I've always enjoyed K. O'Neill's writing, and so I had no doubt that I would find this story every bit as heartwarming as "The Tea Dragon Society" or "Moth" and boy was I right. Though there is minimal wording in this graphic novel, O'Neill's illustrations help to say everything that the characters do not, bringing the reader fully into the story as they explore the beauty laid out before them.

Without giving too much away, this was a gorgeous story about finding yourself even when you're unsure if those around you will accept you for who you are. I cannot wait to give this to all of my tweens & teens who need some reassurance that those who truly care for them and love them will be by their side during any changes they may make during their lives.

A beautifully illustrated, cozy, magical graphic novel from the writer of The Moth Keeper and the Tea Dragon Society. With similar themes of questioning one’s place in the world as other titles from the author, Rowan wants to be a protector and knows they can be a good one, but is questioning if this life is truly for them when they begin to travel and see the world around them. But they do know that the name everyone calls them is not the name they want preserved but is unsure of how to tell their friends and superiors. As Rowan struggles with their frustrations of not being able to share that side of them, they struggle finding the courage to ride again in a parallel emotion. While the story has illustrations of a happy ending it also leaves it open with a lot of showing and little telling, but leaves the reader feeling as though they are soaring through the sky.

Such a wholesome and cute graphic novel. I loved the world building, the art style, and I especially loved seeing Rowan's character arc.

I read this in one sitting, and I can’t recommend it enough! Rowan's journey is beautifully drawn and deeply felt—every page pulls you into a world of gentle fantasy, self-discovery, and tender relationships. Watching Rowan struggle with self-doubt and then gradually find confidence through friendship (and maybe a little more) with Leone is such a heartwarming experience. The pacing is just right, letting the story unfold in a way that feels natural and uplifting. If you love graphic novels that wrap adventure and introspection in a cozy package, this one’s for you! That being said, while the book could be enjoyed by middle graders and romance fans, it wasn't particularly middle grade or romantic; I viewed it as more of a universal story.

Adorable and cozy with incredible art! I love K. O'Neill's Tea Dragon series, and this one is just as cozy and impactful.

Rowan is training to be a ranger, but an "easy" assignment and an accident that hurts their flying horse Kes send Rowan spiraling. With the help of a fiddle-playing sheep herder named Leone, Rowan might just become an even better ranger than before.

The art is outstanding, as usual, especially Kes. I want a flying horse. I related so much to Rowan's journey finding what fits for themself, especially in a name. And, as a music lover, I really liked seeing Leone spread his own wings.

Thank you to NetGalley and publisher for the opportunity to read and review.

Thank you to Random House Children's and NetGalley for this ARC. I’m always looking for new graphic novels for myself—and for the children in my family and community, I’m quite looking forward to reading this (the cover is charming) and will update my review promptly when I do so.

firstly, thank you to the publisher for an arc!

WOW! i expect nothing but fantastic storytelling with beautiful art, wholesome relationships, and gentle but important lessons anytime i pick up a work by k. o'neill -- and a song for you and i did not disappoint.

this was such a lovely story about connecting with nature and one's true self (in a way, it reminded me of the pokémon ranger games!!), paired with the stunningly whimsical art that o'neill is known and loved for.

is it selfish to ask for the next graphic novel?!

I have loved all of her books so loving this one didn’t come as a surprise. This book definitely follows the theme of most of her books that is good lessons for everyone and rare but important topics explored in cozy setting. I’m so glad she explored admiration vs crush and how that can be mistaken for each other. I’m also glad she really didn’t put a label on the queer feelings of the characters. Though, I wish we could have learned more about one of the main’s families since they kept being mentioned. I didn’t really understand the conflict. But honestly, the book was so well constructed, I think I was just wishing for more. With the beautiful illustrations and the well thought-out plot, this book is a delight.

stop why does k. o'neill make the cutest and most atmospheric books ever
such a quick and enjoyable time, you won't regret picking this up
such important messages are portrayed very inexplicately. I don't know how to describe it, but the way that O'neil gets messages across is so interesting, creative, and I love it.
4 stars because not AS good as the tea dragon society books, but seriously the art, story, characters, world is so cute and there's no way you won't like this.

Considering this a MG graphic novel, I find it absolutely fair to give it 4 stars out of 5.
It is a positive and life-affirming story that feature Rowan (more on the name in the book) and part of her coming-of-age (finding her identities, overcoming her insecurities, and building bonds with others).

I loved Kes.
Actually, all of the characters were either likeable and relatable, or interesting.

