I was a huge fan of the Moose Springs series so I was pumped to receive an ARC. WOW. What an emotional gut punch. This has a very different vibe than Moose Springs but still delivers on banter, chemistry, and wonderful, complex characters.

For my first Christmas read this season I did not expect such an emotional story but Sarah Morgenthaler has crafted a story of tragedy, hope, redemption and a little magic in The Christmas You Found Me. Sienna, newly divorced, is struggling running her ranch alone when her friend plays a trick on her and advertises a husband for hire. Never expecting a response, she's shocked when her friend tells her a single dad has responded. The catch: he needs insurance for his daughter's kidney transplant in order for the hospital to approve the transplant. Sienna, worn down from her divorce and her father's failing memory, she feels motivated to help Guy and his sweet daughter Emma. Not bargaining for actual feelings, Sienna and Guy find themselves pulled towards each other. As Emma's health fails, they are in a race against time this holiday season. Told with warmth, decent character development and pacing, The Christmas You Found Me is an emotionally charged holiday novel that her readers will enjoy.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for my honest feedback.

4.25 (points deducted for absurd geography)

I don’t think I’ve ever read such a sad story and, as a fan of the Moose Springs, Alaska series, I was in no way prepared for this book.

I dove in, reading the trigger warnings at the beginning, but really just frustrated with the absurd geography that is laid out (see below).

Putting that aside, this is a beautiful story, but it is full with layers upon layers of hardship and loss right up to the end. I’m not saying that there isn’t some good news or happiness along the way or at the end, but the struggle with Emma and her failing kidney is its own main character and it is layered with the man who is broken and trying to keep her alive, the woman who is also facing several kinds of loss, and the other animals and people they love who have been hit hard. I know I’m a cryer, but this was a new level of tears. If this book doesn’t make you cry, we might need to put you on the transplant list for a new heart.

At one point, I tried to explain a couple scenarios to my mother who thought I must have a really bad cold due to my sniffles, but she soon asked me to stop telling her any more about the book because it was just too sad. I hate to be such a downer because this is a sweet story with a sweet romance for two people who deserve it, but just be prepared. I gave it the rating I did because it’s a good story, just not the rom-com that the cover, title, and author might imply.

That’s all I can say without any spoilers. After the book, the authors note indicates that Sara Morganthaler lost her husband in a motorcycle accident soon after the Moose Springs books. That explains some of the change in the feel of this story, but I can’t imagine writing such a fraught story with that real tragedy weighing on me. You don’t have to have a history with any of the triggers mentioned to feel deeply for the struggles of the characters.

FYI: The story supposedly takes place in northern Idaho. Emma‘s doctors are “two hours away” in Idaho Falls, one of the furthest cities in actual geography, probably more like a ten hour drive to the southeast part of the state, depending on how far north you start. The location of the story takes place next to the Frank Church – River of No Return Wilderness, which is in the center of the state. You would think someone would take a look at a map and at least attempt something plausible. It makes me wonder how naïve I may have been with the Alaska stories and any book somewhere unfamiliar.


Thank you to Sarah Morgenthaler, NetGalley, and Berkeley Publishing Group for providing me with a free advanced copy of this book in exchange for my unbiased review.

When newly divorced Sienna meets Guy, a single father with a four-year-old daughter in kidney failure, she learns that little Emma may lose her place on the transplant list because of insurance complications. Enter: marriage of convenience. Sienna and Guy get married so Emma can have insurance and keep her spot on the list.

This book deals with some heavy emotional situations, but they are all handled so well and balanced with very sweet moments in between. And I really liked seeing Sienna be strong and independence, taking care of her own cattle and land.

I'm very happy to see Sarah Morgenthaler picking up her writing again, and am hopeful to see more!

