Member Reviews

This is a sweet tale of Olaf, a bear who lives in New York City’s Central Park, and his best friend Essex, a loyal and clever fox, how find a baby and must protect it from evil witches. There were elements of this story that I loved, like the relationships between the animals, and even the trees, and the uncanny way our giant protagonist was able to move around NYC unnoticed, and I expect that kids will enjoy the hijinks throughout. However, the last third of the book dragged on, with certain plot points repeating themselves a few too many times. And while I love Shakespeare, most kids, who are the target audience of this book, have not read Macbeth, and the constant references to “the Bard” and quotes from his works are likely to go completely over their heads, if not be downright confusing.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet and endearing middle-grade story about love and longing, as seen from the POV of a sensitive bear, a motherly fox, and a competent but grumpy cat.

Set in an imagined post-crisis New York City, the story teems with witches, and magic-competents - some good, and some as evil and nasty as one can expect.

When Olaf (the bear), released into the streets and separated from his much-loved zoo keeper guardian, Wendy, is befriended by Essex, a tv-watching fox who desperately wants to learn how to read, the two chums do their best to survive, staying away from the increasingly-hard-to-understand humans, and keeping an eye out for the ever-present witches.

As Olaf and Essex, together with their no-nonsense friend Baby, a white cat, come upon a (human) baby in distress, and Mabel Blackthornudder, the self-proclaimed most powerful witch in New York, their lives will be changed forever.

A tale that will tweak the full gamut of emotions, this story is charmingly augmented with line drawings, and creatively plotted — a treat for lovers of fairy tales and fables, underlined with magic and a heart-warming message.

A great big thank you to #Netgalley, the author and the publisher for an ARC of this book. All thoughts presented are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Olaf and Essex is a cute, magical debut. I can tell the author really wanted to create a world where children can dream of being rescued by wildlife as a baby and go against an evil witch.

While this is a cute story, I felt that the story beats were disjointed. Many times, I felt taken out of the book due to the flow of conversations, strange comedic timing, and confusion on character traits. Some chapters felt more polished than others and there was a strange sense of carefulness on the work. Almost as if the author was still holding back on little details that could help enhance the story.

That doesn't mean there were no good parts! For example, the more emotional moments involving Essex and her past were still written well and easy to digest for younger readers.

All this to say, the story and premise are great, but the execution was somewhat lacking in more than one area. I do hope to see how this author transforms in the next project!

Was this review helpful?

What a delight this book is. I read it myself first but then was encouraged to read it again with the younger children ,who loved it. It will become a classic and will be finding space on our bookshelf.

Was this review helpful?

Olaf and Essex is an adorable story with anthropomorphic animals, bungling witch kidnappers, and hilarious hijinks. My feedback is coming via the child I shared the story with, so here goes:

Loved the animal characters
The witch lady perhaps was a little too evil?
Story was a little on the long side, and they struggled to stay focused for some of additional PoVs

Otherwise, a genuinely enjoyable read!

Review will run on Goodreads starting 10/11 in perpetuity
and on Barnes and Noble starting on publication day

Was this review helpful?

This story was fun filled and action packed. I loved the characters in here - not just Olaf and Essex but the rest of the crew in the story as well.

This is a cute, cozy Fall read filled with talking animals, magic, and witches. The theme of family is riddled throughout the story. My daughter absolutely loved me reading this story to her and looking forward to the next book in the series!

Was this review helpful?

This book was delightful. It was full of great characters that were both good and evil and sometimes flawed. The illustrations added a lot to this book and the writing engaging and kept me turning pages. Highly recommend this for middle grade and those older who are looking for a lighter read that also has depth and good writing.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this book without too many expectations and very little foreknowledge, only to be completely charmed and captured by the story and its characters. It's not too much to say that this is a modern classic in the making.

Olaf the bear and Essex the fox overcome the tragedy in their own lives to form a fast friendship, and subsequently (and unexpectedly!) find themselves rescuing a magical baby from a pair of miscreants. But figuring out what to do with the baby afterwards is an entirely different matter...

Featuring a pair of witch sisters, some evil humans who hate magic, a wizard who is turned into a frog, a wise trio of trees, a misanthropic cat and a whole host of other supporting characters with charm and/or ill-intent, this book really is a must-read. Barring one element near the end which I felt was unnecessary, I feel that any readers life will be enriched by this story, which gave me ALL the feels.

Was this review helpful?

I read this book with my 6 year old son and he ABSOLUTELY loved it! The bear was his favorite. Every page he was excited to find out what mischief was coming next! The illustrations were stunning as well.

Was this review helpful?

This is a story of a bear named Olaf and his friend, Essex, who is a fox. When Olaf comes across two witches in the park, his presence scares the witches enough that they leave without taking the baby with them, the baby they were attempting to kidnap in order to force the Chief Magic Detector to leave the magical community alone.

But this baby isn’t just any baby. It’s the son of the Chief Magic Detector.

Olaf really feels for this baby, he was just a cub when his mother died, and his tender heart tells him that they need to care for the baby until they can find the parents, so Olaf and Essex go in search of who they believe is the mother, only to see her turn her husband into a frog.

Olaf and Essex do their best to care for the baby, and to keep him healthy and well fed, while at the same time keeping this magical baby safe and sound, and attempting to find the baby’s real mother and return the baby to her, and keeping the baby away from her father.

There’s a lot of mischief going on in this story, which is all in the name of keeping the baby safe and sound, sprinkled with a dose of magical charm, as well.



Pub Date: 15 Oct 2024


Many thanks for the ARC provided by Pretty Cool ​​ / Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op

Was this review helpful?

This is such a charming story of a Bear who is trying to do what he deems right. In this novel we have a loveable bear (Olaf) and his animal friends, Essex (a Fox) and Baby( a Cat).

This book is perfect it has charming illistrations and there was action and adventure that can keep readers of any age captivated. e

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

Was this review helpful?

I read this with my 9 year old. she was absolutely captivated by this story. She feel in love with the characters and backdrop of this book. 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

Oh my goodness this book was adorable! How can you resist cute animals. This is a perfect for fall. My son didn’t want me to stop reading and flew through it in two sessions. It’s a great mix of cuteness, adventure, action, and found family.

Was this review helpful?