Member Reviews

Sawyer Greene is a romance author who has sworn off love, but can't seem to shake her writing slump. Mason West is an actor, and hopeless romantic, who desperately needs to stop believing in love at first sight. After their Hallmark meetcute of getting stuck in an elevator together, the two make a mutually beneficial deal with no feelings or sex involved- because that always works as planned, right?

Unromance was cheesy and cliché, but in the best way! I loved that both the characters and the writing structure played up every common romance trope. It poked fun at the repetitve plot lines and swoon-worthy grand gestures that you see in romance movies, but not in a way that takes away from the genre.

Sawyer was so relatable, and as much as I can't stand certain romance tropes, they were necessary and made Sawyer (and Mason) more real.

Was this review helpful?

The premise is outstanding: one hopeless romantic and one jaded unromantic agree to rub off on each other. Erm, not like that. Well, kind of like that. And did I mention they had an explosive one night stand first? The premise set high expectations that were absolutely met. Sawyer and Mason are dedicated to ruining romance, but they can’t help the sparks that fly every time they’re together. Pretty soon they realize it’s more than just physical chemistry between them, too. I loved the genuine connection and mutual respect that was present between them the entire book. This isn’t instalove; it’s two mature adults working through their baggage and forging a lasting connection. Loved it and can’t wait to read whatever comes next from this author.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Forever and NetGalley for the advance reader copy. These opinions are my own.

This book was such a fun time, especially for someone like me who loves and adores all kinds of romances. Sawyer writes romance novels, and Mason is an actor known far too much for his love life. So he requests her help in not falling in love by "unromancing" all the standard rom-com tropes.

I literally laughed out loud at the start to each chapter with the glossary definitions of romance tropes. And they each foretold what to expect in hilarious ways. Additionally, Sawyer and Mason shared amazing banter that was quick and just as funny. I want to be their friends and join their conversations.

Because of course, Sawyer and Mason are just friends. Of course.

The writing was phenomenal with fabulous metaphors. It's a good thing when I stop to notice just how well written the prose is. And I loved every single reference to romance stories. They ran from 10 Things I Hate About You (the main characters are correct - that is the best ever rom-com) to many of Jane Austen's classics.

The romance was phenomenal with just the right chemistry and pacing. And I also want to should out the beautiful male friendship Mason shares with Luis. I feel like I am regularly saying how much I enjoy the female friendships in romances, and I would love to see more strong male friendships like this. Last but not least, yay for bi rep!

This book was a delight and the perfect read to start my 2025.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fantastic romance. I loved the integration of the tropes and how self-aware the book was and yet the characters can't see what is developing between them. I also think the romance was A+. I will definitely purchase and recommend.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 rounded up to 5 - This was a great debut romance!

I'm a sucker for a cinnamon roll hero and Mason DELIVERED. I also loved the character development of Sawyer - even if I got frustrated with her at times, I feel like Erin Connor did a great job setting things up so it was believable.

I also loved how each chapter was introduced by a typical romance trope - that made it all the more fun to see how that trope would play out in the book.

** I received an e-ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is such a wonderful debut from Erin Connor!
The banter was fun. The spice was spicy. The characters were real, even if they did frustrate me sometimes, but that was ultimately part of their charm.
Cinnamon rolls are my favorite of baked goods, so I know a thing or two about them, and Mason was the sweetest of cinnamon rolls. Something about a hopeless romantic man.
Sawyer and her chaotic bi black cat energy was perfect. The balance between our two mains fit really well which made for hilarious and sexy moments. They both had their flaws, but it’s all in how they work through them to get to the end. I loved their love. 🥹

My only downside is the pacing. A few scenes felt unnecessarily long, but it didn’t ruin the want to finish this book.

✨ARC review✨

Was this review helpful?

Witty, sexy, and cliché in the best way possible—Unromance is packed with all the tropes we romance girlies love. From the moment you meet the two main characters, their chemistry is undeniable. This book is laugh-out-loud funny and had me smiling nonstop, page after page. I gave it five stars because I truly enjoyed every moment (and trust me, the two-minute voice message I sent to my best friend proves it).

While the second-act breakup is usually a miss for me, it fit perfectly here since the story leans into clichés and book tropes in the best way. I especially loved Mason being the ultimate lover boy while Sawyer, a romance author, was ironically skeptical of love after a bad breakup. Beyond the emotional and funny moments, this book is undeniably sexy. The steam? Top tier. (That tights scene? IYKYK—it will live rent-free in my mind forever.)

Thank you, Erin Connor, for giving me the perfect romcom to kick off my year!

Thank you, NetGalley and Forever (Grand Central Publishing) for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

How adorable was this??? 😍😍

Ruining Romance with all our favorite romance tropes?!
YES! ✨

This book is a good time! With plenty of giddy, funny moments and a MMC who is so freakin sweet!!

…and the spicy scenes were ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

Absolutely a must read if your looking for a romcom that makes you feel so freakin good 🫶

Was this review helpful?

