I loved this devotional for Advent. Each devotional ends with a prayer or a practice to remind you of what you read. I loved that the author features her song lyrics at the beginning of each devotional. I also loved understanding what exile looked like in the Bible and thinking about how we are in exile as we wait to go to Heaven someday. Definitely recommend this advent devotioanl!

My thoughts:
Caroline Cobb's Advent for Exiles beautifully ties the theme of exile to the hope of Christ’s arrival, offering a reflective look at longing and belonging during Advent. This was an excellent introduction to important themes that are often neglected. Cobb also did a good job connecting advent to a wider narrative of Scripture.

Who is this book for:
This book is for advent time. It could make a great devotional for personal time or as a communal guide for a church. I think churches should consider this for the 2025 advent season.

Questions, comments, concerns:
I like that this had a wider approach to scripture than most advent resources.

Cobb is a musical artist first and is now expanding to writing longer form. She weaves her lyrics, poetry, biblical theology and her own perspectives on Advent. What was most fascinating about this devotional is that she spends a lot of time in the Old Testament (especially Isaiah) to demonstrate the wonders of the season, ones that she hopes bring encouragement to we exiles.

Each devotion begins with some verses from Cobb's songs which I appreciated and I expect their presentation in the final published edition would be more prominent and artistic.

This is unlikely to be a devotional I return to but that's not taking away from the insights and encouraging practical reflections Cobb provides in this 25 day book.

I was fortunate to receive an early ebook copy from the publisher via Net Galley. This, however, has had no bearing on my review.

The advent season is a beautiful time. I love the decorations, the picturesque snow blanket over the yard, the candles and dim lighting. These serene settings draw me into reflection of goodness, beauty and truth.


Advent For Exiles: 25 Devotions to Awaken Gospel Hope in Every Longing Heart by Caroline Cobb is a recently published advent devotional that stirs our hearts to the biblical theme of exile and how we notice this in our lives throughout this season.


Advent For Exiles | Book Review

Summary

My Take

My Recommendation

Listen: A Seed, A Sunrise: Advent to Christmas Songs

Quick Stats

More Like This

Scriptures About Advent

Follow Along




Content
Summary
After releasing her Advent album A Seed, A Sunrise, musician Caroline Cobb fulfilled her promise to her patrons by creating a devotional companion to her music. In Advent for Exiles, Cobb delves into the theme of exile as seen through Scripture. She tenderly explores the ache of living in exile, the challenge of waiting for God's promises, and the renewed hope found in His faithfulness. Each day's entry includes a Scripture passage, a thoughtful reflection, and concludes with a prayer or response, making it a meaningful guide for the Advent season.


My Take
Much of our weariness stems from living in a world that isn’t as it should be.


Lately, I’ve been exploring the practice of lament, reflecting on how the brokenness of sin wreaks havoc on our relationships, bodies, environment, and the systems we depend on. Nothing escapes its touch. And it hurts.


Yet, perhaps the greatest burden is not the brokenness itself but how we respond to it.

The darkness of this world often seeks to envelop us, pressing in with grief and pain, tempting us to retreat into despair. Once we feel its weight, it’s easy to sink beneath it, mistaking isolation for safety. But in turning inward, we become stuck—immobile, blinded to hope, and unaware of the light around us.


And yet, into this darkness, a great Light has come.


Though darkness seeks to overwhelm, the Light of the world invites us to lift our gaze. He calls us to see Him and His work in the world, reminding us of His words: “I am the light of the world. Whoever follows me will not walk in darkness, but will have the light of life” (John 8:12). Even more, we are assured: “The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it” (John 1:5).


When weariness in exile threatens to consume us, the gospel gives us hope. The Light of the world has come—He came, He is here, and He is coming again. “At one time you were darkness, but now you are light in the Lord. Walk as children of light” (Ephesians 5:8).


This truth renews my strength to persevere, even as I lament the brokenness around me. We are not without a mission. As children of light, we are called to carry this light into our communities and to the nations. With this purpose, we can press on with courage, knowing the darkness will not have the final word.


As I reflect on these truths, Advent for Exiles has deepened my longing for Christ’s return and renewed my resolve to live as a child of light, even in the midst of darkness. This Advent, may we all find strength in His promises and courage to carry His light wherever we go.




My Recommendation
With many advent devotionals too choose from each year, it may be hard to know how to choose. If you feel weary and longing in this busy season, these reflective readings on the theme of exile will help meet you in the place of burden, longing and waiting, then point you to the hope in the gospel.





Quick Stats
# of Pages: 240

Level of Difficulty: Easy

My Rating: 5 stars

An advent daily devotional that includes some of the author’s own song lyrics, Scripture references to read with each day, a devotional that challenges readers to think deeply about advent, what Jesus’ arrival on Earth in the form of a baby meant to people who had been in exile and those of us still in a type of exile waiting for his next return. Each devotional ends with an application prompt of an activity or prayer idea to put into action relating to the day’s readings.

