Member Reviews

as a vigilante known as the truthsayer raises an army against the wardens, sylah and hassa search for anoor…who’s currently being praised as the child of fire.

i still can’t believe this trilogy is over! i’ve been lucky enough to have received each book early, so i’ve been following this series since before book one came out. needless to say, i had high hopes for this book. i’m so glad that this exceeded my expectations! i really enjoyed how each character’s arc played out. the plot was also very interesting, and the author used the 500+ pages well.

i highly recommend this to anyone who’s enjoyed the previous books in this series, and i’m looking forward to more from saara el-arifi.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars. I have very mixed feelings about this book, I will admit. I think El-Arifi has written a really interesting world, with a complex and intriguing magic system and some really fascinating societies and peoples. Her strength is absolutely in creating these worlds and systems; there is a good amount of depth in them that keeps ones' attention on the page. I really loved the introduction and exploration of the ship-based nation, how they govern, and what their priorities and values are. I thought our time with them was really cool. I also really liked the parts of the book where we saw these different factions coming together to align against the Zalaam. The reveal of the Truthsayer made me punch the air in excitement; I was thrilled with that development. On the darker side, I thought the time we spent with the Zalaam was also incredibly complex and interesting, showing this cult-like society and how they function, how the leaders maintain control, and how they were able to push people to do horrible things in the name of their god. I thought the way that El-Arifi explored how a cult/religion can manipulate vulnerable people was incredibly well-done.

Unfortunately, other elements of this book didn't work for me. First, it felt way too rushed. There were major developments that would happen in the span of a paragraph or two, maybe a few pages if we were lucky. This didn't heighten the tension for me; it just deflated the emotional impact of those developments. There was an introduction of a character connected to a main character, and I suspect I was meant to care about this new character, or be excited to see them, but it really felt like it came out of nowhere and then the character didn't really... do... anything the rest of the book, or even really impact the main character they were connected to. While I think El-Arifi has an incredible strength for worldbuilding, there was one major place where it felt completely flat for me: <spoiler>upon overthrowing the empire, all these different factions that aligned just... agree to representative democracy? with no arguments? with no concerns? despite none of them having a representative democracy already? and based only on a report back from Hassa that this one city is trying it and it seems to be going okay after a month? I'm sorry, but that strained the bounds of reality for me. The book was about the overthrow of the empire and the destruction of the Zalaam threat, so I understand why figuring out the next form of government wasn't the focus, but I would rather it not have been really explored at all rather than everyone apparently being fine with a form of government that they have no experience in and have no reason to all agree to. The mention of a truth and reconciliation kind of council at the end also felt like a strain on credulity. That they might introduce it, sure, but with no push back from anyone at all? Honestly, this felt like a vision of politics in the real world that basically goes "once we have the revolution, everything else will fall in line!" and that just isn't realistic and it completely pulled me out of the story</spoiler>. The deprogramming was also extremely disappointing to me. I was excited to see how the author would explore one of their main characters being radicalized and committing these heinous acts, and then what the process would look like to bring them back from that and the time it would take and the effort, and then the understanding of these heinous acts and how to repent from those acts - but the deprogramming literally happened in the course of three paragraphs. It was very, very upsetting to see such an amazing thread of story just get dropped so quickly. The approach to the work of repentance was also very underdeveloped and not really explored.

