Member Reviews

A first book in a new series, from the blurb this seemed an amazing read. Plus, I've read other Victoria Gilbert books, which I thought were well done.

Being the first book in a series, I really needed detail on setting and characters. The book has both, but many of the characters, including the protagonist, seem lacking in enough detail to give me a full picture of who they are. I feel like the author was attempting to make the protagonist a bit of a prickly personality, maybe trying to season her with an Agatha Raisin vibe. While I appreciate the attempt to create a different personality type for a cosy protagonist, I'm not sure if the balance was right. The prickly personality seemed too strong.

Maybe the reason for this was to introduce an enemies to lovers story line with Zach, a psychologist who should not be a psychologist, given his personality in the book. Both Zach and protagonist, Jen, trade more barbs than politicians at a debate. And apparently, that's what they're both attracted to. So maybe like does attract like. I found the whole enemies to lovers story line, which almost felt insta-love as well, a bit off-putting in this book. I found Zach more than a little creepy.

Now for the mystery side of things. It's a decent enough setup, and our protagonist has a good reason to meddle. But while that was good, the resolution felt too easy. It wasn't about sleuthing really. It was more the culprit walking up and admitting they did the deed.

The journey to the end did have some interesting moments, and on balance I enjoyed the story. But Victoria Gilbert is a seasoned author, so I expected little more. Maybe we'll get more in the second book.

Was this review helpful?

Jennifer Dalton is an educator and author at Clarion University. Her role in the English department is to guide students who seek higher literary aspirations. After one of the college's professors humiliates one of her students, the confrontation between the two results in the discovery of his dead body. Along with his body is a crumpled, marked-down story submission from Mia, one of his students, incriminating her in the murder.
Jen is confident Mia is innocent, but when she mysteriously disappears, Jen moves full speed ahead, using the investigating skills she acquired as a mystery writer and the help of those around her to find the truth and clear Mia’s name.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

Cozy series debut featuring mystery writer/academic Jen Dalton. She runs the creative writing center so is firmly implanted in the college world with its accompanying rivalries and jealousies. When the body of a professor is found and a young mentee of Jen's comes under suspicion, she and several friends decide to help investigate.

Jen is not a particularly likable character. She has a major chip on her shoulder and seems to find snark easier than normal communication. There is a perilous maybe-romance with school psychologist Zachary Flynn. I think the tone attempts banter and repartee but it just feels mean-spirited.

It isn't long before another body turns up. Is it murder? Is it related? Jen and company end up solving both mysteries after a few close calls. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Jen Dalton, the popular head of the Writing Centre at Clarion University in Virginia, is also the author of a successful mystery series in her 'other' life, which the stuffier members of the English faculty are less than impressed by. Intending to do some research in the university library, she is horrified to find the body of one of the more disapproving department's professors.

When Mia, one of her more talented students, is blamed for the death, Jen and two of her friends, Christine, and Brianna, are determined to clear her name and hopefully find the person responsible as well. The campus psychologist, Zach, somehow joins their small team as a somewhat annoying voice of reason. It soon becomes clear that the killer has Jen in their sights, but with Mia still top of the suspect list, she can't stop investigating now, can she?

Book one in this new cosy series is a fun visit to academia, and Jen Dalton is an easy to like main protagonist. The investigation was intriguing, and although everything is new and the inevitable descriptions have to take place, it's clear that this is an experienced author and the necessary facts never overtake the storyline. There is plenty of scope here for another successful series for Victoria Gilbert.

I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Crooked Lane Books, but the opinions expressed are my own. This is a very good series starter. 3.5 rounded up to 4 stars.

Was this review helpful?