I had not heard of this author/singer/songwriter before, but I really appreciated her advent book. I found each day thoughtful and thought-provoking, biblically rich, well-researched, and both emotionally and logically resonant. It prompts you to really ponder the greatness of joy and hope advent means to people in the depths of turmoil and despair. Which is a theme that resonates across the ages, from first century peoples to those today. There aren’t many advent devotionals with activity ideas for each day, and I liked that aspect of this. I also thought it stood out for the way the writing feels so very down to earth and readable, while also tugging on your emotions, and being rich in biblical research and quotes from Christian scholars. It’s a unique combination and makes for a rich advent reading experience.

Notes on content:
Language: None
Sexual content: None
Violence: Deaths and injuries from biblical stories are mentioned.
Ethnic diversity: Mostly historic Bible figures, Middle Eastern people talked about.
LGBTQ+ content: None
Other: Displaced peoples are a common topic.

I received an ARC of this title from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

I have been a fan of Caroline Cobb's music for a long time, and was excited to get a chance to read and review this book and can now say I am also a fan of her writing. This advent devotional is beautifully written and covers much of the story of salvation through the course of the 25 days. Each day includes a portion of scripture and then a beautifully written reflection. I also really enjoy how she includes some of her song lyrics each of the days. She has also created a spotify playlist to accompany this book which is a really nice addition as well. I was so impressed by this book I ordered two physical copies, one for myself and another for a friend.

I received an advanced copy of this book from Netgalley. All opinions are my own.

I love reading something for Advent each year. I was excited to see this devotional by Caroline Cobb. I have loved her music for a long time. I now can say I love her writing as well. What a great read for the Advent season,

While it didn’t blow me away, I’m still glad I picked it up. It’s a solid 4 stars from me! The title is what grabbed my attention but the detail of each day's content and thought behind the heart of it all was what kept me.

Brilliantly written and her album is such a sweet and thoughtful companion. Neither the music or the devotional outweighs each other for both weighty in their own way.

Advent for Exiles is a book I have been looking forward to since I first heard Caroline Cobb was writing it! Her advent album A Seed, A Sunrise is one of my favorites to listen to all winter long (really, until it’s time to switch to Andrew Peterson’s Resurrection Letters album leading up to Easter). I was captivated by the way the music brings you through the longing for the promised Messiah that was prophesied, the joy at his arrival, and the hope of his return.

Advent for Exiles is a kind of companion to this album (although you definitely don’t have to have listened to the music), tracing the similar themes from Isaiah of the feelings of exile in a world that’s not as it should be, the hope that Christ is the only one who can save, and the longing for his second coming and restoration of all things.

The readings were beautiful and seeped in scripture, just like her music. I’m planning to read it again slowly during Advent and take the opportunities for response included with each day’s reading. While I had a digital ARC from being on the launch team, my pre-order arrived so early that I had time to read it in hard copy and it is a beautifully designed little book! Each of the 25 days includes quotes from the songs, a scripture reference to read, the reading, and different ways to respond.

I also was able to attend a house concert with Caroline a few weeks ago and it was a beautiful, worshipful night—and it was so nice meeting Caroline! If you don’t have a book for Advent this year, I highly recommend Advent for Exiles!

Thanks to @netgalley and @bhpub for the opportunity to read and honestly review this book.

A lyrical book, Advent for Exiles guidess the reader through twenty-five devotions that address everything from the pain of loss experienced in the garden to our current longing for the Lord to shine His light in a world wrought with strife, injustice, illness, and aging.

Caroline Cobb writes, "In Advent, we remember our identity as exiles and ask, 'How long, Oh Lord?...As we wait for that day, we link arms with Adam and Eve, the prophets, and the Old Testament exiles in Bablyon and Assyria. Like them, we cling to God's promise of salvation and ache to see it fully realized. But we do so with a more vivid, concrete hope: a radiant,living, unchanging, imperishable, unconquerable hope anchored in the life, death, resurrection, and imminent return of our King and Savior, Jesus Christ (1 Pet. 1:3-5)

Even now the dawn is breaking through, the firstfruits of that everlasting love."

Beyond the beautiful writing and Biblical insight, each chapter includes a quote from Cobb's music and concludes with a prompt in the short section, "Respond in Practice". Ideas range from crafting a poem to purchasing a plant or reciting a prayer.

A contemplative Advent resource, this book will add richness and depth to the days leading up to Christmas.

Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to read Advent for Exiles in exchange for my honest review.

