Member Reviews

I was so excited to see a new book by Eowyn Ivey. Black Woods Blue sky did not disappoint . Atmospheric, magical and heart wrenching, Ivey beautifully weaves the story of Birdie, Emmie and Arthur.

Was this review helpful?

Eowyn Ivey has an incredible imagination. This new book will be on your mind long after you read the last sentence! I also live in Alaska and will forever think of any bear as an Arthur and anyone named Arthur, a bear. I found myself wanting to call out "Arthur, are you there?" when I took my dogs outside the night I finished Black Woods Blue Sky. This book had three parts, all beautifully written with descriptive details that I could totally envision.

Thank you NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Black Woods Blue Sky is best enjoyed on a midwinter night, next to a cozy fire, with your favourite warm drink in hand. This novel is the perfect choice if you’re looking for a good introduction to Eowyn Ivey’s prose and unique storytelling abilities.

Characters
The characters in this novel come from different walks of life. We have Birdie, a young single mother who wants nothing more than to fly away from her current constraints and be free. Then there’s her young daughter Emaleen who is so fiercely independent and extremely curious about the Alaskan wilderness that she calls home with her mother. And of course, we have Arthur - a mysterious mountain man that Birdie is drawn to in hopes that he can lead her to her desired freedom. The neglect that Birdie showed Emaleen throughout the novel was difficult to read. You could tell that Birdie cared for and loved her daughter, but she craved freedom more than anything, and that sometimes got in the way of her parenting. This made it difficult for me to love Birdie’s character. However, these types of dynamic characters are what make a story interesting!

Plot
This novel is equal parts beautiful and tragic. There were moments where I was so distracted by the sheer beauty of Eowyn Ivey’s writing, that I didn’t even see the devastating twists coming. And when those soul-crushing moments came up, I was left speechless. There were times (mainly closer to the start) where things were moving a little slow, but when the setting moved from the lodge to the wilderness, I was fully invested and excited to find out what would happen next. Could this be a plot device curated by the author to highlight how Birdie was feeling during her time stuck working at the lodge…? If so, GENIUS!

Setting/Vibes
The Alaskan wilderness - what a perfect setting for this novel! The descriptors used throughout make you feel like you’re really there in the middle of the woods, or next to the river. The scents, sights, and sounds are all described so well and I really appreciated the care and attention to these details.

Don’t go into this novel thinking it’ll be just another cozy magical realism novel. Black Woods Blue Sky is more than just a reimagining of Beauty and the Beast. Eowyn Ivey highlights people’s capacity to show empathy and kindness for others, and how quickly life can change in the blink of an eye. This is a novel that will impact and stick with you for years to come.

Was this review helpful?

**3.5, rounded up

My first Eowyn Ivey book, and it likely will not be the last. The prose in this book is incredible, it's authentic, and it's hard not to love. Overall, I did like the story, although the ending got way darker than I expected it to and there were a couple of questions that I wanted answers that I never got, although I can suspend my disbelief on some things because of the genre.

This book, however, took me FOREVER to finish. I guess I just found that I was never really that invested in what happened to anyone in the story, and I didn't really feel the urge to continue once I put it down. I understand the full cycle of having Emaleen come back to the cabin when she graduated college, but the ending didn't really feel fulfilling to me.

Still, I did enjoy it, and I probably will read another book by Ivey in the future.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Magnificent! I was initially hesitant to read Eowyn Ivey’s newest novel as I doubted it would live up to her beautiful work in The Snow Child. The author has exceeded my expectations with this stunning book.

The characters are all well developed, especially young Emaleen whose perspectives were perhaps my favorites. The author has a knack for writing from a child’s POV.

The wilderness of Alaska is as much a character in this story as Arthur, Birdie and her daughter Emaleen. The descriptions of the flora and fauna of the Wolverine River area, as well as the quirky, interesting cast of characters, have me wanting to book a flight to Alaska immediately.

