Member Reviews

She has such a way with words! I loved the concept of a mutual gift economy with nature and plants growing and extrapolating into the need for a gift economy in how we support each others work and efforts. Working for a nonprofit, I can see the reflection of this mutual give and take in how we support other organizations and receive support and funding from them in return. This book takes a concept as simple as sharing berries and makes a case for the end of capitalism as we know it. If that isn’t magic, what is?

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited to see Robin Wall Kimmerer expanding on her essay in Essence magazine of the same name. Friends, she did not disappoint. The Serviceberries is an approachable, accessible book that will remain as relevant and as thought provoking as its predecessor “Braiding Sweetgrass” still is at 10+ years after its release. It should be required reading alongside any financial literacy curriculum, in my opinion.

I have pre-ordered my copy with Birchbark Books and encourage anyone and everyone to do the same. This book is ripe for holiday reading!

Take some time and enjoy this one.

Tokšá aké, book friends


Special thanks to Robin Wall Kimmerer for sharing this gift, Scribner and NetGalley for the opportunity to review an eARC. It was a complete joy to read; a breathe of fresh air.

I’ll
Update this review when I post to social, 2 weeks prior to it’s pub date, as requested.

Was this review helpful?

The Serviceberry is a lovely and powerful essay on reciprocity and the potential of a gift economy in the face of our unsustainable current models— illustrated by the analogous natural systems that create the serviceberry and its ecosystem. It’s a timely message—thought-provoking and inspiring.

Was this review helpful?

Astounding and thoughtful. I want to be guided by Robin for the rest of my life. Serviceberries are my favorite berry and I have picked them for years. I enjoyed learning more about them and especially from this author. This should be essential reading for all.

Was this review helpful?

This essay was such a revelation about a gift economy. It makes so much sense; so much a book of hopefulness. I love Kimmerer’s voice.

Was this review helpful?

What a lovely book! Using serviceberries as a central touchpoint, Robin Wall Kimmerer writes about interconnection, reciprocity, kindness — and the fact that our resources are limited, and we must give, share, and connect. The serviceberry tree produces (apparently) sweet, juicy berries, which are eaten by woodland creatures, who distribute the seeds as they roam.  Distributing the seeds this way ensures both the continuation of the serviceberry species and the animals that feed on it.  Neither is self-sufficient. It’s a lovely and timely message, well told.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Reading Robin Wall Kimmerer's prose is something I find meditative, thoughtful, informative and inspiring. Similar to Braiding Sweetgrass, in The Serviceberry, a short and approachable read, Kimmerer shares her perspective of how things could be if there were some small and not-so-small shifts in how individuals and groups act in their everyday interactions and how they relate to the natural world around them. The line drawings that are interspersed in the book are similarly poignant in it's understated simplicity. There's a lot of food for thought in this slim volume and I hope it starts many conversations. Many thanks to NetGalley and Scribner for the e-arc.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to #Simon & Schuster and #NetGalley for letting me read an eGalley version of the book in exchange for my honest review.

I loved [book:Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Teachings of Plants|17465709] but it is a little long and wandering; this book is shorter -- really a long essay -- and more focused, which is very helpful, because it needs to reach a wide audience.

Taking the Serviceberry (known by many names, Saskatoon, Juneberry, Shadbush, Sugerplum among them) as an example of, as the subtitle says "Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World," Kimmerer describes an economy that might replace our current disastrous extractive economy with a more eco-friendly gift economy.

She has written about Native American societies and their use of the gifts from the land in Braiding Sweetgrass, and she returns to that theme, but this time she is focused not only on the natural world, but also on the science of economics. There is now an emerging ecological economics theory that suggests scarcity is not the driving force of economics in our world; it is actually a construct, and it is not serving us well.

I cannot recommend this book highly enough. It's a quick read and beautifully illustrated, but it also provides a lot of food for thought. Hopefully it will inspire many to become involved in a different relationship to the Earth and each other. Pre-order it now. Publication date is Nov. 19 -- just in time for holiday giving.