Romance: fade to black

On the one year anniversary of her divorce, Sienna’s friend jokingly puts an ad in the paper looking for a husband. Guy, a desperate man looking for a miracle (and health insurance) for his very ill 4-year-old daughter responds. Despite not actually wanting a husband, Sienna agrees to marry Guy to help Emma. It isn’t long before the love grows among this fake family.
If you’ve been here for a while you probably know I don’t ever read a synopsis. I quite literally judge a book by its cover and that’s how I decide what to read every single time. This book shows that I have not learned my lesson because I was not prepared for the emotional journey this book took me on, especially that last 25%.
This book was incredible. Truly such a beautiful story of an unlikely family who found each other and created the most incredible bond with the magic of the holidays to back it up. There were some very heavy undertones throughout the book making this different from the lighthearted holiday reads I typically gravitate toward. Although I was ugly crying while reading, I did end this story with a warm heart and it has stuck with me since I put it down.
I listened to the audiobook and it truly captivated me. I finished the book in one day while decorating my library because I was so engrossed in the story I didn’t want to stop. Haley Taylor did a phenomenal job with the narration.
Thank you to Sourcebooks Casablanca, Dreamscape Media, and NetGalley for the advance copies.

Sienna and Guy meet in the most unconventional way. Fresh off of her divorce, as in, the same day it's finalized, Sienna's friend Jess jokingly publishes an ad for a husband for hire in the local paper. Desperate to do what he can for his daughter, Emma, who's in kidney failure, Guy answers. In an awkward meeting at a coffee shop, Sienna's compassion takes over and before the day is through, she finds herself with a fiance, and two new roomates.

I've loved all of Sarah Morganthaler's books, and The Christmas You Found Me is no exception. It's heavier, a little more complicated, it has grief and loss, but ultimately ends on a hopeful note. The fear and frustration of raising a child who's not like the others is accurately and gently handled. Emma is absolutely adorable, Sienna embracing her and adapting to her needs made my heart ache in the best way. Guy is the most devoted of dads, he's what you would hope every child gets to experience. Don't let the heavier elements of the book scare you away, there is definitely humor and laughter and shiny moments that fill your hear.

I’ve read and enjoyed several of Sarah Morgenthaler’s books. The Christmas You Found Me is by far my favourite of hers so far. Her characters were dynamic and there was substance and depth to the story that I haven’t seen in her other books. This was a joy to read.
Thank you NetGalley for providing me with a digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Just a truly beautiful and lovely book. A perfect Christmas time read and you'll fall in love with Guy and Sienna.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Christmas You Found Me by Sarah Morgenthaler is an emotional triumph that completely stole my heart!! Having devoured all of Sarah’s previous works, I can confidently say this is her finest story yet. It’s clear that she poured her own experiences of heartache, healing, and growth into every page, resulting in a story that is raw, poignant, and intensely real!

The story of Guy Maple, a devoted single father desperate to save his precious daughter, and Sienna Naples, a woman craving connection during a lonely holiday season, is as compelling as it is tender. Guy’s determination to secure Emma’s future, despite impossible odds, is truly moving, and Sienna’s warmth and resilience bring a sense of hope that lights up their shared journey! The slow-burn romance between Guy and Sienna is beautifully crafted; each moment is imbued with subtlety and authenticity, making their love story feel natural and deeply affecting!

Morgenthaler’s ability to create a small-town setting filled with holiday magic, quirky animals, and unforgettable characters elevates this story to something extraordinary. Each character, from Guy and Sienna to Emma and the endearing townspeople, is vibrant and memorable, leaving an imprint long after the last page is turned, and familiar enough I will want to come back to this book again and again!

This story made me laugh, cry (more than once!), and root for this newfound family with every fiber of my being!! It’s an honest, heartfelt story that reminds readers of the power of love, sacrifice, and the joy of finding a place—and people—to call home. For those looking for a romance rich in emotion and full of holiday spirit, The Christmas You Found Me is an absolute must-read, I can't recommend it enough!

Sarah Morgenthaler has truly outdone herself!!

This is my first book from this author although I have some of her others on my TBR! Typical! I really enjoyed it and found it quite easy to get into Sarah’s writing. It is an emotionally charged read despite being a bit insta-feelings at times but it’s a good story that will tug your heartstrings. Probably for fans of Sarah Morgan and maybe fans of Elsie Silver.

The Christmas You Found Me is such a heartwarming, emotional and beautiful Christmas romance. While it did break my heart multiple times, it also brought on so much hope and left me smiling. The author truly has a way with words and how she crafted this story to make it absolutely unforgettable. From the start I fell in love with the characters, the setting and the plot of the story.

