Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Historical fiction isn’t a genre that I reach for a lot. But, I enjoyed this book a lot! It sucked me in and I couldn’t put it down until I finished it! I highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

i am so conflicted with this book. it had such a fun premise and i LOVE a historical fiction like this. the writing was engaging and i obviously flew threw it.

i think my conflict comes with each of the third-act conflicts. each of these women were perfectly set up and we could have finished the book. maybe that is all on me for being so hopeful for a happy ending. i just think those conflicts were thrown in there so the author could write another book with these characters. i think i would be more satisfied with even ONE of the girls getting a happier ending.

anyway, the characters were interesting and wonderful to follow. i will be reading the next one so my girls can have a good ending!!!

*thank you to NetGalley and Dial Books for the e-arc of this book for my review*

Was this review helpful?

This novel introduces us to four amazing black women living in Chicago in the early 1910s. We follow their story of trying to find happiness and reaching their desires in their world against family expectations, misogyny, class, and racism. Through four separate POVs we get to meet each of the girls and explore their lives. I don't normally like multiple POVs, but this one, even with four POVs, was written so well, leaving me invested in each of their lives.

First we have Olivia, a woman who meets society's expectations for a woman of her status, looking for a husband, doing charity, etc. Until she stumbles into a civil rights meeting, and in addition to finding herself very attracted to the speaker at the meeting, discovers a desire to stand up for people like her across the country and fight against societal issues like Jim Crow. But, she has a match her parents like, and those same parents are scared for her safety, given their own experiences when they moved to Chicago.

Next, her younger sister Helen, a tomboy who wants nothing to do with the expectations put upon her, only wanting to fix automobiles with her brother in their family shop. She's foiled by her family hiring a manners coach for her, and falling in love with the man she things her sister loves. Her story centered around proving herself and fixing out her love life.

Next is Ruby, Olivia's best friend, whose father is running for mayor, and as such, her family is broke. Struggling to cope with this massive change in her life, she is also trying to win the love of her old crush, Olivia and Helen's brother, John, both to please her parents and, she thinks, herself. But, in her ploy to win his heart, she stumbles into love with another man, and has to decide what is more important to her: her parents approval or her own heart.

Finally, there's Amy Rose, a maid in the Davenport's home who wants to be a business owner (think Madam C. J. Walker). She's saved for a spot in town to sell her wares, and, to her dismay, finds herself falling for John. She faces both a combination of misogyny and racism as a black woman trying to start a business, and class issues both for her business and in getting approval for her and John's relationship.

Their worlds fall apart towards the end of the book, and I can't wait for the sequel in the hopes things improve. The characters are great and engaging and I love them. My only main grievance is I hate that it falls into the corset trap or treating them like terrible torture devices. They're just bras. They just hold parts where they need to be. If anything, with all the things Helen does, she would need the support most.

Was this review helpful?

i like the idea of this book-- a diverse romance set in the early 1900s, but it felt the tiniest bit bland to me. however, i still enjoyed it enough and will be looking forward to the second book.

Was this review helpful?

Starting off strong, I love the idea of this book. I love the time period this is set in, I love it being set in Chicago, I love that this is focused on a wealthy black family instead of a white family that is stereotypical of the genre. It sounded like it was going to be a fresh breath of air for someone who has been heavily in the historical romance genre lately. The writing style on this is wonderful and I look forward to giving this book a second try in the future, but as a mood reader I put this down and moved on and I haven't had the urge to go back and pick this up at all. It was easy enough to read and I was enjoying it as I read it, but all four perspectives seemed to have very similar issues in their romance plots. I felt like I was just going in circles with each shift in perspective, but I know this may be a "me" issue because once a book goes over three perspectives, I lose interest quickly. I truly only enjoyed Amy-Rose's perspective because of the dream of opening her own business; it was at least something that made her stand out.

Was this review helpful?

I truly enjoyed this story about a wealthy black family back in the gilded age. This book gave a bit of the historical fiction, but was more centered around the romance component, which was fine! I did appreciate the deviation from the typical white family, getting to see this side of history though another set of eyes. I really enjoyed this book! Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a review copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this. I liked reading about black characters during this period of history. I hope we get more like this.

Was this review helpful?

