I was feral for Heartless Hunter. But with the way the cliffhanger went I thought there was going to be some world building necessary and I wasn’t sure this would live up to expectations. I was wrong. Ciccarelli found a way to bring the characters right back into the action while staying true to the cliffhanger. This was every bit as enjoyable as book one and solidified this series place into one of my favorite duologies category.

In a world where two-book series are so rare, Ciccarelli proves just how satisfying duologies can be.

Every scene felt so important to both books and, as a result, this was perfectly paced.

Rebel Witch picks up some time after the cliffhanger ending of Heartless Hunter. Once again, readers are dropped into the glamorous world of court intrigue and politics, glittering balls and dresses. The opening scene with Rune and Gideon is perfection - seriously, that’s how you start a book.

As they strike a deal and embark on a sea journey to solve a more short-term problem, they must quickly pivot to a higher-stakes conflict in the form of an evil Witch Queen…all while trying to deny their lingering feelings for one another and a curse meant to keep them apart.

Here’s what you can expect:
- Slow burn
- Espionage/double agents
- Sea voyage
- Enemies to lovers to enemies again to lovers
- Only one bed/forced proximity
- Unique magic

While I would recommend this book to any Romantasy lover, Ciccarelli’s duology would also be a great place for those new to fantasy/Romantasy to start. It’s accessible in its world-building, not *too* magical, and with excellent character work.

Thank you to St Martin’s and Wednesday Books for an eARC of this work in exchange for an honest review

I was absolutely hooked by the first book and was weary on how the second could follow up. Overall, Kristen Ciccarelli did not disappoint!
This is such a solid fantasy ya romance that will have readers devouring from first to final page.
I’m not the biggest third person storytelling fan, but this one is done well so you don’t feel like you’re being told instead of shown which wins big points from me.

I admit the first book didn't fully pull me in, but I wanted to see how the duology would conclude. I have to say the second book, Rebel Witch, hit it out of the park for me. The push and pull of will they or won't they between Rune and Gideon, the battle between witch hunters and witches, the continued world building, and so much more kept me deeply in the story this time. And that ending! I can honestly say I did not see it coming at the conclusion of book one.

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for the dARC of this work in exchange for my honest review.

Also, the narration of the audio book (which I listened to after reading the ebook) is done very well.

4.5 Stars

Rebel Witch is a mesmerizing sequel to Heartless Hunter with even more tension, more stakes, and more banter and an ending that will satisfy readers.

This book is further proof that Kristen Ciccarelli is a master at balancing romance and fantasy. She doesn’t cut corners when it comes to the world-building or magic system in order to focus on the romance between Rune and Gideon. Instead, those elements help fuel the tension between these two. Add in excellent pacing and brilliant foreshadowing, and this book is definitely one of the best YA fantasy books I’ve read recently and one of the best romantasy books I’ve ever read.

While some plot threads were a little predictable, I think that just shows that Kristen did a great job setting everything up for the heart pounding climax and resolution. I also love that she was able to incorporate the “fake married couple” trope into the plot and give more depth to many side characters introduced in book one. It was so fun to see Rune five steps ahead of Gideon this time around.

There was a little bit too much back and forth between both Rune and Gideon and both of them constantly being captured/arrested by their enemies, then escaping, then being captured again only to find a way to escape. By the end it was a little exhausting. I also wish they had addressed the revelation about Rune’s magic more at the end, but overall, this is such a great sequel and I cannot wait to reread and revisit this world and these characters soon.

*Rebel Witch* by Kristen Ciccarelli had some interesting moments, but ultimately, I found it to be a bit predictable and frustratingly over-explanatory. The book's premise is solid, and there’s definitely potential in the story, but I could easily guess where things were headed, which made it hard to stay fully immersed. The lack of surprises or twists left me wanting more in terms of depth and complexity.

What really took me out of the story, though, was how the book explained things in a way that felt almost condescending at times. It often laid out ideas so plainly and repeatedly, as if the reader couldn’t figure things out for themselves. It took away from the sense of discovery that I was hoping for, and instead, it felt like the narrative was spoon-feeding me information rather than letting me interpret or engage with the themes on my own.

