Member Reviews

I absolutely loved I Was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon. This story is moving, heartbreaking and intriguing. I remember as a child hearing about Anna Anderson, the woman who claimed to be Anastasia Romanov. I have always had a fascination with history and the Russian Imperial Romanov family. I have read books about them in the past and couldn’t believe what those innocent children endured, especially poor little Alexei. This is a cleverly constructed story with dual timelines. Anna Anderson’s story is told in reverse while intersecting the Romanov’s final year of their lives. This is the first book that I have read by Ariel Lawhon, but I bought The Frozen River as I now want to read everything Ariel has written! Thanks to NetGalley, the author, and publisher for my digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

"I Was Anastasia" by Ariel Lawhon is a captivating work of historical fiction, exploring the mysterious story of Anastasia Romanov. The book is written with dual time lines that ultimately converge, and explores the story of Anastasia Romanov and Anna Anderson.

In usual Lawhon style, the book is impeccably researched, and brings to life the crumbling world of the Russian Imperial family, and also the history and movements of Anderson. The character of Anastasia is portrayed with depth and complexity, she is a very believable teenage character. Anna Anderson's character is extremely well researched, and gives you an empathy for her character and actions.

Themes of identity, destiny, and the impact of small choices on the course of history are central to the story. Lawhon successfully merges the tension of historical events with the speculative thrill of "could it be," keeping readers engaged as they navigate the shifting timelines.

"I Was Anastasia" offers a thought-provoking and imaginative take on the life of Anastasia Romanov who in all likelihood would have slipped into obscurity if it had not been for Anna Anderson. It's a must-read for fans of historical fiction, as well as those fascinated by the enduring mystery of Anastasia Romanov.

I was given this ARC by NetGalley and Simon & Shuster Australia, and thank them for the opportunity to read it in return for my review. I do note for readers that this is a re-release of the 2018 book by Lawhon.

Was this review helpful?

'Am I truly Anastasia Romanov? A beloved daughter. A revered icon. A grand duchess. Or am I an imposter? A fraud. A liar. The thief of another woman's legacy'.

Most people are already aware of the murder of the royal Romanov family as WW1 closed. However, rumours of young Anastasia surviving pervaded with the appearance of a woman, Anna, who claimed to have escaped the firing squad. This stubbornly persisted for decades, in the absence of technology and DNA testing. Ariel Lawhon puts her spin on the tale, using the alternating POVs of Anastasia and Anna. While Anastasia's story begins as her family is sent into exile in Siberia, Anna's begins at the end and slowly winds back until we reach the pivotal point of what happened after the execution.

'I was Anastasia' is very well-researched and bursts with believability. I did find it a challenge, at times, to read Anna's story backward; to only realise comprehension chapters later. However, as the story reaches its climax, the unique story-telling format is as rewarding as it is revelatory. For a story that is generally so well known, Lawhon does well at delivering a nuanced perspective.

'You're all so enamored with the legend'.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoy Ariel’s books and always been fascinated by the Romanov family and the story of Anastasia. I quite keen to see how Ariel tackled this book. The story alternates between the one of Anastasia Anderson and the last 18 months of the Romanov family. I loved the start and end where you’re challenged to read and make up your own mind. Even though we now know what happened with Anastasia it was interesting to go back to a time where it was unknown and you can’t but help want for one of the Romanov’s go have survived.

Thoroughly researched I enjoyed the two different sides. I have read quite a bit on the Romanov’s before so was more drawn to the story of Anastasia Anderson. Told backwards we first meet her as she waiting to see the outcome her court case to see if she will be formally recognized as Anastasia Romanov. It was interesting to her story play out, from all the different benefactors she had, how she gathered evidence and her time at the asylum where she first became Anastasia. An interesting mix of history and mystery. A very unique take on both stories with Ariel’s meticulous research and storytelling. Definitely take the time to read and decide for yourself.

Was this review helpful?