Member Reviews

Interesting representation of disability, family, and working through childhood crushes. Love novels in verse, compelling and fast paced. Will definitely recommend to kids in the library.

Was this review helpful?

“If there’s something I know how to control, it’s my body - if there’s something I know how to manage, it’s myself.”

Valentina Camacho is the most dedicated fencer on her elite team. She eats, sleeps, and sweats fencing. She did, that is, until the accident. Then, everything changed. Juggling physical therapy appointments, chronic leg pain, and frenemies she isn’t so sure of who she is anymore. If fencing isn’t everything to Vale, then what is?

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this novel about fencing and disability. It deals with middle school friendship drama and our main character, Vale, has to figure out who she is after an accident forces her to recover and take a break from fencing. There is also great LGBTQ representation here!

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this book about fencing. I feel like there's been a lot more written in this genre lately. I like how her strong competitiveness is portrayed and her determination to come back after an injury. I liked that her friendship with the other girl was complicated because of their rivalry. Great middle grade read!

Was this review helpful?

What happens when a middle schooler who is a nationally ranked fencer has an accident that results in chronic pain? Then add in broken friendships and crushes and pressure from parents and you have It's All or Nothing, Vale. There is a whole lot packed into this middle-grade novel in verse. I’m not always a fan of novels in verse, but when it’s done well, like it is in this book, it works. This is a great book and would be great to spark discussion about so many different issues that children face.

I received a digital ARC of this book thanks to NetGalley and the publishers.

Was this review helpful?

Vale is a youth champion fencer until she is injured in an accident and she must undergo intensive rehab on her leg making her return to the sport she loves questionable. As she tries to ease her way back into practice and eventual competition, she finds a new talented, pink ponytailed tween is stealing her spotlight. Vale refuses to give up as she tries to push through the pain, ignoring the sparkling pink cane in her closet and the advice of her mother, brother and physical therapist. As Vale struggles with the term “disability”, she also can’t decide if she has a crush on the friendly girl who has risen to the top of the team. Will it be all or nothing for Vale. Find out in the latest middle grade novel in verse by award winning author, Andrea Beatrice Arango.
I took fencing lessons when I was Vale’s age. It really is a fun and exciting sport that has not found the popularity it deserves. Maybe this beautifully written book packed with determination and sweetness will encourage more kids to give fencing a try!

Was this review helpful?

After an accident Vale struggles with who she is without fencing. Fencing was her whole world. As she fights to get back to fencing and fights the pain she constantly feels, she begins to question who she is becoming.

Was this review helpful?

I never thought I would find a character who mirrors my struggles as much. As you know Vale is an athlete who after a crash, has to endure surgery and all that comes with it. Even possible disability.

This past year, I also had a car crash that ended with a fractured wrist, surgery and months of physical therapy. One year later, I still deal with the aftermath. WOW Vale, you truly understood what's like going through that. One of the things I love the most about Andrea's books is that although they are technically "middle grade", it heals me as an adult. The pressure to go back to your old self as soon as possible, the pains, THE PAINS, the constant and new routine of self care, the endless doctor visits and you just trying to stay afloat. I'm in awe of the love put into this book, and also the hope.

Beautiful and much needed.

Was this review helpful?

Vale’s ongoing struggle with limitation after an accident has left her with chronic pain is such an important story. I especially appreciated how the author brought out that nearly everyone is going to experience disability at some point in their life.

Vale juggles pain, an intense competitive streak that’s already ended one friendship and may end a growing crush on her classmate, and learning to find joy in life.

As someone with an autoimmune disease that limits me. I loved how the author dealt with ongoing challenges, not making them magically disappear, but developing Vale's resilience.

Was this review helpful?

You know what is so great about the time we live in? Middle grade books cover SO MANY TOPICS and feelings and events, so that kids can read these books and be able to form their own wide range of thoughts and emotions, see themselves represented, and be given more tools for maturing. And then on the flip side, it gives adults like me vessels that help heal my inner child (and even my outer adult).

It's All or Nothing, Vale, is about a young Puerto Rican girl who is a competitive fencer. She has recently been in an accident that has caused her to have chronic pain in one of her legs. She is forced to reconcile this new life with her desire for fencing greatness, and is super frustrated when she can't hang like she used to. Then a new girl joins the team, and she is everything Vale thinks she herself needs to be.

This book was equal parts heartbreaking and hopeful. As someone with chronic pain, watching her learn that your value isn't tied up in what your body can accomplish, and that there are more things in life that can fill you with joy, was so relatable and validating. I'm in my 30s and needed a book like this at this time in my life. I needed this book when I was younger, too! So I am extremely impressed with the grace and emotion that this story was written with.

Highly recommend for everyone. Loved it.

Thanks to Random House Books and Netgalley for the e-ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I don’t read middle grade stories often, but the cover and synopsis of It's All or Nothing, Vale drew me in. Vale is a middle grade fencer who we meet after she’s been in an accident and is trying to get back to the fencing star she was before. She grapples with not being the same as she was pre-accident, trying to reconcile who she is when for so long she was a nationally ranked fencer and now she may be disabled. And of course, coming to terms with her new life is complicated by first crushes and family dynamics (no matter how much they love her) and made easier with new friendships.