This bittersweet story will stay with you long after you’ve read the final page. I know I will be rereading this book periodically as I do with The Snow Child.

Thank you Netgalley, Random House and author Eowyn Ivey for this exquisite ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. You know when you are reading a book and you can’t stop thinking about it and the characters? That was this book. I loved her first book, The Snow Child. And this book felt somewhat similar and yet completely different. Eowyn has the most incredible way of combining realism and fantasy.

Preorder this book, it is hauntingly beautiful. February 2025.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Eowyn Ivey's The Snow Child was a wonderful surprise find for me several years ago (shoutout to libraries with "recently published" shelves) and has remained with me ever since. I was very excited to see this new work. It has many of the same elements as Snow Child: a remote Alaskan wilderness, magical realism, and interesting characters who encounter unusual circumstances.

Ivey's fairy tale-like approach softens the landscape and the action to allow the reader some distance from the omnipresent threat of danger that comes from living in the wilderness. In fact, my stomach was tight for the first several chapters until I realized that this story had a strong relationship to Beauty and the Beast and other traditional fairy tales, which contained harshness and violence that was scrubbed out by the time they got to Disney. In keeping with that understanding, the character of the child Emaleen was my favorite character as she looked on life with a child's eyes. Sometimes this got her - and her mother - in trouble, but her thoughts and actions were always logical and sweet. In fact, one of the strengths of the book is that the magical realism is paired with a firm grip on reality. All of the characters are changed in some way, and all are guided by their love for each other. The only "villain" in the story is inevitability. People grow up, people follow their paths to their logical conclusions, and people ultimately have to wrestle with their true natures.

It's hard to describe more without spoilers, but if you are looking for a story that will stick with you, I highly recommend this book. Many thanks to Random House and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Birdie is a single mom to daughter Emaleen. She works at an Alaskan lodge as a waitress. She wants more for herself and her daughter. Birdie meets Arthur at the lodge. He is a unique sort of loner that speaks oddly but lives utterly free in the Alaskan wilderness. Birdie and Arthur fall for each other and Birdie agrees to move to the wilderness with her daughter. She thinks she is prepared for the wild life with Arthur. Things however become very interesting for the new family.
I love the bits of fantastical elements Eowyn Ivey throws into her books ,they almost seem possible.

Was this review helpful?

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐I will be thinking about this book long after I've finished it. It left its mark and I would recommend this to anyone and everyone

Black Woods, Blue Sky is a hauntingly beautiful exploration of life, longing, and the darker side of human nature, set against the stunning backdrop of Alaska. The story centers on Birdie, a 26-year-old woman living in Alaska with her six-year-old daughter, Emaleen. Birdie’s life is a difficult one; she works long hours as a waitress and at a bar, struggling as a single mother while battling her own demons. Yet, despite the hardships, Birdie yearns for more. She dreams of adventure, excitement, and a life that feels truly lived.

Enter Arthur, a mysterious recluse who seems to embody the wilderness and adventure that Birdie craves. But as Birdie gets drawn deeper into Arthur’s world, the story takes a dark turn, and what unfolds is both mesmerizing and heartbreaking. I couldn't stop reading. I couldn't look away.

The novel’s alternating perspectives between Birdie and Emaleen add depth and a unique lens to the narrative. Initially, Emaleen’s point of view appears to be a charming way to contrast the adult struggles with a child’s innocent outlook. As the story progresses, it becomes clear that Emaleen’s perspective is not just clever but essential, offering a poignant and critical view as the tale shifts from hopeful to ominous.

While Black Woods, Blue Sky is said to be a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, I would argue that it transcends that label. The author has crafted something entirely new—a modern folktale that feels, to me, more akin to Romeo and Juliet meets the Brothers Grimm. The way the Alaskan landscape is woven into the story is particularly striking; the land itself feels like a living, breathing character, adding to the novel's haunting beauty.