This is a new series by Victoria Gilbert, set in a fairly recognizable area by anyone who reads her Blue Ridge Library series. Set on the college campus of Clarion, where Richard Muir teaches dance, those characters get a quick mention, we meet Jenn Dalton, director of the campus writing center. Jenn is also a cozy mystery writer by night, where she has an eight book series published. Jenn has arrived at the top floor of the library to find a journal entry not yet offered online when she discovers a dead body instead! Shocked to find something like this in the college library where she also has her office, she even more thrown off when she finds out her colleague was murdered and one of her most talented students is considered the main suspect, and she's is no where to be found. With the help of her friends, Bri, a reference librarian, and Christine, the manager of Student Union Cafe, who also believe in Mia's innocence, they work to find out what really happened. I love the setting here, the college vibe, the diverse characters while still maintaining a small town feeling. I will admit it took a while for Jenn to grow on me. She comes off as very cool and maybe even a little stand offish, but eventually, we get to see a little more from her. It's definitely worth checking out. Thank you to #Netgally, #CrookedLaneBooks, and the author for a chance to read! #SchooledInMurder #VictoriaGilbert #CampusSleuthMysteries #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to like this book i did. the setting the plot... it all seemed soo up my ally. but.. the characters. I could not fully enjoy this book because the characters are so flat that is my biggest complaint there seems to be no growth no personality no nothing. they really just feel like characters on a page. outside of that the stories good! but the characters take away from that 3/5 stars

Was this review helpful?

This is a first in a new series by Victoria Gilbert.

Jennifer "Jen" Dalton helps English students at Clarion University Library in Virginia. She's also a fiction genre author, which is looked down upon by some of the petty members of the English department who encourage 'higher literary aspirations'. One of these uppity professors is found dead after having an argument with one of Jen's students.
Jen enlists the help of Christine Kubiak, cafeteria manager, Zachary Flynn, campus psychologist and Brianna Rowley, librarian. Together they attempt to identify the real killer, putting Jen in harms way more than once.

Was this review helpful?

The protagonist, Jennifer "Jen" Dalton, is a relatable and compelling character who uses her sleuthing skills to clear her student's name after a shocking murder at Clarion University. Gilbert weaves together a fun web of motives and suspects, keeping readers guessing until the very end. The dynamic between Jen and her fellow sleuthers adds depth and humor to the story, making them a lovable and effective investigative team. The novel is not just a murder mystery but also delves into the politics and rivalries within academia, adding an extra layer of intrigue.

Overall, Schooled in Murder is a good for fans of cozy mysteries and amateur sleuths. Victoria Gilbert's storytelling prowess and knack for crafting compelling characters make this book a standout in the genre.

I recommend it to anyone looking for a captivating and well-crafted mystery novel.

#SchooledinMurder #NetGalley @crookedlanebks

Was this review helpful?

"Schooled in Murder" the 1st instalment in the "A Campus Sleuth Mystery" series by Victoria Gilbert. I think this is a great start to a new series. A mystery writer must solve a real murder case before an innocent girl is condemned…

I found myself engrossed in the story and reading it in almost one sitting. It was entertaining, full of twists and turns as well as a few surprises. I did guess the killer before Jen but I still found this to be a fun easy read.

I can’t wait to read the next book and see how things are going for Jen, Zach and the rest of her new found friends.

I highly recommend this book to all my cozy loving friends.

I requested and received an Advance Reader Copy of this book from Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my OWN.

Was this review helpful?

Schooled in Murder by Victoria Gilbert is an intriguing mystery with relatable characters and plenty of suspects to keep the story flowing.
The main character of Jen Dalton is a mystery writer herself, giving her a unique insight into the mystery of who pushed the university professor to his death. The setting of a campus is inviting and familiar at the same time, the dialogue is quick and, in the case of Jen's love interest Zack, entertaining. And I found the cameo appearances by characters from Gilbert's other series fun.
The book is well-written and full of intrigue and suspense, making it a true page-turner.
I am happy to have gotten in on the ground floor of a new series with the ARC of #SchooledinMurder from #NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I guess this is supposed to be a cozy mystery, but it's rather naive even for that style. It's also not very logical at times, but the characters and the dialogue are great, so it's good entertainment.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Victoria Gilbert for providing me with a complimentary digital audiobook ARC for Schooled in Murder coming out January 7, 2025. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

I’m definitely obsessed with cozy mysteries and this is one of my favorite authors. I loved that she came out with a new series. I loved the campus setting. I think Jen is a fun character. I love that she’s an English teacher and author. The mystery was a lot of fun and it was a short read. I’d definitely check out more books in this series!