As for the characters - Hassa was and is amazing, and is probably the strongest, most interesting character in this entire trilogy. I would read these books again just for Hassa. Seeing her growth in this book, and the book finally giving her more of a focus, was deeply refreshing. Her character arc was also incredibly different than all the other main characters in a major sense, which was that while Kwame was certainly an impact on her, Kwame did not drive her and was not her sole purpose (see my issues with other characters below). I would love to return to this world and to Hassa at some point, to see what happens next. El-Arifi did what I thought was impossible and made me actually enjoy Jond in this book. After the first two books, I didn't think it was possible, but I found myself enjoying his chapters, in part because I really liked Kara and in part because he was doing a lot of work to build alliances, and I thought it was really interesting. I didn't particularly care for his romantic storyline, but I think that's just because I thought it was taking up way too much time in his sections. Anoor's chapters were often really interesting because of the look at the Zalaam, their society, and their leadership. I didn't get frustrated with Anoor as often as other readers because I really liked what El-Arifi was doing to explore abusive religions and how they manipulate vulnerable people. Sylah, though. Oh, Sylah. She was such a disappointment to me. For a while I was thinking the author was doing an exploration of how, when you're raised for a specific purpose and that purpose disappears, it can create a void that you desperately try to fill, and how Sylah was trying to fill her void with Anoor, but that was still not going to be enough because Sylah needed to live for Sylah, not Anoor. And maybe that was something the author thought she was doing? But to me, Sylah just because this pathetic character who only cared about one person for most of the book and served next to no purpose. Her chapters were boring, bluntly. There is only so much sighing and pining I can read, chapter after chapter, in a non-romantasy book (and, notably, I don't read romantasy's because I don't find them as interesting). The ending for the characters also felt very underwhelming for me. The book was just moving too fast and didn't give me time to feel any of the emotional impact of what was happening.

Overall, I think El-Arifi is a strong author who spent too much time on this book writing her weaknesses (insta-love romance that takes too much focus) rather than on her strengths (interesting individual characters and deep worldbuilding). Knowing that El-Arifi began writing/publishing a romantasy series while this was still wrapping up makes me wonder if there were publishing pressures on her to dive more into the romance aspects of this book, since romantasy's are hot in publishing right now, or if she just really wanted to be writing more romantasy right now than this series originally began as. While the relationship between Anoor and Sylah was always a key component to the series, I felt that they began with more depth than they ended with, and it was disappointing to see. I still think this is a solid series, despite my disappointments; I would just recommend this more to a romantasy reader or someone less familiar with the fantasy genre than I am. The world, the magic, and Hassa make this series worth reading.

Was this review helpful?

The Ending Fire by Saara El-Arifi - ebook ARC by NetGalley

In The Ending Fire, Saara El-Arifi delivers a gripping conclusion to her epic trilogy, bringing readers back into a world teetering on the brink of destruction. The story's rich character development is a standout, with each character's flaws playing a crucial role in their personal journeys and the larger narrative. As the story builds toward an epic battle, El-Arifi masterfully shifts between multiple points of view, allowing readers to fully immerse themselves in the tension and stakes of the conflict.

Unexpected plot twists are a hallmark of El-Arifi's writing, and The Ending Fire does not disappoint in this regard. These twists keep readers on their toes, adding layers of complexity to the unfolding rebellion and the characters' intertwined fates.

The theme of rebellion and uprising is powerfully conveyed, resonating deeply with current global events and making the narrative feel particularly relevant. El-Arifi handles this theme with nuance, exploring the moral ambiguities and sacrifices that come with fighting for change.

The relationships in the novel are marked by intense angst, adding an emotional depth that enhances the stakes of the story. These dynamics, set against the backdrop of a vividly imagined world, create an immersive reading experience that is difficult to leave behind.

However, while the ending wraps up the major plotlines, it feels somewhat abrupt, leaving readers yearning for a smoother transition or a more extended resolution. Despite this, The Ending Fire remains a compelling and satisfying conclusion to the series, showcasing Saara El-Arifi's talent for creating a richly detailed world filled with complex characters and thought-provoking themes.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for sending an arc of The Ending Fire in exchange for an honest review!
What a finale to an amazing trilogy!
I was nervous going into this book because The Battle Drum was...a lot lol. So many new places, cultures, and characters were introduced that I got a little lost. This may have been because I listened to the audiobook...it probably would've been better to read it.
I've seen several people say the author rushed the ending, but I didn't think that at all. I felt like she really took her time with the characters and the planning to lead up to the final showdown. I appreciate that we got a few one off pov's from side characters during the battle (even Rascal 🥹).
Usually I like when books are wrapped up pretty nice and neat, but this wasn't the case with The Ending Fire. There were some open-ended stories and things that could be left up to interpretation, but it was done in a way that was perfect for the story. You get the sense of their lives continuing on to more adventures and challenges, but not in a cliff-hanger way.
All in all I really enjoyed this world and I can't wait to read more from this author ❤️.

