Member Reviews

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers. This is a fun graphic novel for early readers. It tells a great story about self-esteem and feeling special. I really liked the illustrations.

Was this review helpful?

I had a great time reading this book. The illustrations were beautiful and really helped make this story a blast to watch unfold. This horse wants badly to be different and unique, and when they find something one day it looks like their dream may have come true. Yet when they show some of their friends the new them, things don’t go the way they hope they would. As this story comes to a close this horse learns an important lesson.

Was this review helpful?

This sweet story about Steve the horse wanting to be exceptional was so fun and lovely. This is a great story for kids to learn you're always wonderful and unique just how you are. I look forward to reading a physical copy to my child!

Was this review helpful?

This book is a lot of fun and we really liked Steve!

My daughter thought that Steve was a funny name for the horse but we have two five month old kittens that are called Ralph and Harry and we have met a dig called Dave before so maybe it isn't so bad - but is Steve an exceptional name...!!

I liked the way the story was written, it had a nice flow to it and it wasn't a complex story with unnecessary big words so my daughter was able to read the book to me without help.

The illustrations in the book were a bit quirky, like Steve, and they worked well with the story - I think the whole thing was done well and whilst it is only a book we will read once, I am sure other children will want to read it over and over

Lots of fun - 4 stars from me for this one - highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

I received this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

This is a easy book for early readers that's funny and light hearted.

Was this review helpful?

When the 1st Steve the Horse book came out, my daughter and I enjoyed the whimsical story and art. Steve's a character - flawed, funny - and we were Team Steve <-- title of the 2nd book we read from Kelly Collier. But in "Steve, A Pretty Exceptional Horse," he's become mediocre. Could be because we've grown older since the 1st book came out in 2018, but this just didn't have the same magic. There was a great concept but the execution lacked the freshness when Steve 1st came on the scene. Ultimately, this felt like a rehash of a Mo Willems' Elephant & Piggie kind of book.

Was this review helpful?

ARC Copy...If read the picture books, you can guess how this will go. Surprised Steve was getting a graphic novel adaption and hehe sure to bring a smile to him and anyone whose like "Narwhal and Jelly" style of humor.

Was this review helpful?

Steve is a normal horse who wants to be exceptional, and in trying to be something else, he learns that he's pretty special the way he is and that his friends really look up to him. It's a good moral and a fun story to tell, but there was just something missing that prevented me from really bumping this up beyond the three star rating, and even that felt a little generous. This is a good early reader graphic novel, and there are some fun elements, but I also felt like Steve was a pretty selfish horse and a pretty blind to his friends horse, which detracted from the fun and the overall story. The artwork is nice, although it has been updated from the picture books.

I feel like the picture books are better, but maybe that's just my bias towards picture books for something like this.

If you have an early reader who prefers graphic novels, then this is not a bad one to either pick up or get from the library.

Was this review helpful?

A story about not lettings things over inflate your ego. Following a very similar storyline to a Horse Named Steve. Steve suffers from insecurity, but his self esteem is bolstered when he finds a horn that makes him different, nay, exceptional. He encourages his friends to to also get horns to be exceptional, and when everyone gets a horn they are all the same. Steve realizes his difference makes him exceptional. Steve, a Pretty Exceptional Horse is a fun book for younger readers, sharing a message about assimilation if you read it deeply enough, but it's by and large a lighthearted book about a horse named Steve with high self esteem, self confidence and a huuuuuuge ego.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book and I can see the kids at my library loving it too! It was funny and clever and I think we all can relate to Steve!

Was this review helpful?

"Steve, a Pretty Exceptional Horse" is an early graphic novel by Kelly Collier, based off of Collier's picture books about Steve. Steve is a silly horse who enjoys hanging out with his animal friends. After seeing a peacock showing their beautiful tail, and hearing his friend Bob the raccoon call it "exceptional," Steve decides he wants to be exceptional. He runs around and finds a golden horn with a string to tie to his head. He ties it on and runs around to show all of his friends. Young readers will learn what "exceptional" means, even if Steve doesn't really end up getting the message that he doesn't need to be exceptional. A funny story that early readers will enjoy. A recommended purchase for young graphic novel collections.

Was this review helpful?

This is a delightful graphic novel for young readers. With laugh out loud moments from Steve the horse, or his friends like Bob the raccoon, this is a sweet story of finding your place and being yourself. The artwork is adorable, and I look forward to seeing more from this series!

Was this review helpful?

This is a story about a couple of friends and after seeing a peacock the horse wants to be extraordinary and finds a horn. He puts it on and shows it off to everyone. In the end though he learns that being himself is the most important thing. This is a great book for young kids and preteens who are still trying to figure out who they are.

Was this review helpful?

A cute graphic novel for early readers. This is humourous enough to keep kids engaged and the word count per page makes it accessible for readers looking to read something a bit longer without over shooting their abilities.

Great characters and a fun plot.

Was this review helpful?

I have not read any of the other Steve books, and maybe I should have before reading this book to help understand the characters a little better. Just reading this on its own, it seems as though the characters do not have a good rapport. Bob and the other animals seem to find Steve annoying, and I also found Steve to be a little too much. But again, maybe there was more character set up in the other books to make this rapport more funny. I found the message to be a little lost and conflicting. You need to be different in order to be exceptional. (What about kids who are content to just fit into societal norms?)
I had my own 11 and 8 year old boys read the book and give some feedback. They did seem to enjoy Steve and the other characters and did not seem bothered by the message. They liked the pictures and thought the ending was funny. They did mention that they wished some more action would have happened in the story, but said that they would like to read more books about Steve. My 11 year old rated it 4.5/5 and my 8 year old rated it 4/5. My rating would be 3.5/5
I can see this being a good book for a library. It is something that can be enjoyed once then passed on to someone else. I would not buy this for my classroom or for our home library.

Was this review helpful?

I've gotta be missing something, bc I thought this was terrible. Maybe I needed to have read the picture book first or maybe this is just a manifestation of how my generation was raised? Not sure. But I don't think it's very cool of Steve's buddy to not find anything exceptional about Steve. I'd be sad if my friend couldn't think of a single exceptional thing about me. At least make something up, c'mon.

Also I just don't get what the point is in the end.

Was this review helpful?