This was an interesting book. It had so much premise, but fell flat for me unfortunately. To compare it to outlander is a huge stretch, beyond the aspect of time travel. It lacks the same amount of depth and character development. I would give this 3.5 stars. I’d like to see greater plot development and a less forced romance, if romance at all (it seemed like an afterthought).

4 stars and my thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for the eARC!

Y'all. I read 60% of this at the bar the night prior to writing this review while my family played poker.

Isla is in Japan searching for her family history, believing a however many greats grandfather was one of the last samurai to make a stand against what ended up being modernity in the country. She visits a shrine and finds herself thrown back in time to a month before war breaks out. Struggling with trying to get back to her time and dealing with burgeoning feelings for a quiet samurai, Isla has to figure out if she should share what she knows from the future or if history needs to play out as written.

I'll start with what I didn't like to get it out of the way: The repetition. I feel like inner monologues repeated themselves a lot, both with Isla and with Keiichiro. It probably could have done with some more editing. It's not Kuroki's first novel, but it reads like it. I also felt like the characters are supposed to be college age or even early 20s, but they read as immature 16 year olds at times. Keiichiro and his friends are still playing pranks and getting into trouble when they're supposed to be grown men? Ok.

What I loved: Keiichiro. 100% the best part of the story. 10/10 no notes on this man. We love a man who knows his duty and feels terrible for choosing it first. We love a man who is soft and caring but also knows how to fucking kill a man. Isla and Keiichiro's romance was so sweet and lovely that even a wrinkle like an arranged marriage didn't slow it down by much. Also, that ending! I need more. Gimme more.

this book had a really interesting concept, but I didn't love the execution. I will try to formulate my thoughts and post a full review soon

Gate to Kagoshima is a historical romance, very Outlander meets “The Last Samurai”. I appreciated the author’s deft hand at centering the story in its two timelines (though there’s a part of me that’s devastated to see the 2000s are historical enough to be a time placed in history with relics of old such as the Motorola Razr flip phone), and the thematic throughline of our protagonist, Isla, seeking out answers about her heritage and where a part of her comes from.
However, my enjoyment of the novel was hindered by several other factors. Odd as it may sound, Kagoshima was a little too readable; the prose was so simplistic that it moved from an invisible vehicle by which to consume a story, one that required no remark one way or another, into something that aged down the book and made it feel like it was for a much younger audience. Were it not for the warfare and sex scenes, I’d call this novel accessible to middle-grade readers, and not nearly nuanced enough to get across the more harrowing elements of the story to its YA or adult audiences.
This disconnect colored other elements of the story as well. The pacing of the novel was quick, which it had to be to cover the several elapsed months of the rebellion, but that left little to no room for “showing” characters’ emotional arcs or doing more than telling that time had passed. It was hard to feel a sense of narrative urgency while reading because Isla’s goal throughout was just… waiting. Waiting to meet her ancestor if possible, waiting to get back to her own time. She had no intermediary goals to carry her between any of those points, and she ended up just being swept along into a war that I as a reader had no time to begin caring about.
I wish Isla had been more proactive in figuring out about her ancestor instead of having the answer of it all fall into her lap. 2005 is modern enough that she should’ve been able to guess that she might be something of a “reverse ghost”, complete with western ideas of ghosts having unfinished business that prevents them from moving on. The things she’d do would make her more of an outsider, yes, but I need my protagonist to have some goal or agency or something to carry their own story. As it was, I couldn’t tell if Kuroki wanted to write a romance centering Isla and the samurai Kei or just a creative nonfiction piece about the Satsuma rebellion, because as soon as it was possible, the focus shifted to the latter in a way that made any bit of romance we got later on feel forced/out of place/surprising rather than satisfying. The scenes of warfare were a good change of pace in that they showed the interruption to life and accumulation of trauma, but because we were following an outsider instead of someone in Satsuma who had seen these sentiments brewing, it felt like it all happened so fast with no time to mourn characters we barely got to know anyway. By trying to play both games, I felt Gate to Kagoshima failed to deliver on either.
Because of these large scale problems, I was more aware of smaller gripes throughout the story that I may otherwise have handwaved.
The worldbuilding element of the time travel Yoshii gate not being tied to a specific location broke my immersion in that speculative fiction element (there has to be rules to the magic!). It could have been a good way to save Kei while the rebellion was failing—he needs to escort Isla back to the temple to be able to go home— but instead it just? Appears wherever? And sends Isla straight back to where she came from? And it only sometimes needs a storm to work, and sometimes it makes a musical sound you can follow. There was also inconsistency with the use of the honorifics, where some have dashes and some run into the name that they follow in a way that made the story just a little harder to read. Finally, I just felt the story hit one too many Outlander beats, down to calling Isla a gaijin, and I’m just not a fan when books are too similar to comp titles.

