This was perfectly steamy and emotional, told with a dual timeline of past and present. I loved the audio format, and the narration featured multiple narrators which I enjoyed.

*many thanks to Dreamscape and Netgalley for the gifted copy for review

The So Wrong audiobook, and honestly Abby Millsap's audios in general, are JUST the thing I need when to make lemons into lemonade. June Deborahae shines as Hunter, putting the sass and vulnerability that is her into an emotionally satisfying character. J. River Pierce (Levi) and Liam Dicosimo (Greedy ) both bring the gruffness and lovable characters into my mind, transporting me IMMEDIATELY into Millsap's word. The spice is hot and the emotions are even hotter in the first in the Boys of South Chapel series. Absolutely recommend listening, you're welcome in advance.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review.

This book delivered on a great plot and spice. I really enjoyed the multiple perspectives and chapters from the before and now. These characters were wonderful and went through so much and I was rooting for them the whole time. I really enjoyed this sports romance and look forward to more books in this series.

*So Wrong* by Abby Millsaps is a steamy, emotionally charged romance that explores the complexities of love, second chances, and the messy boundaries between friendship and desire. The story follows the captivating journey of a young woman caught between her past and present, with the two men she can’t seem to escape from complicating everything.

The protagonist, whose heart was once broken by her first love, Greedy, returns to South Chapel, only to find herself stuck in an ongoing emotional tug-of-war with him. Though years have passed since their painful breakup, the weight of their shared history still lingers. Greedy is determined to remind her of their past, but she’s moved on—sort of. Enter Levi, Greedy’s best friend, who’s back in town and in need of a fake girlfriend to appease his mother. As if things weren’t complicated enough, Levi moves in with them, turning their already tense situation into a powder keg of emotions.

The tension between the characters is palpable, and Millsaps does an excellent job of building the slow-burn chemistry between the three of them. The second-chance romance element combined with the "why choose" dynamic makes for a gripping, tantalizing read. *So Wrong* is full of twists and turns, with complex relationships and steamy moments that will keep readers hooked until the very last page.

Abby Millsaps writes with depth, balancing steamy romance with emotional growth and vulnerability. *So Wrong* is a story about healing, the consequences of love, and figuring out where you truly belong—whether it’s with the one you thought you could never have or the one who’s always been there. If you love complex love triangles, second-chance romances, and plenty of heat, this book will not disappoint.

A big thank you to the publisher Dreamscape for providing such a compelling and passionate read!

So Wrong is the first book in the Boys of South Chapel series and starts with Hunter's story. After being introduced to Hunter in the Boys of Lake Chapel series, I was very interested in learning more about her, especially her history with Greedy. Hunter has been through so much. Things are very complicated for Hunter from her relationship with her mother, her relationships with Greedy and Levi, and the secrets she holds close. She's just trying to keep it all together. I loved the "now and then" delivery of the story and learning how the lives of Hunter, Greedy, and Levi are connected in the past and present. Although this book is just a touch of Hunter's story, we start to understand why she made certain decisions. Hunter truly feels she is doing what's best, even if that means hurting those she loves. Hunter, Greedy, and Levi have all dealt with trauma, and it seems they need each other to heal.

I loved this book and how Abby pulled at my heartstrings. This one HURTS! Abby has created amazing characters. I love my Lake Chapel boys, but I can honestly say I've fallen in love with Greedy and Levi, too. I love Hunter! She is strong, independent, and caring. I felt so connected with these characters, a testament to Abby's amazing writing style. I read this book in one sitting, and it was impossible to put it down. Although I was warned and fully expected this to end with a cliffhanger, I was still not ready! I yelled and re-read the last couple of pages a few times to make sure I didn't miss anything. I have so many questions and can't wait to read the rest of this series.

Narration:
After reading this one, I listened to the audiobook months later. June DeBorahae, J. River Pierce, and Liam Dicosimo did a wonderful job and really brought the story to life.

For someone who was expecting a sweet, YA love story, boy, was I in for a surprise! This goes to show that one should always read the description and/or content warnings before listening. That said, this was an interesting, quick listen, and I enjoyed the narrator. It wasn't necessarily for me, but if one likes spice, this would be a good fit!

