Member Reviews
Thank you to Atria Books and Netgalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review and feedback.
We Lived on the Horizon is my third book of Erika Swyler's. While it's really interesting, I wouldn't say I enjoyed it nearly as much as her two previous works.
This is her take on speculative science fiction where AI controls the walled city and the houses within. The world is very imaginative and has a really interesting take on a new economic system where perceived sacrifice is rewarded. After generations, a new class of ultra-rich are deemed Saints and can attain luxuries that extend lives like years credited in a bank account. As opposed to the non-Saints, who can't afford such things and are most likely in some form of life debt.
It's a slow burn, thought-provoking story. Without giving too much away the connectedness of the city was interesting, as well as the socioeconomics and class hierarchies. I did find my interest waning about halfway through. When the nature of being human is discussed for too long, my eyes just glaze. There was only ever one way this story could go and I think it found its natural conclusion.
I really thought I would love this one. The premise and post-apocalyptic world 300 years in the future sounded so promising. But it just didn't some together in a satisfying way for me. Maybe what's left of humanity is surviving inside a walled city. Everything is controlled by artificial intelligence. People are born with or without a debt to society and have to work to pay it back accordingly. Sainted people are descendants of the founders of the city, and receive transplants from body martyrs. Unrest is growing among the working class, and holes are appearing in the code of the computer systems. The world building took almost the entire novel, with the main action happening in the last couple of chapters. There was a lot of character development, but it centered almost entirely on the characters' romantic lives. The character with the biggest story arc was actually an AI system that controls the house of one of the human characters. Nix is transitioning into a body and is losing touch with the "mainframe" of the city. I guess I'm just not ready for "house system as a person" characters.
This is a great choice if you want mellow intrigue. The story was a bit hard to follow at first, but I eventually figured things out. I personally prefer more intensity and action. This book would be perfect for anyone who wants to know that there’s tension and violence and mutiny happening but wants to watch it from afar, where it’s safer.
There are robot people who are Martyrs who donate their limbs for others because of debt (not financial). The Sainted come from lines of good people robots and can do no wrong. The city is Bulwark. I can’t tell you much else. Thank you to Atria Books for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
I was pretty excited about this book when I read the description - AI, a speculative future in a post apocalyptic world. To me, the execution missed a bit. The writing was good, the premise of the story was good, but most of the characters weren’t that interesting to me. The build up and the description of what was coming seemed to also drag & I had some trouble getting in to it. The last quarter of the book had some redeeming qualities, the action picked up and it made me feel some Matrix vibes (and I love the Matrix.) The book didn’t really make me think about AI or bioAI with more curiosity or differently, I hoped to at least get a little of that.
Many thanks to by Erika Swyler, Netgalley and Atria books for the opportunity to read a pre-release e-book version of this novel for the exchange of my honest thoughts.
what a genuinely weird book. the ending was a little corny, but it has plenty of good ideas. people who liked Ancilliary Justice will probably enjoy this.
I didn't love or hate this book and felt it was trying a bit too much. The plot is a little too weird and fantastical for my taste.
We Lived on the Horizon by Erika Swyler offers incredibly detailed world-building, immersing readers in the dystopian city of Bulwark with its AI governance and elite Sainted class. The creativity is undeniable, and the writing is often stunning. However, despite the vivid setting and unique concepts, I found it hard to stay fully engaged throughout - but I'm probably in the minority there. Still, for those who appreciate imaginative sci-fi with rich prose, this book is definitely worth exploring.
Thanks so much to NetGalley and the publisher for teh ARC.
I read somewhere that the author worked on this book for ten years and I think ten years ago I would have had a very different reaction to this book. With the boom of AI, I'm more scared of Artificial Intelligence, more unbelieving in it's "conscienceless". So it's hard for me to be emotionally connected to a main character that is an AI. That being said Nix is actually the most likable character in the novel, so maybe that does say something about humanity. I also thought the book was very repetitive, not a lot happened but musings on the state of AI and on what a house system should provide for humans. This just wasn't the book for me.
the city of bulwark stands alone behind high walls in the desert of a post apocalyptic earth, watched over by an ai called parallax. descendants of early city leaders live lives of luxury, rewarded for the work of their ancestors, only a handful still contributing to their society. but most of bulwark residents are born into an inescapable debt system. in between are the bureaucrats who maintain parallax whilst trading in favors and influence. imbalance is growing. revolution is coming to bulwark. and even parallax agrees it is needed. but their are pieces of themselves they wish to preserve. swyler skillfully navigates issues if class, gender, identity, individualiity, duty, purpose, technology, and economics in a positively le guinian tale. don't be surprised if you see it on some of next year's awards lists.
This book is the latest from the author of the very popular THE BOOK OF SPECULATION. This is odd. While reading it I thought I was liking it quite a bit, but now, hardly any time later, I cannot remember one single thing about it and even looking at my notes doesn’t help. I’m honestly looking at jottings in my own handwriting thinking, “wow, I read this? And wrote all this about it?” Because it is gone. Totally gone. So, it’ was obviously not at all memorable for me.