Was this review helpful?

This meditate quick read left me looking forward to finally seeing serviceberries on my tree in the backyard. Once I finished reading the book, I looked up a recipe for serviceberry pie. Informative and appreciative read about the history of the Serviceberry, a tree I picked up for free during Arbor Day two years ago that is growing quickly, and hopefully will be feeding the bird next summer.

Was this review helpful?

This book was short but clear in its message. It directly indicts the scarcity mindset as a cultural construct of capitalism and shows how antithetical to nature this mindset is. As our climate catastrophe grows nearer, the book is timely and urgent. The guidance is simple and easy to understand "Sustain the ones who sustain you and the Earth will last forever." I found the framing of "the cannibalization of life for accumulation of money" particularly compelling. I don't think this book will create a groundswell of change, but for those of us with our minds open, it will help to move us forward in the right direction.

I will return and update this review to include links to public social posts two weeks before publication date, as requested.

Was this review helpful?

Delighted to get my hands on something new from Kimmerer! This is a compact book that you can read very, very quickly—and then think about long after you turn the final page.

Was this review helpful?

Robin Wall Kimmerer did it again! What an absolutely crucial essay. Everyone should read The Serviceberry!

Touching on themes of abundance, reciprocity, and gift economies that were mentioned in her previous books, Kimmerer explores capitalism and economics through the lens of a Serviceberry. Seviceberry, or Saskatoon as it's often called where I live in Oregon, is a plant that gives freely and in abundance. Kimmerer explores how we as people might do so too. Through farm stands, Little Free Libraries, helping out neighbors, and love the idea grows throughout the pages.

I didn't expect to be brought to tears by a book barely 100 pages long, but just like she did with both Braiding Sweetgrass and Gathering Moss I found myself crying. How have we let it get this far? How do we continue to fail humanity as a whole? Kimmerer reminds us that it's not just "the System" that is doing it to us, but that "the System" is run by real people. People with names, people with addresses.

I highly recommend picking up a physical copy so you can see the gorgeous illustrations by John Burgoyne! What a gem of a book, that I hope makes it into every library, every economics classroom, and is shared and gifted far and wide.

Was this review helpful?

A short and sweet look at how we as individuals and communities can disrupt the hold that capitalism has on seemingly everything. I love Kimmerer's comparisons to the Serviceberry trees and how they help circulate resources for the betterment of all species around it instead of hoarding like capitalistic economies demand. It made for a lovely reading experience as she explored how we as people and neighbors can share our own excess and expect help in return in a form yet unknown to us at present. "I store my [extra] meat in the belly of my brother" was such a good way to encapsulate the understanding of community as protective and comforting when we care for each other in a way that ensures all are fed because one is successful. This book was beautifully meditative and has given me a lot to consider in my daily life going forward. Very good for readers who loved Braiding Sweetgrass or Elizabeth Gilbert.

Was this review helpful?

The Serviceberry is a very short book, but it manages to capture maybe the essential conflict underlying most of our problems (is that hyperbole? Maybe! But I don't think so!). Namely, the discord between gift economies and market capitalism. One encourages reciprocity and care for collective wellbeing and one....does not. Capitalism, being profit-driven, encourages privatization of resources, hoarding, artificial scarcity, and competition between individuals. It financially incentivizes pollution of communal property, like air and water, and necessitates growth for growth's sake, not to sustaining ecosystems (both social and environmental). Rather than collapse into futility, however, Kimmerer highlights some strategies for integrating gift economies into capitalism; I particularly appreciated her ode to public libraries as a model for this.
Ultimately, this is an encouraging and convincing call for individual action to move the needle towards reciprocity and care for the collective. A pessimist might say it's not enough, given the political hopelessness of abandoning capitalism, but Kimmerer intentionally avoids doing so. To motivate change, there has to be some hope for meaningful results. She shows us it's possible, if we can value and accept the scale at which like minded individuals can make an impact.
Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the arc!

Was this review helpful?