Dnf at 56%.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion. The Gate to Kagoshima is a time traveling romance story about a girl named Isla who travels back in time to feudal Japan. When Isla gets randomly transported back to feudal Japan she meets Keichiro, a young samurai man who is trying to figure out whether or not she is a spy. The premise of the book sounded amazing and it was being compared to Outlander, which I really love. However, I feel that this story fell flat. The story isn’t horrible, but I think I just didn’t care what was happening to them. I also think the story rushes the plot along without really building character relationships. The writing felt underdeveloped, and there was this push that Isla and Keichiro liked each other without really giving us time to see that happen. I think if we had more detailed chapters showing Isla’s time with Keichiro and his village, showing a bond growing between the two it would have made the story so much more enjoyable.

I have mixed feelings and emotions about this book. On one hand, I really liked the Japanese culture and the history. The ending had me emotional and I even shed a few tears, it was so heartfelt and beautiful. But the other part of me hated the Kana reveal and how her brother believed an enemy over her. And then to just be like I believed him so now you need to admit it to me? It just felt so gross and my heart was just so broken for Kana. And then it broke again for the unnecessary murders that were a result of it. I did enjoy the writing though and I would definitely read future books by this author.

I saw that this was a Japanese historical romantasy, and I couldn’t pass up the opportunity to read it. The book felt well-researched, and it was fascinating to dive into another culture’s history.

Isla Mackenzie’s trip to Japan takes a very unexpected turn when a typhoon sweeps her 128 years into the past, to the Satsuma Rebellion. There, she meets her ancestors and Kei, a charismatic samurai who captures her heart. With her knowledge of Kei’s doomed fate, Isla must choose to either alter history or find her way back home.

I felt like the book dragged on a bit in the middle, but I loved how everything wrapped up in the end, with all loose ends tied up nicely.

This is what I would consider a historical romance primarily taking place during the Satsuma Rebellion of 1877.
* Likes
* Enjoyed learning more about Japanese culture.
* I appreciate the effort that went into learning about the history and placing these fictional characters within that history.
* Back of book includes a bunch of information on the history and the time lines of actual events.
* Dislikes
* A bit repetitive. We understand her mission.
* Unnatural dialogue.
* Serious overuse mentioning the sprained ankle.
* There are a lot of Random happenings that feel more like an afterthought when you run through a draft with a decision change and have to make it make sense.
* I wanted more show and less tell. Rather than telling me that the main character was nervous show me what nervousness felt like. The sweaty palms and the increased heart rate. That would’ve have helped me have a more emotional connection with the characters.

Overall I would recommend this to anyone who isn’t super critical when reading. If things like sentence structure don’t bother you, I think the story is worth it. Poppy has pulled beautiful fictional characters into this historically accurate story.

Big oof. The premise seemed great. The book got off to a great start and then it lost momentum. The world building and character development seemed to get lost and therefore so did my interest in the book.

WOW! I confess I dove into this book knowing nothing other than that it's been getting compared to Outlander and was about Japanese Samurais. I knew very little about late 19th century Japanese history and enjoyed this soo much!!

The book starts in 2005 where Scottish Isla is spending a study year in the country of her mother's heritage. She herself is one quarter Japanese and is grieving the recent death of her grandfather. While trying to track down a connection to a famous Samurai, she somehow finds herself transported back to 1877 on the eve of the last great battle of the Samurais.

This book was full of action, romance, fascinating history and is sure to appeal to all the Outlander fans out there. I loved how the book ends and am really excited to see where this new series is going to go next! It was also great on audio narrated by Siho Ellsmore and the print copy has GORGEOUS sprayed edges!