Bulwark is a walled city created to protect people to survive any number of horrible events. AI runs the city, “Bulwark was an entity, a thinking, living thing.” Sacrifice is rewarded. There’s an elite class which has evolved from descendants of those who gave up the most long ago; they are called the Sainted.
OK. This is coming back to me now.
Saint Enita Malovis of the House Saint Malovis is a bio-prosthetist, but few citizens choose to use her services. She feels the end of her life approaching and she wants to preserve her legacy so she creates a physical being, Nix, whom she fills with her knowledge and experience. While she is working on Nix another Saint is murdered and for some reason Bulwark Azi erases the incident from its data. Why? Anita and Nix get drawn into the mystery.
Nix is not totally made from scratch; he began as the voice/AI system of Enita’s home, and he first belonged to Enita’s grandfather. As he is first formed he remains attached to the house, but is then able to move freely.
As mentioned, almost none of Bulwark’s citizens want Enita’s prosthetics; when needed they make use of Body Martyrs, citizens who make organ donations. These people have their life debts dramatically reduced (the Saints have untold numbers of life credits), and some Body Martyrs even have life debts forgiven. However, the Body Martyrs are truly altruistic and are generally identified in childhood.
Enita and Nix come into contact with a Body Martyr, Neron. Soon it becomes clear that the murder of a Saint isn’t the biggest problem in Bulwark. Enita, Nix, Neron and Enita’s best friend and former lover have to decide how to best protect themselves against what is to come.
So, yeah, now I remember. This is not the type of book that I would normally read, but I was intrigued by the premise and I enjoyed the discussions of AI. Sometimes the book was from Enita’s POV in the third person, but sometimes it was third person omniscient, when commenting on society, which was occasionally jarring, when it switched.
I enjoyed the book, but, as mentioned, it took me a minute to get sucked back into its orbit. Others will like it much more, I suspect.
We Lived on the Horizon was a captivating and atmospheric read. Swyler's writing is lyrical and evocative, painting vivid pictures with lines like, "The sea was a symphony of blues, crashing against the rocks in a timeless rhythm."
I was drawn into the characters' struggles and triumphs, their deep connection to the sea, and the enduring power of love and loss. The exploration of family secrets and the echoes of the past resonated deeply. However, the nonlinear narrative and the shifting perspectives took a bit of getting used to, and I occasionally found myself losing track of the timeline.
Overall, We Lived on the Horizon is a beautifully written and emotionally resonant novel that explores the complexities of human connection and the enduring power of the natural world.
I am so excited for this book to come out and for everyone to read it so we can discuss it. Be sure to add it to your pre-order list—it’s releasing on January 14, 2025. We’re planning to pick up an extra copy, so feel free to borrow it if you need one.
Erika mentioned that she has worked on this book for 10 years, and it really shows. The story is incredibly layered and nuanced, making this my favorite of hers so far. One of the blurbs compares her writing to that of Ursula K. Le Guin and Iain M. Banks. Having read Le Guin, I can wholeheartedly agree with that comparison.
The story is compelling. I found myself constantly reaching for my Kindle or Kindle app to sneak in a few pages whenever I could, and then devouring large portions at night. The world she’s created feels real and believable, almost like stepping into a Kazuo Ishiguro novel.
Yet, it’s also a quiet novel—one that invites pondering, wondering, and deep thinking. Themes of utopia and revolution, body autonomy, body mutilation, and technology are woven throughout. This will make an excellent book club pick.
I also think this book would pair wonderfully with T.J. Klune's "In the Lives of Puppets", "Klara and the Sun" by Kazuo Ishiguro, and "Service Model" by Adrian Tchaikovsky.
Just an absolutely incredible look into the future asking questions of class, race and the role of artificial intelligence.
In the city of Bulwark, there is a clear divide between the haves - those deemed "Saints" as there families sacrificed greatly in the past to preserve the city and those who are the have nots. The Saints, live in luxury in beautiful houses manned by complex AI systems. The have nots, work hard and spend as much time as possible avoiding places like the hospital where they may go into great debt. Some of the have nots are even Body Martyrs - and live to give up their own organs so that the Saints can continue to thrive.
Saint Enita Malovis, has spent her life devoted to bio-prosthetistism - growing organs and limbs for others that she attaches or inserts at no cost. She feels that is the least she can do as her life was saved by the donation of a liver. Enita is aging and has spent much of her free time growing limbs and skin to create a body that her house AI could inhabit It is her hope that the AI, Nix, will be able to take on her work after she passes.
However, before she finished her work, a rebellion begins to be planned in Bulwark. Enita needs to decide what she should do - can she truly defend the life of the Saints? What does this mean for Nix?
This book is so much more complex than my description - but only in an amazing and great way. If you love speculative fiction this should be your next book!
#atria #welivedonthehorizon #erikaswyler