Was this review helpful?

Saara El-Arifi is my queen and I will read anything they write. This was a fantastic end to the series.

Was this review helpful?

First, this cover is amazing, powerful and gorgeous, and I can't wait to have a physical copy in my collection. That being said, I really enjoyed The Ending Fire. The story continues as they say, and this book evenly matched the mood and standard of the previous books. I love how Saara Wl-Arifi builds worlds in her books, and this book is no exception. The characters and character development in this individual book was well done and, in the context of the whole series, beyond phenomenal. I would definitely recommend this book to other readers.

Was this review helpful?

I still can't believe this is El-Arifi's debut trilogy - she's just incredible!! I'm so excited to see this author's career thrive, and with a book like this to cap off her first trilogy, the future is looking good.
Incredible use of multiple POVs, a masterful layering of details to round out the series, and overall just an epic conclusion to this world!

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley and am voluntarily posting a review. All opinions are my own.
While I was disappointed with Saara El-Arifi’s pivot away from this trilogy with Faebound, I was still hyped for The Ending Fire, and I’m happy to say it did not disappoint. While I did wish there had been a comprehensive “Recalling the Events of the Series So Far,” instead of simply a creatively incorporated recap of the prior book to introduce this one, this is in keeping with how the prior one started as well, and it still makes for a solid scene-setter to reacquaint the reader, without spoon-feeding them everything.
El-Arifi kicks things off from there, with a fast–paced, action-packed epic. While the book is long, it kept me engaged, with the high stakes challenges the characters faced coming to a head as the trilogy came to a close.
There’s a lot of POV characters in this book. The core POV characters that we’ve followed for the past two up to this one have grown as a result of their experiences, and I largely had no issues continuing to follow them. But in the last part of the book, there’s a lot of one-off POV characters, and while they contribute to the effect of exploring the climactic battle from different perspectives, I wasn’t as attached to them, so I found myself largely skimming those.
But minor issues aside, I’m glad this last installment provided worthy closure for the characters and story. Fans of the series so far won’t be disappointed, and I’d recommend the series overall to readers looking for epic African-inspired fantasy.

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5 Stars

This was so good, and a wonderful conclusion to what has been an amazing debut trilogy. The author has incredible world-building throughout all three books, and it is amazing the way she was able to go more in depth into the world with each book. The slow pacing works so well for these as it does a great job at building to the final battle.

There were so many characters and stories to tie together in this final installment, and the author did a wonderful job in bringing all the pieces together in a way that was so satisfying, I loved it.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Random House for the ARC of this book!

Was this review helpful?

OH … MY GODDDDDDDD this was an amazing conclusion to this series holy fuck. i absolutely loved all the POVs, how we saw all of the different groups come together. the world building continued to develop, and the recap at the beginning of the story was amazing to have. I think for two largely FMC anti-hero’s, the ending was done perfectly and was a great conclusion to this trilogy

Was this review helpful?

The story picks up immediately after The Battle Drum left off, following separate journeys of different characters. There is a brief recap at the beginning which was immensely helpful! After the cliffhanger of the last book, this one starts off with a slow build as characters regroup and share information. The story is never rushed, with excellent world building and character development. The multi-POV narrative captures the war from multiple angles, never shying away from the brutal and heartbreaking loss that comes from war.

There are many players in this conflict and each character's intentions are interwoven in a complex web. This novel explores the importance of the war versus the importance of the individual, a theme that permeates multiple character arcs throughout the story. The story also deals with the concepts of home and belonging. Overall, this final installment was an epic and a satisfying conclusion to the Ending Fire trilogy.

Was this review helpful?

Readers' Most Anticipated Fall Books

1Samantha Stone
My Books
Browse ▾
Community ▾

Samantha rated a book it was amazing
less than a minute ago
The Ending Fire by Saara El-Arifi
The Ending Fire (The Ending Fire Trilogy, #3)
by Saara El-Arifi (Goodreads Author)
Read
What an amazing conclusion to such a well thought out fantasy trilogy. Every book is equally as amazing, but the climax of this ending was both so emotional and edge of your sear riveting that I couldn't put it down for the last 15% (I mean I literally couldn't, I finished it on the clock at work lol!).

