Member Reviews

anything that Hilderbrand is going to capture the eyes of readers,and this is no exception. many received via amazon reads, but continue to recommend

Was this review helpful?

Natural Selection
A Short Story
by: Elin Hilderbrand
Amazon Original Stories

Set in the Galapagos Islands, Natural Selection is a short story packed with adventure and character growth for main character, Sophia. She finds herself alone on a couple's cruise, unsure of the direction that her relationship will take. Just as she does in her full-length novels, Hilderbrand pulls me in with her engaging writing in this compact format. The element of self-discovery in an atmospheric locale was a winning theme for me, and a perfect petite read for an autumn evening.

I received an advance reader's copy from Amazon Original Stories and Net Galley. My review is my own.

Was this review helpful?

In this short story, Sophia embarks on a couples' cruise to the Galápagos Islands alone after her boyfriend cancels at the last minute. Initially disappointed, she views the trip as an opportunity to reflect on her relationship, identity, and desires. Surrounded by the wild beauty of nature, Sophia begins to question whether her relationship is as perfect as she once believed. Over the course of eight days, the transformative power of the islands helps her realize that the most important relationship she needs to nurture is the one with herself. I love anything Elin Hilderbrand and this was a perfect treat, my only wish is that is was a whole book!

Was this review helpful?

Elijah Hilderbrand writes the perfect short story. The right amount of details about the characters to get me invested and wanting to continue reading. I was able to pick up their personalities perfectly from this short story. I loved the the comparison between humans and animals in Natural Selection. Beautifully written.

Was this review helpful?

Short, sweet and to the point. It was a nice little break from what I’ve been reading

Though I don’t think short stories are really for me. I like plot building and substance.

I’m new to Elins books and so far loving them. This one was just a quick easy fix.

Was this review helpful?

I found this story relatively entertaining. I have read many of Elin Hilderbrand's books, including the series that takes place on Nantucket, and while I have really enjoyed them I appreciated the fresh characters and setting this short story provided. Overall I liked it.

Was this review helpful?

Sophia is excited to go on a vacation with her boyfriend, JP. He seems to be the perfect man. While the Galapagos weren't exactly her idea of a relaxing vacation, she thinks this will be the next step in their relationship. Sophia is anxious to get married soon and have children. Just before they are about to board the plane, JP gets a phone call and has to back out of the trip. He tells Sophia there is situation with his son, but that Sophia should still go on the trip. Sophia has never met his kids and offers to come with to help, but JP says no. Now she is alone on the trip and has to make the best of it. This book was enjoyable, but different that Elin Hilderbrand's other books.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you netgalley for the chance to read this.
By design, short stories really are required to grab you from the get go and take you on a ride as quickly as possible and I think this does that: Sophia is destined bound to take a trip with her boyfriend to the Galapagos, when he suddenly has to abandon and essentially ghost her. While on the boat, Sophia meets new people, falls for photography, and learns the truth of their romance.
I liked this alot, even if the start had it feeling more like a creepy thriller and less like a romance gone wrong. It was fun and the cast of characters was amusing. But I think the plot, and what was revealed with the romance at the end, would have been much more suited to long form. I just didn't really care about the relationship enough to be invested in the 'twist' so it was just kinda...meh.
More Galapagos next time.

Was this review helpful?

I was enjoying this book so much that when I checked to see how far along I was (thinking maybe 25%), I was already 70% finished! This is the first short story I have read by Elin Hilderbrand, and I liked it was a quick, fun read. Natural Selection jumps right in the first few pages. Sophia is at the airport with her boyfriend for a romantic getaway. Her boyfriend gets a call at the airport and immediately leaves. The story carries on with Sophia for the next week. As someone who will read anything Elin Hilderbrand writes, I was so excited to have something else after her 5 star book, Swan Song.

Thank you to Amazon Original Stories, Elin Hilderbrand, and NetGalley for allowing me to read this novel in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Natural Selection was just ok for me. The plot and characters seemed to lack depth.

Thank you NetGalley, Amazon Original Stories Kindle Edition and author Elin Hilderbrand for the opportunity to read and review this short story.

Was this review helpful?

I love Elin and her novels and this cover is gorgeous as always. I was excited to read this book albeit it was a short novel. It was a fabulous read. Sophia and her boyfriend had a planned vacation in the Galapagos however he couldn't make the trip so she went herself. A predictable easy read but I liked Sophia and her character development. It definitely could've been a full length novel - as it left me wanting MORE!

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

Book review: Natural Selection

Elin Hilderbrand books are a summer staple for me, so I couldn’t wait to dive into this short story. NATURAL SELECTION is set in the scenic Galápagos Islands and I loved the descriptions of the nature and animals. Quite a bit was packed into this story but I was able to devour it in one sitting and loved the mystery throughout and the twist at the end. Hilderbrand’s stories usually have some juicy twists and this one was no different!

Was this review helpful?

3.5*
A quick, easy read only at 54 pages.
My first Elin- a good short story and a good way to get into Elin’s books!

Was this review helpful?

3 stars. This is a fun, quick and easy to read short story, and I liked that it was set in a non-Elin standard location (Nantucket). I enjoyed the FMC and side charcters, but I would have liked more complexity and depth to them. The finale seemed abrupt and I could have read another 30 pages. But it is a great book for a little palette cleanser between other books!

thank you to netgalley for providing an arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This short story by Hilderbrand pulls you right in from the beginning. Did I kind of feel like I might’ve known where it was going? Sure. But that doesn’t mean I didn’t enjoy the journey!! I also loved that even though it was short she still included an epilogue!! I love a good epilogue!

Was this review helpful?

SYNOPSIS
- Sophia is headed to the Galapagos Island by herself. She was meant to come with JP, her boyfriend of six months, but he left abruptly with no real explanation.
- While she explores the island, she also reconsiders her relationship.

MY THOUGHTS
- Short story.
- Writing is good.
- Entertaining, but not a lot happens & not very deep characters.

TL;DR: ⭐️⭐️⭐️short story. fine for a quick read, but mehhh overall.

Thanks to Amazon Original Stories and Netgalley for this digital ARC in exchanges for an honest review. This is out now.

Was this review helpful?

A short story that left me wanting more. I am used to the authors more drawn out stories and enjoy them. This one felt like a rough draft to me. Maybe short stories just aren't for me as many others really liked the book.

Thanks to netgalley and Amazon Original Stories for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun little book. There is a beautiful setting while a character is trying to figure out where her significant other is. Though I guessed where this story would go, I was surprised by the connections to the island/title. The character growth was fantastic for such a short story. I would recommend to Elin fans!

Was this review helpful?

A couples trip to the Galapagos Islands turns into a solo excursion when Sophia's boyfriend has to cancel. Allowing her the opportunity for self-discovery in a truly remarkable setting. As a short story, it was good. A little predictable. I had hoped it would have some intrigue, but not the case. It could have easily been adapted into a full novel, but was good for what it was.

Was this review helpful?

This could have been a full length novel and I would have still been shocked at the end. I really enjoyed this story! Just a taste of the Elin Holderbrand we know and love.

Was this review helpful?