Member Reviews
A charming and witty time travel romance! Tuck Taylor is a 21st century professional hockey player who while visiting his younger sister in England falls through a cracked ice and wakes up in Regency England. Lizzy Woodash finds him in a pond and decides to help him go back to the future with the help of her cousin Georgie and her gal pal Jane Austen. In order for her not to be riddled with scandal for a man to be spending so much time in her company and so that she can claim the independence she desires, her friends suggest a marriage of convenience so they elope to Scotland! But what happens when they both catch feelings?!!!
The Jane Austen references had me screaming laughing!! I loved it!
-Time Travel
-Marriage if Convenience
-Hockey Romance
-Regency Romance
-All the “my wife” and “good girl” vibes
Puck & Prejudice is a book that is the PERFECT combo of a historical romance + a contemporary romance! It is the best book for people who would like to get into historical romances AND the best book for Jane Austen lovers! Not only is Jane Austen mentioned, references and, SHE'S A SIDE CHARACTER! It's such a funny aspect and a different perspective!
This book has an amazing combination of tropes that combine to make such a fun read! There's one bed, nickname, hockey romance, time travel, and more! The best way I can describe this book is that it's like a combination of Lost in Austen and a reverse Kate & Leopold! It is SUCH a fun concept and I loved the idea and the execution!
Thank you so much to Avon for an e-ARC of this book in exchange for an unbiased review!💖
I read Puck and Prejudice in a course of a weekend, it was a swoony hilarious read. Lizzy was delightful and of course for a women in 1812 she was way ahead of time (sh’s different), Jane Austen is her best friend and we do get some one liners for the fan girls of Ms Austen.
Tucker is a NFL who hasn’t played hockey in over a year due to illness who finds himself visiting his sister in England and then ends up in 1812. Honestly we get one scene where Tucker Taylor actually plays hockey, the summary makes you think it will be more hockey based but it really isn’t - hockey takes a back seat in this story. I enjoyed this book but I felt the ending and explanation was so rushed by the end of the book that it kind of overshadowed the overall book for me. It was confusing and unrealistic.
The book is a perfect summer read it’s light, fluffy and honestly kudos to the author for thinking outside the box with combining regency and hockey.
Like most, I'm sure, I came into this thinking I wouldn't be taking this book so seriously. But boy, was I wrong. This was actually phenomenal and I'm so glad I read this. It was hilarious, real, swoony, silly, passionate, thrilling and just everything you could want and more.
Ok buckle up for this review
Take regency+2020’s (it’s after Covid I don’t know the act year)+outlander= this.
When I first heard of a Pride and Prejudice meets Hockey I screamed. You combine my two favorite passions into a romance. Say less. This book was interesting to say the least. I’m going to give a lengthy review. Which may or may not reflect the rating I give. First off this book labels is it as what I thought was a hockey setting. Yes it takes place in regency time but the man plays hockey. He’s a famous NHL player in this book. Yet hockey honestly could have been left out. Tucker hasn’t played hockey in a hot minute at the start of the book. Due to a sickness so it’s just him reminiscing about playing. There’s one scene he actually plays so at least we got that. Lizzie or Elizabeth is from 1812 who stumbles upon Tucker after his accident. She is a head strong female who’s definitely ahead of her time. This book does not do the time gap well. The 1812 and 2020’s era justice. It’s very much mixed in and not in the best way either. Before diving in you should know Lizzie is not Elizabeth Bennet. That’s not her role honestly. Her best friend is Jane Austen yes the writer. Who you will see mentioned throughout and hear talk of her writing the books. Other things to expect heavy usage of historical means. I mean explaining bathrooms, apothecaries, technology, tampons and everything in between. Which I liked but it got redundant after a while. The book is heavy on feminism and female roles. Lizzie is not like other ladies of her time. Shocking I know lol. Not saying this is bad but those topics were really driven in this book. The time travel aspect is honestly odd. You find out towards the end how it worked but it’s almost abrupt. It truly comes out of no where and didn’t flow with the story at all. It’s like the author was in a hurry to end the book. This is an arranged marriage romance. Things you can expect tension, enemies to friends to lovers, one bed, teaching moments, and if you like Bridgerton. A scene similar to Colin and Pen’s mirror scene. All in all it was alright. It took me a lot longer to finish than I anticipated. It wasn’t gripping like I expected and honestly made me cringe. The ending I hated. It was the most unrealistic and odd ending. Go into this with no expectations and you should be golden.