The art style is cute and the colour schemes are amazing.
I might be wrong, but in the print version, I would expect to see more layers and inking.

As an adult reader, I wish this were longer and hoping this is the first instalment of a series.
I will introduce this book to my tween child when they are a couple of years older.

One particular character's smile was a lovely detail.

Plot 3.5
Characterisation 4.5
Themes 5
Mood 5
Art 4.25
Story world 4 (it has more potential - I hope the author/artist explores it further)

K O'Neill's graphic novels are always astounding but this one might have just become my favourite anyway. Not only is the artstyle so remarkably gentle, but the colour palette is perfect for the story: calming & quiet and the story is full of so much warmth. These stories might be over quickly but hold so much emotional depth. It feels like you're drinking a hot chocolate, warming your hands on the cup. A much needed warmth, a much needed joy, This is an easy read but one with messages you need to be told anyway, I can't wait to own this in March.

Rowan deserves the world, as does leone. This is as much a journey of self acceptance as it is finding friends in unlikely places, finding a home in fields of sheep.

This is an absolutely beautiful graphic novel. I love it so much! The illustrations are incredible and the story is very inspiring. Following Rose/Rowan and Leone on their journey of self discovery was lovely. I'm in awe of how such few words can express so much emotion. This story is truly amazing and sends a wonderful message. I highly recommend it!

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for allowing me to read this ahead of release in exchange for my honest opinion.

Thank you author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an eARC of this book!!

K. O’Neill just never misses. There’s something just perfect about the soft fantasy world they create in their stories.

This story is all about acceptance and confidence. Watching the characters come into their own in the beautifully crafted setting is everything! It feels so natural and heartwarming. K. O’Neill is a must read author!

I just, I love anything and everything K.O’Neill writes and I am so happy I got to read this book early. I can’t wait for this to be published and I am so excited!

This author never disappoints; K. O'Neill always presents visually beautiful stories with lovely messages, and this novel was no exception. 'A Song For You and I' is a graphic novel about acceptance, personal challenges, and friendship. It’s a very beautiful story, and I would love to explore more about these characters !!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC in exchange for an honest review!

K. O'Neill is one of my favorite authors of all time, so when I saw that my ARC request was accepted, I literally raced to download this and started reading within the same minute. After immersing myself in the gorgeously serene artwork, heart-felt writing, and diverse, lovable characters that I've come to expect and adore from K, I can say without a doubt that this is a new top graphic novel for me.

The world that K created is rich and beautiful, with so many peaceful moments and soft reminders that we all need so much. Rowan's journey of discovery, Leone's pursuit of joy, and the way those two's narratives intertwine with each other and the broader world was exquisitely done. I saw so much of my own connection to my identity and passions in both of them, and could feel the love and experiences that K poured into this phenomenal story, as with each of their works. I truly treasure this book and its messages!

K. O’Neill always delivers. They’re consistent in their quality, creativity and cozy atmosphere. Like the others, this book is visually a treasure to look at if nothing else. The story is of identity, acceptance, friendship and comfort in self expression. There is a studio ghibli vibe in the scenic beauty of the illustrations and also; in the organic unfolding of the story and characters. What would it be like to have support at every turn? To offer up your vulnerabilities and be met with acceptance? O'Neill shows us.

Would recommend it to middle graders and adults alike. My Ten year old and I both enjoyed it.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!!

This was so cute. The end had me tearing up a little. I love this artist and I’m glad that they are making more graphic novels. This is a super short and full of feels. The art is beautiful as always and the story was engaging. Plenty of development and adorable characters. Can’t wait to read more!

Oh my goodness! This was just the cutest Middle-grade graphic novel. The drawings were gorgeous, I loved them so much. The characters were good, and they had amazing growth. I enjoyed this so much, it felt like a warm blanket on a cold winter night.

This is so worth reading if you like graphic novels, and has an amazing message.

Thank you to Netgalley and Random House Children's for this arc in exchange for an honest review!

This cute graphic novel follows young Rowan (formerly Rose) as they come to terms with their queer identity alongside new friend Leone. I was particularly captivated by the art style; it's my favorite thing about this book. Several pages rely solely on visuals to tell the story, and they were some of the most beautiful and impactful moments.

CAWPILE Ratings:
Characters: 7
Art Style: 9
Writing: 7
Plot: 7
Intrigue: 7
Logic: 7
Enjoyment: 7
Overall, this novel beautifully captures an intimate journey of self-discovery with artistry that speaks volumes without a single word.