This was such a cute and cozy fantasy. Although it’s YA, it felt PG enough that it also seems appropriate for younger readers as well. The world building was fabulous, and the mysteries—though pretty predictable—were fun.

However, I do wish Sage had been a little voicier, had more chemistry with Ximena, and that the other characters had been a tad more distinctive from each other.

Highly recommended to anyone who loves witchy reads and cozy fantasy.

I received an advanced copy from the publisher and am voluntarily leaving this review.

This seemed like an ideal book however I had high expectations that ran flat. Throughout the story, I became a bit bored, couldn't invest my time to finish the book. Maybe if I was more open to this certain satire I would've enjoyed it much more. In all honesty, I did not like this satire as much. I prefer fantasy romance or comedic stories.

this book had the perfect autumn vibes which i loved. i enjoyed the characters but sometimes they acted so immaturely and it really threw me off. i think this book was made for younger audiences but it still had its fun moments!

thank you netgalley for the e-arc!

This was a fun sapphic read that I enjoyed but didn’t really love. I thought the book read more on the younger YA than older YA. Sometimes the characters felt more immature than being high school seniors. At times there were comments from the main characters about how they were “so young” in their relationship and I had to laugh cause it meant they were talking about being in middle school.

The wolf mystery was pretty easy to guess right off the bat but the break-in mystery was a little more difficult to figure out.

Enjoyable read but would recommend to those that enjoy a younger YA vibe. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this ARC. All opinions are my own.

DNF at 20%. This had fun and engaging writing, but unfortunately was a bit more on the younger side of YA than I anticipated. The side characters and magic system were really interesting, but the main characters were a bit too immature and the mystery was obvious as well.

This novel absolutely falls into the category of cozy fantasy! Even more, it's sapphic! A win on all fronts - love this book!

"Brewed with Love" by Shelly Page is a delightful and cozy novel that expertly blends romance with the comforting allure of a small-town café. The story follows the journey of its protagonist, who finds solace and a fresh sense of purpose in her family-owned coffee shop. Page’s writing is warm and inviting, much like the setting she creates, and her portrayal of the close-knit community adds a layer of charm to the narrative. The romantic storyline, while sweet, is grounded in genuine emotional growth, and readers will likely find themselves rooting for the protagonist as she navigates both love and self-discovery.

Despite its many strengths, the novel occasionally falls into the trap of predictability. The romance, while enjoyable, follows a well-trodden path, and some readers may find the plot too familiar. The character development, particularly of the romantic leads, can also feel a bit shallow at times. While their chemistry is evident, the depth of their relationship could have been explored with a bit more nuance. Additionally, the pacing of the story can sometimes be uneven, with the central conflict taking a backseat to the more leisurely moments in the café, which, though pleasant, may cause the narrative to lose momentum.

Nevertheless, "Brewed with Love" is an engaging and heartwarming read that will likely appeal to fans of feel-good romance and small-town charm. Shelly Page’s talent for creating a cozy atmosphere and relatable characters ensures that the novel remains an enjoyable experience, even if it doesn't venture far beyond the conventions of the genre. Perfect for readers seeking a lighthearted and comforting escape, this book offers a satisfying blend of love, community, and the magic of coffee.

I absolutely loved this book. It was such a good balance of a light hearted teen love story and a captivating mystery set in the most charming world. I love the way that the author was able to build this very modern, magical world and provide interesting details without becoming overwhelming. I'd love to see more books set in this town and maybe following other characters (I need Nana and Tiva's love story!) All around, the characters were lovable, the lore was interesting, and the break-in mystery kept me on my toes throughout. Thank you for letting me read and review!

Brewed with Love by Shelly Page is a charming, feel-good romance that’s as warm and comforting as a cup of coffee. With a heartwarming storyline and relatable characters, Page weaves a tale of second chances, self-discovery, and the magic of love. A perfect blend of sweetness and depth, this novel is a delightful escape for fans of lighthearted yet meaningful romance.

Brewed with Love is a sweet, lower stakes YA story about first loves/first hurts. This story had a few small twist that had we wondering who could be responsible for the robbery at the shop. This novel is a bit on the slower side but still enjoyable.
Thank you to Random House Children's, Joy Revolution & NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest book review.