The choice of which character is on the covers of each book is also perfection. I don't know if it just came out coincidentally perfect, but it makes them even better. Our story feels like it mainly started with Sylah, featured on book one's cover. Anoor's story started to grow significantly in book two, plus the title has such a significance to her and the role she plays in the brewing war. And finally, one of my favorite characters to date, Hassa, who is shown on this cover. To end the series showing off the best character was obviously a good choice, but her part in the story also fit so perfectly with the title. This may be a silly thing to gush over but I love the series so much that this stood out to me too.

This series shines with it's characters and world building. Each character is so different and brings life to the story in their own vital ways. The world in The Ending Fire series is by far one of my favorites because it's so detailed, with so many different regions that get explored over the three books. We also get glimpses of the way the world was in the past, and it adds to the crazy amount of world building El-Arifi put in to the series.

The Ending Fire in particular was such a strong conclusion. We see how all the different POVs individual storylines all separated from where the story began, and in this finale, seeing how they all come back together is satisfying. We get multiple different religions, ways of life, environments, and variations of magic. It is incredibly mind boggling that someone could put so much into one trilogy so seamlessly.

Saara El-Arifi has, without a doubt, been solidified as an auto-buy author for me.

Was this review helpful?

Home is not the opposite of belonging. It's choosing where you belong.
I have loved every book I've read by Saara El-Arifi. She is an absolutely incredible writer and her world building and characters captivated me from chapter one of The Final Strife.

The Ending Fire was a little slow to start with but the pace picked up quickly. Anoor is being weaved in Yona's web- manipulated into someone she herself doesn't even recognize. From being sheltered in the keep for most of her life, she easily falls for it. The bitter teas does not help. El-Arifi does a great job touching on addiction throughout this whole series, even though once I realized once Yona was doing broke my heart.

Sylah is still clouded by her love for Anoor but I loved her development to think beyond herself and her heart. I feel proud of her and how far she has come.

Hassa's character development has to be my favorite. She is holding her head high finally.

I especially loved the added POV's in the last part of the book. My favorite being a little feline friend protecting her owner 🥹.

I (mostly) loved the ending of the book and series. I hate when books have a long ending that give readers a sort of forced closure of their characters. There was only one part that I wish I had closure on and find out what happens in their story but that's because I was rooting for them so much.

Overall, I absolutely loved this series. I tell everyone about it. I am so sad that it is over and cannot wait to read more of Saara El-Arifi's books. Thank you so much to Random House Publishing for this ARC (my first one ever!!!!) in exchange for a review.

Was this review helpful?

This was good and a worthy conclusion and I would have read it in one day if not for work, but I do think it might be my least favourite of the trilogy.

Was this review helpful?

The conclusion to the Ending Fire Trilogy picks up right where we left off in book two, with Anoor grappling with her newfound identity, Sylah hoping to reunite with Anoor, Jond recovering from his life choices and learning who he is without Sylah, and Hassa just trying to get by in the Warden Empire. With point of view chapters from all four characters, the world sprawls out farther than we've been before in new and interesting ways. We get to see more of the Zalaam's power, more territories on the mainland, and more ways people in the Warden Empire fight back against oppression.

In the biggest plot twist that I certainly didn't see coming, I found Jond's POV chapters to be the most interesting. I liked Kara's character and plot line and was excited to watch them interact as they traveled across more of the mainland to recruit allies for their part in the war. Hassa's chapters were also equally engaging, and I found even the early parts of her story to be redemptive and enjoyable--she certainly deserved much of what she got in this book after two books of being subjugated to awful treatment and experiences. At the end of this book, I felt like all of the loose ends got tied up and I felt mostly satisfied with where we'd be leaving the characters. There were a few character plot lines that I thought got tied up too tidily, and in the moral dilemma I always face, I wasn't so sure I found the casualty list to be that believable after a war of that scale. While the actual Ending Fire war takes place over the last 25% of the book, it felt much shorter than that and I felt like there was something missing from it that made it less tense and suspenseful. The closest I can put my finger is the shifting POV chapters--rather than focusing solely on the four main characters we've been reading for the earlier parts of the novel, El-Arifi adds a bunch more voices from side characters and even Rascal, the wild cat that Jond finds! I think I would have enjoyed more POV chapters from the main characters and more development of Anoor's final plot moments.