Before reading this ARC, I glimpsed some early reviews praising the author’s previous work. Now, having finished this novel, I understand why. The author’s talent is undeniable, and I’ll certainly be seeking out her other books. Black Woods, Blue Sky is a story that will linger with you, a tale of yearning, beauty, and the shadow that follows both.

Thank you so much to Netgalley and Random House Publishing for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The novel opens with scenes of a mother, Birdie and her young daughter, Emmaleen playing together. The reader finds out that they live in a cabin, in the wilds of Alaska--trees, snows, bear, danger lurking. Birdie is from a broken family, likes danger, loves to party. Emmaleen is a precocious child, not yet old enough to be in school. The book is filled with minor characters who watch over and care for Birdie and Emmaleen. When Birdie plans to move away with Emmaleen to a secluded cabin with Arthur, others attempt to dissuade her. There is something about Arthur that is unspoken. Birdie can feel the danger and is drawn to him. This is such a great novel framed on the story of Beauty and the Beast. I am very appreciative of the complimentary digital ARC I received from NetGalley and Random House. This is my own, true opinion.

Was this review helpful?

How does she do it? How does Eowyn Ivey manage to perfectly encapsulate a riveting story, layered characters and the perfect portrayal of Alaska? (Disclosure: I am Alaskan, I currently live here, and I grew up in the same town Ivey lives in and I am familiar with the area that Ivey uses as inspiration for her fictional locations in her books). 

It has been a long time since I’ve read a book that has me staying up late to read “just a little bit more,” and then Black Woods Blue Sky came along and hooked me. I don’t know how to properly even sum up this book. It’s an exploration of a complex set of characters: Birdie, her daughter Emmaleen, and Arthur. Each of them carries a unique set of circumstances (burdens?) as they attempt to exist and live and yet incorporate each other into their lives taking those circumstances into account. Add to that the backdrop of Alaska which can act as a character in many ways as well. Many authors set their stories in Alaska and only a small handful accurately capture the complexities that is Alaska. Ivey, as always, exceeded in doing this in Black Woods Blue Sky. The Wolverine Valley acts as a mirror to the characters--its dangerous beauty reflects back the complex, sometimes dangerous, love between mother and daughter, woman and man, and human and nature.  

In the end, this was a highly enjoyable book with an accurate representation of Alaska.  

Thank you to NetGalley for a copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for an early read of this wonderful book. Birdie and her daughter Emaleen live in a small community in Alaska. They stay in a lodge and Birdie works there as a waitress and bartender. She often goes outside and looks at the beautiful scenery and mountains in the distance. When she meets Arthur he offers to take her to a family cabin up in those mountains. The writing and descriptions of nature in this book will take your breath away. I loved all the characters and cried like a baby in the end. A MUST read when it comes out in February 2025. From the author of “The Snow Child” ( which i loved) Black Woods Blue Sky by Eowyn Ivey was a brilliant 5 star read!

Was this review helpful?

I recall reading Eowyn Ivey’s The Snow Child years ago and that book has stuck with me in ways that books rarely do for me. I’m absolutely certain Black Woods, Blue Sky will be much the same.

What a hauntingly beautiful story. A reimagining of Beauty and the Beast, yes, but this is no Disney fairy tale. The author leans into the darkness that is commonly found in the oldest, original fairy tales and folk stories and creates a story that is brand new, but feels completely timeless. There are achingly lovely descriptions of the Alaskan wilderness alternated with bluntly brutal acknowledgments of how cruel nature can sometimes be. The author brilliantly shifts between three main points of view to tell this riveting story. The tension builds until you nearly feel it will be too much, but the ending is tender and gentle. Not quite a happy ending, but a fitting one, nonetheless.

Highly, highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't realize this was supposed to be a Beauty and the Beast reimagining until after I read it. I guess I can sort of see it? Minor spoiler - don't expect a fairytale ending as this was a beautiful but also sad book. I'm glad there was a Part 3, as it helped wrap the story up (though I still have some questions).

