truly loved this book! Fabulous rom-com! Aspen is a best selling author that’s in a writing slump and is on a deadline. She heads to the Outer Banks to write at her sister’s home. Loved this familiar setting. The author transported to OBX so well. I loved her writing about the wild horses and turtle nests. Brick local bad bay, but is he really. Brick is running his deceased grandfather’s tourist business. They strike a mutually agreed upon deal and fiction turns to reality quickly. Such an expected fun read! Thank you to Net Galley and Blue Box Press for this advance read

Reading Book of The Month by Jennifer Probst felt like watching a 2000s rom-com—you know, the kind where weird corny stuff happens, and you just have to go with it to enjoy the ride. The story is fun and light, but there were definitely moments where I had to just go along with whatever was happening.

The romance between the two leads, Aspen and Brick, could have used a bit more depth. The insta-love was so strong that I found myself wishing for more buildup—but this is honestly just a personal preference thing.

Certain conflicts added drama but also felt a bit contrived. The ML is also too much of a green flag that I wish we could have had the chance to see more of his flaws just so he feels more attainable/relatable/realistic.

Likewise, certain scenes were also a bit over-the-top that I decided to just take it as pure comic relief (and enjoyed it that way).

Aspen’s life as an author and the insights into publishing were interesting, but her obsession with the idea that getting her heart broken was the only way to write a successful novel was a bit much (even though that’s literally the entire premise of the book). She kept repeating this over and over, which made it feel a bit corny and also made me question her skill as a writer.

Overall, Book of the Month is fun, easy to consume, and perfect if you’re looking to turn your brain off for a bit with some romance with a dash of spice.

A fun entertaining romantic read. Some of the "romance" might be too explicit for some, but all in all a well developed story. Especially liked the Outer Banks history of turtles and wild mustangs. Now it is on my bucket list to visit.

Like a lot of rom-coms, this one is superbly readable and I devoured it quickly. I love a book about books and our FMC Aspen is an author, trying to churn out her next big bestseller.

Aspen is hindered, however, by a lack of emotions since her first big hit. Two other books followed with little fanfare. What’s different? Aspen wrote her first book after a colossal heartbreak, so she engineers another heartbreak to fuel her creativity for her next book of the month.

This was fun, I enjoyed the OBX setting and most of the characters. However, there was a lot of repetition (if I have to read ocean-blue or cocoa-brown as eye color descriptions again I might scratch out my own ocean-blue eyes) and the MCs names were grating - Aspen Lourde and Brick Babel? Is this a porn? So…fun but with a little gag warning from this sporadic romance reader.

Review coming soon!

Thanks to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for the ARC.

Opinions are mine.

I picked this book based on the summary because I thought it was an intriguing plot with a twist on the typical “fake dating” trope. I liked the relationship between the main characters, and their support of each other was sweet. I felt the book was a little slow and could have been edited down quite a bit, there were some parts that felt like they had already been written and I was having to read them again when I just wanted to move on. I also had a hard time with the names of so many characters: Brick, Ursula, Maleficent, Kane, Anastasia, etc. To have one weird Disney villain name is one thing, to have several really takes me out of the story and reminds me this is fiction because no small town has that many crazy names. Otherwise is was a cute read, and I’m tempted to pick up Sierra and Kane’s story next.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

I thought about DNF’ing this book numerous times but kept reading because I needed something mind numbing for a hectic work week. This book was not for me. I was invested in about 5% of the end.

Things I liked:
-that Aspen was the one to break Bricks heart and win him back.

Things I didn’t like:
-the heavy repetition of the words: male, female, masculine, feminine, greedy, greedily, tremble, shudder, aftershocks, clenching.
-why was everyone so mean when they talked about Dug?
-why was PTSD thrown about lightly?
-if Sierra and Kane have a story, why is their story not sprinkled in more
-not very relatable & fell kind of flat
-I’m bummed I pushed through this one


An ARC was received in exchange for an honest review.