While *Rebel Witch* had some interesting concepts, the predictability and the overly explanatory tone made it hard for me to fully connect with the story. It’s an enjoyable read if you're looking for something light and straightforward, but it didn’t offer the kind of depth I was hoping for.

Overall, I loved this book.
After the ending of the first book, I was at a complete loss as to how Ciccarelli would continue the enemies to lovers trope without getting stuck in the enemies zone.

This book did not disappoint. I was actually surprised multiple times and wish that there were more books in this world!

Wow, what a conclusion!
I loved everything about this. The fast-pacing of this book kept me on my toes and Gideon and Rune finally coming to see eye to eye is so good and so heartbreaking at the same time.

I'm really really sad that this is over and I really wish we could get a novella of the world after the war has ended.

I'm excited to see what this author writes next. Usually, I bypass books with witches. Most of the time, I find they don't hold my interest. Heartless Hunter and Rebel Witch are very much exceptions to the rule.

Can't wait for it's official release!

I waited so (im)patiently for Rebel Witch since reading and absolutely loving Heartless Hunter. This book did not disappoint and was definitely worth the wait. The adventures of Rune and Gideon are such a wild ride and I love immersing myself in their story. It's the best kind of emotional rollercoaster, causing feelings of anxiety, joy, devastation, excitement, love and hate... It is so easy to sit down with this book and consume it in one sitting. Every chapter left me being unable to hold off on starting the next one, I had to know what came next. The world-building is immersive, the character arcs are complex, the plot is clever and addictive and I absolutely recommend Rebel Witch to any and all book lovers - be sure to read Heartless Hunter first!

Ahhhhhhhh!!!! I love this duet!!! This one was sooooo good!! I am HERE for the “will they - won’t they” and the forbidden aspect of the relationship which was very prevalent for most of this book as well!! The story moves along great! I just love this duet. :)

#1 New York Times Bestselling YA!!

This is a YA title I recommend for fantasy loving adults as well.

Congratulations @kristenciccarelli on your incredible bestselling duology The Crimson Moth!

𝒮𝓎𝓃𝑜𝓅𝓈𝒾𝓈

Rune Winters is in exile with the surviving witches under the cruel control of the witch queen Cressida Roseblood. Rune is to create an alliance through marriage so troops can be mustered to take back the Republic, but Gideon Sharpe is determined to end the cruel witch’s rule once and for all to protect everyone he loves. The only problem is that Gideon loves Rune. Will they sacrifice each other to get what they want?

𝑀𝓎 𝒯𝒽𝑜𝓊𝑔𝒽𝓉𝓈

Rune Winters is one of my favorite main characters. Fierce and fearless, I have enjoyed every heist and escapade. Rebel Witch had me on the edge of my seat, but I was very satisfied with the heart stopping and strong conclusion to this duology.
I will purchase this duology for my high school collection, and I recommend this as an entertaining fantasy world to escape into.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

QOTD: Do you consult best seller lists to inform your reading choices? What is your favorite place to get reading recommendations?

#newyorktimesbestseller #fantasybooks #thecrimsonmoth #heartlesshunter #rebelwitch #witchbooks #duologybooks #duology #bestsellingbooks #currentlyreading #bookstagram #bookreview #bookrecommendations

In my opinion, The Crimson Moth is one of the best duologies. 🙌 This is also the rare instance where the second book is even better than the first! Again, I loved the dynamic of what it is like to love an officer. While I guessed one of the twists about halfway through the novel, I did not see the ending coming. Just 🔥🔥🔥 all around. I'm sad to see this series go and I can't wait to see what the author comes up with next.

"But it didn't matter, because so long as Gideon was on her side, so long as they were a team, there was nothing she couldn't do."

While it wasn’t AS good as the first book, and there was quite a bit of predictability, it was still excellent end to this duology! Another fast paced page turner. I just adore Rune and Gideon’s chemistry!

Rating: 4.5/5
I received the eARC for my honest opinion.

If you’re looking for a book that is a romantasy, YA, that has witches and witch hunters, great chemistry and enemies to lovers, you need to pick up this duology because wow this book went past my expectations. I loved the wrap up of the book, but I was ready for a wild and emotional road. This book picks up right where book one left off, and it really doesn’t slow down. I loved all the action/adventures that the characters had to do, I loved the romance in this book because it really was like enemies to lovers (I mean one of them hunts and kills the other kind). I found that I was able to connect better with the characters in this book.