Kindly received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

No exaggeration, this is one of the most gorgeously haunting books I've read in my life. Eowyn Ivey is SO good at combining a her signature fairytale cadence with the harsh realities of the Alaskan wilderness, creating a landscape (and characters) who are beautiful, brutal, and oh-so-evocative. This broke my heart and crawled under my skin and instantly transported me north whenever I sat down to open another chapter--

I devoured this story.

(Special shout-out to how convincingly Ivey writes from a child's perspective? Emaleen's chapters were my favourite. Time really is a circle.)

Was this review helpful?

Wow, a difficult book to review. I felt up and down about this one. I was a huge fan of The Snow Child. Ivey's writing is absolutely beautiful. I just had a little more trouble suspending belief with Black Woods, Blue Sky. It is a very intriguing story, and once again the setting really draws you in. Thank you NetGalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I am shamed to say that I have not read a book by Eowyn Ivey before receiving the ARC version of Black Woods, Blue Sky. I have owned The Snow Child for many years but have failed to open it.

With that, I went into this book with no knowledge of the author or what to expect. My best description is a retelling of beauty and the beast with an unsatisfied ending. I appreciate that the book was written from different point of views. Each character, who was able to tell their story, had a very well developed sections. I often feel when a book has different POVs, there tends to be weak characters - this was not the case with Black Woods, Blue Sky.

Without spoilers, Part 3 was my favorite section of the book. It did end with leaving me with questions and not understanding the last line!

Thank you for an advanced readers copy of this book! I look forward to reading more by Eowyn Ivey.

Was this review helpful?

I'll say it off the bat: I may harbor a slight bias, because I love Eowyn Ivey's books. The Snow Child—an impromptu read based off of the pretty cover—turned into one of my all-time favorite books years ago, and so when I heard she was at long last releasing another one returning to the familiar backdrop of the Alaskan wilderness, I instantly tried to get my hands on a copy. You can imagine my excitement when the e-ARC arrived in my inbox.

There's something so haunting about this book. In part a Beauty and the Beast retelling, in other parts hinting at Frankenstein or of Mice and Men, in a fairytale style it depicts the contrast between the capacity for humans to be wild and destructive, but also protective and loving.

At its core, it's a simple story. It follows two characters: Birdie, nicknamed after her constant search for freedom and peace from her rough childhood, and Emaleen, her five-year-old daughter who has a relatively isolated childhood and bears the brunt of her mother's bad decisions.

And then there's Arthur. A recluse who, despite his mysterious past, is simultaneously capable of great love and great cruelty.

In a similar style to The Snow Child, it's set in the Alaskan wilderness, where isolation poses a threat to all three central characters. And while it's not classified as horror, some scenes will stick in your head because of just how vivid and real they feel. I could feel everything—from Emaleen's desperation and fears of her mom leaving her, to Birdie's warring desires for a new life but also loyalty to her daughter, to Emaleen's fears that her younger self tried to cover dark truths about her childhood with imagination. With every step these characters took, and the impossible choices they faced, I hurt with them and hoped they would get their happy endings. Somehow.

Speaking of the ending, it was close to perfect. Ivey excels at these endings—the ones that walk the thin line between being tragic and hopeless and being hopeful and resonant. Despite how dark this story turned out to be, the ending was more uplifting than I expected.

This is a beautiful story. Read it in winter, in the dead of night, with the light of a candle, preferably with hot chocolate with little marshmallows. Or chamomile tea with honey. Iykyk.

(I received a complimentary copy of this book from Random House Publishing. I was not required to provide a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.)

Was this review helpful?

Such a unique, beautiful story.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Black Woods, Blue Sky is the long awaited fantasy novel by Eowyn Ivey. Like The Snow Child, the setting is the Alaskan Wilderness. There are three main characters, Arthur, Birdie and her young daughter Emaleen. I loved all three.
There is something very odd about Arthur but Birdie and Emaleen form a strong attachment and that begins the story that kept me riveted to the very end. Eowyn Ivey has once again created a wonderful story.

Was this review helpful?