Hunter St. Clair season is here!! We meet Hunter & Greedy in Abby's Boys of Lake Chapel series (if you haven't read it, I highly recommend you do!!). In So Wrong we are getting a look into Hunter and Greedy's past relationship and why they are where they are now. And my oh my, I fell hard for Greedy. He's so sweet and loves our Hunter fiercely. Then there's Levi, oh Levi! The Duke to Hunter's Daisy, Greedy's BFF and now Hunter's fake boyfriend. The three of them share a deep connection and a few secrets. Absolutely loved the jumps between now and then. And of course in Abby fashion Book 1 was left on a cliffhanger that had my heart in my throat. But that just means I get more time with these characters so I'll let it slide.

"Good things always leave me," she confesses into my chest. "Please don't be another thing that leaves."

"I like you in Brat Mode, Daisycakes."

I felt Hunter to my bones.

I knew I was going to love Hunter’s book just as much as I love BOLC series, but Hunter’s first book was so much more than I expected and so so perfect.

It was emotional and gut wrenching but also heartwarming and sweet! The dual timeline was so well written! The plot, character and relationship developments were done so organically and it all flowed and progressed beautifully! That cliffhanger at the end!?! Oh. My. God.

I cannot wait to see the rest of Hunter’s journey. No wrong moves 🖤

And this audiobook and I didn’t think I could live this book more but it’s damn was I wrong. The audiobook was so good and I love it so much!!

I absolutely love Abby Millsaps writing! I loved Hunter in The Boys of Lake Chapel and having her as the central character in this series is great! She’s a complex character with many layers and is so well written. I am a huge Greedy fan, he is so loyal and devoted. Levi is such a sweetheart and his devotion to both Greedy and Hunter completely won me over. Who I DON’T LIKE… the horrible moms! Abby can def write a crap parent lol! She can also write the hell out of some spice! The angst throughout this one was perfection and oh wow that cliffy!
The audio was fantastic! June deBorahae absolutely slayed this narration. She is the epitome of Hunter and has such a dynamic voice and range! The male narrators also did a wonderful job and were well cast for the roles.

this was so fun!!! the covers are so cute and girly and fun and then you read the book and you’re blushing for different reasons

This was an interesting audio, narrators did an amazing job bringing these characters to life. If you like why choose sports romance this ones definately for you. There is angst, family drama, and complicated relationships within the characters. I don't like to give spoilers but there is a dual timeline so you get to see the past and present. I was not prepared for the cliffhanger.
💗College Football
💗 Close Proximity
💗 Enemies-to-Lovers
💗 Fake Relationship
💗 “He’s NOT my brother”
💗 Polyamorous Romance
💗Why Choose
💗Step Siblings bestfriends

I just finished listening to the audio of “The Co-Op” by Tarah DeWitt, and I absolutely loved it! The narrator brought the characters to life with such energy and charm, making the quirky dynamics of co-op living even more engaging. I found myself laughing out loud at their antics and really connecting with their stories.

The blend of humor and heartfelt moments was perfectly balanced, and I could totally see this as a movie! The vibrant cast of characters would shine on screen, showcasing the chaos and camaraderie that comes with sharing a home. If you’re looking for a fun, feel-good story, I highly recommend giving it a listen!

Holy cliffhanger Batman!!! Sheesh! I did really enjoy this book after I got into it. It did take me a minute to warm to the storyline and get used to the back and forth and multi-character point of views. Once I did, I got really into it and I’m glad I stuck with it. The MMC and 2nd MMC sounded so hot and protective and I loved the ending, even though it’s a cliffhanger. It does make me super excited for the next book in the series! Super hot sex scenes were scattered throughout, but not too many to make it smutty. Just the right amount in my opinion. Will definitely read more by this author now that I’ve read this!

So Wrong by Abby Millsaps is an emotional, down-to-earth romance that pulls you right in. It follows Maggie and Sam, two people who come from completely different worlds but find themselves drawn to each other in ways they can’t ignore. Millsaps has a knack for making her characters feel real—messy, flawed, and totally relatable.