What a fantastic debut. The stories in The Davenports are so strong.
While I had some trouble following 4 different points of view, I did adore each character and their unique struggles. This is the kind of book that has a character for everyone to relate to.
I'm particularly drawn to Ruby's story and am so interested in reading about her future.
One thing to note when going into this book is that because it's about 4 different characters, the book feels like a lot of set up. However, that just means that the next book will be even more jam-packed, and I can't wait for it!

Thank you to Penguin and Netgalley for the digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I like it, it is interesting, especially because it offers a different history and culture pov. And I love multiple pov novels and family drama. I’m really glad to have read it and can’t wait for the sequel. I really want to know how the story will develop.

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

It’s 1910 and the Davenports are one of the only Black families in the United States with immense wealth and status, even if not everyone chooses to recognize them as such. Olivia, the oldest Davenport daughter, is ready to marry as is her duty. Her younger sister Helen yearns to be a mechanic even though it goes against everything a young lady is supposed to do. And Amy-Rose, who was their childhood best friend but is currently their maid, is in love with the Davenport’s brother. All three women find themselves harboring secret desires that may or may not be the answers to their happiness.

I’d been anticipating this one for a while, and I may have gotten my expectations up a bit too high. I loved the premise, the setting, and the idea of the characters but everything just fell flat.

There were a few main things that didn’t work for me. This story is told from the POV of four women who are right around the same age, but there wasn’t enough development or personality present in their depictions for their voices to be easily differentiated. This was disappointing and made it quite difficult not only to keep them straight for the first portion of the book, but also to connect with them at all.

Then came the romances. Every relationship essentially had the same conflict/issues (everyone fell in love with someone they “weren’t supposed” to love according to society). I disliked how perfectly and neatly the romances all came together and that there was someone for everyone until all the third act breakups (which I also disliked). This didn’t help with keeping the characters apart and felt much too formulaic.

Despite a few elements of conflict introduced, there was never a real feeling of tension or anticipation relating to them. This might be related to the fact that the characters weren’t as strong as they should be or that this was supposed to be romance focused, but sacrificing any real conflict or tension for romance isn’t the way to go. There also just wasn’t much of a plot, and the characters weren’t strong enough to carry this lack.

If you’re interested in YA historical romances then you may enjoy this one, but it wasn’t as strong as I hoped it would be (though I do love that cover!). My thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Group for allowing me to read this work. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I have always loved reading from a commonly misrepresented historical perspective. The Davenports hits the nail on the head with that. Their family and friends have really deep characterization that developed into a passionate story with romance, politics and friendship. All perspectives in this novel vary greatly and beautifully ties their stories together.

Was this review helpful?

1910 Chicago. The Davenports, founders of the Davenport Carriage Company, are the premier Black family in the city, leaders among the Black community and influential as well within some of the White. The story follows the lives of two of their daughters, Olivia and Helen, their friend Ruby, and a young woman on the staff that they grew up with, Amy-Rose. Both the time period and their families have strong expectations for all of them, and naturally, none of them are happy with those limitations. Olivia wants to marry someone she loves as well as find meaning in her life beyond parties and household. Helen is more interested in fixing cars and expanding the carriage business than finding a husband. Ruby is in love with the Davenport son and expected to reel him in for her families political aspirations, until she finds someone else. And Amy-Rose wants to start her own business and start out on her own.
All the pieces are there, and the action and romance proceed exactly as expected. Unfortunately quite predictably until the end. The ending was that much more powerful because that predictability was finally broken, and things livened up for a bit. My biggest problem though, was with the four girls. While they had different interests, their personalities and temperaments were all alike. I could not tell them apart I just did not find myself rooting for them the way I wanted to; it was more of an "are we there yet?" Disappointing.

Was this review helpful?

I thought I would like this book more than I did. By the time I read it, it had gotten a lot of really good reviews. I think the author tried to do too much, and that is what made it fall a little flat. The Davenports are based on a real family that would have made a great story had she really delved into the family history more, but instead the story focuses more on the romance of the three Davenport kids and their close family friend. The romances all follow a very similar plot line which made it quite repetitive. Had this book been more focused, either on the historical aspect or on the romance of one of the characters it would have made the book easier to read. I think the author had a really great idea for a book and it could have been something but as it is I was underwhelmed, especially considering the hype.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the e-copy of this book!

3 ⭐️
0 🌶️

I think this book had lots of potential to be good but it just wasn’t my style of book. Many people say this is like a ‘black Bridgeton’ and i can see why people say that but it’s just not for me.