Overall I enjoyed this series immensely and look forward to reading anything else this author publishes in the future!

Was this review helpful?

4 stars.

This was a solid conclusion to the Ending Fire trilogy. Let's start with the good: the way things concluded in this novel were exciting, made sense, and were ultimately satisfying. That being said, I do kind of wish the ending had been a little less neat as there were some poignant moments that ultimately felt a little undermined. That mixed with how particularly Anoor's plot line developed just left this not as amazing as The Battle Drum. This is still a fantastic trilogy and I would highly recommend people give it a go. A unique blood-based magic system, tropes that get turned on their head, and the bonkers reveals (particularly in book 2) all made this one of the best new fantasy trilogies I have read in recent years.

Thank you to the publisher for providing me a review copy via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I have been so honored to be allowed to enter the world of this author & her surgical ability to dissect the wrongs in the world with this incredible trilogy. I have been blessed to continue walking the path of these characters on to the third book in perspectives I can really feel. IMO this book is a must read.
Set in a world of a rigidly structured caste system created by the least worthy of its inhabitants with a lie based on both birth & blood color. The very colonizers stole all of their science from the very people they persecuted, enslaved & mutilated. Cutting out the tongues & cutting off the hands of the Ghostlings of the clear blood at birth so they couldn't speak or work in their full capacity.
The griot are the storytellers that play the drum & give evidence of what has passed before them to now. It can get them murdered & has with so much truth the overseers don't like so told in riddles most times. Just enough to maybe live another day to teach.
8 different blood colors ran of the peoples in 8 boats that crossed the sea to then enslave the clear bloods for their land & knowledge. The Ember red & now rulers, the Duster blue now workers the only two of the boats that survived until a couple yellow bloods have surfaced. Yellows have their agendas in these stories both a king of criminals, Ananzi who came over accidentally & became a Crime warden or in control of all crimes and Yoni, his sister a warden of law her house. They are Zalaam, She who had come over the seas young to marry into the Embers & find the Child of Prophesy & Fire. Chosen is her granddaughter, but not by blood. Noor, of the blue blood, who was left in another childs place with a warden. The wardens child that by name became one of the Stolen, to be trained to fight the regime. The regime which in turn tried to track down the babies throughout their existence & murder them all. Now Yona has taken Noor off with the disciples group & their vile vials of blue duster marrow sucked from unwilling victims for the worst sort of blood magic. These are used for strongest magic to fight against the wardens & destroy them in war. Sylah, one of the Stolen reds came back in town trying to find her lover Noor of the Blue blood. Syla finds Hassa instead. The ghosting & lover to Sylahs fellow stolen Kwame & tells her all she knows including of Kwames fate of being ripped apart on the rack by wardens. Hassa is further crushed with the news. The Zaleem are bent on total destruction & others are trying to stop them from level of fanaticism & not be persecuted more.
This is the book of finalization of the trilogy. It isn't just tying ends together but of many new things & fleshing out characters & relationships, but it never ends. One end brings another beginning for something. The issue of a ruling caste abusing its power in this case the Embers of the red blood when multi bloods had fled their shores in search of freedom landing & learning from the Ghoslings of the clear blood then enslaving them into the lowest cast & silencing them by cutting out their tongues & keeping them from their own bloodwerk by cutting off their hands is a good example of societies downfall philosophies. So we need to look at the real goals behind the scenes.
It is a good modern multifaceted & encompassing smorgasbord for thought told in a tribal manner with and especially for peoples that can relate to the under hierarchies it shows & makes you feel. I'm not gonna spoilt it for you but say, it had things in it that even made me cry for people & animals alike then I'm getting on my high horse, or emu in this case. I feel emus only lose their dino torch to caraways that are the most dangerous, vicious birds in existence.
Politically you see it now, you saw it hard in 2015 but started when reagan got in & then went flying wild with bogus third parties literally being financed by gop hardliners like Nadar & Stein & even Bernie. The DSA [that I equate with the Zaleem with same goals], sounding altruistic while expecting to rule in the same heavy handed way as their original idols the Bolsheviks] has many decent ppl that are/were serious about social equality & change with a better society & social justice, but the talking head propagandists still shovel shit & have hard edged forced parameters. They're are still tone deaf elitists serving bad koolaid for the masses. Their mo literally came down to watching & aiding things getting more oppressed & worse for people as a whole to use that to make others rise up, using them as their fodder while so much was destroyed. Then they would put on their designer protest clothes to mouth off to authorities because at worse they would be arrested with daddies lawyers card in their back pocket so out before sun moved a turn. Luckily people were able to see clearer the next round but the losses were astronomical for Indigenous, Blacks, any other minority or religion other than mainstream.
The Bolsheviks with Lenin in lead stole & bastardized Marx teaching that were naive & easily used by wannabe dictators & the elite to throw off the monarchy to take its place. Hitler was tight with Stalin & took a lot of ideas of fascism from Russa for his own but flipped it to uber psycho racist dictatorship as did other countries grasped at nationalism at that time. He was the most well known Christofascist. All the little countries biggest legitimate fear was to be invaded by Russa except Germany, then they were afraid of Germany too.