As a novel told in verse, it’s hit and miss for me if the story can portray the deep emotions necessary for the subject. Here, I need not worry. This story is infused with emotions; you can feel what Vale is feeling. There is such a depth and a rawness that I wasn’t expecting from a middle grade book and it took me back to being a pre-teen and teen.

Was this review helpful?

Arangos verse novels are always beautiful and this was no different. An honest portrayal of a character learning to come to terms with disappointment and redirection in her life. With so many kids pushed into high stakes sports, I think young readers will relate to Vale’s struggles in this book. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

It's All or Nothing by Vale has my heart. I felt like I was walking in Vale's shoes, and every step of the way, I just wanted to give her a hug. After a life-changing accident, Vale is navigating her way back to her passion: fencing. And let me tell you, I know nothing about fencing, but I loved following her journey. The intensity of the sport has me wanting more.

The way her accident is handled, along with the emotional exploration of what it means for Vale, was both powerful and poignant. She repeatedly asks her physical therapist, "When do I get to stop seeing you?" Watching her grapple with those difficult conversations, and seeing her come to understand herself, was both heartbreaking and inspiring.

I would recommend this book to anyone. It pulled on my own memories of moments when I didn’t know what to do next, and I believe everyone can gain something from it. The prose was wonderful—short yet powerful, much like the sport of fencing itself. It left a lasting impact on me, and I can’t wait to read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

Vale is a 12 year old competitive fencer trying to recover from an accident that left her seriously injured and in intense physical therapy. The physical and mental challenges she grapples with will pull at your heartstrings. This middle grade novel in verse also tackles the normal everyday issues of a middle schooler than many students - not just student athletes - will relate to.

Was this review helpful?

Vale is a champion fencer on the way to becoming a national winner. Vale is under a lot of pressure from her parents, is an extremely competitive kid, and lacks any identity beyond the role of fencer. When Vale suffers a serious injury the road back to being a champion comes under question. And Vale's sense of self-worth is pretty much shattered. That is the novel's strength as most kids who play a sport will not be a professional or achieve world championship status. Vale is also finding her way in friendships and first romance. The parents are pretty stock characters, the stereotypical pushy parents hoping for college scholarships and national recognition. Other supporting characters add to the story but don't have much depth. Novels in verse are often hard to sell to kids. This is a good book, not a great book. It is nice to see a book that deals with fencing and not the usual sports. And, to see Vale navigate her way through a challenging time.

Was this review helpful?

"Middle grade novel in verse" is arguably one of my favorite genres to read, and Andrea Beatriz Arango is one of the *best* at writing this genre. Vale is one of those truly special characters whom I believe both young readers and adults will love and be able to relate to. Her perfectionism and fiercely competitive nature are some of her greatest strengths, but after sustaining a life-altering injury, she discovers that the fear of failure that comes along with her drive may also be one of her biggest weaknesses.

After returning to fencing for the first time after her accident, Vale must confront some difficult questions, including: Am I still worthy of love if I'm not the best at my sport? Is this what disability looks and feels like? Is disability even a word I would use to describe my experience? How can I let the people I love in?

Andrea Beatriz Arango skillfully infuses her poems with complex thematic layers, including friendship, family, young queer love, and disability. This is a must-read for students and teachers alike, and I have every intention of adding it to both my curriculum and classroom library.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Random House Children's for my advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

Novels in verse fly off our library shelves and Vale’s story is one our students will love. The family dynamics are realistically portrayed and their support of Vale in her struggles is heartwarming. Vale herself is complex, kind, and introspective but also quick tempered and frustrating- just like real middle schoolers! Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Another slam dunk by Andrea Beatriz Arango! A fencing female protagonist is original and important as are LBGTQ+ characters with disabilities. This novel in verse is a quick and emotional book that will be part of my classroom collection.

Was this review helpful?

The book tells the story of a girl who is coming back to the sport of fencing after an accident that has left her with pins in her leg and chronic pain. She returns to a team that includes her ex-bestfriend, Stephanie, and a new fencing star, Myrka. This was a great skeleton of a story but it needed more. I wanted more backstory about her falling out with Stephanie and why her friend held such resentment for her even after the accident. I also wanted more development of Vale's crush on Myrka. It felt like they lived in a time period when comp-het doesn't exist, and we are not there yet especially in the Latinx community. I can understand the author not wanting this to be a coming out book, but in doing so she neglected an important point in the story.

While I personally like reading books such as this that include Spanish phrases, I wish there were footnote translations for our readers who do not understand Spanish.

Was this review helpful?

Arango's writing gets stronger and stronger with each book. In It's All or Nothing, Vale, our main character must reevaluate her identity which was previously tightly wrapped around her fencing ability, but after a terrible accident she's left unmoored and lost. Who is she if she's not a fencer? Vale must learn to let go and step into an uncertain future - which includes confusing feelings around the word disabled - but includes the help of her family, a new friend, and a new crush!! Arango's writing is as sharp as her former fencing champ!

Was this review helpful?