In my youth, I was a Jane Austen purist. I still tend that way now, enough so that there were elements of this book that made me cringe, mostly mangled attempts at rephrasing some of Austen's more famous lines into passing comments that we're meant to believe she polished up and stuck in her work. But beyond that and the name "Wooddash" (for Dashwood, the last name of the family in Sense and Sensibility), I'm glad that I've changed, because that meant that I could enjoy the pure silliness of this book.
The premise is just what the title implies: a pro hockey player falls through time and ends up in 1812, where he encounters Jane Austen. More importantly, he also meets her friend Lizzy Wooddash, and that's who he falls in love with. There are plenty of tropes here, most notably the marriage of convenience and only one bed, but that largely just enhances the silly fun of the book. It knows it's fluff, and that's just fine. Tucker was a bit unbelieveable to be with how little he appeared to know about literature and history, but plots must, you know.
Most of all, I really appreciated the ending. Romance authors have been catching on to the reality that a happy ending doesn't look the same to everyone, and Riley gives Lizzy and Tucker an HEA that works for who they are and what they want. It's about compromise and happiness, and I really admire that.
On the whole, don't go into this expecting anything other than a nice, fluffy, silly, sweet book. It absolutely delivers on those fronts, and at the end of the day, that's more than enough.
Puck and Prejudice by Lia Riley has a hockey player, romance, time travel, and a little Jane Austen all in a fun suspending-belief book that I went into with trepedition, but was surprised at how fun it was.
When recovering hockey goalie, Tucker, swerves to avoid hitting a child he plunges into a frozen pond and just when he thinks he is going to drown, he wakes up in the same spot a few hundred years in the past. Lizzy is spending time in the country with her widowed cousin, avoiding her mother's persistently more pleas that she return to the city and get married. Lizzy finds a confused Tuck and their relationship begins.
Lizzy's friendship with Jane Austen is fun and the way that Austen's quotes and story points are interwoven make it very tongue in cheek, even though she has a minor role in the story.
I enjoyed how Tuck and Lizzy's relationship unfolded, but I do wonder why the author didn't have Lizzy - who was incredibly intelligent and forward thinking - not be super curious about the future.
If you're looking for something different, this could be the book for you. It was definitely worth a read.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this book. All opinons are my own.
2.5
I was ready for this to be cute, if not overly stimulating, but...
In no particular order: Everyone accepts time travel extremely easily, which is weird. Jane Austin is an ancillary character with fewer than a dozen lines.
Neither timeline contains people who behave remotely like people in those timelines.
There's a Lizzy with no Darcy (or darcyesqe person with whom she can have something like tension), so the title is misleading at best.
Time travel, hockey, romance, historical elements all put together. I never thought I would see this type of book but here it is AND it works!
It is quite a tame book compared to other hockey romances so it is refreshing. Although the plot sounds so crazy that it makes you want to read it. That’s a great thing!
Thank you to NetGalley and the Avon and Harper voyage for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. Jane Austen isn’t the love interest here but she is a plot point and involved which makes this a unique book too.
This book is in 3rd POV and I prefer more of a dual POV but nonetheless it was enjoyable!-
Sometimes romances are just fun. This is a great example of a novel idea (time-traveling hockey player meets Jane Austen, somewhat literally). While Jane Austen is not the love interest, she is integral to the plot. I really enjoyed so much of this, from the personality of our goalie protagonist to the Pygmalion-esque undertones of teaching him how to live Regency-style. The ending was predictable, but satisfying. This is a great summer read and I will recommend it to anyone seeking out a light-hearted romance with just a little bit of angst.
Tucker Taylor is a professional hockey player visiting his sister in England, a sister who is studying (and obsessed with) Jane Austen and other Regency-era authors. He has been through a lot through the last year after finding a lump and being diagnosed with Non-Hodgkins Lymphoma, and then when he is visiting his sister, he skids in the car to avoid a child and lands in an iced-over pond. All things look bleak for Tucker until he climbs out of the pond to find himself in 1812 and face-to-face with one of Austen’s friends, Lizzie.
