Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the opportunity to read this advance copy. I’ve really enjoyed the previous books in this series and admire Nina Prose’s writing. However, this installment didn’t quite work for me, as I found it too predictable. While I appreciate the familiar charm of the series, I was hoping for more surprises. That said, I’m sure other readers will still enjoy it, especially those who love comfort reads with a reliable formula.

Just when you thought Molly couldn't get any cozier! This was a warm, funny, and delightful read for the season. Treat yourself this holiday season to some time with your favorite maid.

I’m enjoying Anita Prose The Maid series! And when I saw a nice cozy Christmas mystery was coming I had to have it. I love Christmas mystery books and this one was a delight!

Very predictable and not in a fun way. You could see were it's going to end up from a mile away and it doesn't do a great job at building up to the "reveal"

Nita Prose's "Maid" series is a great, cozy, feel-good mystery that are a nice break from darker series. Her quirky characters and great story lines make them the perfect cozies, and "The Mistletoe Mystery" is a great addition.

I enjoy the "Maid" mysteries. This is a lighthearted Christmas novella that was an easy read.
Molly and Juan make such a sweet couple and the shadow of Gran is always in the background.
Looking forward to more from this author.

Bring the advent calendar out!

At least, this is what Molly, the maid, is doing with her boyfriend, Juan Manuel. She used to do the same with her granny. Molly’s life has come a long way. She’s happy in the present—a stark contrast to a few years ago when she lost her grandmother. She still remembers a Christmas at work when people made fun of her.

However, lately, something peculiar has been happening. Her boyfriend is acting strangely. He looks exhausted all the time, and it seems like he’s keeping secrets from her.

Does Molly have a new mystery to unravel?

For fans of the Molly the Maid series, this novella is a sweet treat. The mystery wraps up nicely, and Juan Manuel steals the show.

A cute little novella—perfect for the Christmas season!

Cliffhanger: No

4/5 Fangs

A complimentary copy was provided by Ballantine Books via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

The Mistletoe Mystery ~ Nita Prose (Molly the Maid #2.5)
Molly the maid has a new mystery to solve. While her beloved Juan Manuel is intent on making the season Holly's most joyful yet, Molly worries that his odd actions don't match his words. She has a bad feeling she has mistaken a frog for a prince. As they prepare the Regency Grand Hotel for the Secret Santa gift exchange Molly has questions about who she can and cannot trust and she dives in headfirst to solve her most personal mystery yet.
Another heartwarming tale of our maid Molly, dappled with memories and holiday traditions with her gran. A perfect cozy read while we patiently await the next installment

I love all that Nina Prose writes, and this one did not disappoint! This was a fun, Christmas cozy mystery that I would highly recommend!

The audio narrator was on point, the storyline was entertaining, and it brought back everything you love about a whodunit mystery classic!

Thank you NetGalley and Ballentine for the advanced listen copy of this book!

Thank you to Netgalley and the Publishing Company for this Advanced Readers Copy of The Mistletoe Mystery by Nita Prose!

This was a super fast, super cute read. This was different from the other books in the series as there's no mystery for Molly to solve in this one. It was different to see her focus on the romance aspect of her life. I thought it was super cute & look forward to the next Molly the Maid Mystery.

I’m rooting for Molly always and this audiobook was cute. 🥰
I loved watching her get what she deserves with a partner! Just adorable

Short And quick read. I remember the hype for the maid and I was so excited to read it but it fell short for me. I read this one before Christmas and while it was quick, it was in the same boat for me as the first.

I feel if you loved the main books you will love this. I just might be in the minority of people who don't like them as much.

Have been enjoying the Molly series so far, but not so much this one. Think it has more to do with the fact that it’s a Christmas novella, and not a full standalone story.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Molly is such a fun protagonist to follow. Even though as a the reader it is clear as to what is happening, it is fun to watch as Molly connects the dots and figures out what is truly happening. This was a fun holiday read that gets me excited to see what Molly has in store for us next!

Thank you to the author and NetGalley for allowing me the ARC of this book. Overall I really like Nita Prose's books. This one just wasn't it for me. I like romance but I was expecting this to be more thriller like her other books. That was not the case. I do like the story and how it continued from the previous books. Overall, I would give it 2/5 stars.

In The Mistletoe Mystery, Nita Prose brings readers a delightful holiday mystery wrapped in heartwarming festive cheer. Molly Gray, a woman with a deep love for Christmas, is determined to make this holiday season her happiest yet. Her boyfriend, Juan Manuel, shares her passion for the season and is keen to help her reclaim the joy she's lost since the passing of her beloved Gran.

When a Secret Santa gift exchange at the Regency Grand Hotel sparks some unsettling questions about trust and loyalty, Molly finds herself unraveling a mystery that's more personal than she ever expected. With her keen sense of intuition and a touch of holiday magic, she dives headfirst into the puzzle—leading to a surprising realization about her relationship and the true meaning of love.

Prose’s writing is charming, and she beautifully captures the nostalgic, bittersweet feeling of the holidays while also weaving in an intriguing mystery. The blend of festive warmth, personal reflection, and suspense creates a well-rounded story that is as heartwarming as it is thrilling.

What makes The Mistletoe Mystery stand out is its exploration of trust, love, and self-discovery. Molly’s journey through the holiday season is both a personal and relational exploration, where she must confront her own heart and decipher the true nature of those around her. The story is a perfect blend of cozy mystery and holiday cheer, reminding us all that sometimes, the greatest mystery in life is love itself.

This is a perfect read for those looking for a festive and heartwarming story filled with charm, mystery, and the spirit of Christmas.

I love this entire series!! I have read them all and this one was no exception ! This was a good novella for the holiday season and I enjoyed it very much ! I can’t wait for more books by this author!

This is a short,sweet story but not really a mystery in my opinion. I didn’t feel like there was much to this book, it needed more of an element of suspense.

Let’s cozy up with The Mistletoe Mystery by Nita Prose, because this novella is like a warm cup of cocoa with a dash of holiday intrigue. Molly Gray, everyone’s favorite meticulous maid, is back, and this time she’s diving into her most personal mystery yet. With her boyfriend Juan Manuel by her side, Molly is determined to make this Christmas her most joyful one since losing her beloved Gran. But when a Secret Santa gift exchange at the Regency Grand Hotel raises questions about trust and loyalty, Molly’s holiday cheer takes a hit. Is Juan Manuel really the prince she thinks he is, or has she mistaken a frog for her happily-ever-after? Cue the sleuthing, the soul-searching, and a whole lot of festive feels.

What makes this story so endearing is Molly’s unique perspective and her unwavering belief in the goodness of people (even when the evidence suggests otherwise). Her quirks and attention to detail are as charming as ever, and her journey to uncover the truth is both heartwarming and relatable. The holiday setting is pure magic, with twinkling lights, cozy traditions, and just enough mystery to keep you guessing. But let’s be real: Molly’s tendency to jump to conclusions can be a little frustrating, especially when you’re yelling at the book, “Molly, no!” Still, her heart is in the right place, and you can’t help but root for her.

I’m giving this one 3 out of 5 stars. While it’s a sweet, festive read with plenty of charm, Molly’s wild assumptions and the novella’s shorter format left me wanting a bit more depth. That said, if you’re a fan of the series or just love a cozy holiday mystery, The Mistletoe Mystery is a delightful way to get into the spirit of the season.