. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This book definitely delivers on the horny in Europe promise here, because that’s what you’ll get here. I do wish we had more of Theo and Kit’s relationship before the breakup and a little more depth. Theo is a bit insufferable at times, and didn’t love their nepo baby bit. Loved the travel writing of it all with the food and drink talk, and overall pretty solid.

Thanks to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?