Caroline Cobb is a singer and songwriter, but in my estimation, she is also a storyteller, and in her showing and telling, she has captured the fragrance of lament that is the essence of Advent. Jesus is “the joy of every longing heart” because we wait for him to end our exile once and for all. In Advent for Exiles, Cobb traces the biblical theme of exile from our banishment from Eden to the ashes and ruin of Jerusalem and on to the hunger for home that you might be feeling today. Digging into the rich biblical imagery of a sunrise, a seed, a king, a highway, and a city she encourages readers to put their hope in God’s bright promise of rescue as we wait for all things to be made new. Each reading comprises a song lyric, a scripture reading, a reflection, and a prompt to respond. The message is strong and true: “We do not despair in the darkness of our exile or our longing for home because the hope of Christ is as sure as the sunrise.”

Realistic yet imaginative, poetic yet literal. I have grown to appreciate Caroline Cobb's writing in a whole new light as well as my exilic journey this side of Eternity. This is truly a Christ-centered, Advent read that displays the true "aesthetic" Christians should desire. I cannot wait to own a hard copy of this treasure!

I truly love this book. It's such a different take on advent from what I am used to, but still points clearly to the gospel throughout. I had never heard of Caroline Cobb before reading this book, but it also gave me a great connection to her music, which is great to listen to while reading. Advent for Exiles reminds the reader that this world is not our home and that God is with us as we await Jesus' second coming. This book is perfectly written for this post-2020 climate. If you enjoy reading books by CS Lewis, you would likely enjoy Caroline's writing style. I think it's more suited for an individual or a small group read, but not as a family devotional. Each day has a prayer and a song accompanying it and I highly recommend singing aloud if you enjoy doing so. It's a nice way to end your read.

A good devotional that I will be recommending to students for advent. It is a bit of a pity that the book does not take the opportunity to be more historically rooted (eg. by splitting the days of advent into the 4 weeks corresponding with the four advent candles of hope, peace, joy, and love), but I think this makes this book a good introduction for someone from a 'low-church' background to Advent and spiritual disciplines accompanying Advent.

I know, it’s too early for Advent. But, she’s one of my favorite song-writers and the title of the book felt perfect for us: “Advent for Exiles: 25 Devotions to Awaken Gospel Hope in Every Longing Heart.”

This advent devotional accompanies Caroline Cobb’s album “A Seed, A Sunrise.” Each day’s reading has an accompanying song, a prayer or a practice, a way to meditate and integrate the Word into the day.

We long and look for Jesus to come again, and to come into our everyday of changing places, people, seasons, jobs, roles, where to get groceries, which gate is open and how to spend our time. We are here trusting Jesus will take this set-apart time, this exile, and make it holy.

That’s the Gospel-Good-News of Advent and Christmas isn’t it? That Jesus enters into our time and space and makes it, makes us holy. If you’re feeling a similar sense of wandering, of aching and needing comfort, consider this devotional as a guidebook during Advent.

5 Stars

“Stop. Feel the weight. Imagine again the midnight of exile, the dark before the dawn. As the darkness of night stirs our longing for the sunrise, our sorrow over our own sin and the brokenness around us heightens our desire for the Saviour. The black cloud draped over this period of judgment; the helplessness God’s people felt to get back home to him—these shadows throw the bright beauty of Jesus’s arrival into sharp relief” (Cobb 47).

Caroline Cobb's music has been one of my companions this year. Well, to be very specific, there were a few months where I found myself listening to "Find Me In This Cave" on loop for days. Her music has a stillness, a humility, and a simple poetry to it that touched my heart deeply when it most needed that song, which was in its own way a prayer that uttered what was unutterable in my own prayers. So when I heard that she was working on a devotional for Advent, I was incredibly excited to read it, knowing her gift with words, and the observations that had come from the still, watchful eye of someone who can hear the song in voicelessness. And as I read the advance copy in a mostly-empty coffee shop, I was moved to joy and to tears in the same quiet, still way as her music had moved me.

Cobb’s craft as a storyteller shines through vividly and transparently in her prose. The very first entry in the devotional succinctly reveals her intention of guiding your imagination through Advent: “Can you imagine Eden?” Her purpose in writing this devotional is not to impart something merely cerebral, but to draw us deeper into relational understanding of our relational God; to stir our imaginations and let the familiarity of these old stories fall away like old skins, revealing the hidden fire within, the wonder that is so easily forgotten in the jargon of the season we easily grow numb to.

“My hope is the use of biblical imagery, music and lyrics, storytelling, and physical or visual exercises might stoke the ember of your imagination into flame, even as the Bible readings and biblical principles within the reflections anchor you, giving boundaries for that fire” (Cobb 8).