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital copy and Librofm for a complimentary ALC in exchange for my honest review. This is definitely going to be a favorite of mine for 2025 and I now have a new fav author!

Thank you Netgalley for this e-arc in exchange for an honest review. I enjoyed this quick read with romance and steeped in history. I didn’t realize how steeped in history it was until I read the notes at the end! It made the story a lot cooler. This is a very fast paced story but to the point that the romance parts are kind of rushed. But I feel like all in all the story flowed pretty well. The war progressed at a good pace and the story moved along well. Time travel is always an interesting concept but honestly feels like a small part of the story in the grand scheme of things. It sounds like there will be more stories like this by this author and I would definitely be curious to read them! A solid 3.5 star read!

Thanks to publisher/author/NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review.

Gate to Kagoshima follows Isla on her trip to Japan to find out more about her ancestors. Her grandpa has passed away, her relationship has ended badly, and she needs some time to herself. ...Except while visiting a shrine in a storm, Isla is transported back in time to 1877.

There's a lot to like about this book as Isla copes with what happens and settles into her new life as a foreigner in 1870s Japan - she learns about the culture, becomes more fluent in the language, makes friends, and falls in love. But to me, it seemed like it fell a bit flat.
Major super mega spoilers:

[It mentions Isla's failed, awful relationship once or twice and kind of doesn't have any bearing on the story whatsoever. Isla asks if anyone's ever heard of her greatx3 grandfather and then just kind of gives up on finding him. He pops up anyway though, don't worry. And she seems very unperturbed by the fact that she's just stuck in the past. She makes her way out to the shrine to see if the gate is back and then just shrugs and carries on. And goes to war?? And then misses her chance to go home because she's in love?? AND THEN, and this is the part that really busts my buffers, she goes home as her love is dying but surprise, he's actually the little coffee shop dude. And remembers everything, but like, from dreams. (hide spoiler)]

I really did enjoy reading this. I'm a big fan of fantasy and time travel fiction, but this just wrapped everything up a little too neatly for me to rate it highly.

Isla is a young Scottish woman who travels to Japan to uncover more about her ancestry. Was her Japanese grandfather descended from a Samurai? What happened to her family during the historic Satsuma Rebellion that effectively ended the way of the Samurai in Japan? She has so many questions—but the answers give her way more than she bargained for.

When caught up in a storm, Isla finds herself magically transported through time to Kagoshima in 1877. Confused and unaware of what happened, she is taken in by the local village and looked after by a Samurai named Keiichirō. As Isla searches for a way to find home, their connection grows—and she finds herself caught up in the tragic and brutal events of history she doesn’t know how to change.

Gate to Kagoshima explores the beauty of 19th-century Japan and the ways of the Samurai; their dedication to their craft, their respect and honor, and their acceptance of the life they lead. The descriptions of the time and setting are rich and detailed, taking you on a tour of rural Japan and cementing you in the era. The historical aspects are well-researched and respectfully portrayed, which serve to highlight the differences between Isla and those around her in an effective way.

The blending of romance into the historical setting is bittersweet but warm, giving Isla a reason to keep going in the face of war and grief. Isla and Keiichirō have decent chemistry and learn so much from one another; you get to see their perspectives and thoughts, which makes their budding love feel more intimate. The friendships and bonds Isla forms with the other villagers along the way are unexpectedly sweet, too, and show off how women were not always helpless victims of war; they often fought and participated in whatever ways they were able.

However, while the foundations are good, the story falls short of what it wants to be. There are certain plot points that don’t seem believable, even in the fantasy element of time travel, and some decisions are maddening. The central mystery of Isla’s journey is intriguing but the execution could have benefited from more revisions, especially when some parts don’t have the payoff they build towards. It felt a little unfocused at times and rushed towards the end.

With that said, if you’re a fan of Outlander or time-travel romance, this is a solid, if a little middling, entry into the genre. It’s an easy read that flows well enough, with some great observations about history and war. There are definite problems that might leave you feeling a bit flat, but the historical descriptions are inviting—so perhaps you’ll enjoy this tour of 19th-century Kagoshima, and indulge in some romance along the way.