4.5 rounded to 5 on GR
—
Very much cozy sapphic! The reason it was more of a 4-4.5 stars for me is because I forgot it was a YA book 😅 and I’m aware that it being YA doesn’t mean adults can’t enjoy it… However, it def felt a little too ‘young’ for my taste (27yo) so I thought I’d share in case other people feel similar to me.

That being said, it was super cute and cozy! I got an eARC for this book and found myself smiling throughout. Kinda made me feel giddy about what a younger self would’ve felt like or thought had i grown up with books like this one.

def recommend as a sapphic read, more so if you don’t mind YA

Cozy, witchy, AND sapphic? What a treat. I love a small town setting, especially when characters have to team together to save a small family business. This story is full of mystery, magic, apothecary potions, werewolf lore, childhood nostalgia, friends to lovers, and comes with cute potion recipes! A very delightful YA read.

Brewed with Love was a perfect queer witchy cozy read for October! It included a mystery that wasn't super high-stakes (at least compared to mysteries I'm used to reading) but still kept you interested in reading to find out what happens. The magic system was cute and interesting too. I also enjoyed and appreciated the romance with Ximena and Sage, although the development felt a little awkwardly paced to me at times.
Overall, I would definitely recommend this to anyone interested in a cozy sapphic witch romance/mystery.

A very sweet treat from author Shelly Page: a mystery and a story about love and redemption, about being, and loving, your true and whole self. Sprinkle in some magic and what's not to love?

Thank you for the opportunity to read an e-ARC for Brewed with Love. Ah, it was such a fun read that just made me feel warm and fuzzy.

This is definitely a cute and cozy read. I enjoyed the world building with the different types of magic the various witches in the coven practice. I liked how much thought went into brewing potions. And I liked the growth the main character had as she was forced to work with ex best friend.

The love interest has a big secret I was able to call early on, but I am so glad I was right. It was such a fun twist and I liked how it added depth to the story.

Overall if you’re looking for a cozy mystery with a big heaping side of paranormal romance, this book is perfect for you!

This sweetly romantic, mystery-tinged story charmed me from the start. Shelly Page has a way with words, and each sentence rooted me to every aspect of the story, from the characters, the world portrayed in the book, and the carefully built magic system within it. I loved the roll-out of information in regards to Sage's past and her relationship (and the cause of her terrible heartbreak) with her former bestie, Ximena. I was rooting for Sage to get to the bottom of the mystery *and* find a cure for her heartbreak the entire time, and was never disappointed with the clues leading up to the big reveal. This book is cozy, it is romantic, and it is everything I've ever wanted in a contemporary witchy fantasy. I will be shouting about this book for years to come.

This was just so cozy and the small town magic worldbuilding really worked here. I adored Sage and Ximena's relationship buildup and I thought it was going to be very predictable but it wasn't, it just the right amount of trope and sweetness to make for an incredible read.

4.5 stars

An adorable second chance Sapphic romance with cozy fantasy elements and a mystery alongside it.

Sage Bishop wants nothing more than to forget the reappearance of her ex-best friend and former crush Ximena Reyes, especially at the apothecary Sage's grandmother owns, so Sage works on a tonic to cure her heartache. When a break-in at the shop reveals someone has swiped the tonic attempt and used it on a student, wiping her memory, Sage and Ximena team up to investigate.

I loved a lot of the aspects of this book. The cozy town feel, the magical worldbuilding, and the sweet Sapphic romance between Sage and Ximena were absolutely fantastic. The mystery was interesting, if not a bit predictable, as was the revelation with Ximena, but it didn't detract from the enjoyment of reading. I think this is a perfect witchy read for teens! (Be warned, it looks like a fall read, but it takes place in spring.) I'm excited to read more from Shelly Page after this magical debut!

Thank you to NetGalley and publisher for the opportunity to read and review.

This book was extremely perfect for the season! It was funny, atmospheric and easy to get into. A quick read but one that will stick with me. Loved the adorable characters and the story was so fun!!