This book was a perfect representation of a meet-cute when you least expect it. Sawyer was a romantic and successful romance author until her real life doesn't have a happy ending. when she has given up on love and almost her career, she has a textbook meet cute with hopeless romantic, Mason. Sawyer's chaotic energy was so well-balanced by Mason as they are on a mission to prove every romance trope wrong. There was tension and banter and all the amazing things. I loved that Mason started falling for Sawyer first, and helped her through her thoughts to realize her feelings for him. This one is for all the hopeless romantics! Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for the free eARC in exchange for a free eARC.

Instagram post to go live on 08Jan25

Was this review helpful?

This was absolutely amazing. The way that Mason and Sawyer both changed each others lives was beautiful. I loved that Sawyer was willing to do it scared and Mason was willing to slow down his timeline for her. I loved Mason's siblings and Lilly, Sawyer's best friend. I would love more by this author!

Was this review helpful?

My sincere thanks to Forever and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read Unromance by Erin Connor. I give my unbiased opinion of this book in the following review.

The story begins with Mason and Sawyer having a rom-com worthy meet cute in an elevator. Unfortunately, neither one is in the right frame of mind for a relationship at that moment. This doesn't stop them from engaging in some also rom-com worthy banter and going back to Mason's place for a no strings never to be repeated one-night stand. When they do meet again, they hatch a plan that is supposed to be for their mutual benefit. Sawyer is a romance writer experiencing a major writing slump since ending a serious relationship. Mason is a well-known actor who has also experienced a recent break-up. He is being kicked around in the tabloids but is still a hopeless romantic. They figure if they go out together and put all the romantic tropes they can think of to the test, Sawyer will get some inspiration for her book and Mason will see how all the romantic scenarios can't possibly be for real and break his belief in romance. Well, I wasn't sure that was going to work, and I was right on when it didn't. Of course, Mason and Sawyer start catching feelings early on. I have to say that Mason was a pretty swoony character. Sawyer was a little prickly, but it wasn't hard to see that deep down she wanted the same things that Mason did. I enjoyed how they were able to build a friendship as well as a romantic relationship. It was fun to see them interact with their best friends while trying to figure out their next steps in their "unromance". All the tropes they tried like going ice skating and chopping down a Christmas tree were well worth the read. Be prepared for some steamy times, but like I said, the friendship building was my favorite part.

Unromance releases on January 14th, 2025

Was this review helpful?

starting the year off STRONG with this one! i was quite literally OBSESSED.

if you’re a romance trope girlie like me, you will absolutely adore this book! sawyer and mason had an elevator meet-cute but neither of them were quite interested in relationships at the moment after both coming off bad-breakups. so what’s the opposite of a meet-cute? a one-night-stand where they’ll never see each other again.

meanwhile, sawyer was an author experiencing writers block and needed to do literally anything to get her book started because she had deadlines to meet. mason on the other hand wanted to be less of a romantic. he believed in true love and all the tropes and desperately needed someone to help him ruin that. alas, sawyer and mason made a pact. she would help him ruin romance and in the midsts of doing romantic things, hopefully she would be inspired to write her romance book.

they completed nearly every trope in the book and i loved every single minute of it. things like going to IKEA (aka every persons worst nightmare) and going ice skating when sawyer didn’t know how to. things that should have been daunting but the two hit it off and had unbelievable chemistry. highly, highly recommend this read especially with valentine’s day around the corner!

Was this review helpful?

A romance debut promising a romp of subverted tropes and elder Millennial references, Erin Connor's Unromance has been high on my list of most anticipated 2025 releases. The story follows Sawyer Greene, a successful romance author struggling to finish a draft while grappling with her own heartbreak and loneliness who finds herself in the midst of a classic elevator meet-cute with a man who turns out to be Mason West, a mildly famous actor known for dating his costars and simping hard. After a (very hot) one-night stand, they decide they can help each other during the holiday season – they can undertake many Hallmark Christmas scenarios together so that he can inspire her to finish a new holiday romance while she can ruin romance for him.

There's much to admire in Erin Connor's debut – I adored the humor and banter, and was often delighted by the amusing "definitions" of classic tropes that accompanied each chapter. But as tongue-in-cheek and witty as this book often was, as much as I liked the main characters, as much as the chemistry and tension sizzled (the tights scene!!!), and as much as I enjoyed that many of the scenarios that felt very grounded and realistic rather than cutesy romantic fluff, things never really came together for me in a way that felt fully satisfying. The character back stories and more emotional beats felt like they were left simmering on the back burner for a little bit too long, making the emotional journeys and resolutions a bit too abrupt for my liking.

Still, I did enjoy the exploration of Sawyer's writing process in how they relate both to her work and relationships, and overall I really liked Erin's voice and sensibilities. Though I didn't ultimately fully love Unromance the way I hoped, I will look forward to more books from her in the future!

Was this review helpful?