Was this review helpful?

I am absolutely obsessed with the first two books in this series, so when I got an ARC for this one I was beyond excited! I reread the first two books in preparation for it and on second read they both were still incredible!

I will say that out of three in the series this is my least favorite, but it was still fantastic! It definitely had the epic, final, everything coming to a head, vibe that I was looking for and expecting going in.

I loved getting to see more of this incredible world that the author has created. She also did a fantastic job of answering all the questions that had been set up in previous books.

One of my favorite parts of this book was getting to see new sides to characters that we’ve been following for so long. As well as seeing new relationships develop which gave us so much new insight into the characters.

I was debating going between 4 and 5 stars for this book mainly because I felt that the last 3rd of the book felt very different from the first 2/3rds. It felt almost like a different book, but I can understand why the author chose to write it in that way. I decided to rate it 5 stars because overall it was exciting, incredibly captivating, and I couldn’t put it down.

I would 100% recommend that anyone who loves fantasy read this series. It has easily jumped into my top 3 favorite series and I just want everyone to read and enjoy it!

I received a a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and statements are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Such a satisfying ending (heh see what I did there😏) to this fantastic trilogy. It wrapped everything up so nicely and I even this Anoor redeemed herself in the end.

Jonds POV was actually a favourite for me in this book which surprised me but his character development was top notch. Also rascal is too cute!😫

As always Hassa has my heart as well and I will miss her!

The cover for this book is absolutely gorgeous and captures Hassa perfectly.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this trilogy, but I think the last book is my least favorite (4 stars vs 4.5/5). That said, I still really enjoyed myself and would reread this entire trilogy again!

The characters were my favorite part. They’re all complex and flawed and interesting. I grew to care about characters I used to hate (Jond) and started to get irritated by characters I used to adore (Anoor).

By the end I was rooting for the entire main cast and had a pit in my stomach because I was so stressed!!

I loved seeing how the different characters grew and changed through this trilogy, but something about this finale left me feeling… unfulfilled?

My biggest gripe is that in the last section of the book (the climax!!) we get a lot of one off POVs from side characters we met through the series… this was so frustrating to me. There’s SO much happening and we spend so many chapters away from our main cast!! I just kept going “okay please let’s get back to it.” I understand the utility of putting these POVs in and I feel like it did add to the story, but the way it’s executed is clunky… especially considering this isn’t how the rest of the trilogy was written!!

Overall I love this series. The worldbuilding was excellent and unique, the plot was entertaining, and the characters were brilliant. I’m not entirely satisfied by the ending, but sometimes that’s life!

Was this review helpful?