Oh man! The premise of this book was really promising but sadly I had to DNF this one. Aspen is an author who is struggling to follow up on the success of her first book. To resolve this issue, she decided to pursue the MMC Brick in hopes of getting "book material" from a future heartbreak. It was so hard to relate to Aspen. At times, I struggled understanding why she is the way she is and the things she does. Brick is also not endearing. Their interaction is pained and forced and I didnt feel any type of connection between the two. Aspen seeking out Brick is borderline harassment. I just couldnt get on the love story. They didnt endear me or made me giddy. This is the first Jennifer Probst book I've read (or tried to) so I dont know if this is unique to this book or not. I will definitely try reading another one of her books to see. Overall, again had to DNF. Great premise, just didnt deliver.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for a honest review.

An easy, fun, summer romance. This book was predictable at most times, but still kept me engaged. The OBX beach setting was perfect for visuals. I liked that Aspen and Brick both heard each other and made the other feel seen. It was fun seeing Aspen find herself for what may have been the first time ever. It does have one of my least favorite tropes, but it needed to happen for this story and wasn’t a heavy hitter. I’d recommend this for a summer beach read.

Aspen is desperate for another bestseller. Ever since making it big with her first book, that she wrote from her own experience with heartbreak, she just hasn’t been able to recreate the magic with her last two books. Under pressure by her readers, publisher and her agent; she decides to take the summer to write a sequel to her first book while spending the summer vacationing with her sister in OBX. She just needs to find the perfect guy to fall in love with and break her heart to spark her writing…

Brick inherited his grandfather’s wild horse touring business in OBX less than a year ago and you might say things aren’t going the best. The women in town think he’s a hunky heartbreaking savage and his competition in town is sabotaging him at every angle. If he doesn’t get some cash flow soon he’s going to lose his grandfather’s business.

Could Brick and Aspen come to an agreement to help each other out? Other will this intentional heartbreak bring disaster for both of them?

This book was such a fun, sexy baby read. This was my first Jennifer Probst book and I absolutely loved it! At times, the book was predictable however the premise of the book was intriguing. I enjoyed the main character developments and their chemistry. The secondary characters were so refreshing and made me want to visit OBX! Can’t wait for the second book in the series, The Reluctant Flirt to come out!

This book was an absolute blast to read! The fake dating trope is always a favorite of mine, but the author took it to another level by weaving it into a story about an author in crisis and a business in need of saving. The setup led to plenty of laugh-out-loud moments, especially when the lines between reality and pretense started to blur.

What really made this story stand out was the chemistry between the main characters. Their banter was sharp, funny, and filled with just the right amount of tension. Watching them navigate their fake relationship while both trying to solve their own problems added a layer of depth to the usual rom-com formula. The humor was spot on, and there were several scenes that had me grinning from ear to ear.

And let’s talk about the steam! The slow build-up of attraction was perfectly done, making those moments of closeness feel all the more intense. The way the author balanced the comedic elements with the romance kept the story engaging from start to finish.

If you're a fan of fake dating stories This book was an absolute blast to read! The fake dating trope is always a favorite of mine, but the author took it to another level by weaving it into a story about an author in crisis and a business in need of saving. The setup led to plenty of laugh-out-loud moments, especially when the lines between reality and pretense started to blur.

What really made this story stand out was the chemistry between the main characters. Their banter was sharp, funny, and filled with just the right amount of tension. Watching them navigate their fake relationship while both trying to solve their own problems added a layer of depth to the usual rom-com formula. The humor was spot on, and there were several scenes that had me grinning from ear to ear.

And let’s talk about the steam! The slow build-up of attraction was perfectly done, making those moments of closeness feel all the more intense. The way the author balanced the comedic elements with the romance kept the story engaging from start to finish.

📖📖 Book of the Month 📖📖 Adulting is hard, it’s especially hard after loss and heartache. And sometimes art imitates life; Aspen doesn’t do happily ever after endings in her books. Perhaps that’s why she has been a one hit wonder. There is one tried and true way to refresh and renew that never fails me….the beach. And Aspen is trading in the cement of Manhattan for some respite in the sand of the Outer Banks with her sister. A handsome tour operator with a reputation with the ladies catches Aspen’s attention and has her thinking he might just be her inspiration. Book of the Month reminds us that it is totally okay to feel overwhelmed and in over our head in the adulting world. And thank you Jennifer Probst for the reminder that taking a break to go to the beach is always a perfect way to recharge and start fresh.