While the premise was intriguing, the execution left me conflicted. The author’s dedication to historical accuracy and cultural detail is evident, but at times, the narrative felt bogged down by an overwhelming amount of information. This "info-dump" style occasionally pulled me out of the story, disrupting the pacing and emotional engagement.

It’s hard not to compare this book to Outlander, as the similarities are undeniable, from the time-travel romance to the historical setting. However, this story leans more toward YA in tone, which sometimes clashed with its adult themes, particularly the open-door romantic scenes. These moments felt out of place and even awkward, making me wonder if a fade-to-black approach might have suited the story better.

Although the ending wrapped things up neatly, the overall storyline and romance felt rushed, leaving little room for character development. While the setting and cultural elements were compelling, the book ultimately struggled to stand apart from its inspirations or find a cohesive balance between its themes.

A historical romance set in Japan’s past, Isla is sent back in time and encounters a samurai, Kei. With the Satsuma Rebellion going on, she soon finds herself struggling with whether she should tempt fate and change the past while navigating falling in love. This book had all the things I love, but unfortunately, it fell flat. I love historical romance, and I love Japanese culture, so I was extremely disappointed that this didn’t live up to my expectations. The plot was all over the place, and there was a lot of repetition and jumping around. The story wasn’t flushed out well, and even though the book was a decent length, it felt rushed.

I was greatly excited by the premise of this book and the cover art is fabulous. The novel is a nice blend between historical fiction, science fiction ( time travel) and Romance reminiscent of Outlander , so if you enjoyed that book., this book is for you ! . The author does well writing the historical aspects portraying Satsuma Rebellion of 1877. The protagonist, Isla MacKenzie, is visiting Japan searching for information on her ancestor when she is caught out in a storm at a shrine and suddenly transported back to 1877 where she meets and develops feelings for the honourable samurai Keiichirō Maeda. Unfortunately, this style of novel with the romance focus was not for me ,if the book had stayed focused on looking for Isla`s ancestor, the historical time period and getting back home I would have enjoyed it more. The writing is good and blends historical facts with a romantic, and science fiction narrative. The characters, are well-developed and the portrayal of Japanese culture historically is respectfully written.

Thanks to Netgalley and Harper Perennial and Paperbacks | Harper Perennial for this ARC. This is my honest review.

the plot came twisted and unexpected as it should!!! this was a great historical fiction read. i wish we got a little more about the main character and the reincarnation at the end of the story

Thank you NetGalley for the ebook arc unfortunately it just wasn’t for me. I’m still hovering 5 stars cause just breccias ro could get into the book doesn’t mean it’s bad.

Firstly, thank you to NetGalley and the Publisher for the early access to this book in exchange for an honest review.

2.5/5 stars.

I was very excited to read this book as it certainly had all the elements in a book that interest me. I'm a huge fan of the Samurai and of the Japanese culture/history. The book cover is absolutely stunning and pulled me in without even having to read the summary. I have seen different reviews of how this book can be somewhat summarized into an "Outlander" kind of vibe, which I totally can see now that I have finished this book.

The story felt pretty rushed in general up until about halfway through. Some of the world-building just didn't feel completely there either. I did enjoy the characters themselves and wished to know a little more about each of them. The romance in the book between the two main characters also felt a little flat - I was really hoping for a little more tension between them or some kind of build-up for it.

Overall, the book is a quick and easy read though for anyone who is interested in a historical time-travel/romance story.

This was such a fun premise and had a lot of potential i really wanted to love this story a sort of Outlander in Japan story but overall it felt rushed. We’re told that she been in 1880 japan for weeks and the only thing we really learn is that her Japanese gets better. There is also no reference or at least I didn’t catch are references to Reincarnation at yet at the end we are supposed to just accept that reincarnation was always part of the story for it to make sense. Our love hero in the 1880 is a samurai and its his whole life and personality, the reason they cannot be together in 1880 and yet in president day he is a medical student slash barista. I just feel like the story wasn’t fleshed out enough, everyone needed more time together and we need to know more about. The president day love interest. Overall it was a fine story that i wanted to wow me and it just didn’t,