The characters are absolutely beautiful. They have the biggest hearts, the best of intentions, are so caring towards one another and are honestly the epitome of what a family is, blood or no blood. The lengths each of them went through was absolutely gut wrenching, the moments between father and daughter, step mother and step daughter absolutely warmed my heart. Add on all the Christmas love and cheer, it just made for a wonderful read.

This is in no way an easy book to read as there are some very emotional moments, but it is highly rewarding in the end. The whole message of the book, the storyline is absolutely beautiful. Morgenthaler is a masterful storyteller and I am definitely on the lookout for more from this author.

✨️Thank you to @netgalley, @dreamscapemedia & @sarahmorgenthaler for my gifted ARC & ALC in exchange for an honest review.

This is the first book I have read by Sarah Morgenthaler, and it has made me want to read everything she's ever written!.
A truly beautiful story full of characters you can't help but love, and a storyline that had me completely invested to the very end.
A fabulous festive read!

Sarah Morgenthaler is back and I could cry from excitement. When I saw she was back and writing again after some much needed time away, I legit screamed at my phone from happiness. I absolutely adore her previous books and just knew she would come back stronger than ever.

This story was seriously so incredible. Sarah has this incredible ability to mesh heavy and sensitive topics with beautiful romance. Her characters are amazing and you are rooting for them the entire story. This absolutely made me cry too. I’ve been thinking about this book nonstop since finishing it and I just want to scream into the void that everyone needs to pick this book up.

I’m unbelievably excited that Sarah is back and this was a stunner of a book to announce her return. I don’t know Sarah personally, but I am so so so incredibly proud of her and adore her with my entire heart. Thank you for writing the stories you do.

This was a just a great read. I was just all in the story.
Loved the MCs. Lovely written book. i enjoyed more than I expected I would

A fair warning if you've never read Sarah's books, they will make you want to pack up and move somewhere cold. Even if you live in NC and would never make through a rural Idaho winter. :)

I've been waiting a long time to read Sarah's next book, and I was still not prepared. If you're a fellow fan of Moose Springs, you'll feel right at home with Sarah's sweet storytelling, loveable characters, and gorgeous settings. But this book had a heartfelt depth to it beyond any of her others. I hate that her own grief is what gives her the ability to write complex feelings and heartbreak so well, but this book moved me to tears on multiple occasions. What a beautiful tribute to deep and enduring love through all the hard things of life.

The deep friendships of this book, particularly between Jess and Sienna, are so lovely. And also, so delightfully silly. Everyone needs a Jess in their life.

My only complaint (and it is a big one), is that I'd really like Sarah to figure out what it would take for Ulysses to wander on down to Idaho. I love all of these new animals on the ranch, but... doesn't every ranch need a moose? Just think about it, Sarah!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC in exchange for my honest opinions!

Sarah Morgenthaler returns with The Christmas You Found Me, a new romance that tugged at my heartstrings, trying its best to break me down into uncontrollable sobbing. But fear not, while it packed an emotional punch, it also left me hopeful and smiling.

The Christmas You Found Me is a holiday romance set in a small town in beautiful Idaho. With her divorce finally official, Sienna is trying her best to move on, focusing on her ranch and animals instead of her past. When her best friend Jess decides to annoy Sienna’s ex by putting up flyers around town advertising ‘Husband for Hire’, Sienna is surprised when an applicant finds her at the local coffee shop. Guy is new in town, unaware that the ad is a joke, and desperate to find work to pay for his very sick daughter’s medical treatment.

Sienna can’t stop thinking about the desperation in Guy’s eyes, especially after she meets Emma, his adorable four year old daughter with late-stage kidney disease. Sienna comes up with an even better plan: marrying Guy so Emma can be covered under her insurance.

This one has a great cast of characters, from Sienna, Guy, and Emma, to Jess, and even Micah, Sienna’s ex. There was plenty to keep me reading, as well, from the marriage of convenience shenanigans, to Emma’s illness, to the holiday festivities, and even to the drama with Micah. I could tell this was the start of a new series for Morgenthaler, and I’m eager to see which side character will be the focus of the next book.

Guy’s love for his daughter is so big, and when it eventually includes Sienna, it’s the sweetest thing. He’s strong, but also a gooey cinnamon roll of a man.