Just like her songwriting, Cobb's writing here is deceptively simple. The precision and beauty of her writing conveys the simple truth of the Gospel, and presents the beauty of it with honesty and an unflinching receptive posture of the astonishing joy of it. And yet she tells you in her introduction that “in these pages, you will not find “the most wonderful time of the year” but thorns, ashes, and deep gloom. You’ll meet Adam and Eve homesick for Eden and the weeping exiles in Babylong hanging up their harps in the polar trees... But as the darkness of a long night augments our longing for the sunrise, I hope these images of exile will expand your desire for the promised Messiah and amplify your joy at his coming” (Cobb 2-3).

Cobb invites you to "let the ache of your own exile, the dark shroud of your helplessness and sin, make Jesus's first advent, and his promised final advent, all the more glorious to you", through the practices of lament and repentance, and the intentional contemplation of our state as exiles (Cobb 43). One of the aspects of this devotional that I found particularly beautiful is her exhortation to be be still and feel the tension between Jesus's first coming and his promised return; not to dwell in the discomfort for the sake of doing so, but to better understand the magnitude of grace, and to allow a renewed and refreshed understanding of how miraculous a gift it is to seep through our everyday rhythms of life.

“Just wait a moment here. Resist the temptation to fast-forward to the happy ending. Let yourself feel the homesickness, the weight of sin on your shoulders, the hunger pangs. Let yourself see the cherubim barring your way to God. When we allow ourselves to linger in the dissonance and ache of exile, we amplify the glory of what God has done in the advent of Jesus” (Cobb 26).

This devotional is an invitation into stillness, contemplation, and understanding. Though not all of the practical tips she recommended were things that I connected with, I found some of the prayers she wrote as responses particularly moving and thoughtful. Cobb's final purpose in this devotional is to spur us to joyful action, as a response to the joy given to us in this season of hope - that we would embody and live out the eternal hope we carry (coming from a liturgical tradition, this was something that I resonated with strongly!).

While she does not flinch from the sorrow and pain in this world that is worth mourning and lamenting over, Cobb does not sit and stay in valleys of despair. Cobb, whose music swells with an unrelenting and quietly persevering hope, urges the reader to walk in both the heights and the depths of life, holding to the same hope that the exiles from Eden and the exiles from Jerusalem found themselves irresistibly drawn to; to "take comfort, because it is precisely in these impossibly dry, desert places that God delights to make a garden grow" (Cobb 72).

It was a real blessing to read this devotional. I hope it will be a blessing to those who read it this Advent, too.

"Jesus is the seed of the new creation, planted right in the middle of your exile and mine. He arrives not to seek out the best soil or sow into only the most suitable plots of land. No, he arrives to bring beauty from the ashes and rivers in the wilderness!" (Cobb 72)

“Advent invites you to remember and rehearse your pilgrim identity. Today, it bids you to practice the discipline of journeying with anticipation, eyes focused on an unseen, eternal destination beyond compare, and—even more!—on the glorious God who makes his home there. Surely, he is worth it all” (Cobb 88).

I was offered an advanced reader's copy in exchange for an honest review, and am glad to be a part of the launch team for this devotional :-)

[I anticipate also posting this on Amazon on Tuesday]

For about a dozen years, Caroline Cobb has been writing and releasing rich, Biblically-saturated songs. Her skill as a wordsmith has earned her comparisons to Michael Card. Expect those comparisons to only grow from here, because - much like Card - she is now writing accessible devotional books. If you've read one of Card's books and liked it, this is definitely for you.

But even if you have no clue who Card or Cobb are, this might still be for you. It's an Advent devotional that walks through the whole span of redemption, from Eden to the New Jerusalem. Fresh insights are interwoven with lyrics from her songs and calls to engage all five senses in application.

In “Advent for Exiles” Caroline beautifully weaves the exhilic theme throughout the Bible from Jesus’s first coming to anticipating His second coming. With passages each day from Isaiah, the New Testament, as well as various other Bible readings to go along with each day, there is a prayer and a meditation based off of a reflective thought, activity, or her own song lyrics. This beautifully and articulately shows just how special and intentional Jesus is not just was with His people in the very beginning, but how specially and intentionally seeks out the lost today. I highly recommend this book for your advent reading! It would be great to incorporate into a family advent devotionals as the activities and reflections can easily be tailored to people of all ages. Plus her song lyrics and musicality is gospel saturated! Highly recommend for advent preparations or any time of year to prepare your heart!

Ms. Cobb's songwriter side shows in these 25 advent devotions, full of rich prose, painting the narrative of a groaning creation longing for a Saviour.
Great for readers who appreciate prose and poetry, each day's readings roll smoothly through reminding us the reason why we celebrate the hope that Jesus brings.

While a well done devotion, it wasn't quite my personal style, but I know many others will enjoy it.