The story tackles heavy themes but does it with heart and humor, and Maggie and Sam’s chemistry is both sweet and intense, making every moment between them feel earned. If you’re into angsty but heartfelt romances that hit you right in the feels, So Wrong is a perfect pick.

This book was good but not my cup of tea. I requested This book solely because my friend told me she loved it. She didn’t tell me anything about it because she knows I like to go into a book blind. However I am not a big fan of why choose and someone else would enjoy this book a lot more than me! It’s just not a trope I like. But I do think people who love the why choose trope will be super happy about this book!

Thank you so much NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for a copy of this book.

This was my first Abby Millsaps book and I am officially ADDICTED OMG!

The FMC was from a previous series and while I haven't read it myself, all my friends talked about was how excited they were for her to get a book, so I was super excited to jump in. She was exactly what I needed in an FMC and it's always extremely inspiring to to find strong FMCs in the book world because I need them in my life.

I am SUCKER for dual timeline. As a second chance girly, I claim dual timelines for myself (okay not really but still)😂

I listened to this book so the spice was spicing and I was sweating just while walking around my apartment while cleaning - LOL! But then the cliffhanger... and look. I knew it was coming but I was like NO NO NO waiting for the audio to continue. I cannot wait to continue in this series. The audiobook was *chefs kiss* and I will continue to read all of them on audio!

You'll like this if you like
✨ College Football
✨ Why Choose
✨ Fake dating
✨ Stepbrother's best friend
✨ Second chance

4⭐️ | 2.5🌶️

Huge thank you to Netgalley for the ALC in exchange for an honest review ❤️

So wrong, yet written so right!

This book was GOOOOOOD! It’s an emotional, angsty, football romance which follows our FMC, Hunter and MMCs, Greedy and Levi. The story is told in multi pov and was narrated in each character’s pov. This relationship dynamic was complicated, but the chemistry was oh soooo yummy! All that angst made those steamy scenes 🥵🥵🥵🥵🥵 The audio narration captured these dynamics very well. The audio quality was good. The narration was emotional and intimate. The narration did not have any background noise or distracting sound effects.

So Wrong by Abby Millsaps

⭐⭐⭐💫

If you’re into steamy second-chance romances and love triangles with all the emotional tension, So Wrong might just be your next read!

“No wrong moves, Temi. You’re my first and my last. I never knew what I was waiting for, but now I know it was you.”

Greedy and Hunter have a past full of heartache and regret, and now that Levi, Greedy's best friend, is back in town and ‘dating’ Hunter, the stakes get even higher. Add in unresolved feelings, family drama, and complicated relationships, and you've got a recipe for some serious angst! While the romance is full of tension and slow-burn chemistry, the story does lean heavily on familiar tropes, making some parts feel predictable. But the emotional rollercoaster between Greedy and Levi keeps things interesting! I loved watching relationships grow and develop throughout the book.
I also really enjoyed the “then” and “now” dual timelines

What you’ll find in So Wrong:
💗 Angsty
💗 College Football
💗 Close Proximity
💗 Enemies-to-Lovers
💗 Fake Relationship
💗 “He’s NOT my brother”
💗 Polyamorous Romance
💗 Second Chance
💗 Sibling's Best Friend
💗 Why Choose

"Life has a rhythm. Everything happens for a reason, even if we don't know what the reason is right away."

Overall, So Wrong offers an intriguing start to the Boys of South Chapel series. Perfect for readers who enjoy why choose romance and second chances with a side of drama! 💫

Holy cliffhanger !!! I was totally not expecting that ending! This book was phenomenal! It was so well written, and I adored the characters! I'm going to need a real life Greedy after reading this book! The audio for this book was just as good as actually reading it! June DeBorahae, J. River Pierce, and Liam Dicosimo did an amazing job narrating!

What on earth was this cliffhanger ??? I need book two straight away!
It took me a few chapters to actually get in the story, but I truly enjoyed it and loved the characters, story, plot twists!!!