This was a very quick read that I was interested in from the beginning. I was invested in finding out about what happened to JP. I feel like there were details about some of the characters and the trip and then all of a sudden we learn about JP… the end. It felt very rushed.

So many little gems packed into one story! I only wish it would have been longer. I think we can all relate to a situation of heartbreak and needing time or heal and reflect only to realize what you thought you wanted maybe isn’t really what you thought.

I enjoy Elin Hilderbrand books. This is a shorter book than many of her writings. It is also a reoccurring theme but she does give it a diffrrent slant.When her boyfriend bails at the last minute, a New York woman embarks on their couples’ cruise alone to find that maybe the person she was supposed to fall in love with was herself.
After a string of bad dates and no prospects, Sophia Othonos has finally hit the jackpot: an actual nice guy. When he suggests a romantic getaway, she’s sure they’re about to take the next step toward their future. A rustic cruise to the Galápagos Islands isn’t exactly her idea of a vacation, but Sophia is ready for anything…until her boyfriend has to cancel.
Now she’s all alone on a trip that was meant for two. Sophia finds herself at a crossroads about who she is, what she wants, and whether her relationship is really everything she thought. But if she’s going to suffer an identity crisis, at least she gets to do it amid the unexpected majesty of nature.

Many thanks to Netgalley for the e-arc!

I requested this book because I've read a lot of Elin Hilderbrand books prior to this and have always enjoyed them. This was ejnoyable, I'm definitely more of a sucker for her Nantucket books, but I enjoyed this one too. Very light book for a beach read.

Great read just like Hilderbrand’s previous books. This book kept me wanting to read just one more chapter.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of Natural Selection by Elin Hilderbrand. This book has all the hallmarks of a classic Hilderbrand novel—family drama, beautiful Nantucket scenery, and characters you can’t help but get invested in. The story explores relationships, regrets, and second chances in a way that feels both relatable and compelling. Hilderbrand’s writing is as immersive as ever, making it easy to sink into the world she creates. While some twists were a little predictable, I still found myself turning the pages, eager to see how it all played out. If you love a good character-driven novel with heart, this one’s worth picking up!

This story is a masterclass in writing a novella. I had just finished Swan Song when I read this and It made me very nostalgic. I hope that this book means that she's not finished writing beach novels. I loved the way that his story ended and thought that the twist was very well written. as per usual, Hilderbrand draws characters so completely that you can actually see them.

i loved this story and wished it was longer! it was the perfect book to read inbetween others. the ending was abrupt and felt like this needed to be fleshed out a bit more. there was zero plot? i still enjoyed it!

This one didn’t quite live up to my expectations, but it was a quick and enjoyable read. It’s a light, introspective story. While brief and somewhat predictable, Hilderbrand’s signature storytelling still shines.

A perfect bite sized version of one of her full novels. Elin Hilderbrand always has a way with atmosphere— hee descriptions are famously beautiful and make you want to drop everything and head to the coast. And her characters are so complex, messy, human.

Meh. As a big fan of Elin Hilderbrand novels, I was curious what her short story would give. It was a predictable story of self discovery when our lead is left on a vacation she didn't want by her boyfriend, who ends up having a wife. She continues on the cruise alone and we all know the rest. Finds herself.

This was a good, quick read. It gave me a lot to think about. Humans need to be adaptable. Especially single women. Good story.

This novella was delightful and enlightening. A quick read about Sophia left to go on a solo cruise. I loved the characters she meets and her self discovery. A charming story with meaningful lessons for all.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC

I wasn’t sure what to expect when starting this book, but Sophia’s self-discovery journey really captivated me. An easy and lighthearted read that won’t be my last from Hilderbrand.

In this short story by Hilderbrand, Sophia is left at the airport by her boyfriend on her way to a romantic getaway to the Galapagos Islands. Sophia decides to take the trip herself and meets an interesting group of travelers. Most importantly, she gets the time for reflection by taking this trip alone. Being a novella, the characters weren't as developed as needed to really connect with them, but this was a good way to pass a short time.

"It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most intelligent, but the one that is the most adaptable to change". Elin as always draws you in with her well developed characters and this story, although short and sweet, does not disappoint.

Sophia suddenly finds herself alone on a trip to the Galapagos Islands even though she was supposed to go on this adventure with her boyfriend of 6 months. She has to learn to adapt to the trip not being as luxurious as she thought it would be and also being alone. There are a few life lessons sprinkled in this book that not only apply to Sophia but can also apply to the reader.

I gave this short story 3 solid stars. Thank you Netgalley for this advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

"Natural Selection" is a delightful and uplifting read. Hilderbrand's engaging writing style and the captivating setting make this a perfect choice for a quick and enjoyable escape.

"Natural Selection" is the first story I've read by Elin Hilderbrand. I quite like short stories, especially as a way to get introduced to new writers.

Sophia Othonos, the main character in this story, is stood up by her boyfriend right before their vacation. So, she goes alone, and during the trip, she finds herself and also discovers that not everything is as it seems when it comes to her relationship. I quite like Sophia and her fellow travelers with whom she hangs out. I like how this trip made her find herself. The ending felt rushed, as if the author needed to show that Sophia would end up living a happily-ever-after life. Had this been a full-length book, had she come home from the trip a bit wiser, I would have loved to read about that. However, it's a short story, so we are left with a quick insight into what happens next.

Just discover this author even though she has been on my tbr list for the last few years. I loved the short story in place of something before her next book comes out

My first Elin Hilderbrand book, but definitely not my last. I went in blind and had thriller vibes, but the author delivered in the most unexpected and authentic way.

I really enjoyed Sophia's journey of self-discovery and the varying dynamics among the tour group. Loved the ending so much! Overall, this is a captivating and hopeful novelette that will stick with me for long. It was exactly what I needed.