I loved that in book 1, I was drawn in and I loved it but, in this book, I was fully immersed in everything that the characters were doing and all the secrets and betrayals that come to light in this book. I didn’t want this book to end, I loved all the twists and turns that the author took to really let the readers be able to connect with the characters and to feel all their emotions. I really felt for Rune and Gideon, all they wanted was to be with each other but everything and everyone was trying to keep them away from each other. I enjoyed the journey that they both had to go through in order to make it their happiness. I loved getting to see the healing that the characters had to go through, even the side characters and can we talk about that shocking revelation!!! OMG, I loved how that came out of the book. I was OMG, for real! I loved seeing the characters show their feelings and how much they mean to each other in this book.

I will cherish this book, and I can’t wait to see what this author will give us next.

I want to thank NetGalley and SMP for the opportunity to review this book.

If you like a good YA enemies-to-lovers romantasy that is a quick read, the Crimson Moth duology may be for you. Imagine The Scarlet Pimpernel if the Scarlet Pimpernel were a witch and Chauvelin is a witch hunter, but they fall in love instead of truly being enemies.

I thought this was very good and I will have to add this to the shop shelves. Thank you for the chance for us to review.

Rebel Witch is the perfect conclusion to an unforgettable duology that blends heart-pounding romance, witty banter, and a rich, unique magic system into an unforgettable reading experience. From the very beginning, the world-building is done effortlessly, making it easy for readers to immerse themselves in the story without feeling overwhelmed. The magic system stands out as one of the most inventive I've encountered, adding layers of depth and intrigue to the already captivating narrative.

After reading Heartless Hunter, I had so many lingering questions about Seraphine, and Rebel Witch delivered the answers I was hoping for and so much more. Seraphine is nothing short of badass.

The romance is perfectly executed, with just the right amount of spice to keep things exciting, yet always tasteful and never overwhelming. The chemistry between Gideon and Rune is undeniable and their banter provides the perfect balance of love and hate. By the end, it becomes clear that what they truly needed all along was to trust one another.

Overall, Rebel Witch is a perfect finale that ties up every thread beautifully while leaving you completely satisfied.

I am so excited to report that Heartless Hunter & its sequel, Rebel Witch, were both five-star reads for me!! What a knockout duology. I truly had SO MUCH FUN reading both! 💥 I love how easy these books read. And the best part? It’s a duology, so you can fully immerse yourself with this magic and these characters in just TWO books (instead of 5+ like most fantasy series lol). 🙌

In Rebel Witch, you can find a lot of what you loved from book one: enemies-to-lovers, witch + witch hunter, morally gray MMC, dual POV, & a fast-paced, action-packed plot. But in this one, we also got fake marriage (“MY WIFE”) and one bed trope… 😩😏 The tension and banter between Rune and Gideon is just soooo good. ❤️‍🔥 I really loved how this book wrapped everything up with the fantasy plot too. No complaints!!! Def recommend 😌

#gifted @wednesdaybooks — tysm!

(4.75 stars)
I absolutely loved Heartless Hunter and was so excited to read the second book in this duology, Rebel Witch! This is marketed as Young Adult, but I’m far from that age and I loved it. It’s got witches with an interesting magic system (there’s blood involved, but not in a gory way for the most part)), romance between enemies, action scenes, and more. In fact, the tag line is “Love has never been so deadly.”

Rune and Gideon are wonderful characters with interesting (and heartbreaking) backstories. They have real chemistry but their life purposes are diametrically opposed: she’s a witch and he’s a witch hunter! It’s the ultimate enemies-to-lovers scenario.

I would not recommend reading this book without having read Heartless Hunter first; you would be confused and miss a LOT of backstory. That being said, the author does provide bits and pieces of their history along the way to help readers remember the important things from the first book.

I felt it got bogged down just a tad in the middle, but that didn’t stop me from wanting to keep turning the pages to see how everything would resolve. There are tons of action scenes throughout, with either Rune or Gideon or both of them trying to outrun or outsmart their pursuers.

A huge thank you to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance readers copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

Fast paced and entertaining I loved finding out more of the mcs romance and growth together. This book did not disappoint but the storyline was predictable