This was a fresh and delightful romcom debut featuring Sawyer Greene, a jaded bisexual disaster who is struggling to write her next romance book and recently dumped famous television actor, Mason West who still believes in love. After a fantastic meet 'not' cute where the two get stuck in an elevator and end the night with a one night stand, they don't see each other again until much later where they strike up a friendship bargain that sees Sawyer trying to destroy romance tropes for Mason and in exchange Mason tries to help Sawyer find her inspiration again.

Set over a number of months and holidays (Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Years), this story takes place in Chicago and was thoroughly entertaining! Full of great banter, sizzling chemistry and supportive family, this dual POV love story was also good on audio narrated by Mia Hutchinson Shaw & Lee Osorio and is perfect for fans of books like You, again by Kate Goldbeck. Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital copy and @librofm for a complimentary ALC in exchange for my honest review!!

Was this review helpful?

Unromance by Erin Connor is a charming and clever romcom with a unique premise. Sawyer, a jaded romance author with writer's block, and Mason, a hopeless romantic actor, team up to ruin romance for him by reenacting classic romcom tropes. Their adventures are fun, creative, and often hilariously romantic, despite their best efforts to avoid falling for each other.

The book’s structure is delightful, with each chapter highlighting a different romance trope—it’s a treat for romcom lovers! Mason is sweet and charismatic, while Sawyer’s wit and stubbornness make her an engaging protagonist. Their chemistry shines, even if the plot feels a little inconsistent at times.

The story drags in places, and the third-act conflict felt slightly overblown, but the grand gesture at the end was adorable. This is a heartfelt, funny, and spicy read that romcom fans will adore. Erin Connor’s debut is definitely worth checking out!

Was this review helpful?

Unromance by Erin Connor is a delightful and charming read that will forever change your perspective on tights. This novel is not only entertaining but also thought-provoking, offering a fresh take on the traditional romance genre. Prepare to be captivated by Connor's unique storytelling and witty humor. You won't be able to put this book down!

Was this review helpful?

3.25 stars! Sawyer is a cynical romance author with writers block and Mason is a hopeless romantic desperate to stop falling hard and fast for the wrong people. They make a pact to experience romance tropes in hopes of giving Sawyer ideas for her book and to ruin romance for Mason so he can take a break from dating. I loved the premise of this book, it’s the perfect setup for a romcom. I think this book would make an amazing movie. When I was reading the book I could so clearly see the scenes in my mind and I feel like it would translate so well!

Each chapter begins with a romance trope or cliche that’s going to be explored in the chapter and its definition. I absolutely loved this idea. I thought it was so original and was such a great addition especially given the plot!

Mason was a really sweet and likable mmc. I thought he really shined when he had conversations with his brother in law Luis. He was funny and charismatic and so supportive of Sawyer. Sawyer was witty and strong willed and hilarious! Their unromance outings were so fun and as a romcom lover I loved knowing what movie each activity came from!

While this book was a good time I was a bit confused by the plot. Sawyer was supposed to ruin romance for Mason but during all of the activities she never really did anything to spoil the romantic moments so every interaction was romantic, so what was the point? I also felt like there was so much internal monologue I would lose interest or get lost in the story so parts of this dragged. At the 70% mark the story really picked up pace and I was invested! There’s this third act conflict regarding Sawyer’s movie rights that, while I understand her anger, I think is blown way out of proportion and I was a bit confused about her reaction. I thought the resolution was a bit rushed but the grand gesture at the end was so cute!

I wasn’t that invested in the characters or their relationship and I something I can’t put my finger on was missing for me but I think a lot of people will really enjoy this book, especially if they love romcoms! It was a quick read that was funny and heartfelt and I’ll be sure to read Erin’s next book!

Thank you to Forever Publishing and NetGalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Sawyer may not believe love can live off the page or screen, but Mason just can’t stop falling. Can Sawyer Greene help him by ruining the illusion of romance one cheesy meet-cute at a time?

*Chefs kiss* this was just so charming and fun (and spicy)!

I would say, with the amount of Christmas and holiday activities being pivotal to the plot, I am very curious about the publisher releasing this mid-January. Was there just not another fall release window?

I hope this largely being a holiday book released post-holidays doesn’t hurt this debut author - because she deserves hype! So get ready for another Christmas…less than a month after Christmas because Unromance is hitting shelves January 14th!

Thank you to Forever (Grand Central
Publishing) and NetGalley for an advanced electronic copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Overall, this book was really fun - I love it when a romance takes traditional tropes and turns them upside down. It really felt like a book written by a book/romance reader, and that always makes it a little more special. I would say I’ll rate this at 3.5 overall - there was some repetition that got to me (but mason is moving to LA… I don’t like romance…. The list) and that took me out of it just a little. I think if it was shortened just a touch that would help relieve that repetition, that really just felt like filler

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book so much. The concept alone is amazing, who doesn't love the personification of a black cat/golden retreiver in the form of a jaded romance author and an actor in love with love? Watching Sawyer and Mason go from strangers to friends to dumb dumbs to lovers was so rewarding and had so many fun nostalgic rom-com nods as well.

Was this review helpful?