I felt like the book did tend to go around in circles a lot which is why i did lower my rating. And also i’m not a huge fan of the time frame in the book but i know that that’s a me problem.

Was this review helpful?

The Davenports is a wonderful historical romance novel that moves through the perspectives and stories of a few siblings. This book is definitely giving all of the Bridgerton vibes. I loved all of the characters, my favorites being Olivia, Washington and Amy-Rose. Sometimes I think character development can get lost in stories that have different POVs but I didn't think that was the case here. The setting was really well developed and all of the details were great. I was enthralled.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this one. The overall pace and character development were good. The plot of how the story developed was good and enjoyable. I didn’t feel lost or like I needed to catch up. I am looking forward to reading the second one when it comes out

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this e-ARC!
DNF @ 62%
2 stars

I tried reallllly hard to finish this book, and I told myself I was going to. But honestly, what was the point when I only read it to be finished with it.

I can understand people liking this. It's romance heavy, quick to read through, and has some interesting situations going on. Also, gotta love Black #ownvoices rep, and it has a fun angle of privileged Black protagonists seeing the reality of Black treatment. That was what was really compelling to me about Olivia's side of the story.

At the end of the day, though, the book felt a bit too aimless for me. Even romances typically have another plot driving the romance, but this felt like romantic scene after romantic scene, with too little plot woven in. And what was there was such a light sprinkling that it didn't feel fulfilling to me. Things also felt repetitive because of this format, and there's some really side-eye-y romances. Like, it's explainable, but also feels like the icks weren't necessary. Honestly, I think if the book focused on two PoV characters at most and really expanding upon the characters rather than the very breezed-through way it is now. But hey, maybe some people like that style way more than I do!

People looking for an easy, romance-heavy read who like multiple storylines in one book will likely enjoy this book a lot, but I didn't personally find it hitting the marks.

Was this review helpful?

*I received a copy of this book on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for this opportunity*

<b>Olivia Davenport</b> is the eldest daughter that can do no wrong. Poised, polite, and beautiful, Olivia is on the cusp of deciding upon an advantageous match that will further secure her family's future in Chicago's elite upper-crust. However, when her eyes are opened to the world outside the ballroom, Olivia struggles to reconcile her expected roles as wife and eventual mother with a growing passion for civil rights.

Olivia's younger and more rebellious sister, <b>Helen Davenport</b>, has no desire to get married. More comfortable in her father's garage disassembling a Model-T than wearing a corset, the restrictions of her gender and familial expectations mean she's labeled as the family trouble maker. But unexpected acceptance from her sister's beau may have her heart leading her down a dangerous path...

<b>Amy-Rose Shepherd</b> has served in the Davenport household since she was a young girl, acting as playmate for Olivia and Helen while her mother's worked in the kitchens. Desperate to make her own way in the world, out from under the thumb of the Davenport influence, Amy-Rose has her eyes set on a storefront for her own salon specializing in the care and maintenance of black hair textures. But just as she's ready to take the leap, everything around her begins to fall apart.

Family friend and confidant of Olivia, <b>Ruby Tremaine</b> has dreamed of officially becoming a Davenport (by marrying John, Olivia and Helen's brother) for most of her life. Her father's campaign for the first black mayor of Chicago has left the family's coffers nearly depleted, and suddenly the weight of her family's future rests on securing the match. However, John's eyes are wandering and the scheme to bring his jealous gaze back onto her has backfired in the best way.

Set in the 1910s, THE DAVENPORTS follow four black women during a time of lavish wealth for some and social upheaval for others. Often compared to the Bridgerton series, Downtown Abbey, or Gossip Girl, I feel like a more accurate comparison would be American Royals. Full of drama, teenage angst, complicated romantic entanglements, and four perspectives (that can, admittedly, get very confusing at times), THE DAVENPORTS fees like a historical, African-American version of Katharine McGee's popular YA series.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this story! I also think it’s an important one to read as it deals with racism. I absolutely love this cover as well!

Was this review helpful?

This read is Bridgerton for YA in the best way possible!
It does read like it is for a younger audience but personally, I think it is a good read for any age.
I loved that each sister had their own thing going on, had interests of their own, and did not want to fit into society norms.
Can't wait for the sequel!

Was this review helpful?