This book is a balm, so much food for thought in this exploration of a gift economy. We can be better and this essay shows us the path. The gift of gifts.... and the gift of giving, so much to ponder here, especially as I read this in the midst of a contentious election year. Robin Wall Kimmerer is a treasure. This book is a gift to the reader and all that surrounds us. Thanks to NetGalley for the gift of this reading experience.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure what to expect when I got the book but was positively delighted in the short length and the topic: reciprocity. It's been one on my mind a lot lately as we continue to battle the deluge in development and pollution and climate change. Kimmerer offers a no holds barred approach and cuts to the chase in this short book. Part of me wishes for her to write a bit more about it but this is the perfect length to allow someone to dip their toes and explore further in other works.

Was this review helpful?

-Thank you to Simon & Schuster for providing a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review. -

Dr. Robin Wall Kimmerer does it again! In a way that I have come to find only she can, Dr. Kimmerer teaches us about the lessons we can glean from the natural world in an approachable, digestible, and poetic manner. Dr. Kimmerer invites readers to reflect on the meaning of abundance and reciprocity by highlighting the natural gift economy created by Serviceberries. In doing so, she calls us on to challenge the construct of scarcity and explains the implications our consumptive economy has on Earth's natural resources.

As an Odawa reader, I appreciated Dr. Kimmerer's inclusion of Potawatomi language and Anishinaabe perspectives throughout the book; reading this book felt healing in a way I cannot yet describe. The illustrations throughout this book were beautiful and concise and a nice complement to Dr. Kimmerer's words. This book left me in a state of reflection and gratitude, questioning the ways in which I can engage in a reciprocal gift economy.

I highly recommend everyone read this important, concise work that Dr. Kimmerer has gifted us!

Was this review helpful?

I've previously read and enjoyed Gathering Moss, but never got around to Braiding Sweetgrass. I saw this one was short and available on Netgalley, so I thought I'd give it a shot. It's an expanded essay on the gift economy and fostering a spirit of abundance, rather than scarcity, centered around the abundant gifts from the serviceberry (which I'd never heard of before). Western economics is generally built on an assumption of scarcity, which leads to hoarding and other self-serving behaviors that become destructive, especially as they scale up. Kimmerer explores what might happen if we flipped that assumption, focusing on sharing and giving, taking only what we need, while making sure others have what they need. I love this in theory, but it's such a shift from how my world is structured, I have a difficult time envisioning how it would work in practice if I try to see it beyond close family, friends and neighbors.

I suspect I would have been as pleased with this in essay form, but I like might never have run across it, so I'm ultimately glad it was made into a book. Also, I read a digital copy and apparently I missed some good illustrations. I'll have to check to them out in a bookstore after the book comes out.

Thank you to Scribner and Simon and Schuster for providing this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a fan of Braiding Sweetgrass and this book is a great addition to Kimmerer's other books. I know fans of Kimmerer are going to come away from reading this ready to put these ideas into action in their life and in their communities. I enjoyed reading Kimmerer's thoughts on these topics and hope to see other books from her in the future focused on ideas like this we can put into action. The art is also lovely.
I posted a blog review of the book as well
https://paperbackpagan.wordpress.com/2024/09/11/the-serviceberry-by-robin-wall-kimmerer/

Was this review helpful?

My word, can Robin Wall Kimmerer write a stunning sentence. This short book is a love letter to nature. Braiding Sweetgrass was one of my favorite reads of 2022 because Kimmerer writes so beautifully about nature. In this one, she explores the connected relationship between nature and humanity, specifically within indigenous communities (of which she is a member) and how their nations treat the natural world, with a mutual respect and admiration. Put that against our own communities who often use nature in an exploitative, harmful way, which bleeds the environment and nature itself, dry. She focuses specifically on the serviceberry of the title to carry her point that our relationship to nature should be one focused on giving and caring. Kimmerer’s writing is like poetry, flowing with gorgeous imagery and a kind voice. I loved this.

Was this review helpful?