And Emma is adorable. Sometimes when children are portrayed in romance novels, they can come across as cheesy, but Emma is her own character, personable and unique.

I also enjoyed the small-town setting, the long history of Sienna’s family home, as well as her history with her ex complicating her future.

While The Christmas You Found Me IS festive, it isn’t overly saturated with Christmas, so it would be fine to read any time of the year, as well. Heartwarming and emotional, The Christmas You Found Me deserves a spot on your TBR!

I read my first holiday novel of the year and loved it. The Christmas You Found Me by Sarah Morgenthaler came out in September and is the perfect emotional, feel good story leading up to the Christmas season. This one is closed door and is so cute. Marriage of *purpose* and single father with a child suffering from kidney failure. There are a lot of funny moments and a few moments that gutted me and made me cry. You'll fall in love with Gus and will be rooting for little Emma.

I have been patiently waiting for a new release from Sarah, as I loved her Moose Springs Alaska series. I am so happy she is back and can't wait to read more by her.

Fresh off her bitter divorce, Sienna's bestie puts an ad in their small-town newspaper for "Husband-for-Hire." What starts as a joke turns into an adventure you wouldn't expect. Sienna meets Guy in the coffee shop and while he's handsome and kind, and willing to help her on her cattle farm, she can not jump into another marriage. That is until she meets Guy's daughter, Emma, who is in Stage-five chronic kidney disease. Emma needs a transplant but without proof of being able to afford Emma's anti-rejection meds, she can't stay on the transplant list. What begins as a marriage of convenience turns into such a sweet relationship with Emma at the center. Get some tissues for this one!

There are so many things I loved about this book. This is Sarah Morgenthaler's first release after the horrible accident that claimed her husband's life. To be able to write such a heartwarming story after such a tragedy made me love this book (and the author) even more!

Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Casablanca for an advanced digital copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

THE CHRISTMAS YOU FOUND ME is an absolutely heart-wrenching but wonderful holiday romance about sienna naples, a recently-divorced cattle rancher whose best friend puts out a "husband for hire" ad for her as a joke to celebrate her divorce being finalized. but when guy maple, a single dad caring for his four year old with chronic kidney disease, shows up to answer the ad, sienna agrees to marry him to help emma get the kidney transfer she needs. after all, it's just a marriage of convenience and they won't fall in love, right?

this was such a beautiful story about love, family, and second chances. while this story does deal with some heavy subjects (and is one of the rare few books to have made me cry!!), it was so incredibly heartwarming and it really got me in the holiday spirit (in october, no less). this is my first book by morgenthaler, but i will definitely be checking out more of her books.

read if you like:
- cattle rancher fmc
- single dad mmc
- marriage of convenience

thanks to netgalley and sourcebooks casablanca for the advanced copy!

The Christmas You Found Me is Sarah Morgenthaler’s sweet Christmas romance about family. The story takes place in a small town in Idaho where everyone interferes in others’ business and involves a marriage of convenience for health insurance reasons. The Christmas You Found Me should be made into a Hallmark movie.
Sienna Naples's family has owned a ranch in Idaho for generations, and she assumed responsibility after her parents died. On the day that her divorce became final, Sienna’s best friend published a “Husband Wanted” ad in the town’s newspaper as a joke. Then a handsome stranger approached Sienna about the ad, wanting to have a mutually beneficial arrangement.
Guy Maple is a construction worker from Montana, and a single father to a very sick four-year-old daughter. Emma has stage-five chronic kidney disease and needs a kidney transplant. Unfortunately, Emma can’t stay on the transplant list unless Guy can prove that he can afford the anti-rejection medications. He needs better health insurance and a higher income in order to prolong his precious daughter’s life.
Of course, lonely Sienna agrees to marry handsome Guy in order to save adorable little Emma. They quickly bond as a family and Sienna falls in love with the perfect Guy. The reader waits anxiously for Emma’s health crisis to be resolved in time for Christmas.
The Christmas You Found Me is a well-written holiday romance perfect for fans of Hallmark movies. While I personally prefer more realistic stories, I found the characters to be very engaging and was drawn into the story.
I received an advance review copy (ARC) from the NetGalley and SourceBooks Casablanca for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.