Are they trying to rope me in on purpose? Jane Austen, hockey, and time travel? I was always going to read this book; the Venn Diagram of my interests insisted upon it. Yes, the premise is ridiculous, but it’s pretty much Outlander’s premise. Yes, it begins with fan-girl Austen banter that is fairly cringy. BUT, I really enjoyed it. I read it in almost a sitting - and would read more if they were handed to me. Lizzie is a cute character, and Tucker is a fun and solid MMC and the two have great chemistry. The entirety of the Regency-era plot was solid, although her family’s villain-eque status was pretty hyperbolic. The end had a fun twist that I didn’t see coming, and it was fairly spicy. I definitely enjoyed this book - whoever came up with this idea needs a raise.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC.
I thought that this was a good romance book. A little tame for my liking, but not bad overall. I thought the time travel aspect was very interesting and added an umph.
Tucker Taylor is a modern-day hockey player who suddenly finds himself transported back to the year 1812. There, he ends up in a marriage of convenience with Lizzy, a Regency-era woman who becomes his ally and is aware that he’s from the future. It’s a wild and imaginative premise, and the author executed it brilliantly.
The contrast between Tuck’s 21st-century knowledge and Lizzy’s 19th-century world leads to plenty of amusing and entertaining moments as he tries to explain his futuristic ideas to her. Their romance develops wonderfully, and I was pleasantly surprised by the level of spice in their relationship. The story also includes delightful nods to Jane Austen, adding another layer of charm to an already intriguing concept.
While I generally enjoyed the book, I would have preferred it to be written in a dual first-person perspective rather than third-person. This is just a personal preference and doesn’t detract from the story's quality. The ending was satisfying and felt like the author skillfully balanced elements from both worlds.
Overall, this book was a unique and enjoyable read. It’s a refreshing blend of time travel, romance, and Regency-era charm that kept me entertained from start to finish.
Many thanks to NetGalley, Lia Riley, and Avon for providing me with an eARC of this book.
This was actually really good! I was a little hesitant about this book, because of it being a mix of a historical romance with a modern day hockey player. Sounds outlandish, right? I wasn't sure how the author would pull it off but it was honestly well done and I enjoyed it. Tucker Taylor is a hockey player who finds himself back in 1812... and has to enter into a marriage of convenience with Lizzy, who is a Regency era woman that befriends him and knows he's from the future. It's a wild concept but I thought the author did a fantastic job with it, especially since Tuck is from the future and has to explain things to Lizzy, and much fun and hilarity ensues. Their romance was great, and there was plenty of spice which I was pleasantly surprised by. I truly enjoyed the Jane Austen aspect of it! That was a really cool addition weaved into an already cool concept of a book. My only critique was that the book was in third person POV and I really would have loved to have a dual first person POV, but this is a personal preference of mine and doesn't take away from the book. I also really liked how it ended and felt like the author gave us the best of both worlds. Overall, I had a really good time reading this different and unique book!
Thank you to NetGalley, Lia Riley, and Avon for the eARC of this book.
This was an enjoyable story. The characters, Lizzy and Tuck, had a lot of chemistry. My only issue with the story was that Lizzy never seemed interested in what was happening in the future. I would be asking so many questions!
An enjoyable romantic comedy! I liked the banter between the two main characters. The time travel plot gave us a nice mix of modern and historical.
A unique combo of time travel, histrom, and hockey (!) that Austen lovers will adore. I have never read a book quite like this before, and while I'm not typically a hockey fan, I am a Janeite through and through. More, Lia Riley! More!
This is a delightful book! It is both modern and historical. I had never read the author before, but will definitely be reading more of her books in the future.
As a hockey romance, I could tell that author had actually watched the game before and wasn’t just jumping in a contemporary bandwagon. As a true hockey fan, I appreciated that.
What I may have enjoyed most was the completely original plot. It was time travel done well. I would highly recommend this book to others.
Time travel. Hockey romance. Marriage of convenience. Forced proximity. This is not a combination that I ever thought I would see, so I knew I had to get my hands on this book as soon as I saw the description. This book brought together four of my favorite tropes and managed to do it quite well. This was a very fun book and honestly I was not expecting to like it as much as I did. It managed to balance a good plot and not focus solely on the romance (although there was plenty of that and quite some spice with it). I was often laughing out loud as Lizzy and Tucker stumbled through England, the time differences, and their relationship. This book was not perfect, but it was extremely enjoyable.
Thank you to NetGalley and Avon and Harper Voyager for the advanced copy!
What a cute romcom. I loved it so much. It was both sweet and humorous. Don’t miss this book. Five stars!