Review is on Goodreads and will be posted on instagram closer to publication date and on Amazon when published!

Aspen, a writer, is currently going through a rough patch as her last two books have failed to do well. She thinks it is because her debut novel, was autobiographical in nature, and hence more real. So, she plans on going through a similar heartbreak to basically get her career back on track. That is where our MMC Brick comes in.
It is a cozy summer-read full of romance, angst, and butterflies. Aspen will have you screaming at her, meanwhile, Brick will make you root for him from the start. I actually loved the fact that it is Aspen in this situation, who breaks Bricks heart, and has to grovel.
A nice read.
Thanks to NetGalley, the author, and Blue Box Press for the ARC.


https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6787108081

Everything you want as a [romance] mood reader in the summer… it’s got: great banter, sunny Carolina/Outer Banks beach setting, fake dating, a book about books (publishing/writing), a bit of spice, small-town romance, lovable main AND side characters.

The main character Aspen is a romance author who is trying to find her spark again writing a new book after her first was a hit… and this gave me the vibes of Yellowface but WAY better!

I personally didn’t like Yellowface because it was way too depressing and a bit too factual about the publishing industry (which is totally fine— just not my cup of tea), but this book described the publishing industry with a happier light to all of its ups and downs. Plus, the main plot of the book is the romance so that helps.

For fans of Emily Henry, this was a cozy enjoyable read. Honestly the only thing I would change about this book is the title so as not to be confused with the book box subscription service.

I was offered this book by Netgalley and grabbed it. To my delight this takes place in my Happy Place.... OBX. Loved the story and characters. The friendly banter and romance and spice.
I highly recommend this book. Thank you Netgalley for introducing me to a new author.

I loved this book. Jennifer’s writing style is it for me. Realistic, sassy, funny, sexy, quirky, all of it. This book did not disappoint. I received an early copy and found a couple of small discrepancies that I reached out to the author about. Overall, this book was very well written and easy to read.

I didn’t really connect with this book. I thought the fake dating didn’t have enough fake. There was barely any transition from fake to real. It was almost immediately a real relationship, which seemed unrealistic to me. There was no growth of feelings, they just appeared. Brick fell flat for me as he just an “ideal” stereotype of a hot guy misunderstood. I really wanted to like it but just wasn’t for me. It seemed less about real love and just lust and sexual attraction.

oh i THOROUGHLY enjoyed this. probst was a new author to me and after being initially drawn in by the title (i subscribe to botm haha) i gave it a shot and boy am i glad i did! this was such a beautifully written book and the subtle romance had me enthralled the entire way through, will def be reading more from her.

I really wanted to like this book and gave it my all, but it fell flat.


Things I didn’t like about this book:
1. Aspen in general. She was so hard to tolerate. She seemed to have multiple personalities. Sometimes she was super serious and sullen, while other times she had golden retriever energy. Too much back and forth on this
2. Brick’s behavior toward his dog Dug. He literally calls this precious creature “the dumbest dog he’d ever had the pleasure of meeting.” He then went on to say “You know what I dreamed of for years? A lab. Well trained, intelligent, and energetic….but I got you instead.” That dog was waiting by the door, wagging his tail and so excited for Brock to come home and he says that? I instantly disliked him and didn’t care what happened next. You can tell a lot about how a person treats animals.
3. I know I dislike Brick, but the way the whole town sexualizes him just didn’t sit well with me. I know women are sexualized all the time, but that’s doesn’t mean we should do that to them or men.
4. The movement of the story was so slow. I really tried to get into this one, but it was a struggle to keep my interest.
5. I love the publishing industry, but there was too much talk of this in the novel.

Not my cup of tea. This is my first book by this author, and well will see if I try her again.

*An ARC was received in exchange for an honest review.