I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys cozy mysteries!

Was this review helpful?

Jenn finds a body in the campus library and learns that her student, Mia, is suspected of the murder. Jenn and her friends believe someone else is the culprit, so they begin sleuthing. Sleuthing can be dangerous, though, as Jenn soon finds out.
This is a fun campus cozy mystery with department politics, resentments, and ambition. There is also a sweet romance developing for Jenn.
Thanks to Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this new book by Victoria Gilbert. It was a cute cozy mystery set within a college campus. The characters were great, the plot had lots of little twists that kept me interested. Overall a great start to a new series.
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book of a new series. If you have read the Blue Ridge Library series, you will reincounter some of the characters from there. The book involves teachers at a college. Jenn, the main character writes mysteries, and runs the writing center. One of the English students was seen arguing with her profess0r over her grade on a paper, and shortly thereafter, Jenn finds the professor dead. When the student becomes the main suspect, Jenn and several of her colleagues don't believe she is a killer, and begin to investigate themselves. They find several possible suspects, and someone wants them to stop looking. They disable Jenn's car brakes and attack her on the campus. The resident psychiatrist finds Jenn after her attack, and takes her to the hospital. Jenn and Zack slowly become more interested in each other, while she and two of her teacher friends continue to investigate putting themselves in a lot of danger.

I have really enjoyed this book, and look forward to the next episode. I thank Netgalley and Crooked Lane Publishing for allowing me to read an ARC before publication.

Was this review helpful?

Schooled in Murder is the first book in Victoria Gilbert's new Campus Sleuth Mystery series.

This book had a great premise, murder on campus, academia setting, English professor as a sleuth.
I enjoyed the setting, it really gave off that college vibe.
I also liked the fact that we had smart, down to earth, relatable main character. Although I found her to behave quite silly and childish regarding her romantic interest. The romance angle was well done, it didn't interfere with the story. Her romantic interest was more likeable but i felt that there was no chemistry between them at all.
The mystery itself was solidly done, I however thought that there was no real investigation as such, it just somehow happened to resolve itself. I was very pleased that I guessed the culprit.
I liked how there were several sleuths who worked well together. Their relationship was much better.
Overall, it was an ok book. I just wished we got to know characters better, they very really very flat and one dimensional.

Was this review helpful?

Wasting no time, in the very first chapter our main character Jen, an author as well as writing advisor at Clarion University finds a dead body. The news spreads fast at the college campus and everyone believes that one of the students that Jen mentors, Mia Jackson is the culprit. Everyone but Jen. It's an interesting murder mystery that unfolds as more characters are introduced with most having motives of their own to kill our victim. I loved the chemistry between Jen and Zach. They had great banter and their chapters together were quite humorous to read.
With a second act murder we are left wondering just how many killers we are dealing with and who if anyone can really be trusted.

Thank you to the publisher for the free copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adore Victoria Gilbert and her cozy mysteries so I was excited to see she has a new series. Jennifer is an author and teacher at an university. One of her students has a confrontation with a snobby prof and then the prof is found dead - and Mia is missing. It was a fun whodunit with a lot of red herrings to keep you guessing. The plotline kept my attention throughout.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I think this book had a lot of potential. I think the premise is great. However, I do think that the book just didn't capture me as much as I had hoped it would.

Was this review helpful?

Jenn and fellow employees at the college set out to clear a student from murder charges. Mia was seen arguing with a professor just before he fell to his death. However, Jenn has mentored Mia in the writing lab and is sure she is innocent. A wonderful new series from a fine author

Was this review helpful?